• Title/Summary/Keyword: Research Ethics Principles

검색결과 59건 처리시간 0.019초

Public Preferences for Allocation Principles for Scarce Medical Resources in the COVID-19 Pandemic in Korea: Comparisons With Ethicists' Recommendations

  • Lee, Ji-Su;Kim, Soyun;Do, Young Kyung
    • Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health
    • /
    • 제54권5호
    • /
    • pp.360-369
    • /
    • 2021
  • Objectives: The purpose of this study was to investigate public preferences regarding allocation principles for scarce medical resources in the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, particularly in comparison with the recommendations of ethicists. Methods: An online survey was conducted with a nationally representative sample of 1509 adults residing in Korea, from November 2 to 5, 2020. The degree of agreement with resource allocation principles in the context of the medical resource constraints precipitated by the COVID-19 pandemic was examined. The results were then compared with ethicists' recommendations. We also examined whether the perceived severity of COVID-19 explained differences in individual preferences, and by doing so, whether perceived severity helps explain discrepancies between public preferences and ethicists' recommendations. Results: Overall, the public of Korea agreed strongly with the principles of "save the most lives," "Koreans first," and "sickest first," but less with "random selection," in contrast to the recommendations of ethicists. "Save the most lives" was given the highest priority by both the public and ethicists. Higher perceived severity of the pandemic was associated with a greater likelihood of agreeing with allocation principles based on utilitarianism, as well as those promoting and rewarding social usefulness, in line with the opinions of expert ethicists. Conclusions: The general public of Korea preferred rationing scarce medical resources in the COVID-19 pandemic predominantly based on utilitarianism, identity and prioritarianism, rather than egalitarianism. Further research is needed to explore the reasons for discrepancies between public preferences and ethicists' recommendations.

새로운 간호윤리학 방법론;통합된 사례방법론 (An integrated Method of New Casuistry and Specified Principlism as Nursing Ethics Methodology)

  • 엄영란
    • 간호행정학회지
    • /
    • 제3권1호
    • /
    • pp.51-64
    • /
    • 1997
  • The purpose of the study was to introduce an integrated approach of new Casuistry and specified principlism in resolving ethical problems and studying nursing ethics. In studying clinical ethics and nursing ethics, there is no systematic research method. While nurses often experience ethical dilemmas in practice, much of previous research on nursing ethics has focused merely on describing the existing problems. In addition, ethists presented theoretical analysis and critics rather than providing the specific problems solving strategies. There is a need in clinical situations for an integrated method which can provide the objective description for existing problem situations as well as specific problem solving methods. We inherit two distinct ways of discussing ethical issues. One of these frames these issues in terms of principles, rules, and other general ideas; the other focuses on the specific features of particular kinds of moral cases. In the first way general ethical rules relate to specific moral cases in a theoretical manner, with universal rules serving as "axioms" from which particular moral judgments are deduced as theorems. In the seconds, this relation is frankly practical. with general moral rules serving as "maxims", which can be fully understood only in terms of the paradigmatic cases that define their meaning and force. Theoretical arguments are structured in ways that free them from any dependence on the circumstances of their presentation and ensure them a validity of a kind that is not affected by the practical context of use. In formal arguments particular conclusions are deduced from("entailed by") the initial axioms or universal principles that are the apex of the argument. So the truth or certainty that attaches to those axioms flows downward to the specific instances to be "proved". In the language of formal logic, the axioms are major premises, the facts that specify the present instance are minor premises, and the conclusion to be "proved" is deduced (follows necessarily) from the initial presises. Practical arguments, by contrast, involve a wider range of factors than formal deductions and are read with an eye to their occasion of use. Instead of aiming at strict entailments, they draw on the outcomes of previous experience, carrying over the procedures used to resolve earlier problems and reapply them in new problmatic situations. Practical arguments depend for their power on how closely the present circumstances resemble those of the earlier precedent cases for which this particular type of argument was originally devised. So. in practical arguments, the truths and certitudes established in the precedent cases pass sideways, so as to provide "resolutions" of later problems. In the language of rational analysis, the facts of the present case define the gounds on which any resolution must be based; the general considerations that carried wight in similar situations provide warrants that help settle future cases. So the resolution of any problem holds good presumptively; its strengh depends on the similarities between the present case and the prededents; and its soundness can be challenged (or rebutted) in situations that are recognized ans exceptional. Jonsen & Toulmin (1988), and Jonsen (1991) introduce New Casuistry as a practical method. The oxford English Dictionary defines casuistry quite accurately as "that part of ethics which resolves cases of conscience, applying the general rules of religion and morality to particular instances in which circumstances alter cases or in which there appears to be a conflict of duties." They modified the casuistry of the medieval ages to use in clinical situations which is characterized by "the typology of cases and the analogy as an inference method". A case is the unit of analysis. The structure of case was made with interaction of situation and moral rules. The situation is what surrounds or stands around. The moral rule is the essence of case. The analogy can be objective because "the grounds, the warrants, the theoretical backing, the modal qualifiers" are identified in the cases. The specified principlism was the method that Degrazia (1992) integrated the principlism and the specification introduced by Richardson (1990). In this method, the principle is specified by adding information about limitations of the scope and restricting the range of the principle. This should be substantive qualifications. The integrated method is an combination of the New Casuistry and the specified principlism. For example, the study was "Ethical problems experienced by nurses in the care of terminally ill patients"(Um, 1994). A semi-structured in-depth interview was conducted for fifteen nurses who mainly took care of terminally ill patients. The first stage, twenty one cases were identified as relevant to the topic, and then were classified to four types of problems. For instance, one of these types was the patient's refusal of care. The second stage, the ethical problems in the case were defined, and then the case was analyzed. This was to analyze the reasons, the ethical values, and the related ethical principles in the cases. Then the interpretation was synthetically done by integration of the result of analysis and the situation. The third stage was the ordering phase of the cases, which was done according to the result of the interpretation and the common principles in the cases. The first two stages describe the methodology of new casuistry, and the final stage was for the methodology of the specified principlism. The common principles were the principle of autonomy and the principle of caring. The principle of autonomy was specified; when competent patients refused care, nurse should discontinue the care to respect for the patients' decision. The principle of caring was also specified; when the competent patients refused care, nurses should continue to provide the care in spite of the patients' refusal to preserve their life. These specification may lead the opposite behavior, which emphasizes the importance of nurse's will and intentions to make their decision in the clinical situations.

  • PDF

고등학교 정보과학의 2015 개정 교육과정에 대한 분석 및 개선 방안: 정보윤리와 멀티미디어를 중심으로 (Analyzation and Improvements of the Revised 2015 Education Curriculum for Information Science of Highschool: Focusing on Information Ethics and Multimedia)

  • 정승도;조정원
    • 한국산학기술학회논문지
    • /
    • 제17권8호
    • /
    • pp.208-214
    • /
    • 2016
  • 인공지능과 빅데이터 기술을 기반으로 하는 지능 정보 기술에 대한 관심이 높아지고 있고, 미국, 영국, 일본 등 주요 선진국을 비롯한 세계 각국은 소프트웨어 산업을 중심으로 하는 제4차 산업혁명에 대비하기 위한 국가적 투자를 아끼지 않고 있다. 우리나라도 뒤늦게나마 소프트웨어에 대한 중요성을 인식하고 초중등 정보교과를 위한 2015년 개정 교육과정을 고시 하였다. 본 논문에서는 고등학교 정보과학의 새로운 교육과정을 살피고, 정보윤리와 멀티미디어를 중심으로 개선방안에 대해 제시한다. 고등학교 정보과학은 우리나라 과학기술을 이끌어나갈 전국의 20여개 과학고 및 영재학교에서 주로 적용되어 지고 있다. 정보기술의 의존도가 더욱 커져갈 앞으로의 인공지능 시대에 그동안의 역기능 중심의 정보윤리 교육과는 다른, 인공지능 시스템을 만들고 주도적으로 활용해나갈 과학영재를 위한 정보윤리교육이 반드시 필요하다. 또한, 실생활에서 흔히 사용하는 이미지와 사운드, 동영상 등의 디지털원리와 압축 기술을 중심으로 하는 멀티미디어 교육은 교육과정에 추가될 필요가 있으며, 컴퓨터과학의 기본 개념과 원리, 기술을 바탕으로 실생활 및 다양한 학문 분야의 문제를 창의적이고 효율적으로 해결하는 능력을 키우고자하는 2015 개정 교육과정의 목표를 더 공고히 할 수 있을 것이다.

아시안 에스닉 룩의 조형성과 미적가치에 판한 연구 (The Research of Visual and Aesthetic Values of an Asian Ethnic Look)

  • 권하진;김민자
    • 복식
    • /
    • 제56권6호
    • /
    • pp.114-131
    • /
    • 2006
  • An Asian Ethnic Look is based on its own values of traditional costumes and the fashion accessories that are influenced by its own genre within their own culture. In this thesis, it contemplates the study of visual values and the traditional influences of the Modern Western Designers and Asian Designers' definitions and the considerations of an Ethnic look in the countries like Middle East, India, Korea, China and Japan. The standard procedure to understand their Visual and Aesthetic values is acknowledgement of body. From that foundation, an Asian Ethnic Look and its Visual and Aesthetic Values were researched through out the Middle East Asian Look, Indian Look, Korean Look, Chinese Look and Japanese Look which effective after 1990's. The studies are further researched to the comparisons and interpretations of the Western Designers and the Asian Designers, and the definitions of an Asian Ethnic Look and its Visual and Aesthetic Values in between those. According to each country's religious attitudes, a beauty of concealment and a beauty of negative space appeal which emphasize an ethics on humanity and non-materialistic attitudes. It takes meanings of a phenomenon of nature's worship, Yin-Yang five elements of principles, oneness of body-mind and oneness of universe-mankind. Following the studies of Visual and Aesthetic Values of an Asian Ethnic Look, in 1990's Western Designers' interpretations were prominent use of the Asian Traditional Motif3. However, the interpretations of the Asian Designers were based on their own traditional ethics and they minimized decorative elements but enhanced naturalism, feminism, calm and sober designs compare to the past. The Asian Designers' interpretations of their visual values were based on their Asian mentality, beauty and its straightforward genuine perspective and respects of their own culture.

공학전공 대학생의 AI 로봇에 대한 윤리적 민감성 (Engineering Students' Ethical Sensitivity on Artificial Intelligence Robots)

  • 이현옥;고연주
    • 공학교육연구
    • /
    • 제25권6호
    • /
    • pp.23-37
    • /
    • 2022
  • This study evaluated the engineering students' ethical sensitivity to an AI emotion recognition robot scenario and explored its characteristics. For data collection, 54 students (27 majoring in Convergence Electronic Engineering and 27 majoring in Computer Software) were asked to list five factors regarding the AI robot scenario. For the analysis of ethical sensitivity, it was checked whether the students acknowledged the AI ethical principles in the AI robot scenario, such as safety, controllability, fairness, accountability, and transparency. We also categorized students' levels as either informed or naive based on whether or not they infer specific situations and diverse outcomes and feel a responsibility to take action as engineers. As a result, 40.0% of students' responses contained the AI ethical principles. These include safety 57.1%, controllability 10.7%, fairness 20.5%, accountability 11.6%, and transparency 0.0%. More students demonstrated ethical sensitivity at a naive level (76.8%) rather than at the informed level (23.2%). This study has implications for presenting an ethical sensitivity evaluation tool that can be utilized professionally in educational fields and applying it to engineering students to illustrate specific cases with varying levels of ethical sensitivity.

Introduction to International Ethical Standards Related to Genetics and Genomics

  • Yim, Seon-Hee;Chung, Yeun-Jun
    • Genomics & Informatics
    • /
    • 제11권4호
    • /
    • pp.218-223
    • /
    • 2013
  • The rapid advances in genetic knowledge and technology raise various, sometimes unprecedented, ethical dilemmas in the scientific community as well as the public realm. To deal with these dilemmas, the international community has prepared and issued ethical standards in various formats. In this review, seven international standards regarding genetics and genomics will be briefly introduced in chronological order. Critical reflections on them will not be provided in this review, and naturally, they have their own problems and shortcomings. However, a common set of the principles expressed in them will be highlighted here, because they are still relevant, and many of them will be more relevant in the future. Some of the interesting contents will be selected and described. After that, the morality of one recent event related to whole-genome sequencing and person-identifiable genetic data will be explored based on those international standards.

European Experience in Implementing Innovative Educational Technologies in the Training of Management Specialists: Current Problems and Prospects for Improvement

  • Tatiana, Voropayeva;Marina, Jarvis;Svitlana, Boiko;Hanna, Tolchieva;Nataliia, Statsenko
    • International Journal of Computer Science & Network Security
    • /
    • 제22권7호
    • /
    • pp.294-300
    • /
    • 2022
  • The article highlights the European experience of innovative educational technologies of training management specialists. Based on existing strategies, relevant in the European educational space, the introduction of regulatory elements to maintain a balance between the traditional and innovative format of the educational process, which is typical for the Ukrainian education system is proposed. The article aims to single out educational and technological innovations into a separate cluster of managerial training at different levels in the context of the principles of the modern synergetic sociocultural paradigm. The main objectives of the work are to develop settings to ensure the effective functioning of innovative educational technologies. Among the synergetic principles of educational technologies, providing the formation of necessary competencies of future managers, are: self-organization, interdisciplinarity, nonlinearity, individuality, and technologization. The methods used in the scientific study can be attributed to the group of scientific synergetic methodology. So, the training of specialists in management, implemented in the European practice assumes the use of new educational strategies. These technologies provide both the necessary skills of different levels (hard-soft-digital skills) and the observance of value components (solidarity, ethics, inclusiveness, openness).

Towards a Strategic Approaches in Alternative Tests for Pesticide Safety

  • Jang, Yoonjeong;Kim, Ji-Eun;Jeong, Sang-Hee;Cho, Myung-Haing
    • Toxicological Research
    • /
    • 제30권3호
    • /
    • pp.159-168
    • /
    • 2014
  • Pesticides have provided significant benefits including plant disease control and increased crop yields since people developed and utilized them. However, pesticide use is associated with many adverse effects, which necessitate precise toxicological tests and risk assessment. Most of these methods are based on animal studies, but considerations of animal welfare and ethics require the development of alternative methods for the evaluation of pesticide toxicity. Although the usage of laboratory animals is inevitable in scientific evaluation and alternative approaches have limitations in the whole coverage, continuous effort is necessary to minimize animal use and to develop reliable alternative tests for pesticide evaluation. This review discusses alternative approaches for pesticide toxicity tests and hazard evaluation that have been used in peer-reviewed reports and could be applied in future studies based on the critical animal research principles of reduction, replacement, and refinement.

학위논문에 사용된 여론조사 자료의 품질평가에 관한 연구 (A Study on the Evaluation for the Public Opinion Survey Data Quality Used in Theses)

  • 이해용;이인경
    • 한국조사연구학회지:조사연구
    • /
    • 제11권2호
    • /
    • pp.161-176
    • /
    • 2010
  • 본 논문은 학위논문에 사용된 여론조사 자료의 품질을 평가하였으며, 또한 학위논문에 사용되는 데이터의 품질평가 모형을 제시하였다. 데이터의 품질평가와 평가모형에 사용한 평가지표는 한국조사연구학회에서 제시한 조사윤리강령 제3조의 16가지 항목을 사용하였다. 연구결과 학위논문에 사용된 여론조사 데이터의 품질은 낮은 수준임을 확인할 수 있었다. 16개 항목별로 석 박사학위에 따른 유의적인 차이가 있는지를 확인하기 위하여 두 집단 간 비율 차이 검정을 실시한 결과 표집오차와 분석방법의 수에서만 차이가 있을 뿐 다른 지표에서는 차이가 나타나지 않았다. 끝으로 학위논문에 사용된 여론조사 자료의 질을 평가하기 위한 품질평가를 위해 9가지 주요 평가지표에 가중치를 부여하는 모형을 제시하였다.

  • PDF

AI 자동 뉴스 추천 서비스 사용자가 인지하는 정보 편향성에 대한 연구: AI 서비스의 윤리 원칙 수립을 중심으로 (A Study on Information Bias Perceived by Users of AI-driven News Recommendation Services: Focusing on the Establishment of Ethical Principles for AI Services)

  • 박민정;채상미
    • 지식경영연구
    • /
    • 제25권3호
    • /
    • pp.47-71
    • /
    • 2024
  • 오늘날 대중화된 AI 뉴스 추천 시스템은 개인화된 뉴스 소비 경험을 제공하여 뉴스 등 다양한 콘텐츠를 사용자가 소비하는 과정에서 효율성을 향상시킨 반면에 특정 관점의 정보만을 제공하여 사용자의 정보 편향성을 심화할 수 있다는 우려가 제기되고 있다. 이는 사용자의 다양한 정보 접근을 제한하는 동시에 특정 사안에 대한 올바른 시각의 형성을 방해하여 필터 버블, 에코 챔버 등의 사회적 문제 현상을 강화하여 사회적 격차 및 정보 불균형을 심화시킬 수 있다. 이에 본 연구는 AI 기반 뉴스 추천 서비스 사용자가 인지하는 정보 편향성에 미치는 영향을 탐색하여 AI 서비스의 윤리 원칙 수립을 위한 기반을 제공하고자 한다. 이를 위하여 AI 뉴스 추천 시스템에 대하여 사용자가 기대하는 책무성, 설명요구권, 선택권, 프라이버시 보호 지원의 윤리적 원칙이 사용자가 인지하는 정보 편향성에 영향을 미치는지 확인하였다. 이를 통해 AI 제공기업의 윤리적 원칙 강화 필요성을 제기하는 동시에 서비스 품질의 향상을 통한 사용자의 신뢰 기반 지속적 사용을 촉진할 수 있을 것으로 예상된다. 또한, AI 서비스를 설계하는 과정에서 우선적으로 고려하여야 하는 윤리 원칙을 본 연구에서 확인함에 따라 본 연구의 결과는 기업의 윤리 원칙 프레임워크 및 내부 정책 수립 및 국내 AI 윤리 가이드라인 등 관련 정책 수립의 토대가 될 것으로 판단된다.