• Title/Summary/Keyword: common facts

검색결과 120건 처리시간 0.022초

언론사로부터 전재 받은 뉴스기사의 댓글에 대한 포털의 작위의무 -서울중앙지법 2005가합64571 판결에 대한 비판적 고찰- (Portal's Liability for User Reply to News Article, Provided by the News Media -A Critical Analysis on 2005 GaHap64571 of Seoul Central District Court-)

  • 김경호
    • 한국언론정보학보
    • /
    • 제42권
    • /
    • pp.140-167
    • /
    • 2008
  • 이 연구는 포털 편집판에 게시된 언론사로부터 전재 받은 뉴스기사에 딸린 댓글의 명예훼손행위를 포털의 작위의무에 따라 판단한 서울중앙지방법원의 법리를 비판적으로 분석하고 있다. 편집판에 게시하는 언론기사의 진위를 포털이 확인하도록 요구하고, 그 기사에 대한 명예훼손적 댓글을 삭제하도록 발행자 수준의 작위의무를 강제하는 것은 결국 사적 검열로 이어져 정보의 유통과 표현의 자유를 제한할 수 있다. 이는 사적 존재인 포털을 검열의 주체로 재판부가 인정하는 것과 다를 바 없으며, 위헌적 요소를 포함하고 있다. 포털이 직접 관리하는 영역과 커뮤니티 관리자에게 위임된 카페와 게시판 등을 구분해서 작위의무를 판단할 필요가 있다. 단순 전달자 수준을 넘어서는 작위의무를 부과하기 위해서는 포털이 언론사로부터 제공받은 기사를 임의로 변경하거나, 내용 변경을 통해 명예훼손을 유도한 경우로 한정해야 한다. 더불어 포털이 언론사로부터 전재 받은 기사의 위법성을 알 수 있었고, 이를 삭제하지 않았다는 사실만으로는 공동정범이 성립될 수 없다. 결론적으로 전재 받은 기사를 적극적으로 변경하여 명백하게 명예훼손에 이르는 경우에 한해서 포털에 책임을 묻는 것이 '사적 검열의 강제'로부터 자유로울 수 있을 것이며, 온라인상에서의 표현의 자유가 보호될 수 있을 것이다.

  • PDF

이주 노동자의 구강건강관리에 따른 치주치료요구도 (Community periodontal index treatment needs in relation to dental health care of migrant worker)

  • 정명희;김주영
    • 한국치위생학회지
    • /
    • 제7권4호
    • /
    • pp.553-567
    • /
    • 2007
  • Migrant Worker are rapidly increasing in Korea since 1990. They are nowadays main sources of laborer groups engaging in medium-sized factories. The purpose of this study is to provide the basic information to establish proper oral health policy. Dental caries and periodontal disese are the most common disease that occur in the mouth. Periodontal disease is the most common disease in humans and the biggest reason for the loss of the teeth in the adult population. The CPITIN has been developed jontly by the international Dental Federation and the World Health Organization. CPITN is now an established index of level, of periodontal condition in populations for which specific intervention might be considered. This study was conducted to obtain the information regarding to CPITN of migrant workers located in Daegu, Questionaire survey was carried out for 289 workers from July 9 to August 8, 2006. Total survey was 289, 224 males and 65 females. The result was as follows: First, The number of nationality was 14. The first majority was China as 31.8% Among 14 nationalities were Cambodia 18.0%, Vietnam 12.8%, Sri Lanka 12.1%, Indonesia 7.3%, Nepal 4.2%, the other 13.8%, those who are aged from 20 to 29 were 43.9%, and salary from 1,000,000 won to 1,490,000 won 51.2%.(as for their residence, those who resided) over 3 years were 42.6% and not insured reached 68.5%. Second, more than 93.4% of the subjects need periodontal treatment, only 4.9% of non-smoker was health periodontal states, four times frequency of tooth brushing per a day was 16.7%. Third, 28.7% of migrant workers had experienced visit of dental clinic, and 22.9% had received treatment of decayed tooth. Fourth, It is difficult for them 65.1% of them to visit dental clinic in korea, the First was a communication problem and the second was time. Fifth, Most of them didn't have a oral health education but 85.1% of them said that they wish they attend oral health education. We conclude that the situation of migrant workers was very bad considering their working conditions, circumstances, and health condition. According to this study, more than 93.4% of the people need periodontal treatment. Besides they didn't have accurate knowledge about prevention of periodontal disease. Therefor our considering these facts, the policy of dental health by government should be established for migrant workers.

  • PDF

우리 나라 복식(服飾)과 서역복식간(西域服飾間)의 공통성(共通性)에 관(關)한 연구(硏究) - 삼국시대(三國時代), 통일신라시대( 統一新羅時代)를 중심(中心)으로 - (A Study on the Common Features of Western Clothing Style and the Style of Korean clothing - Focusing on the Three Kingdom and Unified Shilla era -)

  • 전지은;심화진
    • 패션비즈니스
    • /
    • 제5권4호
    • /
    • pp.127-143
    • /
    • 2001
  • This thesis looks into the characteristics and compares the clothing styles between the Three Kingdom to the Unified Shilla era. The purpose of this study is to see what common themes exists between the foundation of Korean clothing and how it has evolved and through see to what extent the Chinese influence has been to Korean clothing culture. Also by explaining the originality and creativity of Korean clothing, we will be able to make clear the status of Korean culture. These findings include the following; 1. The Korean strait line Gik-ryong Kyo-im can also be found at the Gochang region in the west. 2. The Ban-ryong-ui, worn by the aristocrats of the Three kingdom and Unified Shilla era, began to appear from the nobles from the Nam-Buk cho(South-north era). This combined with a Bokdu(headwear) became a part of casual dress wear. 3. Go(pants) became a traditional part of clothing for Unified Shilla and the west. 4. Ban-bi and Bae-dang, all forms of Bansu-ui ( short sleeve), came from Chinas Kucha and Hotan and came to Korea. 5. Chinas Pae-baek and Pae-za (Shawl) which is the same as Unified Shillas Peo was also to be found to have come from the west. 6. The way a different color line was added to clothing both can be found in Korean and western clothing. Similarities to material used are; First, expensive wool was used and mostly originated from the west. From far away Rome came the O-saek-gae (Five-color wool). Secondly, Kong-gak me (peacock feather) and Bi-chi mo were all originated from the west. Third, Sil-sil is stated in the Sam-kuk Sa-ki (Three Kingdom records) as being prohibited to be worn by Jin-gol women (Highest nobility during Shilla era) as headwear or comb (pin) or as a comb(pin) for yuk-doo poom ( 6th class nobility) women. Suggesting that it existed and other sources tell us that it came from Tashkent region of Russia and was a jewelry of some sort. From what we have seen above, we can see the similarities between Korean and western clothing cultures and that these interactions not only occurred with China but with many other nations. We can see that our ancestors were creative and original that when importing foreign cultures that they transformed them into a Korean style. That these foreign cultures were transformed into our own style is good evidence to these facts.

  • PDF

국내의약품의 약물상호작용 정보 분석 (Analysis of Drug Interaction Information)

  • 이영숙;이지선;이숙향
    • 한국임상약학회지
    • /
    • 제19권1호
    • /
    • pp.1-17
    • /
    • 2009
  • Adverse drug reactions (ADR) caused by inappropriate prescription are responsible for major socioeconomic loss. Drug-drug interactions (DDI) has been recognized as a major part of ADRs and, therefore, healthcare professionals should prevent possible DDIs to minimize preventable ADRs. This study aimed to examine DDI information in drug information references and Korea Food & Drug Administration (KFDA) drug labeling information. Drug ingredients from the formulary of Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service in Korea (HIRA) were included for the study. DDI information source used for the study were Micromedex Drugdex and Drug Information Facts (DIF) with the DDI severity level of "moderate" or more. The DDI information in KFDA drug labeling were collected and compared. Drug ingredients were classified with KFDA Drug Classification and ATC Classification of WHO for the analysis. Among the total 1,355 drug ingredients satisfying inclusion criteria, 738 ingredients involved at least one DDI, which was described in Micromedex and/or DIF. Drug Ingredients of 176 involved DDI only described in KFDA drug labeling, but not Micromedex nor DIF. Drug ingredients of 35 which DDIs were described in Micromedex or DIF did not have DDI based on KFDA drug labeling. Micromedex and DIF retrieved 7,582 and 3,071 DDIs, respectively 57.6% and 58.5% of DDIs were also described in KFDA drug labeling. Central nervous system (CNS) drugs, cardiovascular system (CVS) drugs and the antiinfectives appeared to have higher frequency of DDIs among all drug classes. The highest number of DDIs with high severity level ("contraindicated" or "major") were the DDIs of CNS drugs. The antiinfectives are the second drug group having serious DDIs. The DDI pairs of the CNS drug and the antiinfective had the highest contraindication risk (13.6%). DDI information from Micromedex and DIF were not consistent with the result that only 465 ingredients' DDIs are common in both literature (total DDI numbers were 715 vs 488, respectively). And 1,652 DDI information are common in both references among 7,582 vs 3,071 DDIs, respectively. Only 55.2% of DDI information in the database contained in the KFDA drug labeling. Prescribers and pharmacists should pay attention to the drugs for CV system, CNS and infections because of higher risk of possible DDIs compared to other drug classes. KFDA drug labeling is not likely to be recommended as a good information source for DDI due to significant inconsistency of information. Drug information providers should be aware that DDI information from different sources are not consistent and therefore multiple references should be used.

  • PDF

동지나해의 해황과 선망어장의 분포$\cdot$변동에 관한 연구 1. 고등어$\cdot$전갱이 어장의 분포 (Studies on the Distribution and Fluctuation of the Purse-Seine Fishing Grounds in Relation to Oceanographic Conditions in the East China Sea 1 . The Distribution of Mackerels and Jack Mackerel Fishing Grounds)

  • 조규대
    • 한국수산과학회지
    • /
    • 제14권4호
    • /
    • pp.239-252
    • /
    • 1981
  • 동지나해에 있어서 전갱이$\cdot$고등어 어장의 분포가 해황과 어떻게 관련되어 있는가를 구명한다는 것은, 이들의 어황변동기구를 파악하는 데에 아주 중요한 문제라고 생각된다. 그렇지만, 이제까지 동지나해에 있어서는 이들에 관하여 특정한 해역 혹은 기간을 대상으로 단편적인 연구는 있었으나, 해황이 어장분포에 어떠한 영향을 미치고 있는지에 대한 그 실태는 거의 알려져 있지 않았다. 그러므로, 본 연구에서는 우선 동지나해 및 일본해 서구에 있어서 대중형 선강무업에 의한 전갱이$\cdot$고등어류의 어획통계자료를 가지고 이들 어획양의 평균적인 분포(1968-1976) 실태를 상세히 검토하였다. 그 결과로서 다음과 같은 것이 명확하였다. 1. 1958율 이후의 '고등어류(주로 참고등어)'의 중요어장은 지나해 총면적의 약 $8\%$에 지나지 않는 일본해 (동해)의 사카이(경) 연안, 대마도 동쪽, 시라세(백광), 체주도 남서해에 이르는 대마난류역에 집중하여 있는 것이 밝혀졌다. 이들 해역의 어획양은 동지나해에 있어서 총어획양의 약 $70\%$를 차지하고 있다. 또한, 1968율 이후의 '전갱이'의 중요어장은 시라세, 대마도 동쪽, 오도 남서해에 집중하여있었으며, 이들 어장의 어획양은 동지나해의 총어획양의 $54\%$를 차지하고 있다. 한편, 어획중이 매우 적은 해역은 총해, 중국연안, 시마네(도근)현연안, 동지나해 중부 중의 냉수역 및 흑조외측, 동해의200m 이심의 해역이었다. 2. 대마난류역의 각 어장에서는 '전갱이$\cdot$고등어류'의 어획양의 년변동이 비교적 작고 어황이 안정되어 있었으나, 동지나해 중부 및 서부, 구개 남서안, 총해역의 어장에서는 어획전의 변동이 컸다. 3. 조경주변에 있어서 '전갱이$\cdot$고등어'의 분포경형의 상위가 수온의 상달와 잘 대응하고 있는 것이 분명하게 되었다. 즉, '전갱이'는 주로 대마난류의 조경역의 진수용(수온 $15^{\circ}C{\sim}20^{\circ}C$)에 분포하고 있었으며, '고등어류'의 분포 중심은 약간 냉수측(수온 $13^{\circ}C{\sim}16^{\circ}C$)에 위치하고 있었다. 금후는 동지나해 및 일본해 서부에 있어서 선망어업에 의한 전갱이$\cdot$고등어유의 어획양 분포에 대한 계절적 경년적인 변동, 특히 환경조건과의 관련을 파악할 필요가 있다고 생각된다.

  • PDF

국제항공법상 화물.수하물에 대한 운송인의 책임상한제도 - 미국의 판례 분석을 중심으로 - (The Limitation of Air Carriers' Cargo and Baggage Liability in International Aviation Law: With Reference to the U.S. Courts' Decisions)

  • 문준조
    • 항공우주정책ㆍ법학회지
    • /
    • 제22권2호
    • /
    • pp.109-133
    • /
    • 2007
  • The legal labyrinth through which we have just walked is one in which even a highly proficient lawyer could easily become lost. Warsaw Convention's original objective of uniformity of private international aviation liability law has been eroded as the world community ha attempted again to address perceived problems. Efforts to create simplicity and certainty of recovery actually may have created less of both. In any particular case, the issue of which international convention, intercarrier agreement or national law to apply will likely be inconsistent with other decisions. The law has evolved faster for some nations, and slower for others. Under the Warsaw Convention of 1929, strict liability is imposed on the air carrier for damage, loss, or destruction of cargo, luggage, or goods sustained either: (1) during carriage in air, which is comprised of the period during which cargo is 'in charge of the carrier (a) within an aerodrome, (b) on board the aircraft, or (c) in any place if the aircraft lands outside an aerodrome; or (2) as a result of delay. By 2007, 151 nations had ratified the original Warsaw Convention, 136 nations had ratified the Hague Protocol, 84 had ratified the Guadalajara Protocol, and 53 nations had ratified Montreal Protocol No.4, all of which have entered into force. In November 2003, the Montreal Convention of 1999 entered into force. Several airlines have embraced the Montreal Agreement or the IATA Intercarrier Agreements. Only seven nations had ratified the moribund Guatemala City Protocol. Meanwhile, the highly influential U.S. Second Circuit has rendered an opinion that no treaty on the subject was in force at all unless both affected nations had ratified the identical convention, leaving some cases to fall between the cracks into the arena of common law. Moreover, in the United States, a surface transportation movement prior or subsequent to the air movement may, depending upon the facts, be subject to Warsaw, or to common law. At present, International private air law regime can be described as a "situation of utter chaos" in which "even legal advisers and judges are confused." The net result of this barnacle-like layering of international and domestic rules, standards, agreements, and criteria in the elimination of legal simplicity and the substitution in its stead of complexity and commercial uncertainty, which manifestly can not inure to the efficient and economical flow of world trade. All this makes a strong case for universal ratification of the Montreal Convention, which will supersede the Warsaw Convention and its various reformulations. Now that the Montreal Convention has entered into force, the insurance community may press the airlines to embrace it, which in turn may encourage the world's governments to ratify it. Under the Montreal Convention, the common law defence is available to the carrier even when it was not the sole cause of the loss or damage, again making way for the application of comparative fault principle. Hopefully, the recent entry into force of the Montreal Convention of 1999 will re-establish the international legal uniformity the Warsaw Convention of 1929 sought to achieve, though far a transitional period at least, the courts of different nations will be applying different legal regimes.

  • PDF

공재(恭齋) 윤두서(尹斗緖)의 회화심미(繪畵審美) 고찰 (A Study on the Painting's Aesthetic of Gongjae Yoon Duseo)

  • 김도영
    • 문화기술의 융합
    • /
    • 제7권1호
    • /
    • pp.175-183
    • /
    • 2021
  • 조선 후기 해남(海南) 출신의 공재(恭齋) 윤두서(尹斗緖)(1668~1715)는 숙종년간 활동한 선비화가로서 조선 중기에서 후기로 교체되는 전환기에 조선 후기 사실주의 회화의 선구자로서 그 초석을 다진 인물이다. 그는 남인(南人)의 명문가에서 태어났으나 당쟁에 휘말려 출세길을 접고 서화와 학문에 몰두하였다. 조선 후기가 시작되는 18C는 실학(實學)이 대두되고 민족주의에 대한 자각으로 진경(眞景)시대가 열린 시기였다. 이러한 때 실학사상을 예술세계에 접목하여 실사구시적(實事求是的)이며 현실개혁적(現實改革的) 심미의식을 발휘하여 서민풍속화 개척, 서양화법의 적용, 사실주의적 기법 추구, 남종문인 화풍 도입 등을 도모하였다. 철저한 학고(學古)를 통해 변통(變通)을 도모했던 그의 회화관은 학(學)·식(識)의 학문과 공(工)·재(才) 기예적 요소를 두루 갖추어야 화도(畵道)를 이룰 수 있다는 형신(形神) 겸용을 강조하였다. 그는 다양한 화목을 두루 섭렵하였는데, 특히 인물화는 이형사신(以形寫神)의 사실주의 표현을 심미 특징으로 한다. 대표작인 「자화상(自畵像)」은 극사실적 묘사력과 구도의 혁신성이 탁월하며, 자신의 울분을 비장감있게 전신사조(傳神寫照)한 파격적 실험정신이 돋보인다. 그의 산수화는 형사적 진경과 신사적 관념을 융합하여 형상으로써 도를 아름답게 구현한 망적지적(忘適之適)한 이형미도(以形媚道)를 이루었다. 한편 개방적 사고로써 다양한 서민 생활을 소재로 삼은 서민풍속화는 이형사진(以形寫眞)의 실득(實得)으로 파격을 도모하였는데, 이는 부패한 권력에 대한 소극적 항거이자 애민정신의 표현이기도 하다. 이후 그의 화풍은 장남 윤덕희(尹德熙), 손자 윤용(尹愹)에게 가전되어 전해져 조선 후기 서화예술의 변화와 부흥을 선도하였다.

식민지 신문 '사회면'의 감정정치 -사회적 사실들의 정치적 서사화 (The Society Page of Newspaper of the colonized Korea, its politics of sentiment and modulation of social facts)

  • 유선영
    • 한국언론정보학보
    • /
    • 제67권
    • /
    • pp.177-208
    • /
    • 2014
  • 이 연구는 1920~1930년대 식민지 시기 신문의 사회면-사회적 보도가 정치적으로 부호화되고 해독되는 양식화의 메커니즘을 분석하고 있다. 민족국가와 정치부재, 그리고 주밀한 검열체제 하에서 신문은 비정치적 장르를 정치화하는 담론전략을 시도하며 사회면은 이 식민지적 맥락 안에서 정치적 언설로 구성되고 해독되었다. 이를 규명하기 위해 첫째 민간지의 사회면의 위상 및 편집방향, 둘째 사회면의 사회적 사실을 생산하기 위한 취재, 조직, 기자, 기사작법, 셋째 사회면을 둘러싼 신문과 기자의 부호화 전략 및 이에 공조하는 독자의 해독 규약을 분석했다. 사회면 또는 사회적 사실의 정치적 양식화는 객관적 사실보다 이면의 심리적 사실을 중시하고, 식민지 현실의 부정적 현상(現狀)에 주목하면서 운명공동체로서 민족적 비참을 형상화하며 뉴스를 극적 구조의 감정적 현실 서사(實事敍辭)로 구성하였다. 사회면은 민족공동체적 감각을 공유하고 유지하는 데 의미를 부여하며 이를 위해 민족적 감정을 동요하는 취재보도와 기사의 양식화를 이룬 것이다. 식민지에서는 모든 사회적 사실들이 정치적 문제로 환원된다는 점을 전제하면 사회면에 배치되는 사회적 사실들에 정치적 함의를 덧씌우기 위한 식민지 지식인/기자들의 전략과 전술, 의도는 식민지 저널리즘의 한 특수한 양상을 드러낸다.

  • PDF

잣나무 2-1 묘(苗)와 방크스소나무 1-1 묘(苗)의 생장(生長)에 미치는 밀도효과(密度効果) (Density Effects on the Size of 2-1 Korean Pine and 1-1 Jack Pine Nursery Stock)

  • 마상규
    • 한국산림과학회지
    • /
    • 제32권1호
    • /
    • pp.1-8
    • /
    • 1976
  • 잣나무 2-1묘(苗)와 방크스소나무 1-1묘(苗)의 생장(生長)에 미치는 밀도효과(密度効果)를 보기 위하여 광릉묘포(光陵苗圃)에서 잣나무의 경우는 $m^2$당 36본에서 324본까지 식재(植栽)하였으며 방크스소나무는 25본에서 169본까지 식재(植栽) 하였다. 실험결과(實驗結果) 묘고(苗高), 근원경(根元經), 건중량(乾重量) 및 규격묘(規格苗) 생산(生産)에 뚜렷한 효과(効果)를 보았다. 잣나무 2-1묘(苗)는 밀식(密植)시킬수록 수고생장(樹高生長)은 증대되고, 방크스소나무는 식재밀도구간(植栽密度區間)에 차이(差異)가 없었다. 잣나무와 방크스소나무는 밀식시킬수록 근원경(根元經) 생장(生長)은 감소되는 경향이 있으나 후자(後者)가 급격히 감소하고 있다. 잣나무의 평균목(平均木) 건중량(乾重量)은 밀식(密植)시킬수록 감소율은 낮으나 방크스소나무는 높다. 밀식(密植)으로 인해 일반적으로 T/R율(率)의 값은 증대되나 식재밀도구간(植栽密度區間)에 큰 차이(差異)가 나타나지 않고 있다. 평균목(平均木)의 잎 뿌리와 줄기의 건중량은 밀식(密植)시킬수록 감소되고 있으나 방크스소나무가 잣나무 보다 감소율이 높다. 그리고 잣나무의 경우는 줄기의 건중량(乾重量)은 밀식구(密植區)와 소식구간(疎植區間)에 차(差)가 적다. 밀식(密植)으로 나타나는 잣나무의 세장성(細長性) 보다는 방크스소나무의 세장성(細長性)이 더욱 높게 나타나고 있으나 밀식(密植)시킬수록 전체적인 물질생산량(物質生産量)은 증대되리라 생각 된다. 이상의 생장특성(生長特性)으로보아 잣나무의 이식상(移植床)을 만들때와 조림(造林)은 밀식(密植)시키도록 하고 방크스소나무는 소식(疎植)함이 효과(効果)적일것으로 생각 된다. 잣나무 2-1묘(苗)의 규격(規格)은 간장(幹長) 18cm 근원경(根元經)은 4mm로 개정(改正)시키고 $m^2$당 이식본수(移植本數)는 묘포비옥도(苗圃肥沃度)에 따라 160~200본(本)으로 함이 적합하리라 생각되며, 방크스소나무 1-1묘(苗)의 규격(規格)은 간장(幹長) 25cm 근원경(根元經) 6mm가 적합하며 $m^2$당 이식본수(移植本數)는 묘포비옥도(苗圃肥沃度)에 따라 100-120본(本)이 적합할 것이다.

  • PDF

새로운 간호윤리학 방법론;통합된 사례방법론 (An integrated Method of New Casuistry and Specified Principlism as Nursing Ethics Methodology)

  • 엄영란
    • 간호행정학회지
    • /
    • 제3권1호
    • /
    • pp.51-64
    • /
    • 1997
  • The purpose of the study was to introduce an integrated approach of new Casuistry and specified principlism in resolving ethical problems and studying nursing ethics. In studying clinical ethics and nursing ethics, there is no systematic research method. While nurses often experience ethical dilemmas in practice, much of previous research on nursing ethics has focused merely on describing the existing problems. In addition, ethists presented theoretical analysis and critics rather than providing the specific problems solving strategies. There is a need in clinical situations for an integrated method which can provide the objective description for existing problem situations as well as specific problem solving methods. We inherit two distinct ways of discussing ethical issues. One of these frames these issues in terms of principles, rules, and other general ideas; the other focuses on the specific features of particular kinds of moral cases. In the first way general ethical rules relate to specific moral cases in a theoretical manner, with universal rules serving as "axioms" from which particular moral judgments are deduced as theorems. In the seconds, this relation is frankly practical. with general moral rules serving as "maxims", which can be fully understood only in terms of the paradigmatic cases that define their meaning and force. Theoretical arguments are structured in ways that free them from any dependence on the circumstances of their presentation and ensure them a validity of a kind that is not affected by the practical context of use. In formal arguments particular conclusions are deduced from("entailed by") the initial axioms or universal principles that are the apex of the argument. So the truth or certainty that attaches to those axioms flows downward to the specific instances to be "proved". In the language of formal logic, the axioms are major premises, the facts that specify the present instance are minor premises, and the conclusion to be "proved" is deduced (follows necessarily) from the initial presises. Practical arguments, by contrast, involve a wider range of factors than formal deductions and are read with an eye to their occasion of use. Instead of aiming at strict entailments, they draw on the outcomes of previous experience, carrying over the procedures used to resolve earlier problems and reapply them in new problmatic situations. Practical arguments depend for their power on how closely the present circumstances resemble those of the earlier precedent cases for which this particular type of argument was originally devised. So. in practical arguments, the truths and certitudes established in the precedent cases pass sideways, so as to provide "resolutions" of later problems. In the language of rational analysis, the facts of the present case define the gounds on which any resolution must be based; the general considerations that carried wight in similar situations provide warrants that help settle future cases. So the resolution of any problem holds good presumptively; its strengh depends on the similarities between the present case and the prededents; and its soundness can be challenged (or rebutted) in situations that are recognized ans exceptional. Jonsen & Toulmin (1988), and Jonsen (1991) introduce New Casuistry as a practical method. The oxford English Dictionary defines casuistry quite accurately as "that part of ethics which resolves cases of conscience, applying the general rules of religion and morality to particular instances in which circumstances alter cases or in which there appears to be a conflict of duties." They modified the casuistry of the medieval ages to use in clinical situations which is characterized by "the typology of cases and the analogy as an inference method". A case is the unit of analysis. The structure of case was made with interaction of situation and moral rules. The situation is what surrounds or stands around. The moral rule is the essence of case. The analogy can be objective because "the grounds, the warrants, the theoretical backing, the modal qualifiers" are identified in the cases. The specified principlism was the method that Degrazia (1992) integrated the principlism and the specification introduced by Richardson (1990). In this method, the principle is specified by adding information about limitations of the scope and restricting the range of the principle. This should be substantive qualifications. The integrated method is an combination of the New Casuistry and the specified principlism. For example, the study was "Ethical problems experienced by nurses in the care of terminally ill patients"(Um, 1994). A semi-structured in-depth interview was conducted for fifteen nurses who mainly took care of terminally ill patients. The first stage, twenty one cases were identified as relevant to the topic, and then were classified to four types of problems. For instance, one of these types was the patient's refusal of care. The second stage, the ethical problems in the case were defined, and then the case was analyzed. This was to analyze the reasons, the ethical values, and the related ethical principles in the cases. Then the interpretation was synthetically done by integration of the result of analysis and the situation. The third stage was the ordering phase of the cases, which was done according to the result of the interpretation and the common principles in the cases. The first two stages describe the methodology of new casuistry, and the final stage was for the methodology of the specified principlism. The common principles were the principle of autonomy and the principle of caring. The principle of autonomy was specified; when competent patients refused care, nurse should discontinue the care to respect for the patients' decision. The principle of caring was also specified; when the competent patients refused care, nurses should continue to provide the care in spite of the patients' refusal to preserve their life. These specification may lead the opposite behavior, which emphasizes the importance of nurse's will and intentions to make their decision in the clinical situations.

  • PDF