• 제목/요약/키워드: Types of context problems

검색결과 92건 처리시간 0.027초

대처 개념의 국내 간호연구 분석 (Analysis of Nursing Studies of Coping Conducted in Korea from 1978 to 1995)

  • 소향숙;조복희;홍미순
    • 대한간호학회지
    • /
    • 제26권3호
    • /
    • pp.709-729
    • /
    • 1996
  • This study was done to analyze the trends of research on coping in Korea, to suggest future direction, for research on coping, and ultimately to contribute to an increase in explanation of adaptation. This article reviewed 79 nursing research papers on coping done since 1978 by examining them according to the period of publication or presentation, research design, type of subjects, measurement instruments, research for a degree or not, range of reliability, and association of coping and related variables. The results are as follows : The number of studies on coping increased rapidly from the mid-1980's and decreased slowly from the mid-1990's. The maority of the studies were surveys, comparative studies, or correlational studies. The subects of the 46 studies were healthy people, while those in the remaining studies were patients with a variety of illnesses. Thirth-eight studies on coping were done for master's thesis, three for dissertion, and 38 were not degrees. The Bell and Jalowiec coping scales have not been used since the early 1990's. In contrast, Lazarus and Folkman's W.C.C.L. has been used increasingly since that time. The reliabilities of the coping scale were reported in 37 cases and the Cronbach's alpha coefficients were .71 to .86. All subjects reported using more problem-oriented coping than emotion-oriented coping in short-term or emotion-oriented coping and healthy groups did more long-term coping. It was difficult to describe consistently the relationship between stress and coping according to the type of coping scale or research subjects, but generally moderate relationships were found. This was due to instrumental problems and no consideration of situational context. The subject group who used more short-term coping and less long-term coping reported poorer mental status, and higher scores in burnout and state anxiey than others. That is, the relationship between stress and adaptation increased the power of explanation with intervening the mediating effect of coping. The association of locus of control, mastery, social support, and self-concept with coping showed positive relationships : those of uncertainty and severity in illness with coping showed negativerelationships ; those of state anxiety and depression with short-term coping were positive, and those of self-esteem with long-term coping or problem-oriented coping were negative. There were significant differences in the scores of types of coping according to religion, level of education, and socio-economic status. That is, Presbyterians and Catholics, those with higher education levels and higher socio-economic status used more long-term or problem-oriented coping. On the basis of the above findings the following recommendations are made : 1. There is a need to test the mediating effect of coping variable in order to clarify the concept. 2. Longitudinal studies are needed to determine the patterns of change in coping strategies when stressful events are encountered. 3. It's necessary to develop a reliable and variable measurement tool for coping. 4. There is a need to identify subscales of coping to increase explanation of variance 5. It's necessary to consider personal, situational, and antecedent variables : the characteristics of subject populations, the natures of illness and treatment situations. 6. The power of explanation of studies designed to identify the stress-adaptation process should be increased using the combination model of process-oriented coping and cognitive-structural model.

  • PDF

초등학생의 부력 개념 형성과 인지 수준의 관계 (Elementary School Students형 Conceptions of Buoyance related with Cognitive Levels)

  • 권도현;권성기
    • 한국초등과학교육학회지:초등과학교육
    • /
    • 제19권1호
    • /
    • pp.131-143
    • /
    • 2000
  • The unit of a buoyant force included in the 7th national science curriculum for 6th grade students. On the contrary, it seldom that students' conception about buoyant phenomena is studied, even though there has been many studies of students' conceptions of basic science contents. The purpose of this study was to survey the elementary school students' conceptions of a buoyant force, to analyze their cognitive levels, and to explore the relationships between them. Sixth grade students (total numbers is 192) were selected .from 5 .lasses in two elementary schools in a local city of Kyungsangdo. They were asked to respond two kinds of test, which are the Logical Thinking Ability (GALT) to investigate students' cognitive levels and the Buoyant Force Questionnaire (BFQ). We developed BFQ test, based on the 7th national science curriculum for 6th grade and the previous researches of a buoyant force. We, qualitatively, analysed students' frequency of responses about a buoyant force and their types of explanation, and, quantitatively, analysed the relationships between cognitive levels and conceptions of a buoyant force with SPSS/ PC 7.0 programmes. The results of cognitive level showed that half of 6th grade students were in the concrete operational stage, 43.2% in the transitional stage, 6.8% in the formal stage. However, their sub-logical thinking abilities in a combinational, conservational, controlling variables, proportional, probability and correlational logic were very fluctuated from 91% to 8%. The results that only 4.8% of elementary students had correct conceptions of a buoyant force suggest that 6th grade students had great difficulties in understanding of that concept. Their difficulties would originated from the frequent common-sense explanations of a buoyant phenomena in terms of the weight or the unique properties or the contact area of an object or with/without air. Furthermore students' explanations, frequently, changed with context of problems of a buoyant force. Scheffe test of quantitative results that elementary students in the concrete level had 50.6% of concept formation in a buoyant force, the transitional level 54.5%, and in the formal operational level 62.8% showed significant differences of conceptions of a buoyant force with cognitive levels. Therefore the concrete operational elementary students had more difficulties of understanding of a buoyant force than the transitional and formal level, which is required to higher cognitive levels. This conclusion have implications that the unit of a buoyant force have to be presented with concrete activities for majority of students who are in concrete and transitional levels.

  • PDF

아파트 단지의 보행효율성에 관한 연구 - 단지 내 보행로를 중심으로 - (An Study of Pedestrian Efficiency in Apartment Complexes - Focused on Pedestrian Path in Apartment Complexes -)

  • 양동우;유상균
    • 대한건축학회논문집:계획계
    • /
    • 제34권11호
    • /
    • pp.85-94
    • /
    • 2018
  • This study aims to investigate how easy pedestrians get around within/through the "Apartment Complexes (AC), " a common style of high-rise multi-family housing in Korea. Over the past six decades, the AC has been the most conventional way to provide standardized housing efficiently to address the problems of the shortage of housing and the substandard housing, due to the explosion of urban population with the rapid industrialization. The AC is a huge chunk of homeogenous multi-family housing, mostly condos with decent infrastructure, including parks, pedestrian passages, schools, ect. Both in the new town development and urban renewal programs have utilized the advantages of the AC. Since the design principals of AC tend to adopt the "protective design" to prevent cars and pedestrians coming outside from passing it, it has been criticised for dissecting the continuity of socioeconomic context in neighborhoods. The neo-traditional planning urbanists, including Jane Jacobs, emphasize that smaller blocks and grid road newtworks are the key in improving social, cultural, and economic vitality of the neighborhoods, because these design concepts allow more pedestrians and different types of people to be mixed in a neighborhood. In this study, we first adopted objective measures for pedestrian accessibility and pedestrian efficiency. These measures were used to calculate the lengths of shortest paths from residential buildings to the edges of AC. We tested the difference in shortest paths between the current pedestrian networks of AC and hypothetical grid networks on the AC, and the relative difference is considered as the pedestrian efficiency, using the network analysis function of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and Python programming. We found from the randomly selected 30 ACs that the existing non-grid road networks in ACs are worse than the hypothesized grid networks, in terms of pedestrian efficiency. In average, pedestrians in AC with the conventional road networks have to walk than 25%, 26%, and 27% longer than the networks of $125{\times}45m$, $100{\times}45m$, and $75{\times}45m$, respectively. With the t-test analysis, we found the pedestrian efficiency of AC with the conventional network is lower than grid-networks. Many new urbanists stress, easiness of walking is one of the most import elements for community building and social bonds. With the findings from the objective measures of pedestrian accessibility and efficiency, the AC would have limitations to attract people outside into the AC itself, which would increase dis-connectivity with adjacent areas.

민간공원 관련 제도의 변천과 경로의존성 - 1967년부터 2005년까지 도시공원 법령을 중심으로 - (Institutional Changes and Path Dependence to Private Parks - Focused on the Urban Park-Related Laws from 1967~2005 -)

  • 오창송
    • 한국조경학회지
    • /
    • 제47권2호
    • /
    • pp.133-145
    • /
    • 2019
  • 본 연구는 우리나라 민간공원과 관련된 문제점이 지속할 수 있었던 이유를 밝히고자 하는 필요성에서 제기되었다. 그리고 근본적인 원인을 파악하기 위해서는 민간공원의 역사와 제도적 맥락을 분석하는 것이 요구된다. 따라서 본 연구의 목적은 민간공원 제도의 변천 방향을 파악하고, 그 규칙으로 나타나는 제도의 특성을 도출하는 것이다. 역사적 제도주의 분석에 기초한 본 연구의 틀은 공원법(1967~1980년), 전기 도시공원법(1980~1993년)과 후기 도시공원법(1993~2005년)으로 시대구분을 하였고, 제도 환경과 작동 결과를 분석 요소로 설정하였다. 분석 내용은 환경의 변화에도 불구하고, 제도선택에 대한 관성적 경향이 지속된다는 우리나라 민간공원 제도의 경로의존성을 해석하였다. 본 제도는 '예외규제방식'이라는 특별한 형태를 취하였고, 공원시설 종류의 확대와 기준을 완화하여 수익성을 확보하였다. 그리고 사업자를 토지소유자로 한정한 것은 민간공원을 미집행 도시공원에 대한 재산권 보상 수단으로 작용하였다. 그 결과 도시공원 조성에 미친 기대 효과는 미흡하였고, 도시공원의 환경적 규제 기능은 약화되었다. 역사적으로 우리나라의 민간공원 제도는 제도의 취지와 시행 결과가 일치하지 않은 '제도적 디커플링'이 지속되었다고 볼 수 있다.

터널 지보구조 진단을 위한 초음파 스윕 발생원의 반사법 응용 가능성 연구 - 모형실험을 중심으로 - (Study on the Applicability of Reflection Method using Ultrasonic Sweep Source for the Inspection of Tunnel Lining Structure - Physical Modeling Approach -)

  • 김중열;김유성;신용석;현혜자
    • 한국지반공학회:학술대회논문집
    • /
    • 한국지반공학회 2001년도 봄 학술발표회 논문집
    • /
    • pp.167-174
    • /
    • 2001
  • Reflection method using ultrasonic source has been attempted to obtain the information about tunnel lining structures composed of lining, shotcrete, water barrier and voids at the back of lining. In this work, two different types of sources, i.e. single-pulse source and sweep source, can be used. Single-pulse source with short time duration has the frequency content whose amplitudes tend to be concentrated around the dominant frequency, whereas sweep source with long time duration denotes a flat distribution of relatively larger amplitude over a broad frequency band, although the peak to peak amplitude of single-pulse source wavelet is equivalent to that of sweep source one. In traditional seismic application, a single-pulse source(weight drop, dynamite) is typically used. However, to investigate the fine structure, as it is the case in the tunnel lining structure, the sweep wavelet can be also a desirable source waveform primarily due to the higher energy over a broad frequency band. For the investigation purposes of sweep source, a physical modeling is a useful tool, especially to study problems of wave propagation in the fine layered media. The main purpose of this work was using a physical modeling technique to explore the applicability of sweep source to the delineation of inner layer boundaries. To this end, a two-dimensional physical model analogous to the lining structure was built and a special ultrasonic sweep source was devised. The measurements were carried out in the sweep frequency range 10 ∼ 60 KHz, as peformed in the regular reflection survey(e.g. roll-along technique). The measured data were further rearranged with a proper software (cross-correlation). The resulting seismograms(raw data) showed quitely similar features to those from a single-pulse source, in which high frequency content of reflection events could be considerably emphasized, as expected. The data were further processed by using a regular data processing system "FOCUS" and the results(stack section) were well associated with the known model structure. In this context, it is worthy to note that in view of measuring condition the sweep source would be applied to benefit the penetration of high frequency energy into the media and to enhance the resolution of reflection events.

  • PDF

지속적 관여도 및 인지된 위험이 소비자의 온라인 상인선택 프로세스에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구: 요구신뢰 수준 개념을 중심으로 (How Enduring Product Involvement and Perceived Risk Affect Consumers' Online Merchant Selection Process: The 'Required Trust Level' Perspective)

  • 홍일유;이정민;조휘형
    • Asia pacific journal of information systems
    • /
    • 제22권1호
    • /
    • pp.29-52
    • /
    • 2012
  • Consumers differ in the way they make a purchase. An audio mania would willingly make a bold, yet serious, decision to buy a top-of-the-line home theater system, while he is not interested in replacing his two-decade-old shabby car. On the contrary, an automobile enthusiast wouldn't mind spending forty thousand dollars to buy a new Jaguar convertible, yet cares little about his junky component system. It is product involvement that helps us explain such differences among individuals in the purchase style. Product involvement refers to the extent to which a product is perceived to be important to a consumer (Zaichkowsky, 2001). Product involvement is an important factor that strongly influences consumer's purchase decision-making process, and thus has been of prime interest to consumer behavior researchers. Furthermore, researchers found that involvement is closely related to perceived risk (Dholakia, 2001). While abundant research exists addressing how product involvement relates to overall perceived risk, little attention has been paid to the relationship between involvement and different types of perceived risk in an electronic commerce setting. Given that perceived risk can be a substantial barrier to the online purchase (Jarvenpaa, 2000), research addressing such an issue will offer useful implications on what specific types of perceived risk an online firm should focus on mitigating if it is to increase sales to a fullest potential. Meanwhile, past research has focused on such consumer responses as information search and dissemination as a consequence of involvement, neglecting other behavioral responses like online merchant selection. For one example, will a consumer seriously considering the purchase of a pricey Guzzi bag perceive a great degree of risk associated with online buying and therefore choose to buy it from a digital storefront rather than from an online marketplace to mitigate risk? Will a consumer require greater trust on the part of the online merchant when the perceived risk of online buying is rather high? We intend to find answers to these research questions through an empirical study. This paper explores the impact of enduring product involvement and perceived risks on required trust level, and further on online merchant choice. For the purpose of the research, five types or components of perceived risk are taken into consideration, including financial, performance, delivery, psychological, and social risks. A research model has been built around the constructs under consideration, and 12 hypotheses have been developed based on the research model to examine the relationships between enduring involvement and five components of perceived risk, between five components of perceived risk and required trust level, between enduring involvement and required trust level, and finally between required trust level and preference toward an e-tailer. To attain our research objectives, we conducted an empirical analysis consisting of two phases of data collection: a pilot test and main survey. The pilot test was conducted using 25 college students to ensure that the questionnaire items are clear and straightforward. Then the main survey was conducted using 295 college students at a major university for nine days between December 13, 2010 and December 21, 2010. The measures employed to test the model included eight constructs: (1) enduring involvement, (2) financial risk, (3) performance risk, (4) delivery risk, (5) psychological risk, (6) social risk, (7) required trust level, (8) preference toward an e-tailer. The statistical package, SPSS 17.0, was used to test the internal consistency among the items within the individual measures. Based on the Cronbach's ${\alpha}$ coefficients of the individual measure, the reliability of all the variables is supported. Meanwhile, the Amos 18.0 package was employed to perform a confirmatory factor analysis designed to assess the unidimensionality of the measures. The goodness of fit for the measurement model was satisfied. Unidimensionality was tested using convergent, discriminant, and nomological validity. The statistical evidences proved that the three types of validity were all satisfied. Now the structured equation modeling technique was used to analyze the individual paths along the relationships among the research constructs. The results indicated that enduring involvement has significant positive relationships with all the five components of perceived risk, while only performance risk is significantly related to trust level required by consumers for purchase. It can be inferred from the findings that product performance problems are mostly likely to occur when a merchant behaves in an opportunistic manner. Positive relationships were also found between involvement and required trust level and between required trust level and online merchant choice. Enduring involvement is concerned with the pleasure a consumer derives from a product class and/or with the desire for knowledge for the product class, and thus is likely to motivate the consumer to look for ways of mitigating perceived risk by requiring a higher level of trust on the part of the online merchant. Likewise, a consumer requiring a high level of trust on the merchant will choose a digital storefront rather than an e-marketplace, since a digital storefront is believed to be trustworthier than an e-marketplace, as it fulfills orders by itself rather than acting as an intermediary. The findings of the present research provide both academic and practical implications. The first academic implication is that enduring product involvement is a strong motivator of consumer responses, especially the selection of a merchant, in the context of electronic shopping. Secondly, academicians are advised to pay attention to the finding that an individual component or type of perceived risk can be used as an important research construct, since it would allow one to pinpoint the specific types of risk that are influenced by antecedents or that influence consequents. Meanwhile, our research provides implications useful for online merchants (both online storefronts and e-marketplaces). Merchants may develop strategies to attract consumers by managing perceived performance risk involved in purchase decisions, since it was found to have significant positive relationship with the level of trust required by a consumer on the part of the merchant. One way to manage performance risk would be to thoroughly examine the product before shipping to ensure that it has no deficiencies or flaws. Secondly, digital storefronts are advised to focus on symbolic goods (e.g., cars, cell phones, fashion outfits, and handbags) in which consumers are relatively more involved than others, whereas e- marketplaces should put their emphasis on non-symbolic goods (e.g., drinks, books, MP3 players, and bike accessories).

  • PDF

임시의정원 관련 기록물의 정리 현황과 재정리 방향 (The Current Status of Arrangement and the Direction of Rearrangement of the Archives Relating to the Korean Provisional Assembly)

  • 박도원
    • 기록학연구
    • /
    • 제73호
    • /
    • pp.161-188
    • /
    • 2022
  • 본고에서는 국회도서관이 소장하고 있는 임시의정원 관련 기록물의 정리 현황을 살펴보고 기록물 정리의 원칙을 적용하여 재정리 방향을 제시하였다. 임시의정원은 기록물 관리 규정을 가지고 있었고, 그에 따라 기록물을 생산하고 보관했다. 그러나 어느 시점에 기록물의 원질서가 해체되어 보관되다가 1960년대에 국회도서관이 수집하여 관리하고 있다. 국회도서관은 수집한 기록물을 정리하면서 생산 당시의 기록관리 체계와 보관 과정에서 있을 수 있는 여러 가지 상황을 충분히 고려하지 못했다. 당시 국회도서관은 임시의정원의 질서를 따르지 않고 정리했다. 또한 정리 과정에서 기록물의 계층 개념을 적용하지 않았고, 출처주의와 원질서 존중의 원칙을 고려하지 않았다. 그 결과 기록물의 구조와 맥락을 파악하기 어렵게 되었다. 이러한 문제점을 해결하고 기록물의 재정리 방안을 마련하기 위해서는 우선 기록물 정리 원칙에 따라 임시의정원 관련 기록물이 지니고 있는 특징을 살펴보아야 한다. 첫째, 출처주의에 따라 기록물 조직·기능·산출물이 무엇인지 파악하여 기록물의 기록물건·기록물철, 생산자, 생산일자, 기록물 유형 등을 구분해야 한다. 둘째, 원질서 존중의 원칙을 적용하여 기록물을 생산하여 보존하던 당시의 기록물 질서가 어떠했는지를 파악해야 한다. 셋째, 기록물이 완전하게 성립하였는지 효력을 갖추고 있는지를 검토해야 한다. 임시의정원 관련 기록물을 과거의 모습대로 온전하게 정리하는 것은 불가능하다. 다만 정리 현황과 재정리 방향을 검토함으로써 기록물의 내용·구조·맥락을 새롭게 파악하고 효과적으로 서비스할 수 있는 토대를 만들 수 있을 것이다.

한국제조업에서의 외부통제에 관한 공간적 분석 (The geography of external control in Korean manufacturing industry)

  • 백영기
    • 대한지리학회지
    • /
    • 제30권2호
    • /
    • pp.146-168
    • /
    • 1995
  • 본 연구는 기업의 외부통제에 관한 개념적인 논의와 함께, 한국의 제조업에서 80년 대 중반 이후(1986-1992)에 나타난 통제의 공간적 변화를 경험적으로 조사하였다. 15개의 지역 사이에 다입지 기업의 소유연계에 대한 자료가 외부통제의 대체척도로 이용되었다. 이 자료를 근거로 생산과정의 특성에 따른 세가지 유형의 제조업 부문별로 통제의 변화를 지도 화하여 분석하였다. 전반적인 외부통제의 지리적 특징은 서울이 탁월한 통제의 중심지로서, 서울의 영향력은 수도권과 동남권의 산업발달 지역에 집중되었지만, 최근에 그 영향력은 산 업이 낙후된 지역까지 확산되어 전국적이다. 또한 새로운 통제의 중심지로 수도권과 동남권 의 중심인 대도시가 서서히 부각되고 있다. 이러한 특징에도 불구하고, 제조업 유형별로 상 이한 외부통제의 공간적 패턴은 생산의 조직구조가 생산과정에서 필요로 하는 자본과 노동 은 물론 부문이 처한 외부환경에 따라 변화됨을 보여준다. 이러한 결과는 상이한 생산과정 을 채택하는 다입지 기업의 공간적 영향에 차별적 분석을 요구한다.

  • PDF

독립신호 교차로에서의 교통안전을 위한 서비스수준 결정방법의 개발 (DEVELOPMENT OF SAFETY-BASED LEVEL-OF-SERVICE CRITERIA FOR ISOLATED SIGNALIZED INTERSECTIONS)

  • Dr. Tae-Jun Ha
    • 대한교통학회:학술대회논문집
    • /
    • 대한교통학회 1995년도 제27회 학술발표회
    • /
    • pp.3-32
    • /
    • 1995
  • The Highway Capacity Manual specifies procedures for evaluating intersection performance in terms of delay per vehicle. What is lacking in the current methodology is a comparable quantitative procedure for ass~ssing the safety-based level of service provided to motorists. The objective of the research described herein was to develop a computational procedure for evaluating the safety-based level of service of signalized intersections based on the relative hazard of alternative intersection designs and signal timing plans. Conflict opportunity models were developed for those crossing, diverging, and stopping maneuvers which are associated with left-turn and rear-end accidents. Safety¬based level-of-service criteria were then developed based on the distribution of conflict opportunities computed from the developed models. A case study evaluation of the level of service analysis methodology revealed that the developed safety-based criteria were not as sensitive to changes in prevailing traffic, roadway, and signal timing conditions as the traditional delay-based measure. However, the methodology did permit a quantitative assessment of the trade-off between delay reduction and safety improvement. The Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) specifies procedures for evaluating intersection performance in terms of a wide variety of prevailing conditions such as traffic composition, intersection geometry, traffic volumes, and signal timing (1). At the present time, however, performance is only measured in terms of delay per vehicle. This is a parameter which is widely accepted as a meaningful and useful indicator of the efficiency with which an intersection is serving traffic needs. What is lacking in the current methodology is a comparable quantitative procedure for assessing the safety-based level of service provided to motorists. For example, it is well¬known that the change from permissive to protected left-turn phasing can reduce left-turn accident frequency. However, the HCM only permits a quantitative assessment of the impact of this alternative phasing arrangement on vehicle delay. It is left to the engineer or planner to subjectively judge the level of safety benefits, and to evaluate the trade-off between the efficiency and safety consequences of the alternative phasing plans. Numerous examples of other geometric design and signal timing improvements could also be given. At present, the principal methods available to the practitioner for evaluating the relative safety at signalized intersections are: a) the application of engineering judgement, b) accident analyses, and c) traffic conflicts analysis. Reliance on engineering judgement has obvious limitations, especially when placed in the context of the elaborate HCM procedures for calculating delay. Accident analyses generally require some type of before-after comparison, either for the case study intersection or for a large set of similar intersections. In e.ither situation, there are problems associated with compensating for regression-to-the-mean phenomena (2), as well as obtaining an adequate sample size. Research has also pointed to potential bias caused by the way in which exposure to accidents is measured (3, 4). Because of the problems associated with traditional accident analyses, some have promoted the use of tqe traffic conflicts technique (5). However, this procedure also has shortcomings in that it.requires extensive field data collection and trained observers to identify the different types of conflicts occurring in the field. The objective of the research described herein was to develop a computational procedure for evaluating the safety-based level of service of signalized intersections that would be compatible and consistent with that presently found in the HCM for evaluating efficiency-based level of service as measured by delay per vehicle (6). The intent was not to develop a new set of accident prediction models, but to design a methodology to quantitatively predict the relative hazard of alternative intersection designs and signal timing plans.

  • PDF

근대 역사 경관의 보존과 철거 - 구 조선총독부 철거 논쟁을 사례로 - (Conflicts between the Conservation and Removal of the Modern Historic Landscapes - A Case of the Demolition Controversy of the Japanese General Government Building in Seoul -)

  • 손은신;배정한
    • 한국조경학회지
    • /
    • 제46권4호
    • /
    • pp.21-35
    • /
    • 2018
  • 최근 산업유산, 근대 문화 유산, 포스트 인더스트리얼 공원 등 기억의 경관들이 공공 공간으로 새롭게 활용되고 있다. 여러 유형의 기억의 경관 중 19~20세기에 주로 형성된 근대 역사 경관(modern historic landscape)은 근대사에 대한 평가 및 인식 변화에 따라 보존과 철거 간 논쟁이 가장 많이 발생하는 경관이다. 본 연구는 1995년 철거된 서울의 구조선총독부 철거 논쟁을 사례로 근대 역사 경관을 둘러싼 보존과 철거 사이의 쟁점을 검토하고, 보존 및 철거를 결정하는 가치 판단 기준과 근대 역사 경관의 형성 방식을 탐구한다. 먼저 1980~1999년 사이 조선총독부 철거 논쟁을 다룬 신문기사, 뉴스, 토론 프로그램 자료와 관련 문헌을 검토하고, 철거 논쟁의 주요 쟁점으로 다음의 여섯 가지 항목을 도출한다: 상징적 위치, 새로운 역사적 사실의 발견과 대응, 관련 국가의 반응과 개입, 재정적 여건, 경관의 기능과 이용 방식, 도시 역사 건축 정책 변화. 이를 기반으로 근대 역사 경관을 형성하고 보존 혹은 철거를 결정하는 중요한 가치로서 상징적 가치 간 대립 양상과, 근대 역사 경관이 형성되는 과정에서 발생하는 문제점을 보완하고 비판에 대응하는 기능적 가치의 역할을 고찰한다. 특히 본 연구는 근대사에 대한 인식이 시대에 따라 변화하면서 근대 역사 경관의 보존과 철거의 향방 또한 변화하지만, 오늘날에도 결정의 가장 중요한 요인은 여전히 상징적 가치라는 점에 주목했다. 근대 역사 경관은 오늘날 중요한 설계 대상지 중 하나로서 여전히 합의되고 해결되어야 할 역사적 쟁점을 갖는다. 본 연구는 근대 역사 경관의 가치를 상징적 가치와 기능적 가치로 나누어 평가하고, 그 배경에 자리한 사회적 맥락을 재검토했다는 점에서 동시대적 의의를 갖는다.