• Title/Summary/Keyword: fallacy

Search Result 83, Processing Time 0.023 seconds

A Possible Scientific Inquiry Model based on Hypothetico-Deduction Method Involving Abduction

  • Oh, Jun-Young
    • Journal of The Korean Association For Science Education
    • /
    • v.32 no.3
    • /
    • pp.486-501
    • /
    • 2012
  • The aims of this study are to investigate two main problems for the hypothetico-deduction method and to develop a scientific inquiry model to resolve these problems. The structure of this scientific inquiry model consists of accounts of the context of discovery and justification that the hypothetico-deduction holds as two main problems : 1) the heuristic flaw in the hypothetico-deduction method is that there is no limit to creating hypotheses to explain natural phenomena; 2) Logically, this brings into question affirming the consequent and modus tollens. The features of the model are as follows: first, the generation of hypotheses using an analogical abduction and the selection of hypotheses using consilience and simplicity; second, the expansion phase as resolution for the fallacy of affirming the consequent and the recycle phase as resolution for modus tollens involving auxiliary hypotheses. Finally, we examine the establishment process of Copernicus's Heliocentric Hypothesis and the main role of the history of science for the historical invalidity of this scientific inquiry model based on three examples of If/and/then type of explanation testing suggested by Lawson (International journal of science and Mathematics Education, 2005a, 3(1): 1-5) We claim that this hypotheticho-deduction process involving abduction approach produced favorable in scientific literacy rising for science teacher as well as students.

Korean EFL Learners' Cognitive Tendencies in Critical Reading of Argumentative Texts

  • Lee, Jong-Hee
    • English Language & Literature Teaching
    • /
    • v.12 no.2
    • /
    • pp.107-125
    • /
    • 2006
  • This article reports some Korean EFL learners' cognitive tendencies drawn up from their responses to logical fallacies in the argument passages, and its pedagogical implications. The findings of experimental study show the meaningful disparities in three sets of judgment tests designed to identify and explicate faulty arguments: based on the three general types of fallacies using language, emotions, and distraction tactics, subjects on average gained the highest scores in the test questions with language-loaded fallacies and the lowest scores in those with emotion-based ones among the three different types; for this reason, the scores that subjects obtained in the test of distraction-loaded fallacious arguments fell in between the two poles. These discrepancies, mainly based on statistical inferences, support the possibility that the Korean EFL learners are most likely to be manipulated by emotions/distraction- loaded argument tactics than by language-based ones in the three types of fallacious arguments; and, they are least likely to be influenced by language-oriented trickeries. As a consequence, such variances in abilities to recognize the intrinsic elements of logical fallacies suggest some basic instructional approaches to critical reading of argumentative texts with due weights on the Korean EFL learners' culture-specific cognitive tendencies.

  • PDF

The In/Out Structure : Interpretation of the Korean Architectural Space by Structuralism (안팍구조(構造)-한국건축공간(韓國建築空間)의 구조주의적(構造主義的) 해석(解析))

  • Lee, Hee-Bong
    • Journal of architectural history
    • /
    • v.1 no.2 s.2
    • /
    • pp.172-182
    • /
    • 1992
  • The binary classification, Yin & Yang, can be shown in our culture. Yin & Yang thinking reveals the Up/Down (Principal/Subordinate) relation in space, and Before/After relation in time, and it shows the sequence of Contrast${\to}$Reconciliation & Unification${\to}$Contrast. For example, a follower is Yin against King, while Yang as a father against his son in our trational cognitive structure. With Left/Right, Front/Rear, and Upper/Lower, In/Out division is a basic body-space term to grasp the space position. In the traditional Korean house, when we go out from the deepest 'In', Anbang to Daechung, we may call Anbang 'In' and Daechung 'Out'. When from Daechung to Anmadang reversely, we call Daechung 'In' and Anmadang 'Out'. Namely, Daechung is both 'In' and 'Out'. This is a fallacy logic in view of western basic conception. 'The In/Out Structure, system of a series of inner spaces, is defined as a transformation of cognitive structure of Yin & Yang thinking to the Korean architectural space. The space structure is one of the important deep structure in Korean society.' The concept of the space structure, apperred in east Asia, can make humane space, for it is not a physical 'type' of typepology but related to cognitive structure of human thinking, The structure is applicable to space design in modern society, for the cognitive structure exists in living culture by transformation.

  • PDF

On Fallacies and Problems of Information Resources Development in Digital Era (디지털시대의 정보자원 개발의 오류와 난제)

  • Yoon, Hee-Yoon
    • Journal of Information Management
    • /
    • v.33 no.4
    • /
    • pp.25-55
    • /
    • 2002
  • In most libraries and information centers, access versus ownership is the new dilemma facing in view of the rapidly change of information technologies, the rising costs of serials, and not equally increasing budgets. And libraries and information centers are now confronted with the fact that the more users bypass the library's resources in favor of the results they can get with an ordinary Internet search engine. The purpose of this study is to analyze a difficult problems related to information resources development in digital world with priority given to accesscentered paradigm, the grounds of an argument and fallacy of physical collection building, and limitations of electronic publication.

A Exploratory Research for Solutions of Ethical Issues and Sutainability of Enterprises with Social Ethical Approach (사회윤리학적 접근을 통한 기업의 윤리문제 해결과 지속가능 성장에 관한 탐색적 연구)

  • Kim, SeungBum;Shin, Ho-Sang
    • Korean System Dynamics Review
    • /
    • v.16 no.3
    • /
    • pp.49-75
    • /
    • 2015
  • A company is a core of free market capitalism. It needs to be sustainable to make capitalism better. In this reason, a company has to be ethical to be longer, because unethical company can not be survival. It means that we should understand what is the ethical company and how to be. Because interdisciplinary exchanges give a hint to understand what and how from, so it was studied to find the academic theories which have a relationship with ethics or morality not only in the area of Business management, but also Psychology, Pedagogy, Ethics, Philosophy, and etc.. Making a visible structure by System Dynamics with results through interdisciplinary exchanges to understand the reason why unethical accidences are rising and damages are growing although companies pay "Ethics Pays" more and more to reduce immoral cases is the goal of this study. On the theory of "Social Ethics", 5 ways explain the reason why unethical behavior has not been demolished make a complex structure, which was founded from studying interdisciplinary exchanges such as "Ethics Pays", "Moral Reasoning", "Social Cost", and "Fallacy of Compositions". Finding the controllers and Factors of this model to control to be better, then the market could be more effective with lesser social cost.

A Study on Design and Implementation of Filtering System on Hurtfulness Site (유해 사이트 필터링에 관한 연구)

  • 장혜숙;강일고;박기홍
    • Proceedings of the Korean Institute of Information and Commucation Sciences Conference
    • /
    • 2002.11a
    • /
    • pp.636-639
    • /
    • 2002
  • This article is focused on the research for the system design that isolate noxious data from internet for juveniles Normally, by motivating this software which was designed to isolate noxious data, harmful data was deleted or graded But these normal process contains a lot of complexity, for example, essential continual upgrade, grading mistake, etc. So, to solve these fallacy, word-weighting process, where several harmful words which can be optained in internet site are discriminance and weighted, is utilized by using AC machine. At the result, the isolation rate of harmful site rose up to 90%, which means this process is greatly efficient.

  • PDF

Ad Ignorantiam Revisited (무지에의 호소 다시 보기)

  • Choi, Hoon
    • Korean Journal of Logic
    • /
    • v.14 no.2
    • /
    • pp.77-104
    • /
    • 2011
  • Professor Hasuk Song argues that every argumentum ad ignorantiam, i.e. the argument from ignorance is not fallacious, and social contexts play a crucial role to judge whether the argument is fallacious or not. I generally agree with him, but I think we cannot have help from his position without knowing what those contexts are. In this paper, I argue that the concept of burden of proof is the crucial one to judge whether ad ignorantiam is plausible or not, and then present four criterions who have the burden of proof. There is a burden of proof on one who argues first, who insists the doubtful ones, who has powers, and who thinks that a situation is not dangerous.

  • PDF

A Study about interception on Hurtfulness Site using Aho-Corasik machine (AC 머신을 이용한 유해 사이트 차단에 관한 연구)

  • 정현수;정규철;김후남;박기홍
    • Proceedings of the Korean Institute of Information and Commucation Sciences Conference
    • /
    • 2004.05b
    • /
    • pp.541-544
    • /
    • 2004
  • Change is doing our life more conveniently and abundantly by knowledge information society, but side effect and that is happening considerable and gropes solution in reply that did not expect in advance is urgent real condition. It can be called one of representative dysfunction of information-oriented society that human nature is revealed in open state to great many objectionable material and poisonous information such as violence kind that teenagerses who do not grow are gotten abroad through Information network system yet. So, to solve these fallacy, word-weighting process, where several harmful words which can be optained in internet site are discriminance and weighted, is utilized by using AC machine. At the result, the isolation rate of harmful site rose up to 90%, which means this process is greatly efficient.

  • PDF

Cooperative User Equilibrium Under Advanced Traveler Information Systems (첨단교통정보체계(ATIS)하에서 협력적 사용자 균형)

  • Lim Yong-Taek
    • The Journal of The Korea Institute of Intelligent Transport Systems
    • /
    • v.4 no.1 s.6
    • /
    • pp.81-88
    • /
    • 2005
  • Cooperation among network users would be possible in a near future, as real time communication between them can be available by telematics. This implies that non-cooperative assumption like Wardrop's principle, which has been widely used so far in network modelling may not be appropriate for route choice problem. So a new principle requires for describing such cooperative case. This paper presents a criterion, which represents cooperative route choice behaviour among network users. With some examples, we compare the non-cooperative principle and the cooperative one presented in this paper. Numerical results from the examples show that the new principle would be better than the existing one.

  • PDF

Reading Projected Objects: Thing Theory and Sensation Novels (욕망화된 사물읽기: Thing Theory와 선정소설)

  • Kim, Heesun
    • English & American cultural studies
    • /
    • v.18 no.2
    • /
    • pp.51-78
    • /
    • 2018
  • To put it simply, thing theory is a study of meaningful capacities of materiality. Although T. S. Eliot regarded pathetic fallacy as the bad example of objective correlatives in his modernism poetry theory, it is clear that many objects in literary works reflect diverse human desires. Among many, Victorian sensation novels are the most distinct genre where the various paraphernalia in them indicate the distorted and exaggerated greed of the industrial revolution era. Whereas the male protagonists are usually related with the norms objects of authority such as portrait and locket, the female characters' connection with cosmetics and white dress shows their oppressed and fragile position in the patriarchal and hierarchical society. In the (post)modern society, the ambiguity of things has grown rapidly due to the increasing discrepancy between objects and things. In special, the new journalism and the psychological realism novels often reveal the post-truth phenomenon because consumerized audience depend more upon the attraction and affect than the mere evidence and facts. For the individual, according to object relations theory, these alternative facts are rather internalized into their mind as the internal object when they are motivated by the non/contact with primary caregivers in their childhood. The dominant material imagery in (post)modern fiction becomes the site of resistance because of their reconstructed and extended meaning. The object relations theory and thing theory can be effectively used to uncover the complicated meanings of desired objects by using the human-object's meaningful relations and early mental images that are secretly alive still in the present.