DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A study on the dimension unit of framework on Yingzaofashi - Confrontation between Chi(尺) hypothesis and Fen(分°) hypothesis -

송 『영조법식』의 건축계획 치수 단위에 대한 이론적 고찰 - 자(尺) 단위 계획설과 분(分°) 단위 계획설 간의 논쟁을 중심으로 -

  • Received : 2022.05.05
  • Accepted : 2022.05.28
  • Published : 2022.06.30

Abstract

Fen(分°) is the proportional dimension unit of the standard timber section on Yingzaofashi(營造法式), and there is a phrase that not only structural members but the whole structural design of a building also use Fen as the dimension unit on the book. But in fact only the section dimensions of structural members are recorded by Fen, but the design dimensions are recorded by Chi(尺) on the book. Other historical records also described the building size by Chi. So there has been long-standing debate on the phase in Chinese architectural history society, including the recent confrontation on the analysis of survey figures of the east great hall of Foguangsi temple(佛光寺 東大殿). This paper analyzes all the records about the size of structural members and section planning on the book to make various calculation and evaluation. And it makes a survey of Cai(材) as the dimension and design unit between Chi and Fen through geometric analysis. Cai might be a rough unit of measurement in terms of structural and proportional scheming on Yingzaofashi, and the full size Cai(足材) had been a building scheming module before the Song dynasty.

Keywords

References

  1. [宋]李誡, 「營造法式」 陶本
  2. [淸]徐乾学, 「读禮通考」 卷九十二.葬考十.山陵五.髙宗永思陵
  3. 梁思成, 「营造法式注释」, 北京:中国建筑工业出版社, 1983
  4. 陳明達, 「營造法式大木作制度研究」, 北京:文物出版社, 1981
  5. 潘谷西, 何建中, 「營造法式解讀」, 南京:东南大学出版社. 2005, 54-57쪽
  6. 傅熹年 「关于唐宋时期建筑物平面尺度用"分"还是用尺来表示的问题」, 古建园林技术, 2004年 03期, 34-41쪽
  7. 傅熹年, 「日本飞鸟, 奈良时期建築中所反映出的中国南北朝, 隋, 唐建築特点」, 文物, 1992年 第10期, 28-50쪽
  8. 张十庆, 「 「营造法式」 变造用材制度探析」, 南京:东南大学学报(自然科学版), 1990, 20(5), 8-14쪽
  9. 颜炳亮, 「"材份,制"如何走向"斗口制"-苏州元明大木斗栱用材尺度探析」, 城市建築, 2021. 6. 393(18), 153-156쪽
  10. 呂舟, 劉暢, 張榮, 李貞娥 等, 「佛光寺东大殿建筑勘察研究报告」, 北京:文物出版社, 2011
  11. 肖旻, 「佛光寺东大殿尺度规律探讨」, 建筑学报, 2017年 06期, 37-42쪽
  12. 윤재신, 「靈巖寺址 금당의 목조 架構構造 복원에 관한 연구」, 건축사연구 제19권 5호 통권72호, 2010. 10, 25-47쪽
  13. 이용준, 「宋「 營造法式」 을 통해 본 木造建築 平面尺度構成의 考察」, 건축사연구 제14권 3호 통권43호, 2005. 9, 119-128쪽