• 제목/요약/키워드: Interobserver variation

검색결과 15건 처리시간 0.064초

Large Variation in Clinical Practice amongst Pediatricians in Treating Children with Recurrent Abdominal Pain

  • van Kalleveen, Michael W.;Noordhuis, Elise J.;Lasham, Carole;Plotz, Frans B.
    • Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology & Nutrition
    • /
    • 제22권3호
    • /
    • pp.225-232
    • /
    • 2019
  • Purpose: To evaluate intra- and inter-observer variability and guideline adherence amongst pediatricians in treating children aged between 4 and 18 years referred with recurrent abdominal pain (RAP) without red flags. Methods: The first part of the study is a retrospective single-center cohort study. The diagnostic work-ups of eight pediatricians were compared to the national guidelines. Intra- and inter-observer variability were examined by Cramer's V test. Intra-observer variability was defined as the amount of variation within a pediatrician and inter-observer variability as the amount of variation between pediatricians in the application of diagnostic work-up in children with RAP. Prospectively, the same pediatricians were requested to provide a report on their management strategy with a fictitious case to prove similarities in retrospective diagnostic work-up. Results: A total of 10 patients per pediatrician were analyzed. Retrospectively, a (very) weak association between pediatricians' diagnostic work-ups was found (0.22), which implies high inter-observer variability. The association between intra-observer diagnostic was moderate (range, 0.35-0.46). The Cramer's V of 0.60 in diagnostic work-up between pediatricians in the fictitious case implied the presence of a moderately strong association and lower inter-observer variability than in the retrospective study. Adherence to the guideline was 66.8%. Conclusion: We found a high intra- and inter-observer variability and moderate guideline adherence in daily clinical practice amongst pediatricians in treating children with RAP in a teaching hospital.

Accuracy of digital periapical radiography and cone-beam computed tomography in detecting external root resorption

  • Creanga, Adriana Gabriela;Geha, Hassem;Sankar, Vidya;Teixeira, Fabricio B.;McMahan, Clyde Alex;Noujeim, Marcel
    • Imaging Science in Dentistry
    • /
    • 제45권3호
    • /
    • pp.153-158
    • /
    • 2015
  • Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate and compare the efficacy of cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) and digital intraoral radiography in diagnosing simulated small external root resorption cavities. Materials and Methods: Cavities were drilled in 159 roots using a small spherical bur at different root levels and on all surfaces. The teeth were imaged both with intraoral digital radiography using image plates and with CBCT. Two sets of intraoral images were acquired per tooth: orthogonal (PA) which was the conventional periapical radiograph and mesioangulated (SET). Four readers were asked to rate their confidence level in detecting and locating the lesions. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was performed to assess the accuracy of each modality in detecting the presence of lesions, the affected surface, and the affected level. Analysis of variation was used to compare the results and kappa analysis was used to evaluate interobserver agreement. Results: A significant difference in the area under the ROC curves was found among the three modalities (P=0.0002), with CBCT (0.81) having a significantly higher value than PA (0.71) or SET (0.71). PA was slightly more accurate than SET, but the difference was not statistically significant. CBCT was also superior in locating the affected surface and level. Conclusion: CBCT has already proven its superiority in detecting multiple dental conditions, and this study shows it to likewise be superior in detecting and locating incipient external root resorption.

Validation and comparison of volume measurements using 1 multidetector computed tomography and 5 cone-beam computed tomography protocols: An in vitro study

  • Juliana Andrea Correa, Travessas;Alessandra Mendonca, dos Santos;Rodrigo Pagliarini, Buligon;Nadia Assein, Arus;Priscila Fernanda Tiecher, da Silveira;Heraldo Luis Dias, da Silveira;Mariana Boessio, Vizzotto
    • Imaging Science in Dentistry
    • /
    • 제52권4호
    • /
    • pp.399-408
    • /
    • 2022
  • Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare volume measurements obtained using 2 image software packages on Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) images acquired from 1 multidetector computed tomography and 5 cone-beam computed tomography devices, using different protocols for physical volume measurements. Materials and Methods: Four pieces of bovine leg were prepared. Marrow was removed from 3 pieces, leaving cortical bone exposed. The resulting space of 1 piece was filled with water, another was filled with propylene glycol, and the third was left unfilled. The marrow in the fourth sample was left fully intact. Volume measurements were obtained after importing DICOM images into the Dolphin Imaging 11.95 and ITK-SNAP software programs. Data were analyzed using 3-way analysis of variance with a generalized linear model to determine the effects of voxel size, software, and content on percentage mean volume differences between tomographic protocols. A significance level of 0.05 was used. Results: The intraclass correlation coefficients for intraobserver and interobserver reliability were, respectively, 0.915 and 0.764 for the Dolphin software and 0.894 and 0.766 for the ITK-SNAP software. Three sources of statistically significant variation were identified: the interaction between software and content (P=0.001), the main effect of content (P=0.014), and the main effect of software (P=0.001). Voxel size was not associated with statistically significant differences in volume measurements. Conclusion: Both content and software influenced the accuracy of volume measurements, especially when the content had gray values similar to those of the adjacent tissues.

음차를 일정하게 자극하는 장치의 개발 및 이 장치로 측정한 진동 감지 시간의 변이 (Development of A Device Constantly Stimulating Tuning Fork and Variability of Its Vibration Perception Time)

  • 이종영;홍대용;윤형렬
    • Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health
    • /
    • 제24권1호
    • /
    • pp.93-97
    • /
    • 1991
  • 진동감각의 이상을 검사하는데 음차를 이용한 진동 감지 시간을 측정하는 방법이 임상에서 널리 이용되고 있으나 이 방법은 동일 피검자에 대해서도 검사자에 따라 많은 차이가 있다. 이는 주로 음차에 가해지는 자극이 표준화되어 있지 못하고 경험에 의해 이루어 지고 있기 때문이다. 검사자간의 오차를 제거하기 위해 음차에 일정한 자극을 줄 수 있는 장치 (그림 1)를 전자석의 원리를 이용하여 개발하였다. 본 장비를 이용하여 28명의 건강한 의예과 남학생을 대상으로 그들의 오른손 집게손가락에서 측정된 진동 감지시간은 평균 12.44 초 였고, 9.47 에서 17.25 초 사이에 분포되었다. 그 변이 계수는 16.89% 였다. 30 분 후 재검사 한 결과와 첫 검사 사이의 상관계수는 0.957 이었다 (p<0.01). 본 검사법은 비침입적이며, 비염오적이고 간단하다. 이를 실시함에 있어 숙련이 요하지 않으며, 현상에서 쉽게 이루어질 수 있다. 검사 시간은 1 분 정도 밖에 걸리지 않으며 추적 조사도 가능하다. 또한 본 장비는 휴대에 간편하다. 진동감각의 장애가 말초신경 질환의 초기 징후일 수 있으며, 진동 지각 역치를 측정하는 방법들이 말초신경 질환의 조기발견에 이용되고 있음에 비추어 볼 때, 본 장치에 의해 진동 감지 시간을 측정하는 방법이 직업성 말초신경 질환의 조기발견을 위한 집단검진에 널리 사용될 수 있을 것으로 생각된다.

  • PDF

관상동맥질환에서 심장풀 스캔의 육안적 평가에 대한 ROC 분석 (ROC Analysis of Visual Assessments Made in Gated Blood Pool Scans of Patients with Coronary Artery Disease)

  • 이경한;최윤호;이범우;문대혁;궁성수;정준기;이명철;고창순
    • 대한핵의학회지
    • /
    • 제23권2호
    • /
    • pp.175-181
    • /
    • 1989
  • Visual assessment of regional wall motion abnormality (RWMA) by gated blood pol scan (GBPS) serves as an useful parameter in the diagnosis, functional evaluation, and follow up in various clinical settings, but are still subject to some inherent limitations. On important problem may be the interobserver as well as intraobsever variation that may well be present due to the subjective nature of the interpretations. This study was carried out to determine the reliability and reproducibility of visual assessments made in GBPSs, and to observe the degree to which the results would be influenced by observer variation. Fifty two patients with coronary heart disease had resting GBPS and contrast ventriculography within 4 days appall. Contrast ventriculography-showed normal wall motion in 6 patients and the remaining 46 had RWMA in one or more segments. The anterior and left anterolateral views of all 52 GBPSs were analyzed by three independent observers, who selected from 5 scales, their level of confidence that there was RWMA in that segment. Reciever operating characteristic (ROC) curves for each analysis was plotted and the area under the curve $(\theta)$ was used as a parameter representing each observer's performance in his interpretations. The findings of contrast ventriculographies were used as the standard for RWMA. The apical and inferoapical segments showed the best correlation with contrast ventriculography ($\theta=0.90-0.94$, 0.81-0.94, respectively), and the inferior wall showed the poorest correlation $(\theta=0.70-0.74)$. The interpretations of the inferior, septal, apical, and posteroinferior, segments showed no difference between the observers, but there was significantly better performance in assessment by observer A compared to that by B or C for the anterolateral segments ($\theta=0.87$, 0.78, 0.76, respectively. p<0.01 for A vs B, p<0.05 for A vs C), as well as when all segments were considered altogether ($\theta=0.88$, 0.83, 0.82, respectively. both p<0.05). This was also true for the infero-apical segment between A and C ($\theta=0.09$, 0.81, p<0.05). The intraobserver variation, however, did not appear significant, with only the inferior segment for observer B showing any significant difference when observer A and B repeated the analysis 10 days latter. There was no difference in assessing dyskinesia, with all observers showing a high performance ($\theta=0.98$, 0.87, 0.97, respectively). The visual assessment of left ventricular ejection fraction by all three observers correlated well with the calculated value from a semiautomated method (Spearman's r = 0.91, 0.83, 0.83. p<0.01, p<0.05, p < 0.05). The assessment of LV and RV size also correlated well between the three observers (Kendall's w = 0.80, 0.51, p<0.01 for both left and right ventricles). The above findings suggest that RWMA visually assessed by GBPS correlates well with that done by contrast ventriculography. And although the observer's experience or skill may influence the results in certain segments, visual analysis of GBPS may serve as a reliable and reproducible means for evaluating ventricular function.

  • PDF