Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.net.2021.03.027

Review of researches on coupled system and CFD codes  

Long, Jianping (Xi'an Jiaotong University)
Zhang, Bin (Xi'an Jiaotong University)
Yang, Bao-Wen (Xi'an Jiaotong University)
Wang, Sipeng (Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics)
Publication Information
Nuclear Engineering and Technology / v.53, no.9, 2021 , pp. 2775-2787 More about this Journal
Abstract
At present, most of the widely used system codes for nuclear safety analysis are one-dimensional, which cannot effectively simulate the flow field of the reactor core or other structures. This is true even for the system codes containing three-dimensional modules with limited three-dimensional simulation function such as RELAP-3D. In contrast, the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes excel at providing a detailed three-dimensional flow field of the reactor core or other components; however, the computational domain is relatively small and results in the very high computing resource consuming. Therefore, the development of coupling codes, which can make comprehensive use of the advantages of system and CFD codes, has become a research focus. In this paper, a review focus on the researches of coupled CFD and thermal-hydraulic system codes was carried out, which summarized the method of coupling, the data transfer processing between CFD and system codes, and the verification and validation (V&V) of coupled codes. Furthermore, a series of problems associated with the coupling procedure have been identified, which provide the general direction for the development and V&V efforts of coupled codes.
Keywords
CFD; System code; Coupling; Thermal-hydraulics;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Y. Ku, Y. Tseng, J. Yang, S. Chen, J. Wang, C. Shin, Developments and applications of TRACE/CFD model of maanshan PWR pressure vessel, in: NURETH-16, 2015. Chicago, IL.
2 N.A. Anderson, Coupling RELAP5-3D and Fluent to analyze a Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) outlet plenum (Doctoral dissertation, Texas A&M University), 2006.
3 S.Y. Lee, J.J. Jeong, S.H. Kim, S.H. Chang, COBRA/RELAP5: a merged version of the COBRA-TF and RELAP5/MOD3 codes, Nucl. Technol. 99 (1992) 177-187.   DOI
4 W. Li, X. Wu, D. Zhang, G. Su, W. Tian, S. Qiu, Preliminary study of coupling CFD code FLUENT and system code RELAP5, Ann. Nucl. Energy 73 (2014) 96-107.   DOI
5 D. Martelli, N. Forgione, G. Barone, W. Ambrosini, Validation of the coupled calculation between RELAP5 STH code and ansys FLUENT CFD code, 2013.
6 V.F. Gonzalez-Albuixech, G. Qian, M. Sharabi, M. Niffenegger, B. Niceno, N. Lafferty, Coupled RELAP5, 3D CFD and FEM analysis of postulated cracks in RPVs subjected to PTS loading, Nucl. Eng. Des. 297 (2016) 111-122.   DOI
7 R. Baviere, N. Tauveron, F. Perdu, E. Garre, S. Li, A first system/CFD coupled simulation of a complete nuclear reactor transient using CATHARE2 and TRIO_ U. Preliminary validation on the Phenix Reactor Natural Circulation Test, Nucl. Eng. Des. 277 (2014) 124-137.   DOI
8 D. Bertolotto, Coupling a System Code with Computational Fluid Dynamics for the Simulation of Complex Coolant Reactivity Effects, Lausanne, EPFL, 2011.
9 F. D'Auria, J.L.G. Moreno, G.M. Galassi, D. Grgic, A. Spadoni, Three mile island unit 1 main steam line break three-dimensional neutronics/thermal-hydraulics analysis: application of different coupled codes, Nucl. Technol. 142 (2003) 180-204.   DOI
10 A. Papukchiev, G. Lerchl, C. Waata, T. Frank, Extension of the simulation capabilities of the 1D system code ATHLET by coupling with the 3D CFD software package ANSYS CFX, in: The 13th International Topical Meeting on Nuclear Reactor Thermal Hydraulics (NURETH-13), 2009 (Kanazawa City, Ishikawa Prefecture, Japan).
11 I.K. Park, J.R. Lee, S.W. Lee, H.Y. Yoon, J.J. Jeong, An implicit code coupling of 1-D system code and 3-D in-house CFD code for multi-scaled simulations of nuclear reactor transients, Ann. Nucl. Energy 59 (2013) 80-91.   DOI
12 R.R. Schultz, W.L. Weaver, Using the RELAP5-3D advanced systems analysis code with commercial and advanced CED software, in: The 11th Proceedings Of the International Conference On Nuclear Engineering (ICONE11), 2003.
13 G. Theodoridis, A. Papukchiev, D. Scholz, G. Lerchl, A New Data-Driven ATHLET-ANSYS CFD Coupling Method for Efficient Simulation of Nuclear Power Plant Circuits, in: International Conference on Nuclear Engineering (Vol. 45943, p. V004T10A047), American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 2014, July.
14 A. Toti, J. Vierendeels, F. Belloni, Extension and application on a pool-type test facility of a system thermal-hydraulic/CFD coupling method for transient flow analyses, Nucl. Eng. Des. 331 (2018) 83-96.   DOI
15 D.L. Aumiller, E.T. Tomlinson, R.C. Bauer, A coupled RELAP5-3D/CFD methodology with a proof-of-principle calculation, Nucl. Eng. Des. 205 (1/2) (2001) 83-90.   DOI
16 D. Martelli, N. Forgione, G. Barone, A.D. Nevo, I. Di Piazza, M. Tarantino, Coupled simulations OF natural and forced circulation tests IN NACIE facility using RELAP5 and ANSYS FLUENT codes, in: Proceedings of the 2014 22nd International Conference on Nuclear Engineering (ICONE22), 2014 (Prague, Czech Republic).
17 S. Kliem Thur, MAIN STEAM LINE BREAK ANALYSIS OF A VVER-440 REACTOR USING THE COUPLED THERMOHYDRAULICS SYSTEM/3D-NEUTRON KINETICS CODE DYN3D/ATHLET IN COMBINATION WITH THE CFD CODE CFX-4, 1999.
18 Y. Liu, H. Zhang, B.S. Jia, Research on coupling between RELAP5 and CFX codes, Atomic Energy Sci. Technol. 44 (2010) 304-308.
19 L. Vyskocil, J. Macek, Coupling CFD code with system code and neutron kinetic code, Nucl. Eng. Des. 279 (2014b) 210-218.   DOI
20 D. Ziabletsev, M. Avramova, K. Ivanov, Development of pressurized water reactor integrated safety analysis methodology using multilevel coupling algorithm, Nucl. Sci. Eng. 148 (2004) 414-425.   DOI
21 Y. Yan, Rizwan-uddin, COUPLED CFD-SYSTEM-CODE SIMULATION OF A GAS COOLED REACTOR, American Nuclear Society, 2011a.
22 Q. Peng, H.X. Yu, S. Vandroux, F. Perdu, W. Yang, Analytical study on coupling of CATHARE and TRIO_U code for nuclear reactor thermal-hydraulic analysis, Nucl. Power Eng. 34 (S1) (2013) 201-205.
23 K.A. Smith, A.J. Baratta, G.E. Robinson, Coupled RELAP5 and CONTAIN accident analysis using PVM, Nucl. Saf. 36 (1995).
24 A. Toti, J. Vierendeels, F. Belloni, Improved numerical algorithm and experimental validation of a system thermal-hydraulic/CFD coupling method for multi-scale transient simulations of pool-type reactors, Ann. Nucl. Energy 103 (2017) 36-48.   DOI
25 J. Ming, W. Guowei, W. Xianjuan, B. Yunqing, Z. Zhumin, L. Yazhou, Preliminary study of coupled Fluent and RELAP5 code for heat transfer of leadbased reactor, in: The 14th National Reactor Thermal Fluid Academic Conference of CHINA, 2015 (Beijing, China).
26 B. Yang, J. Long, H. Ninokata, et al., Subchannel analysis-current practice and development for the future, Nucl. Energy Des. (2020). In preparation.
27 D.L. Aumiller, E.T. Tomlinson, W.L. Weaver, An integrated relap5-3d and multiphase cfd code system utilizing a semi-implicit coupling technique, Nucl. Eng. Des. 216 (2002) 77-87.   DOI
28 T.P. Grunloh, A. Manera, A novel multi-scale domain overlapping CFD/STH coupling methodology for multi-dimensional flows relevant to nuclear applications, Nucl. Eng. Des. 318 (2017) 85-108.   DOI
29 J.J. Jeong, S.K. Sim, C.H. Ban, C.E. Park, Assessment of the COBRA/RELAP5 code using the LOFT L2-3 large-break loss-of-coolant experiment, Ann. Nucl. Energy 24 (1997) 1171-1182.   DOI
30 S. Kliem, R. Franz, Quick-look Report of the ROCOM Tests 1.1 and 1.2 Conducted within the OECD PKL2 Project, 2010.
31 A. Nava Dominguez, Y.F. Rao, T. Beuthe, Advances of the AC-DC code, a coupled computational tool to perform thermalhydraulic modeling of fuel bundles with annular fuel elements, Nucl. Eng. Des. 356 (2020) 110360.   DOI
32 Y. Yan, Development of a coupled CFD-system-code capability (with a modified porous media model) and its applications to simulate current and next generation reactors (Doctoral dissertation, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign), 2012.
33 E. Volpenhein, RELAP5-3D Coupling with STAR-CCM, 2013.
34 T. Watanabe, Y. Anoda, M. Takano, System-CFD coupled simulations of flow instability in steam generator U tubes, Ann. Nucl. Energy 70 (2014) 141-146.   DOI
35 L. Xing, H. Yeung, Y. Geng, Y. Cao, J. Shen, Study on hydrodynamic slug flow mitigation with wavy pipe using a 3D-1D coupling approach, Comput. Fluids 99 (2014) 104-115.   DOI
36 T.T. Feng, W.X. Tian, P. Song, D.L. Zhang, S.Z. Qiu, Transient characteristics analysis of water hammer phenomena based on coupling program, Atomic Energy Sci. Technol. 51 (2017) 1364-1370.
37 A.T. Edwards, T.P. O'brien, Studies of phenomena connected with the depressurization of water reactors, J. Brit. Nucl. Energy Soc 9 (2) (1970) 125-135.
38 D. Bertolotto, A. Manera, S. Frey, H.M. Prasser, R. Chawla, Single-phase mixing studies by means of a directly coupled CFD/system-code tool, Ann. Nucl. Energy 36 (2009) 310-316.   DOI
39 T.H. Fanning, J.W. Thomas, Nuclear Engineering Division, Advances in coupled safety modeling using systems analysis and high-fidelity methods. United States. https://doi.org/10.2172/982349.   DOI
40 A. Geist, PVM: parallel virtual machine, A Users Guide & Tutorial for Networked Parallel Computing 92 (1994) 19-23.
41 M.J. Thurgood, T.E. Guidotti, G.A. Sly, J.M. Kelly, R.J. Kohrt, COBRA/TRAC - a thermal-hydraulics code for transient analysis of nuclear reactor vessels and primary coolant systems, Developmental Assessment and Data Comparisons 4 (1983).
42 T.P. Grunloh, A. Manera, A novel domain overlapping strategy for the multiscale coupling of CFD with 1D system codes with applications to transient flows, Ann. Nucl. Energy 90 (2016) 422-432.   DOI
43 D. Martelli, N. Forgione, G. Barone, I. Di Piazza, A. Del Nevo, Coupled Simulation of the NACIE Facility using the RELAP5 Thermal System Code and the CFD Ansys FLUENT Code, in: HLMC-2013, 2013, pp. 1-15.
44 T.K.P.K. Francesco Cadinu, STUDY OF ALGORITHMIC REQUIREMENTS FOR A SYSTEM-TO-CFD COUPLING STRATEGY, 2014.
45 M. Garcia, R. Tuominen, A. Gommlich, D. Ferraro, V. Valtavirta, et al., A Serpent2-SUBCHANFLOW-TRANSURANUS coupling for pin-by-pin depletion calculations in Light Water Reactors, Ann. Nucl. Energy 139 (2020) 107213.   DOI
46 H. Kyu Cho, Y.J. Cho, H.Y. Yoon, Heat structure coupling of CUPID and MARS for the multi-scale simulation of the passive auxiliary feedwater system, Nucl. Eng. Des. 273 (2014) 459-468.   DOI
47 X.J. Liu, X. Cheng, Sub-channel/system coupled code development and its application to SCWR-FQT loop, Nucl. Eng. Des. 285 (2015) 39-47.   DOI
48 A. Papukchiev, C. Geffray, M. Jeltsov, K. Kap, P. Kudinov, D. Grischenko, Multiscale analysis of forced and natural convection including heat tranfer phenomena in the TALL-3D experimental facility, in: Proc. Of NURETH-16, 2015 (Chicago, IL).
49 J. Jimenez Escalante, V. Di Marcello, V. Sanchez Espinoza, Y. Perin, Application of the ATHLET/COBRA-TF thermal-hydraulics coupled code to the analysis of BWR ATWS, Nucl. Eng. Des. 321 (2017) 318-327.   DOI