Browse > Article

Application of Response Surface Methodology for the Optimization of Process in Food Technology  

Sim, Chol-Ho (Department of Fine Chemistry & New Materials, Sangji University)
Publication Information
Food Engineering Progress / v.15, no.2, 2011 , pp. 97-115 More about this Journal
Abstract
A review about the application of response surface methodology in the optimization of food technology is presented. The theoretical principles of response surface methodology and steps for its application are described. The response surface methodologies : three-level full factorial, central composite, Box-Behnken, and Doehlert designs are compared in terms of characteristics and efficiency. Furthermore, recent references of their uses in food technology are presented. A comparison between the response surface designs (three-level full factorial, central composite, Box-Behnken and Doehlert design) has demonstrated that the Box-Behnken and Doehlert designs are slightly more efficient than the central composite design but much more efficient than the three-level full factorial designs.
Keywords
food technology; optimization; Response surface methodology; three-level full factorial design; central composite design; Box-Behnken design; Doehlert design;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 28  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Aggarwal A, Singh H. 2005. Optimization of machining techniques: A retrospective and literature review. Sadhana 30(part 6): 699-711.   DOI   ScienceOn
2 Alamprese C, Datei L, Semeraro Q. 2007. Optimization of processing parameters of a ball mill refiner for chocolate. J. Food Eng. 83: 629-636.   DOI   ScienceOn
3 An SW, Choi JY, Cha MW, Park JW. 2010. Adsorption characterization of Cd by coal fly ash using response surface methodology( RSM). J. Korean Geo-Env. Soc. 11(1): 19-26.
4 Aragao NM, Veloso MCC, Bispo MS, Ferreira SLC, Andrade JB. 2005. Multivariate optimisation of the experimental conditions for determination of three methylxanthines by reversed-phase highperformance liquid chromatography. Talanta. 67: 1007-1013.   DOI   ScienceOn
5 Araujo P, Couillard F, Leirnes E, Ask K, Bokevoll A, Froyland L. 2006. Experimental design considerations in quantification experiments by using the internal standard technique: Cholesterol determination by gas chromatography as a case study, J. Chromatogr. A. 1121: 99-105.   DOI
6 Atkinson AC, Tobias RD. 2008. Optimal experimental design in chromatography. J. Chromatogr. A. 1177:1-11.   DOI
7 Ban YJ, Baik MY, Hahm YT, Kim HK, Kim BY. 2010a. Optimization of processing conditions for making a black ginger and design mixture for black ginger drinks. Food Eng. Prog. 14(2): 112-117.
8 Ban YJ, Yang BW, Baik MY, Hahm YT, Kim BY. 2010b. Optimization of the manufacturing process for Black ginseng. J. Korean Soc. Appl. Biol. Chem., 53(1): 71-77.
9 Bezerra MA, Santelli RE, Oliveira EP, Villar LS, EscaleiraL A. 2008. Response surface methodology as a tool for optimization in analytical chemistry. Talanta. 76: 965-977.   DOI   ScienceOn
10 Bezerra MA, Bruns RE, Ferreira SLC. 2006. Statistical designprincipal component analysis optimization of a multiple response procedure using cloud point extraction and simultaneous determination of metals by ICP OES. Anal. Chim. Acta. 580: 251- 257.   DOI   ScienceOn
11 Box GEP, Behnken DW. 1960. Some new three level designs for the study of quantitave variables. Technometrics. 2(4): 455-475.   DOI   ScienceOn
12 Cardenes L, Martin-Calero A, Ayala JH, Gonzalez V, Afonso AM. 2006. Experimental design optimization of solid-phase microextraction conditions for the determination of Heterocyclic aromatic amines by high-performance liquid chromatography. Anal. Lett. 39: 405-423.   DOI   ScienceOn
13 Davies MP, Biasi VD, Perrett D. 2004. Approaches to the rational design of molecularly imprinted polymers. Anal. Chim. Acta. 504: 7-14.   DOI   ScienceOn
14 Cho KJ, Baik MY, Choi YJ, Kim BY. 2008. Preparation of functional solid tablets using oyster hydrolysate and plant extracts, Food Eng. Prog. 12(3): 163-169.
15 Cho IH, Lee NH, Chang SW, An SW, Yonn YH, Zoh KD. 2006. Analysis of characteristics and optimization of photo-degradation condition of reactive orange 16 using a Box-Behnken method. J. of KSEE. 28(9): 917-925.
16 Choi MS, Shin JK, Chung MS. 2007. Optimization of conditions for manufacturing vegetable juice using pulsed electric field (PFF) technique. Food Eng. Prog. 11(3): 216-224.
17 Doehlert DH. 1970. Uniform shell designs, applied statistics, 19: 231-239.   DOI   ScienceOn
18 Ferreira SLC, Bruns RE, Ferreira HS, Matos GD, David JM, Brandao GC, Silva EGP, Portugal LA, Reis PS, Souza AS, Santos WNL. 2007a. Box-Behnken design; An alternative for the optimization of analytical methods. Anal. Chim. Acta. 597: 179-186.   DOI   ScienceOn
19 Ferreira SLC, Bruns RE, Silva EGP, Santos WNL, Quintella CM, David JM, Andrade JB, Breitkreitz MC, Jardim ICSF, Neto BB. 2007b. Statistical designs and response surface techniques for the optimization of chromatographic systems. J. Chromatogr. A. 1158: 2-14.   DOI
20 Ferreira SLC, Santos WNL, Quintella CM, Neto BB, Bosque- Sendra JM. 2004. Doehlert matrix: a chemometric tool for analytical chemistry-review. Talanta. 63: 1061-1067.   DOI   ScienceOn
21 Ferreira SLC, dos Santos WNL, Bezerra MA, Lemos VA, Bosquo- Sendra JM. 2003. Use of factorial design and Doehlert matrix for multivariate optimisation of an on-line preconcentration system for lead determination by frame atomic absortion spectrometry. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 375: 443-449.
22 Guerrero ED, Marin RN, Mejias RC, Barroso CG. 2006. Optimisation of stir bar sorptive extraction applied to the determination of volatile compounds in vinegars. J. Chromatogr. A. 1104: 47- 53.   DOI
23 Garcia-villar N, Saurina J, Hernández-Cassou S. 2006. High-Performance liquid chromatographic determination of biogenic amines in wines with an experimental design optimization procedure. Anal. Chim. Acta. 575: 97-105.   DOI   ScienceOn
24 Ghafoor K, Choi YH. 2009. Optimization of ultrasound-assisted extraction for antiradical activities of peel and seed extracts of Campbell early grapes. Food Eng. Prog. 13(1): 32-37.
25 Gilmour SG. 2006. Response surface designs for experiments in bioprocessing. Biometrics. 62: 323-331.   DOI   ScienceOn
26 Han MR, Kim AJ, Chung KS, Lee SJ, Kim MH. 2005. Optimization for manufacturing soybean curd adding mulbery leaf powder and extract. Food Eng. Prog. 9(4): 276-282.
27 Hernandez-Borges J, Rodriguez-Delgado MA, Garcìa-Montelongo FJ, Cifuentes A. 2005. Analysis of pesticides in soy milk combining solid-phase extraction and capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry. J. Sep. Sci. 28: 948-956.   DOI   ScienceOn
28 Hill WJ, Hunter WG. 1966. A review of response surface methodology: A literature Review, Technometrics, 8: 571-590.   DOI   ScienceOn
29 Hong KJ, Jeon KK, Cho YS, Choi DH, Lee SJ. 2000. A Study on the construction of response surfaces for design optimization, Trans. of the KSME(A). 24(6): 1408-1418.
30 Hows MEP, Perrett D Kay J. 1997. Optimisation of a simultaneous separation of sulphonamides, dihydrofolate reductase inhibitors and $\beta$-lactam antibiotics by capillary electrophoresis. J. Chromatogr. A. 768: 97-104.   DOI
31 Jeon JY, Jo IH, Kyung HK, Kim HA, Lee CM, Choi YH. 2010. Optimization of solvent extraction process on the active functional components from chinese quince. Food Eng. Prog. 14(2): 92-98.
32 Hwang SK, Hong JT, Jung KH, Chang BC, Hwang KS, Shin JH, Yim SP, Yoo SK. 2008. Process optimization of dextran production by Leuconostoc sp. strain YSK. isolated from fermented Kimchi. J. Life Sci. 18(10): 1377-1383.   DOI
33 Im SJ, Jun JY, Choi YH. 2007. Optimization for the extraction process of effective components from paprica. Food Eng. Prog. 11(1): 31-37.
34 Jalbani N, Kazi TG, Arain BM, Jamali MK, Afridi HI, Sarfraz RA. 2006. Application of factorial design in optimization of ultrasonic-assisted extraction of aluminum in juices and soft drinks. Talanta. 70: 307-314.   DOI   ScienceOn
35 Jeon JY, Park JH, Kim SH, Choi YH. 2009. Optimization of $\beta$-glucan extraction process from rice bran and rice germ using response surface methodology. Food Eng. Prog. 13(1): 8-15.
36 Jeon JY, Ha SY, Kim YJ, Lee JE, Choi YH. 2008. Optimization of hot-water extraction process of functional components from Glycyrrhiza uralensis using a response surface methodology. Food Eng. Prog. 12(4): 289-296.
37 Joo NM, Lee SM, Jeong HS. 2009. Optimized recipe for cookies with dried danggue powder determined by response surface methology, J East Asian Soc. Dietary Life. 19(3): 421-429.
38 Juntachote T, Berghofer E, Bauer F, Siebenhadl S. 2006. The application of response surface methodology to the production of phenolic extracts of lemon grass, galangai, holy basil and rosemary, Int. J. Food Sci. Technol. 41: 121-133.   DOI   ScienceOn
39 Kim DS, Park YS. 2010. Application of the central composite design and response surface methodology to the treatment of dye using electrocoagulation/flotation process, J. Korean Soc. Water Qual. 26(1): 35-43.
40 Kim MY, Kim JM, Lee YJ, Heo OS, Kim MR. 2009. Optimization of spirulina added korean rice cake(Garaeduk) using response surface methodology, J East Asian Soc. Dietary Life 19(1): 38-44.
41 Kim DS, Park YS. 2009. Optimization of the turbidity removal conditions from $TiO_{2}$ solution using a response surface methodology in the electrocoagulation/flotation process, J. Env. Health Sci. 35(6): 500-508.
42 Kim HR, Seog EJ, Lee JH. 2007. Effects of onion powder and baking temperature on the physicochemical properties of cookies, J. Food Sci. Nutr. 12: 160-166.   DOI
43 Kim SI, Hong J.P. 2005. Optimum design using response surface methodology. World of Electricity 54(9): 24-28.
44 Lee SI. 2010. Drug interaction: focusing on response surface models. Korean J. Anesthesiol. 58(5): 421-434.   DOI   ScienceOn
45 Lee JH, Kim DE, Park CH, Kang WS. 2008. Extraction-cooking of tartary buckwheat (Fagopyrum totaricum) flour using a twinscrew extruder, Food Eng. Prog. 12(2): 107-114.
46 Lee SH. 2008. Data Analysis of Engineering Statistics using Minitab, revision, Iretec Inc., Kunpo, ROK, pp.647-778.
47 Lee KA, Jung JE, Choi YH. 2007. Optimization of microwaveassisted extraction process of hericium erinaceus, Food Eng. Prog. 11(3): 195-202.
48 Lee SM, Jung HA, Joo NM. 2006. Optimization of iced cookie with the addition of dried red ginseng powder. Korean J. Food Nutr. 19(4); 448-459.
49 Lee JK, Ryu GH. 2006a. Effect of extrusion process variables on rutin content in buckwheat, Food Eng. Prog. 10(4): 280-285.
50 Lee MS, Ryu GH. 2006b. Optimization of hot water extraction conditions for cod byproduct by response surface methodology analysis, Food Eng. Prog. 10(4): 248-255.
51 Lee C. 2004. Optimization for extrusion-cooking of rice-isp-file fish mixture by response surface methodology J. Korean Soc. Food Sci. Nutr. 33(10): 1742-1747.   DOI
52 Martinez-Bustos F, López-Soto M, Martìn-Martìnez ES, Zazueta- Morales JJ, Velez-Medina JJ. 2007. Effects of high energy milling on some functional properties of jicama starch and cassava starch, J. Food Eng. 78: 1212-1220.   DOI   ScienceOn
53 Lee KD, Lee JE, Kwon CH. 2000. Application of response surface methodology in food chemistry Food Sci. Ind. 33(1): 33-45.
54 Lomillo MAA, Campo FJ, Pascual FJM. 2006. Preliminary contribution to the quantification of HMF in honey by electrochemical biosensor chips. Electroanalysis. 18(24): 2435-2440.   DOI   ScienceOn
55 Martendal E, Budziak D, Carasek E. 2007. Application of fractional factorial experimental and Box-Behnken designs for optimization of single-drop microextraction of 2,4,6-trichloroanisole and 2,4,6-tribromoanisole from wine samples, J. Chromatogr. A. 1148: 131-136.   DOI
56 Martinez-Urunuela A, González-Sáiz JM, Pizarro C. 2004. Optimisation of a headspace solid-phase microextraction method for the direct determination of chloroanisoles related to cork taint in red wine, J. Chromatogr. A. 1056: 49-56.
57 Mead R, Pike DJ. 1975. A review of response surface methodology from a biometrics view point. Biometrics 31: 803-851.   DOI
58 Mejias RC, Marin RN, Moreno MVG, Barroso CG. 2003. Optimisation of headspace solid-phase microextraction for the analysis of volatile phenols in wine. J. Chromatogr. A. 995: 11-20.   DOI
59 Mok CK. 2007. Texture changes of soybean paste(Doenjang) by heat treatment. Food Eng. Prog. 11(2): 84-88.
60 Momenbeik F, Khorasani JH. 2006. Separation and determination of sugars by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography after pre-column microwave-assisted derivatization. Anal. Bioanal Chem. 384: 844-850.   DOI   ScienceOn
61 Myers RH, Montgomery DC, Vining GG, Borror CM, Kowalski SM. 2004. Response surface methodology; A Retrospective and literature survey, J. Qual. Technol. 36(1): 53-77.
62 Park JW, Kim HS, Park IB, Shin GW, Lee YJ, Jo Y.C. 2009. Optimization of ethanol extraction conditions from glasswort (Salicornia Herbacea) using response surface methodology. Korean J. Food Preserv. 16(3): 376-384.
63 Myers RH, Kliuri AI, Carter WH. 1989. Response surface methodology: 1966-1988, Technometrics 31: 137-157.
64 Nanda V, Singh S, Raina CS, Jindal N, Singh K. 2004. Optimization of the process variables for the preparation of processed paneer using response surface methodology. Eur. Food Res. Technol. 218: 529-534.
65 Navalon A, Prieto A, Araujo L, Vìlchez JL. 2002. Determination of oxadiazon residues by headspace solid-phase microextraction and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, J. Chromatogr. A. 946: 239-245.   DOI
66 Park SH. 2005. Modern experimental design, revision, Minyoungsa, Seoul, ROK, pp.453-490.
67 Ren J, Lin WT, Shen YJ, Wang JF, Luo XC, Xie MQ. 2008. Optimization of fermentation media for nitrite oxidizing bacteria using sequential design. Biores. Technol. 99: 7923-7927.   DOI   ScienceOn
68 Saccani G, Tanzi E, Mallozzi S, Cavalli S. 2005. Determination of niacin in fresh and dry cured pork products by ion chromatography: experimental design approach for the optimisation of nicotinic acid separation. Food Chem. 92: 373-379.   DOI   ScienceOn
69 Santelli RE, Bezerra MA, SantAna OD, Cassella RJ, Ferreira SLC. 2006. Multivariate technique for optimization of digestion procedure by focussed microwave system for determination of Mn, Zn and Fe in food samples using FAAS, Talanta, 68: 1083- 1088.   DOI   ScienceOn
70 Seog EJ, Lee JH. 2007. Effects of prunus mume extract and red pepper powder on the sensory taste of Kochujang, Food Eng. Prog. 11(4): 321-325.
71 Shyy W, Papila N, Vaidyanathan R, Tucker K. 2001. Global design optimization for aerodynamics and rocket propulsion components. Prog. Aerospace Sci. 37: 59-118.   DOI   ScienceOn
72 Shih IL, Lin CY, Wu JY, Hsieh C. 2009. Production of antifungal lipopeptide from Bacillus subtilis in submerged fermentation using shake flask and fermentor. Korean J. Chem. Eng. 26(6): 1652-1661.   DOI   ScienceOn
73 Shin HH, Kang MJ, Cho HY, Kim BC, Cho EK. 2008. Optimization of extraction conditions for Houttuynia cordara Thunb and Saururus chinesis baill mixture by response surface methodology. Food Eng. Prog. 12(4): 247-255.
74 Shin SM, Park KJ, Choi YS, Lee SK, Choi GJ, Kwon BS, Cho BR. 2007. Development of process analytical technology(PAT) for total quality innovation on pharmaceutical processes. J. Kor. Pharm. Sci. 37(6): 329-338.
75 Simpson JR, Landman D, Giroux R, Zeisset M, Halll B, Rhew RD. 2008. Adapting second-order response surface design to specific needs. Quality and reliability engineering international. 24: 331-349.   DOI   ScienceOn
76 Stafieg A, Pyrzynska K, Ranz A, Lankmayr E. 2006. Screening and optimization of derivatization in heating block for the determination of aliphatic aldehydes by HPLC. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods. 69: 15-24.   DOI   ScienceOn
77 Sung RK. 2004. SAS/STAT Regression Analysis, 3rd ed., Freedom Academy, Paju, ROK, pp.234-282.
78 Tarley CRT, Silveira G, Santos WNL, Matos GD, Silva EGP, Bezerra MA, Miró M, Ferreira SLC. 2009. Chemometric tools in electroanalytical chemistry : Methods for optimization based on factorial design and response surface methodology. Microchemical J. 92: 58-67.   DOI   ScienceOn
79 Trinca LA, Gilmour SG. 1999. Difference variance dispersion graphs for comparing response surface designs with applications in food technology. Appl. Statist. 48(4): 441-455.
80 Wang J, Wan W. 2009. Experimental design methods for fermentative hydrogen production: A review. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, 34: 235-244.   DOI   ScienceOn
81 Weuster-Bolz D. 2000. Experimental design for fermentation media development: Statistical design or global search. J. Biosci. Bioeng. 90(5): 473-483.
82 Yim YB, Park SH, An BJ, Kim YI. 2008. Practical experimental design, Freedom academy, Paju, ROK, pp.333-378.
83 Yoon SR, Lee GD, Kim HK, Kwon JH. 2010. Monitoring of chemical changes in explosively puffed Ginseng and the optimization of puffing conditions. J. Ginseng Res. 34(1): 59-67.   DOI
84 Youn KS, Hong JH, Choi, YH. 2006. Optimization for extraction of Sancho(Zanthoxylum schinifolium) extraction using supercritical carbon dioxide. Food Eng. Prog. 10(4): 207-213.
85 Zhang X, Lu W, Yang P, Cong W. 2008. Application of response surface methodology to optimize the operation process for regeneration of acid and base using bipolar membrane electrodialysis. J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol. 83: 12-19.   DOI   ScienceOn