• 한국산학기술학회논문지
• /
• 제19권1호
• /
• pp.168-178
• /
• 2018

본 연구의 목적은 초기 노인의 은퇴 후 재취업 경험의 본질과 의미 구조를 규명함으로써 지지적 간호중재 방안을 찾기 위함이다. 본 연구의 대상자는 C 시에 거주하고 있으며 은퇴한 후 재취업 경험이 있는 60세에서 74세 사이의 한국인 노인 7명을 편의표본 추출하여 선정하였다. 연구방법은 심층 인터뷰와 테이프 녹음을 사용하여 2016 년 6월에서 8월까지 자료를 수집했다. 인터뷰 자료는 Giorgi의 현상학적 분석 방법으로 분석하였다. 분석 결과 다음과 같은 네 가지 구성 요소가 도출되었다; 삶의 변화에 혼란스러움, 다시 일하기가 쉽지 않다는 것을 인식함. 새로운 변화에 적응함, 새로운 인생이 열림. 결론으로 평균수명의 증가와 노인인구의 증가로 인해 노인 간호에 있어서 핵심적인 역할을 수행해 왔던 간호사는 임상에 국한된 업무에서 벗어나 사회 전반에 걸친 확장된 업무를 담당해야 한다는 중요성이 점점 주목받고 있다. 따라서 초기 노인 은퇴자를 포함하여 노인을 대상으로 하는 간호 시 은퇴 이후 노인의 삶에 대한 만족도를 높일 수 있고 건강한 노년기를 보낼 수 있도록 사회적 지원 시스템과 지속적인 간호중재에 필요한 간호지침이 제공되어야 하므로 생각한다.

• 한국산학기술학회논문지
• /
• 제16권11호
• /
• pp.7648-7655
• /
• 2015

간호서비스 질에 대한 대상자들의 요구가 점점 높아지고 있는 현실에서 간호서비스 질은 간호사의 직무태도와 행동에 따라 달라질 수 있다 하였다. 그 것은 자발적이고 능동적인 조직시민행동으로 설명할 수 있다. 임상실무에서는 간호사들의 업무성과에 영향을 미치는 조직시민행동이 매우 중요하며 조직공정성은 조직시민행동의 중요한 영향요인이다. 본 연구는 조직공정성이 간호사의 조직시민행동에 미치는 영향관계를 파악하고자 시도된 서술적 조사연구이다. 연구대상은 K지역 소재 500병상 미만의 2차 의료기관 3곳에서 근무하는 간호사 230명을 대상으로 하였다. 데이터 분석은 SPSS Win18.0을 사용하여 기술통계, t-test, ANOVA, Perason's correlation coefficient, Multiple Regression을 하였다. 연구결과에서 총 조직공정성과 그 하위요인 인 분배, 절차, 상호작용공정성은 조직시민행동에 유의한 정(+)의 상관관계를 나타내었다(r=.172~.540, p=.000). 또한 총 조직공정성은 29.1%의 설명력을 가지고 총 조직시민행동에 유의한 영향(${\beta}$=.540)을 미쳤다(F=93.777, p=.000). 하위요인을 살펴보면, 절차공정성을 제외한 분배공정성(${\beta}$=.283)과 상호작용공정성(${\beta}$=.249)은 조직시민행동에 유의한 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다. 따라서 간호사의 조직시민행동을 유도하기 위해서는 성과, 보상에 대한 분배공정성과 사회적 관계인 상호작용공정성에 초점을 맞춘 간호관리 전략이 필요하다.

• 철학연구
• /
• 제131권
• /
• pp.353-381
• /
• 2014

사상의학은 비단 의학에서뿐만이 아니라, 경영학이나 정치학, 교육학 등 다양한 분야에서 응용되고 있다. 하지만 사상의학이 근본적으로 치심치병(治心治病)을 치료의 근본으로 하는 심신의학임에도 불구하고, 실제 심리나 정신치료에서 활용되는 경우는 극히 드물었다. 실제 임상에서의 치료법은 약물치료나 침구요법(체질침) 정도에 머물고 있다. 하지만 질병 병리 현상에 대해 사상의학이 제시하는 치유법은 개인의 성정(性情)의 다스림은 물론이고, 연령 지역에 따른 환경적 요인, 주(酒) 색(色) 재(財) 권(權)과 같은 사회적 문화적 요인을 포괄한다. 특히, 사상의학의 수양론은 인간의 타고난 성정 가운데 그림자처럼 항상 숨어 있고, 비밀스럽게 간직되어 있는 사심(邪心)과 태행(怠行)을 올바르게 인지하여 박통(博通)과 독행(獨行)으로 나아가는 것이 중요하다고 강조한다. 또한 의학의 통합적 접근을 시도하면서, 지인정기(知人正己)론을 근본으로 의론(醫論)을 전개하기 때문에 대인관계(對人關係)가 중시되는 현대인들에게 많은 시사점을 준다. 마찬가지로, 세계철학과 통합심리학을 주도하는 윌버(Ken Wilber, 1949~)는 실제적이고 체험적인 통합적 접근을 경험 차원에 적용하는 '통합적 삶을 위한 훈련(ILP)'을 제시하고 있다. ILP는 성장가능한(또는 깨어남이 가능한) 영역 전체의 성장을 위한 실제적인 훈련법(수련법)으로 선례가 없는 것이다. ILP에서는 몸 모듈, 마음(Mind) 모듈, 그림자(Shadow) 모듈, 영(Spirit) 모듈이라는 4가지 핵심 모듈과 윤리, 성(性), 일(Work), 정서(Emotion), 관계성(Relationships) 등의 성장을 지향하는 5가지 보조 모듈을 제시한다. 이에 ILP가 제시하는 핵심 보조 모듈과 다양한 심신치유기법들에 사상의학의 심신 치유법을 대입시켜 본다면 양자(兩者) 간에 보다 발전된 심신치유 접근법을 모색할 수 있을 것이다.

• 대한간호학회지
• /
• 제27권2호
• /
• pp.364-376
• /
• 1997

This study was made to analyse the nursing professional attitudes and mental health of clinical nurses in order to promote good mental health and positive attitudes. The 150 subjects obtained from 3 hospitals in Seoul completed a self-report questionnaire. Demographic data was collected in addition to data about nursing professional attitudes and mental health. The data was analyzed by SAS, t-test, scheffe's test, pearson's correlation and the GLM procedures. The results of the data analysis as follows : 1) Nursing professional attitudes were positive (MS=3.76) 2) Mental health was shown to be satisfactory (MS=0.65) 3) The relationship between nursing professional attitudes and mental health of the subjects were shown to be significant according to the professional education level with depression(r=-0.19, p=0.03/sup */), anxiety(r=-0.23, p=0.01/sup **/), hostility(r= -0.19, p=0.03/sup */), phobicanxiety(r=-0.18, p=0.04/sup */), but there was a significant difference according to the pursit of social profit with anxiety(r=-0.17, p=0.03/sup */). There was a significant difference according to autonomy with somatization(r=-0.23, p=0.01/sup **/), obsessive-compulsive(r=-0.22, p=0.01/sup **/), depression(r=-0.20, p=0.02/sup */), anxiety(r=-0.17, p=0.05/sup */). Finally, There was a significant difference according to ethics with hostility(r=-0.17, p=0.05/sup */). 4) According to nursing professional attitudes and demographic fators there was a significant difference in the professional position(t=2.01, p=0.05/sup */), work location(f=4.99, p=0.01/sup **/), length of employment (f=3.66, p=0.03/sup **/). 5) The nursing professional attitudes and occupational factors showed a positive correlation with the anticipation of length of employment (t=2.00, p=0.05/sup */). 6) According to Mental health and dmographic factors there was a significant correlation with the professional position(t=-2.21, p=0.03/sup */). 7) According to mental health and occupational factors there was a significant difference correlation. Based on the study results, the following recommendation are made : 1) Nursing education curriculum should be developed for the continuous promotion of mental of professional nurses. 2) Follow up study of identification of the variables which positively influence professional nurses attitudes.

• 치위생과학회지
• /
• 제5권1호
• /
• pp.1-5
• /
• 2005

본 연구는 치위생과에 재학중인 학생들의 윤리의식에 미치는 영향요인을 규명하여 윤리교육의 기초자료로 활용하고자 개별자기기입법에 의한 설문을 실시하여 다음과 같은 결론을 얻었다. 1. 기초윤리 의식수준에 연관된 변수는 치과윤리교육필요성인지, 임상실습경험, 직업윤리교육경험이었다. 치과윤리교육필요성을 인지한 학생들이 기초윤리 의식수준이 높았고, 임상실습경험과 직업윤리교육경험이 있는 학생들이 기초윤리에 관한 의식수준이 높은 것으로 나타났다. 2. 면허법규 의식수준은 치과위생사윤리강령개정을 알고 있는 학생일수록, 치과윤리교육필요성을 인지하고 있는 학생일수록 면허법규에 관한 의식수준이 높았다. 3. 전문가윤리 의식수준에 연관된 변수는 치과위생사윤리강령 개정인지, 치과윤리교육필요성인지, 윤리 의식을 배우는 역할모델이었다. 가장 큰 영향을 미친 변수는 치과위생사 윤리강령개정이었다. 4. 의사결정 의식수준은 치과윤리교육필요성을 인지하고 있는 학생일수록, 치과위생사윤리강령개정을 인지하고 있는 학생일수록, 임상실습경험이 있는 학생일수록, 윤리의식을 배우는 역할모델이 교회라고 응답한 학생일수록 의사결정에 관한 의식수준이 높았다. 5. 팀웍에 관한 의식수준은 치과위생사윤리강령개정인지와 치과윤리교육필요성인지이었다. 치과위생사윤리강령개정을 인지하고 있는 학생일수록, 치과윤리교육필요성을 인지하고 있는 학생일수록 팀웍에 관한 의식수준이 높았다. 6. 치과위생사윤리강령개정에 대해 모르고 있다고 응답한 학생은 88.4%이었고, 치과위생사 윤리강령개정을 알고 있는 학생의 전문가윤리 의식수준이 $3.44{\pm}0.23$으로 높았다 (p=0.000).

• 대한간호학회지
• /
• 제4권1호
• /
• pp.1-21
• /
• 1974

A considerable change of the Korean nursing system has been made during the last decade not only in its philosophy but also in its function and structure to meet political and scientific need of the modern society. The main purpose of this study is to develope the new concept of comprehensive nursing care, both its Philosophy and ethics, as the basic of modern clinical nursing theory and practice. Comprehensive nursing care is the concept of human centered nursing care, and it helps a man to meet the basic physical, psychological, environmental, socioeconomic and teaching needs. It also helps him to help himself to meet these needs. This concept starts from the individualized nursing care and its ultimate goal is to improve a man to have a better position in his own community so that he may able to have a meaningful life. To accomplish this goal, an individualized nursing care plan as a nursing diagnosis and problem solving method should be set up for different patients with similar diagnosis to meet their needs, because each patient has a different social background. from this viewpoint, nursing is a science as well as abstruse humanity. The performance of comprehensive nursing care is a goal and issue of modern clinical nursing care. If nursing is a science and a profession for man, it should have ethics which recognize the dignity of man and offers infinite service voluntarily, and should be able to show leadership in carrying out the nursing responsibility. This leadership finds a person's potential and encourages him to utilize it. Such concepts should develop into a nursing ideology and this ideology should become a priority in comprehensive nursing care. The following statements are the conclusion of this study. 1) Modern nursing has been developed from disease centered nursing care to comprehensive nursing care based on humanity. The primary principle of nursing was to assist in the treatment of disease, but it has been changed to the professional nursing system independently. 2) The concept of nursing is one of continuous or endless scope of dispersion. It proves that nursing is grasping the professional responsibility to be able to coordinate scientific principles Patient health problems are according to scientific principles rather than adhering to nursing technical discipline as a daily work. 3) In chapter I and Ⅱ, the philosophy and ideology of nursing have been discussed and the flow of concept of clinical nursing and the rate of progress which emerges from naturalizing performance of the concept of comprehensive nursing in clinical nursing studied. The discussion developed the theory that a nurse should be to embody nursing ideas and objectives by establishing definite conviction of professions and study. 4) In chapter lil, nursing planning based on nursing diagnosis as a method to attain ideal nursing care for humanity with a definite idea of establishing philosophy of nursing was presented. 5) From the result of survey on patient needs about treatment and nursing, it was observed that all patient had emotional stress from unknown factors. Therefore it was concluded that nurses should not only educate the patient but also give them the opportunity to communicate freely their needs and anxieties. Furthermore complaints and doubts of the patient should be carefully noted and must be considered to meet these needs. 6) Patient teaching is the most important part of comprehensive nursing care. In chapter, Ⅲ, the important of patient teaching was emphasized by demonstrating the effect of patient teaching for diabetic patient. 7) In Chapter Ⅳ, from the result of the study on nurses attitudes to comprehensive nursing care, it was pointed that the evolution of nursing education and the establishment of a complete concept and value of comprehensive nursing was necessary.

• 대한간호학회지
• /
• 제4권2호
• /
• pp.1-16
• /
• 1974

This Study involved the development of a survey form and the collection of data in an effort-to provide information which can be used in the improvement of nursing curricula. The data examined were the kinds courses currently being taught in the curricula of nursing education institutions throughout Korea, credits required for course completion, and year in-which courses are taken. For the purposes of this study, curricula were classified into college, nursing school and vocational school categories. Courses were directed into the 3 major categories of general education courses, supporting science courses and professional education course, and further subdirector as. follows: 1) General education (following the classification of Philip H. phoenix): a) Symbolics, b) Empirics, c) Aesthetics. 4) Synthetics, e) Ethics, f) Synoptic. 2) Supporting science: a) physical science, b) biological science, c) social science, d) behavioral science, e) Health science, f) Educations 3) Professional Education; a) basic courses, b) courses in each of the respective fields of nursing. Ⅰ. General Education aimed at developing the individual as a person and as a member of society is relatively strong in college curricula compared with the other two. a) Courses included in the category of symbolics included Korean language, English, German. Chines. Mathematics. Statics: Economics and Computer most college curricula included 20 credits. of courses in this sub-category, while nursing schools required 12 credits and vocational school 10 units. English ordinarily receives particularly heavy emphasis. b) Research methodology, Domestic affair and women & courtney was included under the category of empirics in the college curricula, nursing and vocational school do not offer this at all. c) Courses classified under aesthetics were physical education, drill, music, recreation and fine arts. Most college curricula had 4 credits in these areas, nursing school provided for 2 credits, and most vocational schools offered 10 units. d) Synoptic included leadership, interpersonal relationship, and communications, Most schools did not offer courses of this nature. e) The category of ethics included citizenship. 2 credits are provided in college curricula, while vocational schools require 4 units. Nursing schools do not offer these courses. f) Courses included under synoptic were Korean history, cultural history, philosophy, Logics, and religion. Most college curricular 5 credits in these areas, nursing schools 4 credits. and vocational schools 2 units. g) Only physical education was given every Year in college curricula and only English was given in nursing schools and vocational schools in every of the curriculum. Most of the other courses were given during the first year of the curriculum. Ⅱ. Supporting science courses are fundamental to the practice and application of nursing theory. a) Physical science course include physics, chemistry and natural science. most colleges and nursing schools provided for 2 credits of physical science courses in their curricula, while most vocational schools did not offer t me. b) Courses included under biological science were anatomy, physiologic, biology and biochemistry. Most college curricula provided for 15 credits of biological science, nursing schools for the most part provided for 11 credits, and most vocational schools provided for 8 units. c) Courses included under social science were sociology and anthropology. Most colleges provided for 1 credit in courses of this category, which most nursing schools provided for 2 creates Most vocational school did not provide courses of this type. d) Courses included under behavioral science were general and clinical psychology, developmental psychology. mental hygiene and guidance. Most schools did not provide for these courses. e) Courses included under health science included pharmacy and pharmacology, microbiology, pathology, nutrition and dietetics, parasitology, and Chinese medicine. Most college curricula provided for 11 credits, while most nursing schools provide for 12 credits, most part provided 20 units of medical courses. f) Courses included under education included educational psychology, principles of education, philosophy of education, history of education, social education, educational evaluation, educational curricula, class management, guidance techniques and school & community. Host college softer 3 credits in courses in this category, while nursing schools provide 8 credits and vocational schools provide for 6 units, 50% of the colleges prepare these students to qualify as regular teachers of the second level, while 91% of the nursing schools and 60% of the vocational schools prepare their of the vocational schools prepare their students to qualify as school nurse. g) The majority of colleges start supporting science courses in the first year and complete them by the second year. Nursing schools and vocational schools usually complete them in the first year. Ⅲ. Professional Education courses are designed to develop professional nursing knowledge, attitudes and skills in the students. a) Basic courses include social nursing, nursing ethics, history of nursing professional control, nursing administration, social medicine, social welfare, introductory nursing, advanced nursing, medical regulations, efficient nursing, nursing english and basic nursing, College curricula devoted 13 credits to these subjects, nursing schools 14 credits, and vocational schools 26 units indicating a severe difference in the scope of education provided. b) There was noticeable tendency for the colleges to take a unified approach to the branches of nursing. 60% of the schools had courses in public health nursing, 80% in pediatric nursing, 60% in obstetric nursing, 90% in psychiatric nursing and 80% in medical-surgical nursing. The greatest number of schools provided 48 crudites in all of these fields combined. in most of the nursing schools, 52 credits were provided for courses divided according to disease. in the vocational schools, unified courses are provided in public health nursing, child nursing, maternal nursing, psychiatric nursing and adult nursing. In addition, one unit is provided for one hour a week of practice. The total number of units provided in the greatest number of vocational schools is thus Ⅲ units double the number provided in nursing schools and colleges. c) In th leges, the second year is devoted mainly to basic nursing courses, while the third and fourth years are used for advanced nursing courses. In nursing schools and vocational schools, the first year deals primarily with basic nursing and the second and third years are used to cover advanced nursing courses. The study yielded the following conclusions. 1. Instructional goals should be established for each courses in line with the idea of nursing, and curriculum improvements should be made accordingly. 2. Course that fall under the synthetics category should be strengthened and ways should be sought to develop the ability to cooperate with those who work for human welfare and health. 3. The ability to solve problems on the basis of scientific principles and knowledge and understanding of man society should be fostered through a strengthening of courses dealing with physical sciences, social sciences and behavioral sciences and redistribution of courses emphasizing biological and health sciences. 4. There should be more balanced curricula with less emphasis on courses in the major There is a need to establish courses necessary for the individual nurse by doing away with courses centered around specific diseases and combining them in unified courses. In addition it is possible to develop skill in dealing with people by using the social setting in comprehensive training. The most efficient ratio of the study experience should be studied to provide more effective, interesting education Elective course should be initiated to insure a man flexible, responsive educational program. 5. The curriculum stipulated in the education law should be examined.

• 대한간호학회지
• /
• 제25권2호
• /
• pp.351-361
• /
• 1995

The main purpose of the study is to identify critical risk factors for development of a family assessment tool to screen high risk family. This study used a conceptual framework of family diagnosis developed by Eui-sook Kim's (1993) and analyzed risk factors to identify the high risk family. As employing a explorative and methodological study design, this study has four stages. 1. In the first stage, 34 family risk factors were identified by doing intensive literature review on conceptual framework of family diagnoses. 2. In the second stage, above risk factors were tested for content validity by consultation with 29 persons in community health nursing, nursing education, family theory, and social work. 3. In the third stage, existing survey data was used for actual application of the identified risk factors. The survey data used for this purpose was previously collected for the community diagnosis in a region of Seoul. At the final stage, through the comparison between high risk and low risk families, initially identified 34 risk factors decreased to 25 risk factors. Among 34 risk factors, six factors did not agree with content of questionnaries sand two factors were not significant in differentiating the high risk family Also, two risk factors showed high correlation between themselves, so only one of those two factors was chosen. As a result, twenty-five risk factors chosen to identify the high risk family are following ; 1. A single parent family due to divorce or death of a partner, or unweded single mother 2. A family with an unrelated household members 3. A family with a working mother with a young child 4. A family with no regular income 5. A family with no rule in family or too strict rules 6. A family with little or no support from other lam-ily members 7. A family with little or no support from friends or relatives 8. A family with little or no time to share with each other 9. A family with family history of hypertension, diabetus, cancer 10. A family with a sick person 11. A family with a mentally ill person 12. A family with a disabled person 13. A family with an alcoholic person 14. A family with a excessive smoker who smokes more than 1 pack / day 15. A family with too much salt intake in their diet. 16. A family with inappropriate management skills for family health 17. A family with high utilization of drug store than hospital to solve the health problems of the family 18. A family with disharmony between husband and wife 19. A family with conflicts among the family members 20. A family with unequal division of labor among family members 21. An authoritative family structure 22. A socially isolated family 23. The location of house is not residential area 24. A family with high risk of accidents 25. The drinking water and sewage systems are not hygienic. The main implication of the results of this study is clinical use. The high risk factors can be used to identify the high risk family effectively and efficiently. The use of high risk factors woule contribute to develop a conceptual framework of family diagnosis in Korea and the list of risk factors need to be revised continuously. Further researches are needed to develop an index of weight of each risk factor and to validate the risk factors.

• 한국산학기술학회논문지
• /
• 제11권12호
• /
• pp.4896-4906
• /
• 2010

2010년 D대학 치위생과 3학년 200명을 대상으로 해외 진학 및 취업에 관심이 있는 아시아 국가를 조사한 결과, 일본이 114명(60.3%)으로 가장 높게 나왔고, '기회가 된다면 아시아권 해외 진학 및 취업을 희망하십니까?'라는 질문에 그렇다가 72명(38.1%)으로 가장 많았다. 가장 관심이 높았던 일본은 2년제 51개 대학, 3년제 101개 대학, 4년제 6개 대학으로 총 158개 대학에서 치위생학과가 개설되어 있었고, 학교 법인은 관동지방(간토)이 25개로 가장 많았다. 일개 학제별 한 일 교육과정을 분석한 결과, 동일하거나 유사한 교과목이 다수였으며, 3년제는 39개 4년제는 44개였다. 일본의 국가고시 교과목이 19개 과목으로 해부학 외 9개 과목이 100점, 치과임상개요의 치과임상개론 외 8개 과목이 50점, 치과진료보조 외 1과목이 50점으로 총 배점이 200점이였고, 일본의 4년제 치위생사양성과정은 졸업 후 치과위생사 면허와 함께 동경의과치과대학 치과구강보건학과에서 사회복지사, 히로시마대학 치과 구강건강과학과는 양호교사(보건교사) 1종 면허 등을 선택적으로 동시에 자격을 취득할 수 있도록 업무영역을 확대한 교육과정을 편성하고 있다.

• 대한예방한의학회지
• /
• 제17권2호
• /
• pp.29-46
• /
• 2013

A survey conducted on 1,103 patients or caretakers visited Korean medical clinics and hospitals between August 25, 2011 to September 30, 2011 by the Ministry of Health and Welfares and Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs was analyzed and obtained following results: 1. For sociodemographic distribution, female(813) outnumbered male(290) patients with majority of patients ranging from 30s to 60s. Married patients(793) outnumbered unwed(150) patients and 65.0% with higher than high school education. Statistical significance was seen in gender, age, marital status, and education level but no significant difference for status of employment, income level, and types of insurance between the clinics and hospitals. (P<0.05). 45.1% had less than \2,000,000 in monthly salary and most of coverage was provided by either regional or work insurance. 2. 67.9% of the patients rated health conditions to be better than average and 32.1% listed as poor. People in good health showed tendency to visit Korean medical facilities. Musculo-skeletal conditions such as arthritis, ankle sprain, lumbago, muscular injury, and frozen shoulder were common conditions, followed by gastric disorders, common cold and herbal tonics. No significant difference was observed between the clinics and hospitals for above conditions, but significance was seen in atopic dermatitis, stroke, and sequela from traffic accidents (P<0.05). 3. Ten most common conditions addressed at Korean medical facilities were lumbago, arthritis, muscular injury, back sprain, gastric disorders, ankle sprain, common cold, herbal tonics, frozen shoulder and stroke. Major treatment modalities rendered were herbal medicine, herbal supplements, acupuncture and moxibustion, cupping, tuina, and Korean midical physical therapy. No significant difference existed between the clinics and hospitals. 4. All modalities showed at least 85% effectiveness. No statistical significant difference between the clinics and hospitals except for herbal decoction. (P=0.0452) 5. 88.3% of responses showed treatment satisfaction with significant difference between the clinics and hospitals (P=0.002). The occurrence of side effects was at 2%, mostly corning from treating digestive, skin, kidney disorders and neurological issues. No significant difference was observed between the clinics and hospitals. From the above results, the typical population visiting Korean medical facilities can be summarized as being middle aged female with relatively higher education and moderately low income. The health condition is generally good and the purpose of visit is to receive traditional treatments of acupuncture, herbal medicine, and physical therapy. Treatment efficacy and satisfaction were high with no significant differences between the clinics and hospitals.