• 제목/요약/키워드: Si Dan

검색결과 70건 처리시간 0.033초

경추 경막외강 확인법의 비교 연구 (Comparison of Methods to Confirm the Cervical Epidural Space)

  • 옥시영;전혜림;백영희;김상호;김순임;김선종;박욱;송단
    • The Korean Journal of Pain
    • /
    • 제22권2호
    • /
    • pp.158-162
    • /
    • 2009
  • Background: The loss of resistance (LOR) method is most commonly used to identify the epidural space. This method is thought to rely on the penetration of the ligamentum flavum. Unfortunately the exact morphology of the ligamentum flavum is variable at different vertebral levels. Especially, it has been pointed out that the lower cervical ligamentum flavum may be discontinuous in the midline in up to 50% of patients. Thus, the LOR method may be inaccurate to confirm the cervical epidural space. The aim of this study is to determine which method is the safest and most exact for confirming the cervical epidural space. Methods: 100 adult, chronic renal failure patients who were undergoing an arteriovenous bridge graft for hemodialysis at the upper arm under cervical epidural anesthesia were recruited for this study. During the cervical epidural puncture, we identified the cervical epidural space by subjectively feeling the resistance with using a finger just through the ligamentum flavum, and we also used the drip infusion method, the loss of resistance method using air, and the hanging drop method. By using 5 grades, we classified the extent of whether or not the techniques were effective. Results: Using the drip infusion method, we identify the epidural space in all the patients as +/++ grade. The catheter insertion method was also successful in identifying those epidural spaces over a ${\pm}$ grade. The pseudo LOR was over ${\pm}$ grade in 47 patients. Conclusions: The combined LOR/hanging drop with drip infusion method is useful for confirming the cervical epidural space.

국내 양송이버섯 재배 중 발생하는 버섯파리류 분자생물학적 종 동정 (Molecular Identification of the Dominant Species of Dark-winged Fungus Gnat (Diptera: Sciaridae) from Button Mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) in Korea)

  • 윤정범;김형환;정충렬;강민구;권선정;김동환;양창열;서미혜
    • 한국응용곤충학회지
    • /
    • 제55권4호
    • /
    • pp.471-475
    • /
    • 2016
  • 버섯파리는 국내 양송이 균상 재배지에서 발생하여 버섯 균사와 자실체를 가해하고 간접적으로는 병을 매개하여 피해는 해마다 증가하고 있다. 부여군 세도면, 보령시 성주면, 용인시 남사면, 칠곡군 약목면 등 총 4개 지역의 버섯 재배사에서 끈끈이트랩을 이용하여 채집한 버섯파리 성충을 DNA barcoding 방법으로 Cytochrome Oxidase I (COI)의 염기서열 분석을 통해 종 동정을 실시하였다. 그 결과 4개 조사지역의 양송이에서 발생하는 버섯파리는 모두 긴수염버섯파리(Lycoriella ingenua)로 동정되었다.

라돈 우선관리 대상 지역 선정에 적합한 공간분석모형의 선정 및 활용에 관한 연구 (Study on the Selection and Application of a Spatial Analysis Model Appropriate for Selecting the Radon Priority Management Target Area)

  • 남궁선주;최길용;홍형진;윤단기;김윤신;박시현;김윤관;이철민
    • 한국환경보건학회지
    • /
    • 제45권1호
    • /
    • pp.82-96
    • /
    • 2019
  • Objective: The aims of this study were to provide the basic data for establishing a precautionary management policy and to develop a methodology for selecting a radon management priority target area suitable for the Korean domestic environment. Methods: A suitable mapping method for the domestic environment was derived by conducting a quantitative comparison of predicted values and measured values that were calculated through implementation of two models such as IDW and RBF methods. And a qualitative comparison including the clarity of information transmission of the written radon map was carried out. Results: The predicted and measured values were obtained through the implementation of the spatial analysis models. The IDW method showed the lowest in the calculated mean square error and had a higher correlation coefficient than the other methods. As results of comparing the uncertainty using the jackknife concept and the concept of error distance for comparison of the differences according to the model interpolation method, the sum of the error distances showed a modest increase compared with the RBF method. As a result of qualitatively comparing the information transfer clarity between the radon maps prepared with the predicted values through the model implementation, it was found that the maps plotted using the predicted values by the implementation of the IDW method had greater clarity in terms of highness and lowness of radon concentration per area compared with the maps plotted by other methods. Conclusions: The radon management priority area suggests selecting a metropolitan city including an area with a high radon concentration.

울산 산단지역 PM2.5 중 중금속 노출에 의한 건강위해성평가 (Health Risk Assessment by Exposure to Heavy Metals in PM2.5 in Ulsan Industrial Complex Area)

  • 정지윤;이혜원;박시현;이정일;윤단기;이철민
    • 한국환경보건학회지
    • /
    • 제49권2호
    • /
    • pp.108-117
    • /
    • 2023
  • Background: When particles are absorbed into the human body, they penetrate deep into the lungs and interact with the tissues of the body. Heavy metals in PM2.5 can cause various diseases. The main source of PM2.5 emissions in South Korea's atmosphere has been surveyed to be places of business. Objectives: The concentration of heavy metals in PM2.5 near the Ulsan Industrial Complex was measured and a health risk assessment was performed for residents near the industrial complex for exposure to heavy metals in PM2.5. Methods: Concentrations of heavy metals in PM2.5 were measured at four measurement sites (Ulsan, Mipo, Onsan, Maegok) near the industrial complexes. Heavy metals were analyzed according to the Air Pollution Monitoring Network Installation and Operation Guidelines presented by the National Institute of Environmental Research. Among them, only five substances (Mn, Ni, As, Cd, Cr6+) were targeted. The risk assessment was conducted on inhalation exposure for five age groups, and the excess cancer risk and hazard quotient were calculated. Results: In the risk assessment of exposure to heavy metals in PM2.5, As, Cd, and Cr6+ exceeded the risk tolerance standard of 10-6 for carcinogenic hazards. The highest hazard levels were observed in Onsan and Mipo industrial complexes. In the case of non-carcinogenic hazards, Mn was identified as exceeding the hazard tolerance of 1, and it showed the highest hazard in the Ulsan Industrial Complex. Conclusions: This study presented a detailed health risk from exposure to heavy metals in PM2.5 by industrial complexes located in Ulsan among five age groups. It is expected to be utilized as the basis for preparing damage control and industrial emission reduction measures against PM2.5 exposure at the Ulsan Industrial Complex.

The Prognostic Value of 18F-Fluorodeoxyglucose PET/CT in the Initial Assessment of Primary Tracheal Malignant Tumor: A Retrospective Study

  • Dan Shao;Qiang Gao;You Cheng;Dong-Yang Du;Si-Yun Wang;Shu-Xia Wang
    • Korean Journal of Radiology
    • /
    • 제22권3호
    • /
    • pp.425-434
    • /
    • 2021
  • Objective: To investigate the potential value of 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) PET/CT in predicting the survival of patients with primary tracheal malignant tumors. Materials and Methods: An analysis of FDG PET/CT findings in 37 primary tracheal malignant tumor patients with a median follow-up period of 43.2 months (range, 10.8-143.2 months) was performed. Cox proportional hazards regression analyses were used to assess the associations between quantitative 18F-FDG PET/CT parameters, other clinic-pathological factors, and overall survival (OS). A risk prognosis model was established according to the independent prognostic factors identified on multivariate analysis. A survival curve determined by the Kaplan-Meier method was used to assess whether the prognosis prediction model could effectively stratify patients with different risks factors. Results: The median survival time of the 37 patients with tracheal tumors was 38.0 months, with a 95% confidence interval of 10.8 to 65.2 months. The 3-year, 5-year and 10-year survival rate were 54.1%, 43.2%, and 16.2%, respectively. The metabolic tumor volume (MTV), total lesion glycolysis (TLG), maximum standardized uptake value, age, pathological type, extension categories, and lymph node stage were included in multivariate analyses. Multivariate analysis showed MTV (p = 0.011), TLG (p = 0.020), pathological type (p = 0.037), and extension categories (p = 0.038) were independent prognostic factors for OS. Additionally, assessment of the survival curve using the Kaplan-Meier method showed that our prognosis prediction model can effectively stratify patients with different risks factors (p < 0.001). Conclusion: This study shows that 18F-FDG PET/CT can predict the survival of patients with primary tracheal malignant tumors. Patients with an MTV > 5.19, a TLG > 16.94 on PET/CT scans, squamous cell carcinoma, and non-E1 were more likely to have a reduced OS.

국내 재배 베리류의 화학 조성 및 기능성 성분과 항산화 활성 (Chemical Composition, Functional Constituents, and Antioxidant Activities of Berry Fruits Produced in Korea)

  • 이용철;이집호;김성단;장민수;조인순;김시정;황금택;조한빈;김정헌
    • 한국식품영양과학회지
    • /
    • 제44권9호
    • /
    • pp.1295-1303
    • /
    • 2015
  • 국내에서 주로 재배되는 대표적인 베리류에 대한 화학 조성 및 기능성을 알아보고자 일정 시기에 수확한 오디, 블랙라즈 베리, 라즈베리, 블루베리의 pH, 산도, 유리당, ${\gamma}-aminobutyric$acid(GABA), 무기질 함량, phenolic compound, 항산 화 활성을 조사하여 비교하였다. 베리류 4종의 pH는 3.3~5.2로 블루베리가 가장 낮았고 오디가 가장 높은 반면, 산도는 0.26~1.10%(w/w)로 오디가 가장 낮았고 블랙라즈 베리가 가장 높았다. 베리류에서 검출된 유리당인 fructose와 glucose는 같은 비율로 존재하였고, 그 총량은 4.80~12.93%(w/w)로 오디가 가장 높았으며 블랙라즈베리가 가장 낮았다. GABA는 오디에 69.3 mg/100 g이 함유되어 있었는데, 이는 다른 베리류에 비해 3배 이상 많은 양이다. 베리류에 함유된 주요 무기질은 칼륨, 칼슘, 마그네슘이었고, 총 무기질 함량은 92.9~256.0 mg/100 g으로 블랙라즈 베리에 유의적으로 높게 함유되어 있었으며(P<0.05) 블루베리가 가장 낮았다. Total polyphenol과 total flavonoid 함량은 각각 198.2~547.2 mg/100 g과 5.0~94.6 g/100 g의 범위로 블랙라즈베리가 가장 높았고, 라즈베리는 유의적으로 가장 낮았다(P<0.05). Total anthocyanin은 19.8~385.6 mg/100 g의 범위로 블랙라즈베리가 가장 높았고, 라즈베리가 유의적으로 낮았다(P<0.05). Total PA(phenolic acids)는 블랙라즈베리와 라즈베리에 각각 14.0 mg/kg과 5.9 mg/kg이 함유되어 있었는데 이는 오디에 함유된 50.4 mg/kg보다 낮았으며, 391.4 mg/kg으로 가장 높게 함유된 블루베리에는 PA의 대부분이 chlorogenic acid였다. 베리류 4종의 항산화 활성을 DPPH 및 ABTS free radical scavenging activity를 분석하여 Trolox equivalent 값으로 나타낸 결과 Trolox equivalent antioxidant capacity와 total polyphenol, total anthocyanin, total flavonoid 함량 과는 유의적인 양(+)의 상관관계(Pearson 상관계수 r${\geq}0.85$; P<0.01)를 나타내었고, 블랙라즈베리가 DPPH 및 ABTS 항산화 활성이 가장 우수하였다.

흡즙성 및 저작성 해충과 거미류에 대한 imidacloprid의 살충효과 (Insecticidal effect of imidacloprid to sucking, chewing insect pests, and predacious spiders)

  • 최병렬;이시우;송유한;유재기
    • 농약과학회지
    • /
    • 제3권3호
    • /
    • pp.60-67
    • /
    • 1999
  • 흡즙성 해충과 저작성 해충 및 천적에 대한 imidacloprid의 살충력을 처리방법별로 조사하였다. 흡즙성 해충인 벼멸구에 대하여 imidacloprid의 미량국소처리에 의한 $LD_{50}$$0.015{\mu}g/g$ (48시간)이었으며, 유묘침지와 근부처리시의 $LD_{50}$은 각각 21.5 와 18.1 ppm을 보였으며, 처리간의 살충력 차이는 보이지 않았다. Imidacloprid 액제를 근부처리를 하였을 경우 20 ppm에서도 살란효과가 99%을 보였으며, 반수살란농도는 6.8 ppm이었다. 복숭아혹진딧물에 대한 imidacloprid의 $LD_{50}$$0.4{\mu}g/g$(48시간)이었으며, 엽침지처리와 근부처리 48시간 후 $LC_{50}$은 각각 1.9과, 13.7ppm으로 엽침지처리에 의한 살충효과가 높았다. 저작성 해충인 담배거세미나방과 파밤나방에 대한 imidacloprid의 $LD_{50}$은 1492.5이상과 $3125{\mu}g/g$으로 살충력이 낮았으며, 엽침지처리에 의한 $LC_{50}$은 각각 4803.3과 5000 ppm 이상을 보여 imidacloprid는 흡즙성 해충보다 저작성 해충에 대해 살충력이 낮았다. 배회성거미인 황산적거미(Pirata subpiraticus)와 턱거미(Pachygnata clercki)에 대한 $LD_{50}$이 각각 294.1과 $2976.3{\mu}g/g$ 이상으로 독성이 매우 낮았으며, 조망성거미인 등줄가슴애접시거미(Ummeliata insecticeps)에 대한 $LD_{50}$은 357.1 ${\mu}g/g$로 역시 독성이 낮았다. Imidacloprid의 거미류와 벼멸구간 선택독성은 각각 196,000 이상과 199,000이상 및 23,800이상으로서 독성이 벼멸구에는 높은 반면 거미류에는 낮았다.

  • PDF

기공학(氣功學) 발달(發達)에 관한 문헌적(文獻的) 연구(硏究) (A Documentational Study on the Development of Chi-Kung-Hak)

  • 김우호;홍원식
    • 대한의료기공학회지
    • /
    • 제1권1호
    • /
    • pp.13-59
    • /
    • 1996
  • Dep. of Classics &Medical History, College of Oriental Medicint, Kyung Hee University Today, many people are more interested Today, many people are more interested in preventing the disease than curing it. Chi-Kung(氣功) is the way of Life-Cultivation(養生法) peculiar to the orient, it is reported in china that Chi-Kung has an excellent curative value not only in curing the disease but also in preventing it. But the full-scale study of Chi-Kung is not be made up to now in Korea, so I studied the developmental history of chinese Chi-Kung through the oriental medical books. From this study, I reached the following conclusions; 1. Chi-Kung is naturally derived from the self-preservation instinct to adapt oneself to circumstances of the nature, but in the investigation from the documentational records, it is originated in the treatment method of the Sam-Huang-O-Jae(三皇五帝) period to cure the abnormal circulation of the vital force and blood caused by damp(濕). 2. As the principle and the method of the Life-Cultivation of the Chun-Chu-Jeon-Kook(春秋戰國) period were recorded in Huang-Jae-Nai-Gyung(黃帝內經) detailly and the remedy examples by ancient Chi-Kung such as Tao-Yin(導引), Haeng-Chi(行氣) were presented, we considered that theoretical basis of the development of Life-cultivation and Chi-Kung study was furnished in that period. 3. A famous doctor, Hwa-Ta(華引) lived in Han dynasty, researched the theory and practice of Tao-Yin transmitted from the former generations, as that result, he formed a kind of medical, gymnastics what is called O-Keum-Hi(五禽?). It is considered that 'O-Keum-Hi' is a Tao-Yin method developed more practically and systemetically than the Tao-Yin appeared in the 'Jang-Ja'(莊子) or 'Hoy-Nam-Ja'(淮南子). 4. In Wui-Jin-Nambook-Jo(魏曺南北朝) periods, the contents of Chi-Kung were more abundant under the influence of Buddhism(佛敎) and Taoism(道敎). Galhong(葛洪), the author of 'Po-Bak-Ja'(抱朴子) arranged the ancient Chi-Kung method systematically first of all, Tao-Goeng-Gyung, the author of 'Yang-Seong-Yeun-Myung-Rok'(養性延命錄) recorded the 'Yook-Ja-Geul'(六字訣) first time. 5. There is a new development of Chi-Kung therapy in Soo-Tang-Odae(隋唐五代) periods, especially So-Won-Bang(巢元方), the author of 'Jey-Bang-Won-Hwu-Ron' collected almost all of the Chi-Kung method, for curing the disease formed before Soo(隋) period. From that fact, we supposed that Chi-Kung was utilized more widely in curing the disease. 6. 'So-Ju-Cheon-Hwa-Hu-Peob'(小周天火候法) was adopted as the best orthodox approach under the influence of Nae-Tan-Taoist(道敎內丹學波) in Song-Keum-Won(宋金元) periods, especially in the song dynasty, 'Pal-Dan-Geum'(八段錦) was appearde and assignment of six-Chi(六氣) for bowel and viscera in the 'Yook-Ja-Geul'(六字訣) was decided firmly, that is to say Lung-Si(肺-?), Heart-Kha(心-呵), Spleen-Hoa(脾-呼), liver-Hoe(肝-噓), Kidney-chui(賢-吹), Three-Burner-shi(三焦-?). 7. In Myung-Cheong(明淸) periods, The general practitioner applied the principle of 'Byun-Jeng-Ron-Chi(辨證論治) to the Chi-Kung field, and after Myung dynasty the style of doing 'Yook-Ja-Gyel'(六字訣) was developed to the moving style. 8. Today, in china, the study on the Chi-Kyung is being progressed constantly under the positive assistance of government, Chi-Kung-Hak(氣功學) has taking its place as a branch of study step by step. It is considered that the establishment of Chi-Kung-Hak Classroom(氣功學敎室) and Medical Chi-Kung Center(氣功療法室) for special and systematic research are needed, at the same time the settlement of institutional system for training the Chi-Kung technician(氣功師) is also needed.

기공학(氣功學) 발달(發達)에 관한 문헌적(文獻的) 연구(硏究) (A Documentational Study on the Development of Chi-Kung-Hak)

  • 김우호;홍원식
    • 대한한의학원전학회지
    • /
    • 제4권
    • /
    • pp.19-73
    • /
    • 1990
  • Today, many people are more interested in preventing the disease than curing it. Chi-Kung (氣功) is the way of Life-Cultivation (養生法) peculiar to the orient, it is reported in china that Chi-Kung has an excellent curative value not only in curing the disease but also in preventing it. But the full-scale study of Chi-Kung is not be made up to now in Korea, so I studied the developmental history of chinese Chi-Kung through the oriental medical books. From this study, I reached the following conclusions ; 1. Chi-Kung is naturally derived from the self-preservation instinct to adapt oneself to circumstances of the nature, but in the investigation from the documentational records, it is originated in the treatment method of the Sam-Huang-O-Jae (三皇五帝 )period to cure the abnormal circulation of the vital force and blood caused by damp (濕). 2. As the principle and the method of the Life-Cultivation of the Chun-chu-Jeon-Kook (春秋戰國) periods were recorded in Huang-Jae-Nai-Gyung (黃帝內徑) detailly and the remedy examples by ancient Chi-Kung such as Tao-Yin (導引), Haeng-Chi (行氣) were presented, we considered that theoretical basis of the development of Life-cultivation and Chi-Kung study was furnished in that period. 3. A famous doctor, Hwa-Ta (華陀) lived in Han dynasty, researched the theory and practice of Tao-Yin transmitted from the former generations, as that result, he formed a kind of medical gymnastics what is called O-Keum-Hi (五禽戱). It is considered that 'O-Keum-Hi' is a Tao-Yin method developed more practically and systemetically than the Tao-Yin appeared in the 'Jang-Ja' (莊子) or 'Hoy-Nam-Ja' (淮南子). 4. In Wui-Jin-Nambook Jo (魏晋南北朝) periods, the contents of Chi-Kung were more abundant under the influence of Buddhism (佛敎) and Taoism (道敎). Galhong (葛洪), the author of 'Po-Bak-Ja' (抱朴子) arranged the ancient Chi-Kung method systematically first of all, Tao-Goeng-Gyung (陶宏景), the author of 'Yang-Seong-Yeun-Myung-Rok' (養性延命錄) recorded the 'Yook-Ja-Geul' (六字訣) first time. 5. There is a new development of Chi-Kung therapy in Soo-Tang-Odae (隋唐五代) pefiods, especially So-Won-Bang (巢元方), the author of 'Jey-Byung-Won-Hwu-Ron' (諸病源候論) collected aimost all of the Chi-Kung method, for curing the disease formed before soo (隋) period. From that fact, we supposed that Chi-Kung was utilized more widely in curing the disease. 6. 'So-Ju-Cheon-Hwa-Hu-Peob' (小周天火候法) was adopted as the best orthodox approach under the influence of Nae-Tan-Taoist (道敎內丹學派) in Song-Keum-Won (宋金元) periods, especially in the song dynasty, 'Pal-Dan-Geum' (八段錦) was appeared and assignment of six-Chi (六氣) for bowel and viscera in the 'Yook-Ja-Geul' (六字訣) was decided firmly, that is to say Lung-Si (肺-呬), Heart-Kha (心-呵), Spleen-Hoa (脾-呼), Liver-Hoe (肝-噓), Kidneychui (賢-吹), Three-Burner-shi (三焦-嘻). 7. In Myung-Cheong (明淸) periods, The general practitioner applied the principle of 'Byun-Jeng-Ron-Chi' (辨證論治) to the Chi-Kung field, and after Myeong dynasty the style of doing 'Yook-Ja-Gyel' (六字訣) was developed to the moving style. 8. Today, in china, the study on the Chi-Kung is being progressed constantly under the positive assistance of government, Chi-Kung-Hak (氣功學) has taking its place as a branch of study step by step. It is considered that the establishment of Chi-Kung-Hak Classroom (氣功學教室) and Medical Chi-Kung Center (氣功療法室) for special and systematic research are needed, at the same time the settlement of institutional system for training the Chi-Kung technician (氣功師) is also needed.

  • PDF

서울시 유통 원두커피의 품질 특성 (Study of the Characteristics of Roasted Coffee Bean in Seoul)

  • 조인순;홍미선;이은순;김시정;이용철;김성단;조한빈;김정헌;정권
    • 한국식품위생안전성학회지
    • /
    • 제30권3호
    • /
    • pp.236-241
    • /
    • 2015
  • 2014년 서울시에서 유통 되고 있는 볶은 원두커피 50건에 대하여 pH, 총산도, 납, 카드뮴, 카페인, 총 폴리페놀 함량을 분석하였다. pH는 4.72~5.25의 범위에서 평균 4.99를 나타내었고, 배전정도에 따른 pH는 약배전 4.85, 중배전 4.98, 강배전 5.07로 나타났다. 총산도는 평균 1.59%였으며 최소 0.72%에서 최대 2.25%였다. 배전정도에 따른 총 산도는 약배전 1.75%, 중배전 1.56%, 강배전 1.39%로 나타났다. 납, 카드뮴 평균 함량은 각각 0.0112 mg/Kg, 0.0011mg/Kg 이었으며 납 함량은 최소 불검출에서 최대 0.0535 mg/Kg 이었고. 카드뮴 함량은 최소 0.0010 mg/Kg 에서 최대 0.0069 mg/Kg 이었다. 배전정도에 따른 납 함량은 약배전에서 0.0690 mg/Kg, 중배전에서 0.0195 mg/Kg, 강배전에서 0.0129 mg/Kg로 나타났다. 카드뮴의 함량은 약배전에서 0.0005 mg/kg, 중배전에서 0.0017 mg/kg, 강배전에서 0.0032 mg/kg로 나타났다. 시료의 평균 카페인 함량은 12.29 mg/mL이었으며, 최소 0.51 mg/mL 최대 20.28 mg/mL의 함량을 나타내었다. 배전 정도에 따른 평균 카페인 함량은 약배전일 때 12.00 mg/mL, 중배전일 때 12.39 mg/mL, 강배전일 때 12.48 mg/mL을 나타내었다. 생산 국가별로 카페인 함량은 이탈리아 커피의 카페인 함량 평균이 15.58mg/mL로 가장 높게 나타났고, 미국산 커피의 카페인 함량 평균이 11.02 mg/mL로 가장 낮게 나타났다. 시료의 평균 총 폴리페놀 함량은 31.94 mg/mL이었으며, 최소 18.88 mg/mL 최대 43.90 mg/mL의 함량을 나타내었다. 배전 정도에 따른 총 폴리페놀 함량은 약배전 일 때 평균 함량이 34.60 mg/mL로 가장 높게 나타났고, 강배전일 때 평균 함량이 29.72 mg/mL로 가장 낮게 나타났다. 생산 국가별 총 폴리페놀 함량 평균이 37.75 mg/mL로 가장 높게 나타났고, 브라질 커피의 총 폴리페놀 함량 평균이 27.84 mg/mL로 가장 낮게 나타났다.