• Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society
• /
• v.37 no.1
• /
• pp.353-373
• /
• 2006

The purpose of this study is to research the concepts of reading ability and debate ability, and the components of both abilities and to make the performance assessment's standards to apply them to the classroom for reading debate in the school libraries. For doing this, I studied the necessity of reading debate, assessment, and the components of reading/debate abilities. The components of the reading and debate abilities were derived from the theoretical researches and the performance assessment's standards for the reading debate were proposed in the viewpoint of the teacher librarians and classroom teachers in the school libraries in order that the teacher librarians and teachers could apply them to the reading debate classes and assess the performance achievement of the students.

• Proceedings of the Korea Information Processing Society Conference
• /
• 2005.05a
• /
• pp.1031-1034
• /
• 2005

사회생활을 통하여 직면하게 되는 다양한 형태의 문제들을 해결할 수 있는 사고력을 기르는 것은 교육적으로 매우 중요하다. 특히 남과 더불어 문제를 해결하는 능력이 가장 직접적으로 실현되는 사고 혹은 활동 형태는 바로 토론이다. 또한 토론을 통한 학습은 학습자 중심의 교수-학습 활동으로 교사와 학생 간, 학생과 학생 간의 대화를 활성화함으로써 달성하고자 하는 학습 목표를 학생들 스스로 성취 할 수 있는 길을 열어준다는데 교육적 의의가 크다. 본 논문은 기존의 웹 기반 토론 학습의 제약을 극복하는 것에 초점을 맞추어 웹 기반 토론 학습시스템을 설계하였다. 이러한 웹 기반 토론 학습시스템은 첫째, 원활한 토론 학습을 위하여 실시간 및 비실시간 토론 학습을 모두 제공해야 한다. 둘째, 토론 학습의 사회자 역할, 토론자 역할, 방청객 역할을 두어 과제 중심적 역할 유형과 사회성 촉진적 역할을 모두 실현할 수 있어야 한다. 셋째, 사회자중재를 위한 토론중단 및 토론재개 기능과 방청객 질의 응답 시작과 종료기능을 제공하야야 한다. 넷째, 기존의 웹 토론 학습을 위해 이용되는 게시판이나 대화방은 학습자 평가를 위한 기능이 없고 현장 적용에 어려움이 많기 때문에 웹 토론 학습시스템에 학습자들을 평가할 수 있는 자기평가, 동료평가, 교수자 평가 등의 평가 기능을 제공하여야 한다.

• Proceedings of the Korean Society for Cognitive Science Conference
• /
• 2002.05a
• /
• pp.99-104
• /
• 2002

본 연구는 의사결정과 성격평가에 있어서 컴퓨터를 매개로 한 의사소통(CMC) 조건과 면대면 조건간에 어떠한 차이가 있는지를 알아보았다. 4∼5명으로 구성된 17개 집단 각각은 CMC 조건에서 기여입학제, 면대면 조건에서 학부제에 대해 30분씩 찬반토론을 하였다. 참가자들은 토론 전 및 진행동안 매 8분씩 총4회에 걸쳐 개인 의사결정을 평가하였고, 토론 마지막 부분에서 집단의사결정을 실시하였다. 분석 결과, 두 조건 모두에서 집단의사결정의 극단화 현상이 나타났다. 면대면 조건에서는 집단토론이 이미 초기단계에서 개인들의 의사결정에 영향을 미쳐 더 극단적으로 변화시켰지만, CMC 조건에서는 집단토론이 개인의사결정에 어떠한 영향도 미치지 않았다. 또한, 각 조건에서 토론 후 자신과 타인에 대한 성격을 평가하였다. 그 결과, 두 조건 모두에서 자신에 대한 평가는 유사했으나, 다른 사람에 대한 평가는 면대면 조건보다 CMC 조건에서 더 부정적이었다. 또한, CMC 조건보다는 면대면 조건에서 나에 대한 자기평가와 타인에 의한 평가간의 일치도가 외향성과 지적인 측면의 교양 차원에서 더 컸다.

• Korean Journal of Cognitive Science
• /
• v.30 no.4
• /
• pp.175-197
• /
• 2019

Writing is an activity known to enhance higher level thinking. It allows the writer to utilize, apply, and actively expand the acquired knowledge. One way to increase writing activity in classroom setting is to use peer assessment. In this study, we sought to increase the accuracy of peer assessment by having students discuss about the scoring rubric or by referring to an expert's assessment. One hundred and fifty college students participated in the experiment. In the group that referred to the expert's assessment, the accuracy of peer assessment increased when the same piece of writing was evaluated; however, no such increase was observed when another piece of writing was assessed. On the other hand, in the group that discussed about the scoring rubric, the accuracy of peer assessment remained the same when the same piece of writing was evaluated, but increased when another piece of writing was assessed. Also, in the discussion group, the accuracy increased in proportion to the number of comments during the discussion. The results suggest that active and voluntary participation of students increase the accuracy of peer assessment.

• Korean journal of communication and information
• /
• v.22
• /
• pp.107-130
• /
• 2003

This study evaluated the debate formats adopted in the 2002 Televised Presidential Debates. Presidential Debate Committee have sponsored Televised Presidential Debates during the official campaign period. However, it is not easy task for the Committee to coordinate each party's different interests, such as voters, candidates, and broadcasters. Presidential candidates tries to use the debates as one of their campaign strategies. Broadcasters argued limitations in programming and production process. Regardless of the obstacles, voters expect that the committee makes ideal debate formats. The committee adopted two new forms in the 2002 Debates. The committee allowed direct exchange between candidates as well as advance question preparation by candidate. The committee intends that candidates focus on discussing policy issues. Some studies found that the debate format to allow direct exchange between candidates makes candidates focus on image issues rather than policy issues. The findings of this study are similar to the previous studies'. The new debate formats adopted in 2002 televised presidential debates did not guarantee policy issue oriented discussion. The committee or scholars should evaluate the debate formats used in the presidential debates in order to establish ideal debate formats that gives important information for votes to determine their choice. It is necessary to systematically evaluate the debate formats of former presidential campaign for developing right debate formats.

• Defense and Technology
• /
• no.6 s.124
• /
• pp.8-11
• /
• 1989

한국국방연구원(KIDA)이 주최하고 한국방위산업진흥회(KDIA)가 후원한 "방위산업 정책토론회"가 4월27일 한국국방연구원에서 성황리에 개최되었다. 이번 토론회는 1970년대 초반 태동된 방위산업에 대한 전반적인 평가와 전망을 진단하고, 향후 발전방향을 모색하기 위해 마련되었다. 총 4개 부문으로 나뉘어 진행된 이번 토론회는-제1토론 : 방위산업의 평가, 역할 및 전망, 제2토론 : 국방연구개발 활성화방안, 제3토론 : 군사기술이전과 국제방산협력, 제4토론 : 방위산업 육성정책등의 주제에 관해-각계 전문가의 발표에 이어 종합토론의 순서로 이어졌다. 이 좌담회 글은 Panel 토론자들의 토론내용을 요약 및 발췌하여 정리한 것이다

• Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society
• /
• v.35 no.3
• /
• pp.1-22
• /
• 2004

The students were instructed to prepare the materials for the reading discussion as they read books by the analytical reading, in order to make them know the efficient method of the reading discussion as activity of after reading. As the results, They understood the plot and substance of the book, comprehend the whole subject and selected the subject of the discussion better after they read books by the analytical reading than after they didn't. But it's not satisfactory to communicate their own ideas mutually during the reading discussion as before.

• Proceedings of the Korea Technology Innovation Society Conference
• /
• 2010.11a
• /
• pp.362-378
• /
• 2010

글로벌프론티어연구개발사업의 정의 및 개념을 소개하고, 미래도전과제 및 과학기술대안 후보 Pool 구축 방안과 사전기획을 위한 후보과제 도출 과정, 상세기획 추진방법론, 사업관리 프로세스 설계 및 국내에서 처음으로 시도된 토론평가를 통한 연구단장 선정 등, 향후 국가 대형 장기 연구개발사업의 기획 선정평가 방안을 제시함.

• Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association
• /
• v.16 no.1
• /
• pp.63-77
• /
• 2004

The purpose of this study was to construct an issue-centered discussion instructional model for Home Economics and to determine its effect on middle school students' critical thinking. The research questions were posed as below. 1) The object and content of home economics in the 7th national middle school curricula are analyzed to sort out possible issues. 2) An issue-centered discussion instructional model is constructed to be applicable to middle school home economics class. and a lesson plan is prepared. 3) The effect of the issue-centered discussion instructional model developed in this study on student critical thinking faculty is examined. The findings of this study were as follows : First. seven criteria were selected to determine what types of issues were applicable to home economics lesson. Based on the selected criteria. 41 themes of issues were extracted from the 7th middle school textbooks. and their content validity was verified. Second, an issue-centered discussion instructional model was designed to deal with four themes in eight sessions in the procedure of problem raising, confirming, term defining. tentative alternative selecting, data gathering. discussing/critical approaching. and selecting/concluding. Third, two different third-year classes of K middle school in the city of Busan that consisted of 75 students were respectively selected as an experimental group and a control group, and the experiment was conducted in eight sessions for five weeks to see whether the teaching plan brought any changes to the critical mind of the students. The experimental group exposed to the issue-centered discussion lesson made a significant progress in critical thinking faculty(P＜.05). In particular. that instruction gave a favorable impact on demonstration evaluating(P＜.05). one of the critical thinking subfactors. When the students were asked to assess the issue-centered discussion lesson. most of them viewed it favorably. In the future, more research efforts should be dedicated to enhancing the practical applicability of issue-centered discussion instruction in home economics education. developing good evaluation tools about critical thinking faculty and finding out how discussion instruction could be conducted more efficiently.

• The Journal of the Acoustical Society of Korea
• /
• v.27 no.5
• /
• pp.244-251
• /
• 2008

In this research, we propose an unsupervised debate indexing method using audio and visual information. The proposed method combines clustering results of speech by BIC and visual by distance function. The combination of audio-visual information reduces the problem of individual use of speech and visual information. Also, an effective content based analysis is possible. We have performed various experiments to evaluate the proposed method according to use of audio-visual information for five types of debate data. From experimental results, we found that the effect of audio-visual integration outperforms individual use of speech and visual information for debate indexing.