DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

The Revisionary Ratio and Architectural Identity of Seung, Hyo-Sang against the Precursor Kim, Swoo-Geun - Focusing on the Dialectic of Revisionism by Harold Bloom -

김수근에 대한 승효상 건축의 수정주의 행보 - 해럴드 블룸의 수정주의 변증법을 중심으로 -

  • 강윤식 (강원대학교 건축학과) ;
  • 강훈 (강원대학교 건축학과)
  • Received : 2013.12.15
  • Accepted : 2014.02.28
  • Published : 2014.02.28

Abstract

Architecture is a product of numerous influences, as shown in the apprenticeships of Kim, Jung-Up and Kim, Swoo-Geun with Le Corbusier's influences. Therefore, its identity is need to be re-defined based on such complex relationships. The rhetorical images of 'the Map of Misreading', as the core of the poetic identification proposed by Harold Bloom's 'the Theory of Influence', provide an efficient way of explaining the relations between architectural apprenticeships and identities. This research is to re-build a new methodology of architectural criticism based on it. The diachronic transformations of the architecture of Seung, Hyo-Sang also had very characteristic 'revisionary ratios' about his precursor Kim, Swoo-Geun. As an antithetic stance of his precursor's final phase, his early days works pursued continuously geometric abstraction and objective images of the architecture of Adolf Loos. However, his recent works are showing the obvious symptoms of regression to his origins. Finally, the architectural identity should be re-conceptualized as a complexity, based on inter-textuality from complex influences. This new architectural identity can be reflected into the modern obsessive identity.

Keywords

References

  1. Kang, Yun-Sik, Lee, Dong-Eon, The Complex Relationships on the Late Kim, Swoo-Geun's Architecture, Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea,Vol.20, No.7, 2004
  2. Kang, Yun-Sik, Lee, Dong-Eon, The Apprentice -ships of the Epebes of the Late Architect Kim, Jung-Up and Kim, Swoo-Geun, KAAH Spring Conference, 2006
  3. Kim Swoo Geun Foundation, Tribute to Late Swoo-Geun KIM, Seoul: SPACE Magazine, 2002
  4. Kim, Young-Joon, Youngdong Jeil Hospital and E-mun 291, Plus Magazine 9403, 1994
  5. Seung, Hyo-Sang, City of Wisdom, Architecture of Wisdom, Seoul: Seoul Forum, 1999
  6. Seung, Hyo-Sang, Architecture, Signs of Thought, Paju: Dolbegae Publisher, 2004
  7. Seung, Hyo-Sang, Beauty of Poverty, Seoul: Migunsa, 1996
  8. Seung, Hyo-Sang and etc., Architectureal Guide -lines for Paju Book City, Paju Book City, 1999
  9. Lee, Dong-Eon, New Reading of Architecture through Poetry, Ideal Architecture Ltd., 1999
  10. Lee, Jong-Keun, Narcissism of Decentration, Seoul: E-suk Media ltd., 2001
  11. Josept Childers and Gary Hentzi edt., The Columbia Dictionary of Modern Literary & Cultural Criticism, New York: Columbia University Press, 2001
  12. Interview with Choi, Wook, The Constancy and Change of Architect Min, Hyun Sik and Seung, Hyo Sang, anc Magazine 0102, 2001
  13. Harold Bloom, The Anxiety of Influence-A Theory of Poetry, Oxford Univ. Press, 1973
  14. Harold Bloom, A Map of Misreading, New york: Oxford University Press, 1975
  15. Harold Bloom, Wallace Stevens-The Poems of Our Climate, Ithaca and London: Cornell Univ. Press, 1976
  16. J. Habermas, Modernity: an Incomplete Project, in edited by H. Foster, The Anti-aesthetic Essays on Postmodern Culture, Baypress, 1983