Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.7318/KJFC/2015.30.1.041

Comparative Study of Cooking Methods in 「Suwoonjabbang」 vs. 「Eumsikdimibang」  

Chung, Hae Kyung (Department of food and Nutrition, Hoseo University)
Yoon, Kyung Soo (Department of food and Nutrition, Hoseo University)
Kim, Mi Hye (Department of food and Nutrition, Hoseo University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Society of Food Culture / v.30, no.1, 2015 , pp. 41-53 More about this Journal
Abstract
This study aimed to examine the cooking methods used in the Joseon Dynasty using cooking books. We chose "Suwoonjabbang" (1500's) and "Eumsikdimibang" (1610) as the subjects of this study. Cooking methods from these two recipe books were categorized into staples, side dishes, rice cakes, Korean traditional sweets and cookies, drinks, fermented foods, seasonings, and storage methods. Firstly, "Suwoonjabbang" contains a total of 121 cooking methods divided into two volumes. In contrast, "Eumsikdimibang" includes 146 cooking methods. There are 18 methods for noodles and dduks, 74 methods for fish and meat, and 54 methods for drinks and vinegars, and others. Secondly, "Suwoonjabbang" written by Yu Kim in Chinese characters can be described in simple terms. It provides caution against indulging in the taste of food. In contrast, "Eumsikdimibang" by Kye Hyang Jang contains detailed cooking methods that have disappeared. Thirdly, "Eumsikdimibang" introduced more diverse cooking methods for noodles, dumplings, side dishes, rice cake, Korean traditional sweets and cookies, and fermented foods as compared to "Suwoonjabbang". In conclusion, unique cooking methods introduced in these two cooking books, which are rare these days, are expected to be further applied and developed.
Keywords
Food Culture; "Eumsikdimibang"; "Suwoonjabbang"; Chosun Dynasity;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Choi YS. 2013. Health functional benefits of Korean cuisines and their foodstuffs covered in Korean Traditional Food Eumsikdimibang. Master's degree thesis, Daegu Haany University, Korea, pp 14-18
2 Chung HK. 2013. A Literature Review of Cooking Method in Jusiksiui compared with Eumsikdimibang and Gyuhapchongseo. J. Korean Soc. Food Cult., 28(3):234-245   DOI
3 Chung RW, Cho SH, Choi YJ, Kim EM, Won SI, Cha GH, Kim HS, Lee HG. 2007. An investigation of side-dishes found in Korean literatures before the 17th century. Korean J. Food Cook. Sci., 23(5):731-748
4 Claflin KW. 2013. Representations of Food Production and Consumption: Cookbooks as Historical Sources. in The handbook of Food Research. Broomsbury, London, pp 109-130
5 Jang GH (張桂香). Eumsikdimibang (음식디미방). In: Bak DH editor. 2006. Glnurim Co., Seoul, Korea, pp 1-487
6 Jang JH. 1989a. Study of Korean traditional fermented food history. Suhaksa, Seoul, Korea, pp 12-15
7 Jang JH. 1989b. Study of Korean traditional fermented food history. Suhaksa, Seoul, Korea, pp 233-247
8 Jeon SE (全循義). Sangayorok (山家綠). In: Rural development administration editor. 2004. Rural development administration, Korea
9 Jeon SE (全循義). Sikyochanyo (食療纂要). In: Kim JD editor. 2006. Yesmin Co., Kyounggido, Korea, pp 157
10 Joo YH. 2012. Royal cuisine and record of the Choseon Dynasty period. National archives and records service of the ministry of public administration and security. Daejeon, Korea pp 78-85
11 Jo JS. 1994. Historical review of Kimchi. J. East Asian Soc Diet. Life, 4(2):93-108
12 Kim HS. 2004. A comparative study on the changing pattern of fish and shellfish uses in Eum-sik-di-mi-bangand Gyuhapchong-seoin sight of the development of fishing technlology. J. Korean Soc. Food Cult., 19(3):273-284
13 Kim MH, You MN, Choi BY, An HS. 2003. The study of the uses of agricultural products in the Kyuhap-Chongseo. Korean J. Home Manag., 20(1):113-127
14 Lee HJ. 2004. Korean food culture. Sinkwang publication, Seoul, Korea, pp 26
15 Kim US, Han MJ. 2009. Original Articles: The Changes of Side Dishes in Eumsikdimibang, Gyuhapchongseo, Chosunmusangsinsikyorijebub according to the Current of the Time. J. Korean Soc. Food Cult., 24(4):375
16 Kim Y (金綏). Suwoonjabbang (需雲雜方). In: Yoon SK editor. 1998. Sinkwang publication Co., Seoul, Korea, pp 155
17 Lee HJ. 1981. A study on the chap. Food and wine in Gwuhab ch'ongsur. College of Education Hanyang University, 1(1):85-103
18 Lee HJ, Jo SH, Chung NW, Kim HS, Yoo YR, Choi YJ, Kim EM, Bak SE, Won SI, Kim SY, Cha KH, Bak HN. 2004. Si Ei Jun Seo. Sinkwang publication, Seoul, Korea, pp 180
19 Lee SI. 2012. Confucian hermits' poetic adventure and communication in the 16th century: focusing on the cultural politics of Suwoon-Jabbang. J. East. stud., 80:267-298
20 Lee SI, Kim MY, Kim JD, Joo YH, Chung HK. 2012. Grace of classical scholar, taste of women's quaters. Glhangari, Seoul, Korea, pp 343-420
21 Lee SW. 1985. Cultural history of Korean food. Kyumoonsa, Seoul, pp 19-133
22 Lee YK, Chun HJ, Lee HG. 1992. A bibliographical study on the Tojangguk in Korea. J. Korean Soc. Food Cult., 7(1):81-90
23 Park OJ. 2000. The Literary Study on Pinghugak's (憑虛閣) Kyuhapchonseo. Soc. Korean Class. Woman Lit., 1(1):271-304
24 Pinghugak Lee (憑虛閣 李氏). Kyuhapchonseo (閨閤叢書). In: Jung YW editor. 1992. Bojinjea Co., Kyounggido, Korea, pp 87
25 Yoon SS, Cho HJ. 1993a. commentary food cooking method the Joseon Dynasty. J. Korean Soc. Food Cult., 8(1):79-84
26 Woo MO. 2012. The Cosmetic Culture Described in Korea Literature in the Late Choson Period. Doctoral degree thesis. Dong-A University, Korea, pp 1-126
27 Yu JL (柳重臨). Jungbo Salrim Kyungjae (增補山林經濟). In: Rural development administration editor. 2003. Rural development administration, Korea