• Journal of Environmental Policy
• /
• v.9 no.4
• /
• pp.125-154
• /
• 2010

Among the various contemporary issues that confront the nation or society, surely one of the most difficult to resolve are environmental disputes between government authorities, developers, local residents and advocacy groups. While such disputes can in some cases be the result of a selfish and illegal NIMBY("Not In My Back Yard") syndrome, they can also be an expression of rational and appropriate demands from local residents to preserve the ecology and quality of life for their communities, particularly with respect to the planning of "locally unwanted land uses(LULUs). Accordingly, rethinking NIMBYism entails several implications for planning of LULUs. Until the 20th century many planners considered only "functional rationality" in their decision making, in a confrontational "us versus them"process of "decide-announce-defend(DAD)". I believe, however, that a fair, voluntary, and negotiated process of alternative dispute resolution(ADR) based on consensus building is the means to resolving these disputes. A voluntary process is more desirable and feasible than a coercive one, making ADR well worth pursuing. From this perspective, I explore several factors which affect the resolution of environmental disputes. I suggest three main factors as follows: i) extension of citizen participation, ii) enhancement of equity, and iii) building of trust. Alternatives are presented based on these factors.

• 대학교육
• /
• s.135
• /
• pp.66-73
• /
• 2005

우리는 그간 정부 주도의 대학개혁이 소기의 성과를 달성하지 못하고 실패로 끝났던 역사적 사실을 상기해 볼 때 새로운 패러다임은 누군가의 강요가 아닌 구성원들의 합의와 공감대가 형성되었을 때 가능함을 분명히 각인해야 한다.

• Nuclear industry
• /
• v.37 no.7
• /
• pp.98-101
• /
• 2017

본고는 일본 종합자원에너지조사회의 기본정책분과회에서 생산한 자료로서 고준위 방사성폐기물 대책에 대한 국민의 합의 형성 방안과 입지 선정 프로세스 문제 등을 다루고 있다.

• Information Systems Review
• /
• v.13 no.3
• /
• pp.141-163
• /
• 2011

The advancement of information technologies including the Internet has affected the way of social information processing as well as brought about the paradigm shift to the information society. Accordingly, it is very important to study the process of social information processing over the digital media through which social information is generated, distributed, and led to social consensus. In this study, we analyze the mechanism of social information processing, identify a process model of social consensus and institutionalization of the results, and finally propose a set of information processing characteristics on the internet media. We deploy the ethnographic approach to analyze the meaning of group behavior in the context of society to analyze two major events which happened in Korean society. The formation process of social consensus is found to consist of 5 steps: suggestion of social issues, selective reflection on public opinion, acceptance of the issues and diffusion, social consensus, and institutionalization and feedback. The key characteristics of information processing in the Internet is grouped into proactive response to an event, the changes in the role of opinion leader, the flexibility of proposal and analysis, greater scalability, relevance to consensus making, institutionalization and interaction. This study contributes to the literature by proposing a process model of social information processing which can be used as the basis for analyzing the social consensus making process from the social network perspective. In addition, this study suggests a new perspective where the utility of the Internet media can be understood from the social information processing so that other disciplines including politics, communications, and management can improve the decision making performance in utilizing the Internet media.

• Convergence Security Journal
• /
• v.14 no.6_2
• /
• pp.63-72
• /
• 2014

The purpose of this study is to investigate the relationship between organizational culture, job characteristics and job continuance will among police officers. This study targets the police officers dispatched in the Seoul metropolitan area in 2012, and it uses judgment sampling method to analyze 187 samples. This study conducted the statistical analysis, including frequency analysis, factor analysis, reliability analysis and multiple regression analysis, by using SPSS WIN 18.0. The result is as follows. First, the organizational culture among police officers has effects on job characteristics. That is, the feedback increases as the organizational culture becomes more mutual development- or agreement-oriented, or as it becomes more hierarchical; on the other hand, the job importance increases as more hierarchical and rational a culture becomes. Also, self-determination increases as an organization becomes more mutual development- or agreement-oriented. Second, the organizational culture among police officers has effects on the job continuance will. That is, the expected satisfaction increases but intentional insincerity decreases as the organizational culture becomes more mutual development- or agreement-oriented. Also, risk-perceiving behavior increases as an organizational culture becomes more hierarchical. Third, police officers' job characteristics have effects on the job continuance will. That is, the feedback and job importance increases the expected satisfaction while reducing functional diversity. The feedback also reduces the contraction factor. The job importance increases intentional insincerity while reducing functional diversity. The functional diversity not only increase alternative expectation but also increases risk-perceiving factors.

• Proceedings of the KIEE Conference
• /
• 2009.07a
• /
• pp.2127_2128
• /
• 2009

전기공사협회가 추진하는 전기설비시공의 '마스터 스펙 프로젝트'는 민간에 의한 '표준 제정'의 사례에 해당한다. 이 글에서는 표준 제정의 환경 및 요소에 따라 마스터 스펙의 특성을 분석한다. 분석 결과, 마스터 스펙의 제정과정은 산업협회(association) 중심의 거버넌스 형태를 띠는 것으로 나타났으며, 이 경우는 특정 산업 부문 내에서 이루어지는 합의 방식이 표준 제정의 특징으로 보인다. 한편, 우리나라에서 산업에 대한 규제나 지원이 정부 주도로 이루어진다는 점, 산업분류에서 전기공사업의 위치가 이중적이라는 점, 또 전기공사 산업 부문이 분산적 산업구조를 띠고 있다는 점 등이 마스터 스펙의 제정에 영향을 미치는 것으로 분석되었다. 그러므로 전기공사협회는 마스터 스펙을 제정하면서 수직적 수평적 전기공사업 관련 조직들을 관리하면서 합의형성을 추진하고 제정 과정을 관리해야 할 것이다.

• Journal of The Korean Association For Science Education
• /
• v.37 no.6
• /
• pp.1037-1049
• /
• 2017

The purpose of this study is to explore how the flow of discourse move and their reasoning process in dialogic argumentation during group modeling on excretion. Five groups of three to four students in the second grade of a middle school participated in the modeling practice of a Gifted Center. Analysis was conducted on argumentation during the modeling activity in which students should explain how the waste product (ammonia) leaves the body. It was found that there was a sequential argumentative process-tentative consensus, solving the uncertainty, and consensus. There were several discourse moves - 'claim' and 'counterclaim' in the stage of tentative consensus, 'query' and 'clarification of meaning' in the stage of solving the uncertainty, and 'change of claim' in the stage of consensus. Students participated in the dialogic argumentation by constructing argument collaboratively for reaching a consensus. Critical questioning in the stage of solving the uncertainty and reasoning in the stage of consensus were the impact factors of dialogic argumentation. By answering the critical questions, students changed their claims or suggested new claims by defending or rebutting previous claims. Students justified group claims with diverse argumentation scheme and scientific reasoning to reach a group consensus. These findings have implication for science educators who want to adopt dialogic argumentation in science classes.

• Journal of Environmental Policy
• /
• v.7 no.4
• /
• pp.105-134
• /
• 2008

Local opposition and protest constitute single greatest hurdle to the siting of locally unwanted land uses(LULUs), especially siting of high-level radioactive disposal not only throughout Korea but also throughout the industrialized world. It can be attributed mainly to the NIMBYism, equity problem, and lack of participation. These problems are arisen from rational planning process which emphasizes instrumental rationality. But planning is a value-laden political activity, in which substantive rationality is central. To achieve this goals, we need a sound planning process for siting LULUs, which should improve the ability of citizens to influence the decisions that affects them. By a sound planning process, we mean one that is open to citizen input and contains accurate and complete information. In other word, the public is also part of the goal setting process and, as the information and analyses developed by the planners are evaluated by the public, strategies for solutions can be developed through consensus-building. This method is called as a co-operative siting process, and must be structured in order to arrive at publicly acceptable decisions. The followings are decided by consensus-building method. 1. Negotiation will be held? 2. What is the benefits and risks of negotiation? 3. What are solutions when collisions between national interests and local ones come into? 4. What are the agendas? 5. What is the community' role in site selection? 6. Are there incentives to negotiation. 7. Who are the parties to the negotiation? 8. Who will represent the community? 9. What groundwork of negotiation is set up? 10. How do we assure that the community access to information and expert? 11. What happens if negotiation is failed? 12. Is it necessary to trust each other in negotiations? 13. Is a mediator needed in negotiations?

• Journal of Legislation Research
• /
• no.55
• /
• pp.57-94
• /
• 2018

Crisis of trust in Korean society, especially south-south conflicts among Korean political circle, civil society and peoples on the issue of the Korean peninsula policy driven by south Korean government, have weakened the sustainable and consistent energy of the policy for peace and unification of Korea peninsula. At the moment of drastic change of south-north relation in Korean peninsula, National agreement as a foundation of sustainable peace and unification policy has very important meaning. Because of this, national contract of unification as a kind of social concertation, has been demanded. National contract for peace and unification is an unprecedented process for making unofficial legal norm because it authorize quasi-legislative binding force on the agreement which is concluded by the Korean political circle, civil society and peoples for the peace and unification of Korean peninsula. National contract for peace and unification includes 'agreed aim and principles' for peace, prosperity and unification as well as process and result. And National contract for peace and unification, also is characterized long duration of aim achievement and openness of participating subjects. In terms of law, it will be legitimate source for comprehensive modification of international and internal law. In addition, The nature of National contract for peace and unification, as a people's law, should be considered as soft law which has the power to realize its contents through the enactment of legislation and policy. In order to guarantee the establishment and effectiveness of National contract for peace and unification, the setting of organization is need to determine the range of representatives, who participate in the process of contract making, procedure of contract and to carry out the contract after the conclusion of National contract for peace and unification. For the reason, the Council of National Contract for Peace and Unification as a independent administrative government committee and 'Act on National Contract for Peace and Unification' is needed.

• Communications of Mathematical Education
• /
• v.14
• /
• pp.61-70
• /
• 2001

수학은 추상적인 학문이다. '추상'은 몇 개 또는 무한히 많은 사물의 공통성이나 본질을 추출하여 파악하는 사고작용이다. 이렇게 추상된 것들을 모아 분류를 하고 그 다음에 이름을 붙이는 것이 바로 개념이 형성되는 과정이고 수학자가 수학을 하는 과정이다. 이 개념들은 여러 가지 모양으로 결합하여 스키마라고 부르는 개념 구조를 형성하게 되는데, 이 스키마는 수학적 사고를 하는데 매우 중요한 역할을 하여 수학을 개념적으로 이해하는데 도움을 주며, 새로운 지식을 얻는데 필요한 필수적인 도구가 된다. 본 논문에서는 연속적인 수열의 합의 공식에 대하여 학생들이 Skemp가 말한 '관계적 이해'를 할 수 있도록 스키마를 이용하여 문제를 해결할 수 있는 모델과 원주의 스키마를 이용한 생활 속의 문제를 제시하여 학생들이 공식을 암기하기보다는 수학의 구조를 파악하고 연계성을 이해함으로서 능동적인 구성활동을 유발하여 수학에 대한 흥미를 느낄 수 있도록 도움을 주고자 한다.