Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회지)

The Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Development of Site Evaluation Criteria for Woodland Burial Grounds

수목장림 입지 평가기준 설정 연구

  • Moon, Chang Soon (Dept. of Horticulture & Landscape Architecture, Graduate School of PaiChai University) ;
  • Lee, ShiYoung (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, PaiChai University)
  • 문창순 (배재대학교 대학원 원예조경학과) ;
  • 이시영 (배재대학교 조경학과)
  • Received : 2019.02.12
  • Accepted : 2019.05.16
  • Published : 2019.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The demand for National Woodland Burial Grounds is expected to increase as interest in natural burial, including woodland burial, is increasing. This study was performed to provide evaluation criteria applying weighting factors to the evaluation for location selection. Through literature review, location selection evaluation factors for forest facilities, similar to forest welfare facilities, were reviewed and analyzed. As a result of the analysis, 74 preliminary evaluation criteria were selected. Based on the results, three expert groups (public servants in central and local governments and other public agencies in charge of forest welfare facility, related field researchers, and civil experts) reviewed the preliminary evaluation factors. Evaluation factors were classified into two categories, 6 sub-categories, and 22 segments. The selected evaluation factors were layered for the second preference survey. They were classified into Forest Environment and Human Environment, and those categories were further classified into three categories. Then they were further classified into segments. After segmentation, the experts who participated in the first survey checked the differences in the significance of the layered factors by utilizing AHP. The site evaluation criteria table was prepared using the evaluation criteria and the significance of each layer. In order to apply it to the candidate sites, 10 sites including the existing National Woodland Burial Grounds and 9 candidate sites considered in the previous studies were compared and analyzed including Ulju County Ulsan City, Suncheon City Jeollanam-do and Janggun-myeon Sejeong City.

수목장을 비롯한 자연장에 대한 관심이 증가됨에 따라 국립수목장림의 수요는 증가할 것으로 예상된다. 수목장림의 입지 선정을 위한 평가요소를 마련하고, 가중치 적용을 통해 수목장림 조성에 도움이 되는 입지 평가기준을 제시하고자 다음과 같이 연구를 진행하였다. 선행연구를 검토해 다른 산림복지시설과 유사한 산림시설, 기타 시설들에 대한 입지선정 검토요소를 분석하여 74개의 예비평가요인을 선정하였다. 이를 토대로 3그룹의 전문가집단(국가 지자체 공공기관 산림복지시설 담당자, 관련분야 연구자, 수목장림 민간 전문가)의 예비평가요인 검토를 거쳐 2개 대분류, 6개 중분류, 22개 소분류의 평가요인을 선정하였다. 선정한 평가요인은 2차 선호도 조사를 위해 계층화 하였다. 먼저 산림환경과 인문환경으로 대분류하고, 각각 3가지 항목으로 중분류 후에 다시 한 번 각각 소분류하여 1차 조사에 참여한 전문가를 대상으로 AHP를 활용해 계층화된 요인별 중요도 차이를 확인하였다. 평가요인을 활용하여 입지평가 기준표를 마련하고, 각 계층별 중요도를 적용하였다. 이를 후보지에 적용하기 위해 기존에 운영하고 있는 국립수목장림과 선행연구에서 국립수목장림 후보지로 검토하였던 9개소 등 10개소를 대상으로 평가하여 비교 분석하였다. 평가 결과, 울산 울주, 전남 순천, 세종 장군의 순으로 나타났다.

Keywords

References

  1. Choi, J. Y.(2018) A Study on the Prioritization of Locational Elements of a Golf Course. Ph.D. Dissertation. Daejin University. Pocheon. Korea.
  2. Choi, Y. N.(2016) Development of Evaluation Indices for Locating Public Spaces and Facilities in Rural. Ph.D. Dissertation. Kyung Hee University. Seoul. Korea.
  3. Gwon, B. S.(2014) A Study on the Public Perception and Satisfaction Analysis of Tree Burials in South Korea. Master's Thesis, Kongju National University. Kongju. Korea.
  4. Hong, S. E. and S. H. Park(2003) Analyzing the location of urban neighborhood parks using GIS and AHP techniques. Journal of the Korean Geographical Society 38(5): 849-860.
  5. Jeong. S. K.(2017) A Study on Locational Determinants and Evaluation Model based on Railway Logistics Depots. Ph.D. Dissertation, Mokwon University. Daejeon. Korea.
  6. Jo, Y. B.(2010) A Study on the Development of Suitable Locations Evaluation Model and Therapy Type to Therapeutic Forests. Ph.D. Dissertation, Wonkwang University. Iksan. Korea.
  7. Kim, C. J.(2012a) A Study on the Classification of the Natural Funeral Landscape Facilities andIts Visual Preference. Ph.D. Dissertation, Paichai University. Daejeon. Korea.
  8. Kim, H. S., H. Y. Hwang and Y. U. Ban(2010) Evaluation model building and application for suitable locations reflecting recreation forest types. Journal of Korean Forest Society 99(1): 111-124.
  9. Kim, J. J., R. H. Yoo, K. C. Sung and E. Y. Youn(2003) Criteria for assessing suitability of green shower sites. KFRI. J. For. Sci. 66: 77-93.
  10. Kim. S. Y.(2012b) A Study on Prioritization of the Elements to Promote Private Investment into Tourism Development Projec. Ph.D. Dissertation, Dong-Eui University. Korea.
  11. Korea Forest Service(2015a) A Basic Survey on Forest Welfare. pp. 21, pp. 143.
  12. Korea Forest Service(2015b) A Study on Efficient Planning and Application Model of Woodland Burial. pp. 126-153.
  13. Korea Forest Service Notice(2018) No. 71.
  14. Korea Forest Service(2008) Master Plan of Forestry Culture and Recreation.
  15. Korea Forest Service(2011) A Study on the Improvement of Pre-Authorization Planning for Healing Forest.
  16. Korea Forest Service(2012) Manual of Natural Burials Creation and Operation and Management.
  17. Korea Forest Service(2014) Natural Burials Activation Plan.
  18. Korea Forest Welfare Institute(2017) National Woodland Burial Ground Resource User Survey.
  19. Korea Forest Welfare Institute(2018) Understanding Forest Welfare. pp. 31-33.
  20. Kyon, B. H.(2011) Research on The Effective Improvement Plan of Environment Friendly Funeral Culture, with the Natual Burials as the Center. Master's Thesis, Myongi University. Seoul. Korea.
  21. Lee, H. U.(2013) Positive Researchon Optimum Location Factor Decision for a Military Facility in Accordance with Changes of Governance Environment. Ph.D. Dissertation, Myongi University. Seoul. Korea.
  22. Lee, K. S.(1998) Study on the waste incinerator location problem in Seoul. Journal of the Korea Regional Science Association 14(1): 91-107.
  23. Lee, S. H.(2018) A Study on the Prioritization of Locational Elements of a Golf Course. Ph.D. Dissertation, Daejin University. Pocheon. Korea.
  24. Lim, Y. S.(2008) A Study on Planning Guidelines for Therpeutic Forests. Master's Thesis, Seoul National University. Korea.
  25. Ministry of Environment(2007) Resource Recycle Technology of Wastes Development of Decision Support System for Landfill Siting Using Optimization and Risk Communication.
  26. Ministry of Health and Welfare(2007) A Study on the Development of Natual Burials Model. pp. 100-102.
  27. Ministry of Health, Welfare and Family Affairs(2009) A Study on the Activation of Natural Burial Ground.
  28. Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs(2007) A Study on the Feasibility of the National Cemetery in Central Region.
  29. Moon, C. S. and S. Y. Lee(2018) Estimation of the Availability of National Woodland Burial Ground through GIS-based Limited Area Analysis. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 46(5): 36-43. https://doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2018.46.5.036
  30. Moon, C. S., D. S. Kim and S. Y. Lee(2018) A study on the process of creating new forest welfare facilities. Journal East Asian Landscape Studies 12(2): 41-50. https://doi.org/10.51549/JORAL.2020.12.2.041
  31. Nam, Y. S. and H. S. Lim(2011) A study for MICE multiplex location attributes which use AHP. Journal of The Korean Association of Professional Geographers 45(1): pp. 125-136.
  32. Park, B. J., D. G. Yeom, S. B. Kim, C. W. Kyeon, D. W. Joung, G. W. Kim and Y. H. Choi(2015) A study on the characteristic analysis for the facilities of the Korea forest welfare for life cycle. Journal of Korean Society of Forest Science 104(2): 285-293. https://doi.org/10.14578/jkfs.2015.104.2.285
  33. Park, G. C. and J. H. Song(2010) A Study on Regional Allocation Plan of Logistics Complex in Gyeonggi-do. Journal of GRI. Gyeong Research Institute.
  34. Park, S. H.(2013) Study Based on Facilities for the Composition of the Forest Healing Village. Master's Thesis, Chungbuk National University. Cheongju. Korea.
  35. Woo, J. W.(2013) A Study on the Improvement Plan based on the Preference Factor Analysis on Tree Burial, Ph.D. Dissertation, Korea University. Seoul. pp. 1-2, pp. 61-64.
  36. Yoon, Y. B.(2006) A Study on Development of an Assessment Method for Landfill Site Selection. Ph.D. Dissertation, Chonnam National University. Gwangju. Korea.
  37. http://luris.molit.go.kr/web/index.jsp
  38. https://gis.kofpi.or.kr/gis/mainServiceIntro/view.do#title1