• 제목/요약/키워드: Disease concept

검색결과 497건 처리시간 0.023초

Review of Production, Husbandry and Sustainability of Free-range Pig Production Systems

  • Miao, Z.H.;Glatz, P.C.;Ru, Y.J.
    • Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences
    • /
    • 제17권11호
    • /
    • pp.1615-1634
    • /
    • 2004
  • A review was undertaken to obtain information on the sustainability of pig free-range production systems including the management, performance and health of pigs in the system. Modern outdoor rearing systems requires simple portable and flexible housing with low cost fencing. Local pig breeds and outdoor-adapted breeds for certain environment are generally more suitable for free-range systems. Free-range farms should be located in a low rainfall area and paddocks should be relatively flat, with light topsoil overlying free-draining subsoil with the absence of sharp stones that can cause foot damage. Huts or shelters are crucial for protecting pigs from direct sun burn and heat stress, especially when shade from trees and other facilities is not available. Pigs commonly graze on strip pastures and are rotated between paddocks. The zones of thermal comfort for the sow and piglet differ markedly; between 12-22$^{\circ}C$ for the sow and 30-37$^{\circ}C$ for piglets. Offering wallows for free-range pigs meets their behavioural requirements, and also overcomes the effects of high ambient temperatures on feed intake. Pigs can increase their evaporative heat loss via an increase in the proportion of wet skin by using a wallow, or through water drips and spray. Mud from wallows can also coat the skin of pigs, preventing sunburn. Under grazing conditions, it is difficult to control the fibre intake of pigs although a high energy, low fibre diet can be used. In some countries outdoor sows are fitted with nose rings to prevent them from uprooting the grass. This reduces nutrient leaching of the land due to less rooting. In general, free-range pigs have a higher mortality compared to intensively housed pigs. Many factors can contribute to the death of the piglet including crushing, disease, heat stress and poor nutrition. With successful management, free-range pigs can have similar production to door pigs, although the growth rate of the litters is affected by season. Piglets grow quicker indoors during the cold season compared to outdoor systems. Pigs reared outdoors show calmer behaviour. Aggressive interactions during feeding are lower compared to indoor pigs while outdoor sows are more active than indoor sows. Outdoor pigs have a higher parasite burden, which increases the nutrient requirement for maintenance and reduces their feed utilization efficiency. Parasite infections in free-range pigs also risks the image of free-range pork as a clean and safe product. Diseases can be controlled to a certain degree by grazing management. Frequent rotation is required although most farmers are keeping their pigs for a longer period before rotating. The concept of using pasture species to minimise nematode infections in grazing pigs looks promising. Plants that can be grown locally and used as part of the normal feeding regime are most likely to be acceptable to farmers, particularly organic farmers. However, one of the key concerns from the public for free-range pig production system is the impact on the environment. In the past, the pigs were held in the same paddock at a high stocking rate, which resulted in damage to the vegetation, nutrient loading in the soil, nitrate leaching and gas emission. To avoid this, outdoor pigs should be integrated in the cropping pasture system, the stock should be mobile and stocking rate related to the amount of feed given to the animals.

간호학 교육에서 기초의과학 교과목별 목표와 내용에 대한 연구 (Objectives and Contents of Basic Medical Sciences in Nursing Education)

  • 최명애;신기수
    • 대한간호학회지
    • /
    • 제29권6호
    • /
    • pp.1455-1468
    • /
    • 1999
  • The purpose of this study was to investigate the objectives and contents of basic medical sciences at department of nursing in college of nursing, and junior college of nursing, thus ultimately providing the basic data to standardize the curriculum of the basic medical sciences in nursing education. Seventy eight professors who were in charge of teaching basic medical sciences to at 22 colleges of nursing/ department of nursing, and 20 junior colleges of nursing responded to the questionnaires that consisted of the questions regarding objectives and contents, of basic medical sciences. Based on the description of objectives, the description related to nursing, nurse, nursing science was cathegorized as on objective applicable to nursing science, the description related to medicine or clinical medicine as medical model, the description without description related to medicine was cathegorized as knowledge acquisition. The number of schools corresponding to each category were summerized in descending order. The objectives of basic medical sciences were categorized by concepts and number of schools corresponding to the categorized concept. The findings of the study are as follows ; 1. The subjects of basic medical science identified were physiology, anatomy, biochemistry, pathology, microbiology, and pharmacology in most colleges of nursing and junior colleges. Two colleges of nursing/department of nursing (9.1%) and 19 junior colleges of nursing(95%) did not offer biochemistry, 1 college of nursing /department of nursing(5%) did not offer pathology & pharmacology. 2 junior colleges of nursing (10%) did not offer pharmacology, 1 junior college of nursing(5%) did not offer pathology. The other 1 junior college of nursing did not offer microbiology. 2. Objectives of physiology were to acquire knowledge and understanding on human function in both 6 (50%) colleges and 5 junior colleges. Objectives of anatomy were to acquire knowledge on human structure in both 4 (57%) colleges and 2 (50%) junior colleges; knowledge applicable to nursing sciences in both 3 (42.8%) colleges and 2 (50%) junior colleges. Objectives of biochemistry was to obtain knowledge and understanding on biochemistry, and understanding of basic concepts about biochemistry. Objectives of pathology were to obtain knowledge and understanding on pathology in both 4 (57.1%) colleges and 5(62.5%) junior colleges. Objectives of microbiology were to acquire knowledge and understanding on microbiology in both 5(83.8%) colleges and 6(85.7%) junior colleges. Objectives of pharmacology were to acquire knowledge on pharmacology in both 7(100%) colleges and 8(100%) junior colleges. 3. Contents of physiology in 19 (100%) schools were membrane transport, digestion, circulation, nervous system and respiration. In 16(84.2%) were kidney and muscle, that in 13(68.4%) were endocrine physiology. In 11(57.9%) were introduction and that in 9(47.4%) were structure and function of cells. Contents of anatomy in 11(100%) schools were skeletal system, muscle system, digestive system, circulatory system, concepts regarding human structure. In 10(90.9%) schools were endocrine system and nervous system, and in 5(45.5%) schools were blood, urinary system and cell. Contents of biochemistry in 6(100%) schools were history of biochemistry, body regulating factor, bioenergy, health and nutrition, nutrition of cell, energy production system. In 5(83.3%) schools were metabolism of protein and carbohydrate and enzyme, and in 3(50%) schools were metabolism of energy and fat. Contents of microbiology in 13(100%) schools were environment and influenc of bacteria, virus, G(-) rods, purulent cocci, G(+) rods. In 10 (76.9%) were immunity, diphtheria, enterobacteria, and in 9(69.2%) were spirochete, rickettsia and clamydia, and that in 6(46.2%) were sterilization and disinfection. Contents of pathology in 14(100%) schools were cell injury and adaptation, inflammation, respiratory diseases, circulatory diseases. In 10(71.4%) were neurological disorders, in 8(57.1%) were immunity and disease, and in 7 (50%) were tumor and progressive changes. Contents of pharmacology in 15(100%) were cardivascular drugs, introduction to pharmacology, hypnotics, analgesics, local anesthetics, an ticonvulsants. In 12(80%) were drugs activity on sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous system, and in 11(73%) were sulfa drugs, antibiotics, drug abuse and addiction.

  • PDF

연세지역(延世地域)에 대(對)한 보건기초조사(保健基礎調査) (A Basie Health Survey of the Yonsei Community Health Service Area, Seoul)

  • 양재모;김명호
    • Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health
    • /
    • 제1권1호
    • /
    • pp.25-36
    • /
    • 1968
  • Introduction In order to improve medical education through the introduction of a concept of comprehensive health care of a community, an area surrounding the University Campus was chosen for the Community Health Service Project. It has been on operation for last 4 years with its major emphasis on family planning services, and maternal and child health care. The major objectives of this survey at the area are to obtain: 1) The demographic data, 2) The health need and trend of medical care, 3) The attitude and practice in maternity care to be used for further improvement of the planning and the services of the project. Population and Survey Method Out of three Dongs of the Community Health Service Area, only two Dongs namely Changchun and Yonhee were selected for the survey. Total number of households and population in the area studied was 3,683 and 21,857 respectively. An interview was performed with questionnaire schedule which was recorded by interviewers. This includes the degree of utilization of health services provided by the Community Health Service Program such as family planning, prenatal care during their last pregnancy, delivery history and complications of the delivery as well as the incidence of illnesses in general. Prior to the interview, all interviewers were trained for interviewing technique for two days. The survey was carried out during the period from October December 1967. Results 1) Demographic Data : 41.3% of the population studied were children under age 15 and only 3.5% were over 60 years of age. Crude birth rate and crude death rate of this area studied during the period of November 1966-October 1967 were 20.5 and 7.7 respectively. Infant mortality rate during the same period was 35.9. 50.4% of the 2,832 households fell into the category of middle class, 39.8% to the lower class and 9.5% to the upper class in economic condition. 19.8% of 2,832 householders had no formal education, 22.7% primary school, and 57.5% middle or higher school education. 2) Health Status and Utilization of the Community Health Service: Those who suffered from many illnesses during the month of October, 1967 were 690(4.6% of 14,891 persons). Classification of these patients into the type of disease shown respiratory diseases 27.4%, gastrointestinal diseases 18.1%, tuberculosis 10.9%, skin and genitourethral diseases 4.5% and gynecologic patients 4.5%. Only 55.9% of the patients received medical care at hospital or doctor's clinic. But among TB and gynecologic patients, 70.7% and 72.4% were treated at medical facilities. 10.6% of 2,832 householders interviewed has ever utilized the Community Health Service Program provided by the Yonsei Medical School, Classifying these clients into the type of service, 35.9% utilized the wellbaby clinic, 31.0% the family planning clinic, 14.7% the home delivery care, and the rest utilized other services such as the premarital guidance cinlic and the sanitary inspection service. 3) Maternity Care: 23.6% of 2,151 deliveries were done at medical facilities such as hospital, private clinic, while 76.4% were done at home. Acceptance rate of prenatal care was 32.6% as whole, but 49.6 of 774 women who had the prenatal care service had their deliveries at medical facility. 45.1% of total deliveries were attended by medical and or paramedical personnel. 75.8% of the deliveries of those received prenatal care were attended by medical and or paramedical personnel while only 27.8% of the deliveries of those who did not have prenatal care attended by medical and or paramedical personnel. 49.8% of deliveries of the upper class, 29.8% of the middle class and 9.9% of the lower class were attended by medical and or paramedical personnel. 6.2, 3.3% and 24.8% of mothers reported about their xeperience of edema, coma and fever during the period of trimester of pregnancy and puerperium. 4) Family Planning: The rate of practice of family planning was 27.9%. 31.7% of them were by IUD, 2.9% by oral pill, 15.2% by sterilization and the rest by traditional methods. Those women who had 3 to 4 children had highest(30.2%). Practice rate among the various methods of family planning, oral pill was the most popular method to whom had 2 or less children. In relation between the practicing rate of family planning and living standard, the upper, middle and lower class practiced 37.5, 29.4 and 19.9% respectively.

  • PDF

식품과 생의학을 위한 계란 항체생산과 IgY 기술의 활용 (Egg Antibody Farming and IgY Technology for Food and Biomedical Applications)

  • 심정석
    • 한국가금학회:학술대회논문집
    • /
    • 한국가금학회 2003년도 국제 심포지움
    • /
    • pp.37-54
    • /
    • 2003
  • 포유동물과 마찬가지로 암탉은 태어날 병아리에게 계란을 통해서 면역항체를 이행시켜 해로운 병원균의 침입으로부터 병아리를 보호해준다 . 즉 어미 닭의 혈청으로부터 특정항체가 난황에 이행되고 이 면역항체를 IgY 라고 부르며 이것이 발육중인 태아와 갓 부화한 병아리의 면역항체가 되는 것이다. 상대적으로 면역능력이 낮은 갓 부화한 병아리는 병원균에 대한 방어능력을 계란을 통해 어미로부터 받은 항체를 통해 얻는다. 그 결과, 난황 내에는 많은 양의 IgY를 보유하게 되고 이 면역물질이 있으므로 말미암아 계란 내에 들어와 있는 병원균이냐 외부에서 들어오려는 병원균을 무력화시켜 아무 탈없이 병아리가 부화하게 된다 . 이처럼 산란계에 각종 병원균을 접종함으로서 면역항체 IgY 가 많이 들어 있는 계란을 생산할 수 있다. 난황 1 개에는 136~340 mg 의 IgY 가 들어있고 이는 난황 $m\ell$ 당 8~20 mg의 IgY 가 함유되어 있는 셈이다. 그리고 산란계 한 마리로부터 일년에 30 g 이상의 IgY 를 얻을 수 있다. 산란계에 항원을 접종하여 난황으로부터 IgY 를 수확하면 IgY g 당 10$ 도 안 되는 낮은 비용으로 항체를 얻을 수 있게 된다. 이에 비하여 포유동물의 경우 19 의 IgG 를 얻는데 20,000$가 소요된다. 이와 같은 IgY 제조기술을 의학, 공중 보건, 수의학, 식품안전과 같은 분야에 응용을 함으로써 잠재력이 높은 새로운 시장을 여는 장이 될 것이다. IgY 기술을 더욱 폭넓게 활용할 수 있는 분야들로는 생물제제나 의학진단기구, 생리적 기능성 물질이나 기능성식품의 개발, 질병예방을 위한 경구투여제 그리고 질병감염을 막는 특정 병원균성 항미생물 제제와 같은 것들을 들 수 있다. 이 논문에서 우리가 강조하고자 하는 것은 IgY 가 함유된 계란을 생산하고 섭취하였을 때 특정항체들의 결합을 통해 병원성 미생물의 성장이나 군체를 형성하는 것을 무력화시켜 결과적으로 병원균을 감소시키거나 억제시킨다는 점이다. 오늘날 약물에 내성을 지닌 박테리아의 출현으로 질병감염을 막는데 항생제의 사용효과가 점차 감소하고 있기 때문에 이러한 항생제를 대체할 수 있는 방안으로 계란항체를 이용할 수 있다.

  • PDF

${\ll}$삼일신고(三一神誥).진리훈(眞理訓)${\gg}$에 나타난 氣功原理(氣功原理) 및 한의학(韓醫學)과 의 상관성(相關性)에 관(關)한 연구(硏究) (A Study on Principle of Kigong mentioned in the lecture on Truth of ${\ll}$Samilshingo${\gg}$(三一神誥) and its Interrelationship with Oriental Medicine)

  • 반창열;지선한;강고신
    • 대한의료기공학회지
    • /
    • 제4권2호
    • /
    • pp.153-186
    • /
    • 2000
  • Jigam(止感), Josik(調息), Kumchock(禁觸), from the lecture on Truth of ${\ll}Samilshingo{\gg}$(三一神誥) treat three elements of Kigong, regulation of mental activties, regulation of breathing and adjustment of posture and there are some similar mentions with the view of human body based on oriental medicine like those Samjin(三眞), Sammang(三妄), Samdo(三途) and Sippalkyoung(十八境) ect. Thus as a result of comparison and observation about the interrelationships between principle of Kigong in the lecture on Truth of ${\ll}Samilshingo{\gg}$(三一神誥) and oriental medicine. I have conclusion as follows. 1. According to the lecture on Truth, the components of human body are the one and only Samjin(三眞), Sammang(三妄) and Samdo(三途) resulted from facing Samjin(三眞) to Sammang(三妄) and Sippalkyoung(十八境). This fact presents the principle of human change. 2. the principle of Kigong mentioned in the lecture on Truth shows the original Ilshin(一神) on the basis of Samjin(三眞), Sammang(三妄), Samdo(三途) and Sippalkyoung(十八境). This makes common, unity and sound Sim(心), Ki(氣) and Shin(身), Sammang(三妄) through Jigam(止感), Josik(調息) and Kumchock(禁觸), be versed, intellected and guaranteed Sung(性), Myoung(命) and Jung(精), Samjin(三眞) and emit Kyun(見), Mun(聞), Ji(知) and haeng(行), Sadaeshingi(四大神機) and finally all these are harmonized into Duk(德), Hye(慧) and Ryuk(力), Samdae(三大) which is the entity of God. 3. Samsipyookjongmyowhasang(三十六種妙化相) is an ascetic practice done after a chulin(哲人) deduce Ji(止), Jo(調) and Kum(禁), Sambup(三法) on the basis of the lecture on Truth. So I suppose it correlates nature's six elements. Kong(空)(Chun(天)). Yol(熱)(Wha(火)). Jin(震(Jeon(電)), Seup(濕)(Shoo(水)), Han(寒)(Poong(風)) and Ko(固)(Ji(地)), human's Samjin(三眞), Sung(性), Myoung(命) and Jung(精) and Sammang(三妄), Sim(心), Ki(氣) and Shin(身) and makes clear the principle of discipline. 4. In comparison with Samjin(三眞) and Sammang(三妄) says from the lecture on Truth and the Three Essential Elements of the body construction(三寶) from oriental medicine, Samjin(三眞) and Sammang(三妄) as factors of human body in the concept of practical knowledge. That is the one and only Samjin(三眞) in terms of the Three Essential Elements of the body construction(三寶) is considered a structural principle for every single person and Sammang(三妄) is considered a functional form for each individual. And it can be Sung(性)+Sim(心)=Spirit(神), Myoung(命)+Ki(氣)=Vital Force(氣) and Jung(精)+Shin(身)=True Essence(精). 5. In comparison with Sippalkyoung(十八境) of Samdo(三途) from the lecture on Truth and three medical causes of disease, Gamdoyookkyoung(感途六境) is similar with endopathic cause caused by Naesangchiljung(內傷七情), Sikdoyukkyoung(息途六境) is similar with exopathic cause by six climatic conditions in excess as pathogenic factors(六淫) and Yoegi(?氣) and Chokdoyukkyoung(觸途六境) is similar with non-endo-exopathogenic causes by diet imbalance, fatigue, intemperance in sexual life and trauma etc. 6. In the lecture on Truth, the Chulin(哲人) who discipline Sambup(三法), Sangchul(上哲), Choongchul(中哲) and Hachul(下哲) can be compared with Kigong expert(health preserving expert) such as the Spiritual Men(眞人), the Sapients(至人), the Sages(聖人) and the Men of Exellent Virtue(寶人) in the Sang Gu Tian Zhen Lun of the Huang Ti Nei Ching Su Wen(素問 上古天眞論) and then Sangchul(上哲) is the Spiritual Men(眞人), Choongchul(中哲) is the Sapients(至人) and Hachul(下哲) is the Sages(聖人) while the men of Exellent Virtue(賢人) is inferior to Chulin(哲人) when he goes to extremes.

요추 추간판 탈출증 환자의 의·한의 협진 의료이용 현황 분석: 건강보험심사평가원 환자표본 데이터를 이용하여 (Analysis of Lumbar Herniated Intervertebral Disc Patients' Healthcare Utilization of Western-Korean Collaborative Treatment: Using Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service's Patients Sample Data)

  • 고준혁;유지웅;서상우;서준원;강준혁;김태오;조휘성;서연호;안종현;이우주;김보형;최만규;김승범;김형석;김고운;조재흥;송미연;정원석
    • 한방재활의학과학회지
    • /
    • 제31권4호
    • /
    • pp.105-116
    • /
    • 2021
  • Objectives Lumbar herniated intervertebral disc (L-HIVD) is common disease in which Western-Korean collaborative treatment is performed in Korea. This study aimed to analyze Western-Korean collaborative treatment utilization of Korean patients with L-HIVD using Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service's Patients Sample Data. Methods This study used the Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service-National Patient Sample (HIRA-NPS) in 2018. Claim data of L-HIVD patients were extracted. The claim data were rebuilt with the operational concept of 'episode of care' and divided into Korean medicine episode group (KM), Western medicine episode group (WM) and collaborative treatment episode group (CT). General characteristics, medical expenses and healthcare utilization were analyzed. In addition, the difference of average visit day and average medical expenses between non-collaborative group (KM plus WM) and CT were analyzed by the propensity score matching method. Results A Total of 64,333 patients and 365,745 claims were extracted. The number of episodes of WM, KM and CT was 69,383 (92.97%), 3,903 (5.23%), and 1,341 (1.80%) respectively. The frequency of collaborative treatment episode was higher in women and the age of 50s. The most frequently described treatment in CT was acupuncture therapy. As a result of the propensity score matching, the number of visit days and medical expenses in the collaborative treatment group was higher than in the non-collaborative group. Conclusions The analysis of healthcare utilization of Korean-Western collaborative treatment may be used as basic data for establishing medical policies and systematic collaborative treatment model in the future.

감염병 팬데믹에서의 '리스크' 개념과 방역조치에 대한 비례성 심사의 구체화 -집합제한조치에 대한 국내외 판결을 중심으로- (The Concept of 'Risk' and the Proportionality Review of Infectious Disease Prevention Measures)

  • 유기훈
    • 의료법학
    • /
    • 제23권3호
    • /
    • pp.139-207
    • /
    • 2022
  • 코로나19 팬데믹에 대한 방역 과정에서 개인의 자유에 대한 국가의 다양한 자유제한 조치가 이루어짐에 따라, '감염병 예방'이라는 공익을 근거로 국가의 과도한 기본권 제한이 무분별하게 허용되고 있다는 지적이 이루어졌다. 따라서 국가의 개인에 대한 자유제한의 허용가능한 한계를 어떻게 설정할 것인가 하는 문제가 감염병 팬데믹 상황에서의 주요한 문제로 떠오르게 되었다. 그러나 '감염병 팬데믹'이라는 현상이 지니는 난해한 특성으로 인하여, 감염된 개인으로 인해 초래되는 '공익의 훼손'은 비례성 심사와 같은 법적 평가의 분석 대상이 되지 못하는 경우가 많았다. 감염(의심)자가 타인을 감염시키고, 감염시킨 타인을 통한 감염의 연쇄로 인구집단으로 감염이 퍼져나가는 현상은 오직 '확률적'으로만 예측되는데, 그러한 '확률적 불확실성'의 결과로 초래되는 '감염병 리스크(risk)'를 어떻게 법적 분석의 대상으로 다룰지가 문제가 되었던 것이다. 이러한 이론적 분석틀이 부재한 상황 속에서 감염병 팬데믹하의 감염(의심)자의 리스크는 법적 차원에서 구체적이고 엄밀하게 분석되지 못하였고, 감염병 팬데믹하의 기본권 제한 조치에 대한 비례성 심사 또한 '공익 보호의 중대성'과 '개인의 기본권 제한'이라는 추상적 차원의 비교에 그치는 경우가 많았다. 따라서 본 논문은 ① 감염병 팬데믹이라는 공중보건 위기 상황에서의 '리스크'를 어떻게 구체화하고 분석의 대상으로 개념화할 수 있는지에 대한 이론적 검토를 수행하고, ② '리스크' 개념의 구체화에 대한 이론적 검토를 바탕으로 감염병 팬데믹 상황에서의 기본권 제한 조치에 대한 비례성 심사의 세부 심사기준을 확립하여, ③ 감염병 팬데믹하 방역조치의 정당성을 보다 엄밀히 판단할 수 있는 이론적 자원을 확보하는 것을 그 목표로 하였다. 우선 2장에서는 고전적 해악 개념이 감염병 팬데믹을 적절히 설명하지 못한다는 점을 지적하고, 선행연구를 발전시켜 '해악'에서 '리스크'로의 개념 확장을 시도하였다. 또한 감염이 연쇄적으로 발생하며 인구집단으로 퍼져나가는 현상을 법적으로 분석가능한 대상으로 포섭하기 위해, 감염병 역학의 '재생산지수' 논의를 접목하여 '인구집단에 대한 리스크'를 법적으로 분석가능한 대상으로 정립하였다. 3장에서는 기존 비례성 심사의 방법론에 2장의 이론적 논의를 접목하여, 감염병 팬데믹 상황에서의 국가의 기본권 제한 조치에 대한 과잉금지원칙의 구체적 심사기준을 제시하였다. 우선 수단의 적합성 심사에서는, 공익에 대한 훼손이 '확률적'으로 나타나는 감염병 팬데믹의 경우에 '공익에 대한 수단의 인과적 기여'를 평가하는 구체적 방식을 제시하였다. 피해의 최소성 심사는 '개입 방식에 있어서의 피해의 최소성'과 '규율 대상의 범위에 있어서의 피해의 최소성'으로 나누어 검토하였으며, 법익의 균형성 심사에서는 '인구집단에 대한 리스크' 방지의 법익과 '개인의 자유제한' 초래의 법익 사이의 비교형량의 구체적 방법론을 제시하였다. 이를 통해 단지 '감염병 팬데믹의 리스크가 중대하다'라거나 '리스크가 불확실하다'는 것을 근거로 비례성 심사를 건너뛰어서는 안 되며, 해당 방역조치로 인한 자유제한과 공익 훼손의 리스크 저감 사이의 비례적 관계를 명확히 논증하여야 함을 주장하였다. 4장에서는 2장의 '리스크'에 대한 이론적 논의와 3장의 감염병 팬데믹에서의 방역조치에 대한 비례성 심사기준 논의를 종합하여, 감염병 팬데믹하 집합제한조치의 정당성을 검토하고, 국내외 판례에서의 논증 구조를 비판적으로 분석하였다. 일부 판례에서는 비례성 심사를 누락하고 있다는 점을 지적하였으며, 세부적 논증을 제시한 판례의 경우, 해당 논증이 3장에서 제시한 비례성 심사기준을 통해 보다 엄밀하게 판단되고 해석될 수 있음을 살펴보았다.