A Study on Establishing the Evaluation System of the Stock Enhancement Program

수산자원조성사업의 합리적인 평가체계 도입 방안에 관한 연구

  • Received : 2009.12.14
  • Accepted : 2009.12.22
  • Published : 2010.06.30

Abstract

The main goal of the study is to propose an objective and standardized evaluation system of stock enhancement programs. In order to achieve this goal, the study first suggested the need for stock enhancement program evaluation system through the review of current status and problems. Second, the study identified possible problems of the existing stock enhancement program evaluation by reviewing domestic and foreign evaluation systems. Finally the study proposed a new evaluation system and implementation plan of it. This study also classified the program evaluation criteria into ex-ante evaluation and ex-post evaluation according to the evaluation point in time, and applied the economic, political and technical feasibility tests into the evaluation of the stock enhancement program in order to solve the current problems of the evaluation. The evaluation process of the stock enhancement program is composed of an evaluation system design, estimation of weights using the analytical hierarchy process, design of estimation standard, conversion of scores and final summary of the evaluation. The central government takes the lead in the evaluation of the regional (metropolitan city or province) projects and the regional government is in charge of the evaluation of the local (city or county) projects. For the implementation of the ex-ante evaluation, either the regional or local governments ask for the evaluation and then submit an evaluation plan and other necessary documents to the upper level governments. The ex-post evaluation is then carried out by the upper level governments.

Keywords

References

  1. 국립수산과학원, 종묘방류효과조사 2007년 보고서[1단계], 2008.
  2. 고영선 외, 재정사업 심층평가 지침, 한국개발연구원, 2007, pp.53-63.
  3. 김광수 외, "울산 연안의 전복 방류사업에 대한 경제적 효과분석", 수산해양교육연구, 제18권, 제3호, 2006, pp.261-271.
  4. 김대영, "일본 인공어초사업의 추진현황과 시사점", 월간 해양수산, 통권 267호, 한국해양수산개발원, 2006, pp.6-20.
  5. 김대영, "인공어초사업의 추진 동향 및 효율화 방안", 월간 해양수산, 통권 284호, 한국해양수산개발원, 2008, pp. 23-45.
  6. 김대영 외, 수산자원조성사업의 평가체제 구축방안에 관한 연구, 정책연구 2008-19(기본), 한국해양수산개발원, 2008.
  7. 김동건, 비용.편익분석, 박영사, 2008, pp.35-72.
  8. 농림수산식품부, 농수산사업지침, 각 년도.
  9. 농림수산식품부, 인공어초시설사업집행및관리규정(농림수산식품부 제70호), 2008.
  10. 류정곤 외, 인공어초시설사업의 종합평가 및 향후 정책방향 설정에 관한 연구, 해양수산부, 2000.
  11. 류정곤 외, 수산자원조성사업 발전방안, 해양수산부, 2002, p.52.
  12. 수산자원관리법, 법률 제9627호, 2009년 4월 22일 제정.
  13. 심달상 외, 2004년 예비타당성 조사 연구보고서 - 예비타당성조사 수행을 위한 일반지침 수정.보완 연구[제4판]-, 한국개발연구원, 2004, pp.81-83.
  14. 한국수산경제신문, "방류사업 이대로 좋은가", 2007.
  15. 황진욱 외, "수산종묘방류사업의 경제성 평가", 수산경영론집, 제36권, 제1호, 2005, pp.121-138.
  16. 水産庁資源生産推進部整備課, 沿岸漁場整備開発事業費用対效果分析の手引き, 平成12年3月 (2000).
  17. 水産庁漁港漁場整備部.財団法人漁港漁場漁村技術研究所, 平成15年度水産基盤基礎調査, 漁場整備事業の事後許.調査報告書, 漁場整備事業事後評価事例集, 平成16年3月(2004).
  18. 水産庁homepage. http://www.jfa.maff.go.jp/j/kikaku/toukei/index.html.
  19. European Commission, Evaluating EU Expenditure Programmes : A Guide, First Edition, January 1997, p. 20.