• Title/Summary/Keyword: argument

Search Result 1,207, Processing Time 0.024 seconds

Logic for Engineers: a teaching.learning model for logic in 'Presentation and Discussion' (공학도를 위한 논리: '발표와 토론'을 위한 논리 교수.학습 모형)

  • Yang, Eun-Suk
    • Korean Journal of Logic
    • /
    • v.13 no.2
    • /
    • pp.83-116
    • /
    • 2010
  • In this paper we provide a teaching learning method for logic in debate, in particular, in debate of engineers. First we criticize the concept of argument and the Toulmin model on argument used in education for debate. We next provide a general method for learning arguments needed in debate. Finally, we suggest the hypothetico-inferential method and the model for inference to the best choice as argument methods coming in useful in debate education for engineers.

  • PDF

Van Fraassen on Empirical Equivalence Argument and Interpretations of Space-time (반 프라쎈의 경험동등성 논변과 시공간에 대한 해석)

  • Yang, Kyuong-Eun
    • Korean Journal of Logic
    • /
    • v.15 no.1
    • /
    • pp.85-107
    • /
    • 2012
  • This essay criticizes Van Fraassen's argument for empirical equivalence among competing theories, which is based on his interpretation of Newtonian space-time. I argue that his misleading interpretation of the ontology of absolute space-time results in his ineffective attacks against a residual structure of space-time, absolute velocity. Van Fraassen's argument basically misleads us into empirical equivalence in that his literal reading of Newtonian space-time disregards a variety of aspects of its model.

  • PDF

The Realization of Meaning Differences between English Resultative and Depictive Predication Constructions in Focus Theory

  • Noh, Bokyung
    • Korean Journal of English Language and Linguistics
    • /
    • v.1 no.2
    • /
    • pp.273-293
    • /
    • 2001
  • In this paper, I examine the phenomenon of English depictive and resultative predications with specific attention given to the relation between accentual focus structure and argument structure. The goal is pursued primarily through a production experiment and analyses to establish the interconnection between focus and argument structure. The central claim is that the resultative predicate forms a complex predicate with a main verb, whereas the depictive predicate behaves as an adjunct in English secondary constructions. The result shows that the relationship between focus and accent depends at least in part on their argument structure, confirming that current focus theories about argument-head and adjunct-head structures in primary predication constructions can be extended to secondary predication constructions.

  • PDF

사동화에 의한 논항구조와 사건구조와 변화

  • 김윤신
    • Proceedings of the Korean Society for Language and Information Conference
    • /
    • 2001.06a
    • /
    • pp.25-58
    • /
    • 2001
  • This study explores the lexical-semantic structure of derived causative verbs in Korean based on Pustejovsky(1995)'s Generative Lexicon Theory (GL), Mor-phological causative verbs are derived from their root stems by affixing ‘-i, -hi, -li, -gi’ in Korean and the meanings of derived predicates are closely related to the meanings of their root verbs. In particular, the change of the ARGUMENT STRUCTURE by morphological derivation leads to the change of the EVENT STRUCTURE. In this study, causation is defined as the cause-effect relation having a causer. The ARGUMENT STRUCTURES of derived causative verbs includes a causer argument, which is added to the ARGUMENT STRUCTURE of their root verbs. Their EVENT STRUCTURE has a headed process related to a causer and their result is the event which their root verbs represent. This approach can also suggest that the (in)directness of causative is determined by which verb is its root and explain the difference between the morphological causativization and the syntactic causativization in Korean.

  • PDF

Silent Verbs in Northern Mandarin: A Silence Neither Gaps Nor Emptiness Can Fill

  • Kim, Ji-Yung
    • Language and Information
    • /
    • v.11 no.2
    • /
    • pp.87-103
    • /
    • 2007
  • This paper reanalyzes examples with missing verbs. Northern Mandarin rejects argument nominal phrases after a silent verb, as well as silent verbs inside islands. These restrictions suggest a grammatical process which silences verbs. I propose that these restrictions are the result of VP-topicalization followed by ellipsis. This analysis accounts for the island sensitivity of these constructions: since VP-topicalization feeds ellipsis, constructions with elided VPs are not derivable from configurations where movement is impossible. Also, to avoid topicalization along with the VP, the argument must move out of VP; the subsequent topicalization of the VP containing the argument's trace would then give rise to a configuration where that trace c-commands the moved-out DP. Adjuncts do not pose a problem because they are located outside of that smallest VP-shell. The data presented here are accommodated by neither of Tang's (2001) proposals for silent verbs (gapping and empty verbs). Instead, they provide support for a third source for silent verbs, VP-ellipsis via topicalization.

  • PDF

Korean Middle School Students' Epistemic Ideas of Claim, Data, Evidence, and Argument When Evaluating and Critiquing Arguments (한국 중학생들의 주장, 자료, 근거와 과학 논의에 대한 인식론적 이해조사)

  • Ryu, Suna
    • Journal of The Korean Association For Science Education
    • /
    • v.35 no.2
    • /
    • pp.199-208
    • /
    • 2015
  • An enhanced understanding of the nature of scientific knowledge-what counts as a scientific argument and how scientists justify their claims with evidence-has been central in Korean science instruction. However, despite its importance, scholars are generally concerned about the difficulty of both addressing and improving students' epistemic understanding, especially for students of a young age. This study investigated Korean middle school students' epistemic ideas about claim, data, evidence, and argument when they engage in reading both text-based and data-inscription arguments. Compared to previous studies, Korean middle school students show a sophisticated understanding of the role of claim and evidence. Yet, these students think that there is only a single way of interpreting data. When comparing students' ideas from text-based and data-inscription arguments, the majority of Korean students barely perceive text description as evidence and recognize only measured data as evidence.

The Change of toxical Structure by Causativization in Korean: a generative lexicon approach (한국어 사동화와 어휘의미구조의 변화: 생성어휘부(Generative Lexicon) 이론에 의한 접근)

  • 김윤신
    • Language and Information
    • /
    • v.6 no.2
    • /
    • pp.57-82
    • /
    • 2002
  • This study explores the lexical-semantic structure of derived causative verbs in Korean based on Pustejovsky(1995)'s Generative Lexicon Theory (GL). Morphological causative verbs are derived from their root stems by affixing ‘-i, -hi, -li, -gi’ in Korean and the meanings of derived predicates are closely related to the meanings of their root verbs. In particular, the change of the ARGUMENT STRUCTURE by morphological derivation leads to the change of the EVENT STRUCTURE. The ARGUMENT STRUCTURES of derived causative verbs include a causer argument, which is added to the ARGUMENT STRUCTURE of their root verbs by means of the causative derivation. Their EVENT STRUCTURE has a headed process related to a causer and its result is the event which their root verbs denote. This approach can also suggest that the (in)directness of causative is dependent on is the semantics of its root verb.

  • PDF

A Two-Phase Shallow Semantic Parsing System Using Clause Boundary Information and Tree Distance (절 경계와 트리 거리를 사용한 2단계 부분 의미 분석 시스템)

  • Park, Kyung-Mi;Hwang, Kyu-Baek
    • Journal of KIISE:Computing Practices and Letters
    • /
    • v.16 no.5
    • /
    • pp.531-540
    • /
    • 2010
  • In this paper, we present a two-phase shallow semantic parsing method based on a maximum entropy model. The first phase is to recognize semantic arguments, i.e., argument identification. The second phase is to assign appropriate semantic roles to the recognized arguments, i.e., argument classification. Here, the performance of the first phase is crucial for the success of the entire system, because the second phase is performed on the regions recognized at the identification stage. In order to improve performances of the argument identification, we incorporate syntactic knowledge into its pre-processing step. More precisely, boundaries of the immediate clause and the upper clauses of a predicate obtained from clause identification are utilized for reducing the search space. Further, the distance on parse trees from the parent node of a predicate to the parent node of a parse constituent is exploited. Experimental results show that incorporation of syntactic knowledge and the separation of argument identification from the entire procedure enhance performances of the shallow semantic parsing system.

A Development of the Automatic Predicate-Argument Analyzer for Construction of Semantically Tagged Korean Corpus (한국어 의미 표지 부착 말뭉치 구축을 위한 자동 술어-논항 분석기 개발)

  • Cho, Jung-Hyun;Jung, Hyun-Ki;Kim, Yu-Seop
    • The KIPS Transactions:PartB
    • /
    • v.19B no.1
    • /
    • pp.43-52
    • /
    • 2012
  • Semantic role labeling is the research area analyzing the semantic relationship between elements in a sentence and it is considered as one of the most important semantic analysis research areas in natural language processing, such as word sense disambiguation. However, due to the lack of the relative linguistic resources, Korean semantic role labeling research has not been sufficiently developed. We, in this paper, propose an automatic predicate-argument analyzer to begin constructing the Korean PropBank which has been widely utilized in the semantic role labeling. The analyzer has mainly two components: the semantic lexical dictionary and the automatic predicate-argument extractor. The dictionary has the case frame information of verbs and the extractor is a module to decide the semantic class of the argument for a specific predicate existing in the syntactically annotated corpus. The analyzer developed in this research will help the construction of Korean PropBank and will finally play a big role in Korean semantic role labeling.