Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.14697/jkase.2012.32.8.1295

Can Definitions Contribute to Alternative Conceptions?: A Meta-Study Approach  

Wong, Chee Leong (Nanyang Technological University)
Yap, Kueh Chin (Nanyang Technological University)
Publication Information
Journal of The Korean Association For Science Education / v.32, no.8, 2012 , pp. 1295-1317 More about this Journal
Abstract
There has been disagreement on the importance of definitions in science education. Yager (1983) believes that one crisis in science education was due to the considerable emphasis upon the learning of definitions. Hobson (2004) disagrees with physics textbooks that do not provide general definition on energy. Some textbooks explain that "there is no completely satisfactory definition of energy" or they can only "struggle to define it." In general, imprecise definitions in textbooks (Bauman, 1992) and inaccuracies in definition provided by teachers (Galili & Lehavi, 2006) may cause alternative conceptions. Besides, there are at least four challenges in defining physical concepts: precision, circularity, context and completeness in knowledge. These definitional problems that have been discussed in The Feynman Lectures, may impede the learning of physical concepts. A meta-study approach is employed to examine about five hundreds journal papers that may discuss definitions in physics, problems in defining physical concepts and how they may result in alternative conceptions. These journal papers are mainly selected from journals such as American Journal of Physics, International Journal of Science Education, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, Physics Education, The Physics Teachers, and so on. There are also comparisons of definitions with definitions from textbooks, Dictionaries of Physics, and English Dictionaries. To understand the nature of alternative conception, Lee et al. (2010) have suggested a theoretical framework to describe the learning issues by synthesizing cognitive psychology and science education approaches. Taking it a step further, this study incorporates the challenges in semantics and epistemology, proposes that there are at least four variants of alternative conceptions. We may coin the term, 'alternative definitions', to refer to the commonly available definitions, which have these four problems in defining physics concepts. Based on this study, alternative definitions may result in at least four variants of alternative conceptions. Note that these four definitional problems or challenges in definitions cannot be easily resolved. Educators should be cognizant of the four variants of alternative conceptions which can arise from alternative definitions. The concepts of alternative definitions can be useful and possibly generalized to science education and beyond.
Keywords
Definitions; Alternative conceptions; meta-study;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Thomaz, M. F., Malaquias, I. M., Valente, M. C. & Antunes, M. J. (1995). An attempt to overcome alternative conceptions related to heat and temperature. Physics Education, 30(1), 19-26.   DOI   ScienceOn
2 Tipler, P. A. & Mosca, G. (2004). Physics for Scientists and Engineers (5th ed.). New York: W.H. Freeman & Company.
3 Tribus, M. & McIrvine, E. C. (1971). Energy and information (thermodynamics and information theory). Scientific American, 225(9), 179-188.   DOI
4 Trowbridge D. E. & McDermott, L. C. (1981). Investigation of student understanding of the concept of acceleration in one dimension. American Journal of Physics, 49(3), 242-253.   DOI
5 Van Camp, M., Camelbeeck, T. & Richard, P. (2003). The FG5 absolute gravimeter: metrology and geophysics. Physicalia Magazine, Journal of the Belgian Society, 25(3), 161-174.
6 Warren, J. W. (1972). The teaching of the concept of heat. Physics Education, 7(1), 41-4.   DOI   ScienceOn
7 Warren, J. W. (1983). Energy and its carriers: a critical analysis. Physics Education, 18(5), 209-212.   DOI   ScienceOn
8 Whelan, P. M. & Hodgson, M. J. (1989). Essential Principles of Physics (2nd ed.). John Murray.
9 Wilczek, F. (2005). Whence the Force of F = ma? 2: Rationalization. Physics Today, 58(12), 10-11.
10 Wilczek, F. (2008). The Lightness of Being. New York: Basic Books.
11 Williams, H. T. (1999). Semantics in teaching introductory physics. American Journal of Physics, 67(8), 670-680.   DOI
12 Wilson, J. D., Buffa, A. J. & Lou, B. (2007). College Physics (6th ed.). New Jersey: Pearson.
13 Wong, C. L. & Yap, K. C. (2010). In Search of a Framework to facilitate Statements of Definitions in Physics: Is Feynman's Lectures on Physics a good Guide? Paper presented at Global Chinese Conference on Science Education, 2010.
14 Yager, R. E. (1983). The importance of terminology in teaching K 12 Science. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 20(6), 577-588.   DOI
15 Yates, J. (1985). The content of awareness is a model of the world. Psychological Review, 92(2), 249-284.   DOI
16 Yeo, S. & Zadnik, M. (2001). Introductory thermal concept evaluation: Assessing students' understanding. The Physics Teacher, 39(8), 496-504.   DOI   ScienceOn
17 Young, H. D. & Freedman (2004). Sears and Zemansky's University Physics (11th ed.). California: Addison Wesley.
18 Zemansky, M. W. (1970). The use and misuse of the word "heat"in physics teaching. The Physics Teacher, 8(6), 295-300.   DOI
19 Roche, J. (1989). Applying the history of electricity in the classroom: a reconstruction of the concept of 'Potential'In "Teaching the History of Science ed Michael Shortland & Andrew Warwick". Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 168-184.
20 Rogers, E. H. (1981). Methodology for metaresearch. Presidential address at the conference of the International Communication Association.
21 Romer, R. H. (2001). Heat is not a noun. American Journal of Physics, 69(2), 107-9.   DOI   ScienceOn
22 Rossing, T. D. (1995). Magnetic forces and fields: A note on terminology, definitions, and pedagogy. American Journal of Physics, 63(10), 957-958.   DOI
23 Ruggiero, S., Cartelli, A., Dupre, F. & Vincentini-Missoni, M. (1985). Weight, gravity and air pressure: mental representations by Italian middle school pupils. European Journal of Science Education, 7(2), 181-194.   DOI   ScienceOn
24 Sexl, R. U. (1981). Some observations concerning the teaching of energy concept. European Journal of Science Education, 3(3), 285-289.   DOI
25 Scherr, R. E., Shaffer, P. S. & Vokos, S. (2001). Student understanding of time in special relativity: Simultaneity and reference frames. American Journal of Physics, 69(7), S24-S35.   DOI
26 Sears, F. W. (1950). Mechanics, Heat and Sound. Addison-Wesley.
27 Serway, & Faughn J. S. (2003). College physics (6th ed). California: Thomson Learning.
28 Shaffer, P. S. & McDermott, L. C. (1992). Research as a guide for curriculum development: An example from introductory electricity. Part II: Design of instructional strategies. American Journal of Physics, 60(11), 1003-1013.   DOI
29 Shaw, R. E. M. (1969). A question of heat. Physics Education, 4(4), 251-2.   DOI   ScienceOn
30 Slisko, J. J. & Dykstra D. I. (1997). The Role of Scientific Terminology in Research and Teaching: Is Something Important Missing? Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 34(6), 655-660.   DOI
31 Smith, P. L. & Ragan, T. J. (1999). Instructional design. USA: John Wiley & Sons. Soter, S. (2007). What is a Planet? Scientific American, 296(1), 34-41.
32 Spalding, D. B. & Cole, E. H. (1966). Engineering Thermodynamics. London: Edward Arnold.
33 Stuart, M. C. (1938). Use and Meaning of the Term Heat. American Journal of Physics, 6(2), 40.
34 Suzuki, M. (2005). Social Metaphorical Mapping of the Concept of Force "CHI-KA-RA" in apanese. International Journal of Science Education, 27(15,16), 1773-1804.   DOI   ScienceOn
35 Swartz, C. E. & Miner, T. (1996). Teaching Introductory Physics: A Sourcebook. New York: AIP Press.
36 Moore, G. S. M. (1993). General, restricted and misleading forms of the First law of thermodynamics. Physics Education, 28(4), 228-237.   DOI   ScienceOn
37 Swendsen, R. H. (2011). How physicists disagree on the meaning of entropy. American Journal of Physics, 79(4), 342-8.   DOI   ScienceOn
38 Taber, K. S. (2000). Finding the optimum level of simplification: the case of teaching about heat and temperature. Physics Education, 35(5), 320-5.   DOI   ScienceOn
39 Mendelson, K. S. (2003). Physical and colloquial meanings of the term "work". American Journal of Physics, 71(3), 279-281.   DOI   ScienceOn
40 Moore, T. A. (2003). Six Ideas That Shaped Physics. Unit C: Conservation Laws Constrain Interactions (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
41 Mullet, E. & Gervais, H. (1990). Distinction between the concept of weight and mass in high school students. International Journal of Science Education, 12(2), 217-226.   DOI
42 Mungan, C. (2005). Work and Energy. American Journal of Physics, 73(3), 197-198.
43 Newburgh, R. (2009). Carnot to Clausius: caloric to entropy. Europe Journal of Physics, 30(4), 713-728.   DOI   ScienceOn
44 Newton, I. (1687/1999). Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
45 Noce, G., Torosantucci, G. & Vincentini, M. (1988). The floating of objects on the moon: prediction from a theory or experimental facts? International Journal of Science Education, 10(1), 61-70.   DOI   ScienceOn
46 Okun, L. B. (1989). The concept of mass (Mass, Energy, Relativity). Sov. Phys. Usp., 32(7), 629-638.   DOI   ScienceOn
47 Paterson, B. L., Thorne, S. E., Canam, C., & Jillings, C. (2001). Meta-study of qualitative health research: A practical guide to metaanalysis and meta-synthesis. Thousand Oaks, California: Sage.
48 Palmer, D. (2001). Students'alternative conceptions and scientifically acceptable conceptions about gravity. International Journal of Science Education, 23(7), 691-706.   DOI   ScienceOn
49 Papadouris, N. & Constantinou, C. P. (2011). A Philosophically Informed Teaching Proposal on the Topic of Energy for Students Aged 11-14. Science & Education. 20(10), 961-79.   DOI
50 Parton, C. G. (1975). Weight and mass. Physics Education, 10(1), 58.
51 Piaget, J. (1974). Understanding causality. New York: Norton.
52 Redish, E. F. (2003). Teaching Physics with the Physics Suite. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.
53 Redish, E. F. (2004). A Theoretical Framework for Physics Education Research: Modeling student thinking, in Proceedings of the International School of Physics, -Enrico Fermi Course CLVI, Redish, E. F. & Vicentini, M. (eds.) Amsterdam: IOS.
54 Rickheit, G. & Sichelschmidt, L. (1999). "Mental Models: Some Answers, Some Questions, Some Suggestions" in Mental Models in Discourse Processing and Reasoning, edited by Rickheit G. & Habel C., North-Holland: Elsevier, pp. 9-40.
55 Robertson, B. (2008). Science 101: Do balance and scales determine an object's mass or its weight? Science and Children, 45(7), 68-71.
56 Roche, J. (1971). Teaching heat using the joule. Physics Education, 6(2), 125.   DOI   ScienceOn
57 Hobson, A. (2004). Energy and work. The Physics Teacher, 42(5), 260.
58 Iona, M. (1975). The Meaning of Weight. The Physics Teacher, 13(5), 263-274.   DOI
59 Hudson, R. C. & Munley, F. (1996). Re-score the Force Concept Inventory! The Physics Teacher, 34(5), 261.   DOI
60 Iona, M. (1973). Energy is the Ability to do Work. The Physics Teacher, 11(5), 259.   DOI
61 Iona, M. (1987). Weightlessness is Real. The Physics Teacher, 25(7), 418.
62 Iona, M. (1999). Weight An Official Definition. The Physics Teacher, 37(4), 238.
63 Itza-Ortiz, S. F., Rebello N. S., Zollman D. A. & Rodriguez-Achach M. (2003). The Vocabulary of Introductory Physics and its implications for learning physics. The Physics Teacher, 41(9), 330-336.   DOI   ScienceOn
64 Johnson K., Hewett S., Holt, S. & Miller, J. (2000). Advanced Physics for You. Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes.
65 Karplus, R. (2003). Introductory Physics: A Model Approach (2nd ed.). Buzzards Bay: Captain's Engineering Services.
66 Keyes, O. B. (1973). The concept of temperature again. Physics Education, 8(1), 60.
67 Kruger, C. J., Summers, M. K. & Palacio, D. J. (1990). An investigation of some English primary school teachers'understanding. British Educational Research Journal, 16(4), 383-397.   DOI   ScienceOn
68 Kurnaz, M. A. & Saǧlam-Arslan, A. (2011). A Thematic Review of Some Studies Investigating Students'Alternative Conceptions about Energy. Eurasian Journal of Physics and Chemistry Education, 3(1), 51-74.
69 Langsberg, G. S. (1971/2000). Textbook of Elementary Physics, Volume 1. Honolulu, Hawaii: University Press of the Pacific.
70 Lederman, N. G. & O'Malley, M. (1990). Students'perceptions of tentativeness in science: Development, use, and sources of change. Science Education, 74(2), 225-239.   DOI
71 Lee, G., Shin, J., Park, J., Song, S., Kim, Y. & Bao, L. (2005a). An Integrated Theoretical Structure of Mental Models in Science Education: Students'ideas of the circular motion. Journal of the Korean Association for Research in Science Education. 25(6), 698-709.
72 Lee, G., Shin, J., Park, J., Song, S., Kim, Y. & Bao, L. (2005b). Alternative conceptions, memory, & mental models in physics education. 2004 Physics Education Research Conference. 1ed. Sacramento, California (USA): AIP. 165-168.
73 Leff, H. S. (2007). Entropy, Its Language, and Interpretation. Foundations of Physics, 37(12), 1744-1766.   DOI
74 Lindsay, R. B. (1937). A Critique of Operationalism in Physics. Philosophy of Science, 4(4), 456-470.   DOI   ScienceOn
75 Mach, E. (1883/1989). The science of mechanics. La Salle, IL: Open Court.
76 Mayer, J. R. (1842). Bemerkungen umber die Krafte der unbelebten Natur. Annalen der Chemie und Pharmacie. In J. R. Mayer (Ed.), Die Mechanik der Warme: Samtliche Schriften (Vol. 42, pp. 233-240). HP Munzenmayer, Stadtarchiv Heilbronn, Stadtarchiv Heilbronn, Heilbronn.
77 French, A. P. (1968). Special relativity. New York: W W Norton.
78 French, A. P. (2000). Is Maxwell's Displacement Current a Current? The Physics Teacher, 38(5), 274-6.   DOI   ScienceOn
79 Galili, I. (1993). Weight and Gravity: teachers'ambiguity and students'confusion about the concepts. International Journal of Science Education, 15(1), 149-162.   DOI
80 Galili, I. & Kaplan, D. (1996). Students' Operation with the Concept of Weight. Science Education, 80(4), 457-487.   DOI
81 Galili, I. & Lehavi Y. (2006). Definitions of Physical Concepts: A study of physics teachers' knowledge and views. International Journal of Science Education, 28(5), 521-541.   DOI   ScienceOn
82 Gao, L. B. (1998). Cultural Context of School Science Teaching and Learning in the People's Republic of China. Science Education, 82(1), 1-13.   DOI
83 Giordano, N. J. (2010). College Physics: Reasoning and Relationships. Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole Cengage Learning.
84 Gomez, E. J. & Duran, E. F. (1998). Didactic Problems in the Concept of Electric Potential Difference and an Analysis of its Philogenesis. Science & Education, 7(2), 129-141.   DOI   ScienceOn
85 Grayson, D. J. (2004). Concept substitution: A teaching strategy for helping students disentangle related physics concepts. American Journal of Physics, 72(8), 1126-1133.   DOI   ScienceOn
86 Gunstone, R. F. & White, R. T. (1981). Understanding of gravity. Science Education, 65(3), 291-299.   DOI
87 Halliday, D., Resnick, R. & Walker, J. (2005). Fundamentals of Physics (7th ed.). New York: Wiley.
88 Halloun, I. A. & Hestenes, D. (1985). Common sense concepts about motion. American Journal of Physics, 53(11), 1056-1065.   DOI
89 Harper, J. (2003). Archimedes'Principle and the FCI. The Physics Teacher, 41(9), 510.   DOI
90 Harris, J. (1969). Temperature - its meaning and measurement. Physics Education, 4(4), 204-6.   DOI   ScienceOn
91 Hatsopoulos, G. N. & Keenan, J. H. (1965). Principles of General Thermodynamics. Chichester: John Wiley.
92 Heisenberg, W. (1967). Nonlinear problems in physics. Physics Today, 20(5), 27-33.
93 Hayakawa, S. I. & Hayakawa, A. R. (1990). Language in thought and action, 5th edition. Harcourt Brace.
94 Hecht, E. (2003). Physics: Algebra/Trig (3rd ed.). Pacific Grove: Thomson Learning.
95 Hecht, E. (2006). There is No Really Good Definition of Mass. The Physics Teacher, 44(1), 40-45.   DOI   ScienceOn
96 Helsdon, R. M. (1976). Teaching thermodynamics. Physics Education, 11(4), 261-2.   DOI   ScienceOn
97 Hestenes, D., Wells, M. & Swackhamer, G. (1992). Force concept inventory. The Physics Teacher, 30(3), 141-158.   DOI
98 Hewitt, P. (2006). Conceptual Physics (10th ed.). San Francisco: Addison Wesley.
99 Hobson, A. (2003). Physics: Concepts and Connections (3rd ed.). New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
100 Bishop, R. (1999). Weight - An Accurate, Upto-Date, Layman's Definition. The Physics Teacher, 37(4), 238-9.
101 Black, J. (1775). The supposed effect of boiling upon water in disposing it to freeze more readily. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A, 65, 124-128.   DOI
102 Breithaupt, J. (1995). Understanding Physics for Advanced Level (3th ed.). Cheltenham: Stanley Thorne.
103 Brookes, D. & Etkina, E. (2009). Force, ontology and language. Physical Review, Special Topics, Physics Education Research, 5(1), 010110.
104 Brooks, M. (2009). Seven things that don't make sense about gravity. New Scientist. 202, 28-32.
105 Brown, R. (1999). Weight Don't use the word at all. The Physics Teacher, 37(4), 241.   DOI   ScienceOn
106 Clement, J. (1982). Students'preconceptions in introductory mechanics. American Journal of Physics, 50(1), 66-71.   DOI
107 Carlton, K. (2000). Teaching about heat and temperature. Physics Education, 35(5), 101-5.   DOI   ScienceOn
108 Carnot, S. (1824/1988). Reflections on the Motive Power of Fire. edited E Mendoza. Mineola, New York: Dover.
109 Chi, M. T. H., Slotta, J. D. & deLeeuw, N. (1994). From things to processes: A theory of conceptual change for learning science concepts. Learning and Instruction, 4(1), 27-43.   DOI   ScienceOn
110 Coelho, R. L. (2012). Conceptual Problems in the Foundations of Mechanics. Science & Education. 21(9), 1337-1356.   DOI
111 Crew, H. (1929). General Physics. Macmillan.
112 Crundell, M. (2001). AS/A Level Physics. Oxfordshire: Philip Allan Updates.
113 de Berg K. C. (2008). The Concepts of Heat and Temperature: The Problem of Determining the Content for the Construction of an Historical Case Study which is Sensitive to Nature of Science Issues and Teaching-Learning Issues. Science & Education, 17(1), 75-114.   DOI
114 Deeson, E. (2007). Collins internet-linked dictionary of Physics. London: HarperCollins.
115 Dictionary of Physics (2005). London: Constable & Robinson.
116 Driver, R. & Warrington, L. (1985). Students use of the principle of energy conservation in problem situations. Physics Education, 20(4), 171-176.   DOI   ScienceOn
117 Einstein, A. (1905). On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies. Annalen der Physik, 17(10), 891-921.
118 Feynman, R. P. (1969). What is Science? The Physics Teacher, 7(6), 313-320.   DOI
119 Ferguson-Hessler, M. G. M. & de Jong, T. (1987). On the quality of knowledge in the field of electricity and magnetism. American Journal of Physics, 55(6), 492-497.   DOI
120 Feynman, R. P., Leighton, R. B. & Sands, M. L. (1963). The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol 1. Redwood City: Addison Wesley.
121 Feynman, R. P. (1998). The Meaning of It All. Massachusetts: Addison Wesley.
122 Alexander, (1939). Concepts and Definitions of Electromotive Force. American Journal of Physics, 7(1), 23-28.   DOI
123 Alvegard, C., Anderberg, E., Svensson, L. & Johansson, T. (2010). The Interplay between Content, Expressions and Their Meaning when Expressing Understanding. Science & Education, 19(3), 283-303.   DOI
124 Aristotle (1934). Physics. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
125 Arnold, M. & Millar, R. (1994). Children's and lay adults'views about thermal equilibrium. International Journal of Science Education, 16(4), 405-419.   DOI   ScienceOn
126 Arons, A. B. (1999). Development of energy concepts in introductory physics courses. American Journal of Physics, 67(12), 1063-1067.   DOI
127 Bacon, F. (1620/1898). Novum Organum. London: George Bell & Sons.
128 Baierlein, R. (1994). Entropy and the second law: A pedagogical alternative. American Journal of Physics, 62(1), 15-26.   DOI   ScienceOn
129 Balamuth, L., Wolfe, H. C. & Zemansky, M. W. (1941). The temperature concept from the macroscopic point of view. American Journal of Physics, 9(8), 199-203.   DOI
130 Bauman, R. P. (1992). Physics that textbook writers usually get wrong: II Heat and Energy. The Physics Teacher, 30(9), 353-6.   DOI
131 Bazire, M., & Bre、zillon, P. (2005). Understanding Context Before Using It. (Dey, A., Kokinov B., Leake, D. & Turner, R. Eds.) Modeling and Using Context, 3554, 29-40. Springer.   DOI   ScienceOn
132 Berg, B. L. (2009). Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences (7th ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
133 Beynon, J. (1994). A few thoughts on energy and mass. Physics Education, 29(2), 86.   DOI   ScienceOn
134 Bierman, J. & Kincanon, E. (2003). The Physics Teacher, 41(6), 340-344.   DOI   ScienceOn