경관영향평가서의 실효성 평가 -경관영향평가서와 환경영향평가서의 내용분석을 중심으로-

An Evaluation on the Efficacy of Landscape Impact Statement -through Content Analysis of Landscape Impact Statements and Environment Impact Statements-

  • 발행 : 2000.02.01

초록

Landscape impact assessment(LIA) is an aid to decision-making. For the decision maker, LIA provides a scientific examination of the predicted landscape implications of a proposed action and of the mitigation measures, before a decision is taken. Thus, the efficacy of LIA depends on the scientific credibility of the prediction and mitigation measures described in the landscape impact statement. The purpose of this paper was to examine the efficacy of LIA through the content analysis of prediction and mitigation measures in the selected 39 landscape impact statements and 34 environmental impact statements. The content of the selected statements was analyzed in terms of the quantification, precision, significance, and likelihood. The results showed that both prediction and mitigation measures were very low in the scientific credibility. Specifically, the prediction was ambiguously described without scientific probability, and the effect of mitigation measures was not specifically presented in the reports. Thus, landscape impact statement can not give credible information in the decision making process, which weakens the efficacy as an aid to decision-making. Based on the results, several suggestions were presented to enhance the efficacy of LIA.

키워드

참고문헌

  1. 한국조경학회지 v.22 no.1 제주도 경관영향평가제도의 현황과 과제 고동희
  2. '93-'96 인문사회과학분야 중점영역연구 과제 우리 나라 환경영향평가제도의 실태분석 2차 년도 보고서 김번웅;이영경;오영석;박병식
  3. '93-'96 인문사회과학분야 중점영역연구 과제 우리 나라 환경영향평가제도의 실태분석 3차 년도 보고서 김번웅;이영경;오영석;박병식
  4. 경관관리를 위한 경관영향평가제도의 도입에 관한 연구 김성준
  5. 도시경관 영향평가 심의제도에 관한 연구 박제양
  6. 한국조경학회지 v.22 no.1 경관영향평가의 필요성 양병이
  7. 한국조경학회지 v.22 no.1 경관영향평가 기법개발의 과제 오규식
  8. 환경영향평가: 이론과 실제 이병인;이영경
  9. 한국조경학회지 v.25 no.3 환경영향평가서 예측에 관한 연구 이영경
  10. 환경영향평가 v.6 no.2 환경영향 평가서 저감방안의 실효성에 관한 연구 이영경;이병인
  11. 건축 v.37 no.2 도시경관관리 개선방안 임승빈
  12. 한국조경학회지 v.22 no.1 경관영향평가 지표의 개발 임승빈
  13. 한국조경학회지 v.22 no.1 경관보존의 필요성과 방안 정기호
  14. 한국조경학회지 v.22 no.1 경관영향평가제도의 확립방안 정찬용
  15. 제주도 경관평가서 작성 등에 관한 규칙
  16. Science and the National Enviromental Policy Act Redirecting Policy Through Procedural Reform Caldwell, Lynton
  17. Forecasets and Enviromental Decision making The Content and Predictive Accuracy of Enviromental Impact Statements Cullhane, P. J.;Friesema, H. P.;Janice A. Beecher
  18. Prdiction in Enviromental Impact Assessment Enviromental Resource Ltd.
  19. Introduction to Enviromental Impact Assessment Glasson, J.;Therivel, R.;A. Chadwick
  20. Enviromental Impact Assessment Jain, R. K;Urbon, L. V;Stacey, G. S.;Balbach, H.E
  21. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science v.38 Recent trends in enviromental impact assessment Rosenberg, D.;Resh, V.;Balling , S.
  22. The Planner v.75 no.28 Enviromental statement : guidance for review and audit Tomlinson, P.
  23. A Review of Enviromental Impact Assessment Methodologies Warner, Maurice;Preston, E.