Browse > Article

A Heuristic Application of Critical Power Ratio to Pressurized Water Reactor Core Design  

Ahn, Seung-Hoon (Korea Institute of Nuclear Safety)
Jeun, Gyoo-Dong (Hanyang University)
Publication Information
Nuclear Engineering and Technology / v.34, no.1, 2002 , pp. 68-79 More about this Journal
Abstract
The approach for evaluating the critical heat flux (CHF) margin using the departure from nucleate boiling ratio (DNBR) concept has been widely applied to PWR core design, while DNBR in this approach does not indicate appropriately the CHF margin in terms of the attainable power margin-to-CHF against a reactor core condition. The CHF power margin must be calculated by increasing power until the minimum DNBR reaches a DNBR limit. The Critical Power Ratio (CPR), defined as the ratio of the predicted CHF power to the operating power, is considered more reasonable for indicating the CHF margin and can be calculated by a CPR orrelation based on the heat balance of a test bundle. This approach yields directly the CHF power margin, but the calculated CPR must be corrected to compensate for many local effects of the actual core, which are not considered in the CHF test and analysis. In this paper, correction of the calculated CPR is made so that it may become equal to the DNB overpower margin. Exemplary calculations showed that the correction tends to be increased as power distribution is more distorted, but are not unduly large.
Keywords
CHF; DNBR; CPR; PWR; local flow condition; heat balance;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Final Safety Analysis Report for YongGwang Units 3 and 4, KEPCO (1994)
2 B.S. Pei, et al., Evaluation of Performance of Five Correlations for PWR Applications, Proc. of the Int. Nuclear Power Plant Thermal Hydraulics and Operations Topical Mtg., Taipei,Taiwan, R.O.C., Oct.(1984)
3 G.S. Lellouche, 'The Boiling Transiton: Analysis and data Comparisons,' Nucl. Engrg. & Des. 116, 117-133 (1989)   DOI   ScienceOn
4 Pavel Hejzlar and Neil E. Todreas, 'Consideration of CHF Margin Prediction by Subcooled or Low-Quality CHF Correlations,' Nucl. Engrg. &. Des. 163, 215-223 (1996)   DOI   ScienceOn
5 L.S. Tong, 'Boiling Crisis and Heat Flux,' U.S. AEC. TID-25887 (1972)
6 Y.S. Chen, et al., The Modifications of the EPRI-1 Correlation for PWR Applications, Transactions of the American Nuclear Society, 1984 Winter Meeting (1984)
7 Nissley, M.E. 'Consideration for Comparing CHF correlations,' 2nd International Topical Mtg. on NPP Thermal Hydraulics and Operations, Tokyo, Japan (1986)
8 Moshe Siman-Tov, 'Application of Energy Balance and Direct Substitution Methods for Thermal Margins and Data Evaluation,' Nucl. Engrg. &. Des. 163, 249-258 (1996)   DOI   ScienceOn
9 R. Ayed and J.P. Bourteele, 'Theoretical Evaluation of Currently Used Critical Heat Flux Correlations,' Trans. ANS, Vol. 59, Atlanta June (1989)
10 R.V. Macbeth, 'An Appraisal of Forced Convenction Burnout Data,' Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs. Vol.180 Pt 3C (1965-1966)
11 C.L. Wheeler et al., COBRA-IV-i: An Interim Version of COBRA for Thermal Hydraulic Analysis of Road Bundle Nuclear Fuel Elements and Cores, BNWL-1962, (1976)
12 J. Weisman, 'Methods for Detailed Thermal and Hydraulic Analysis of Water-Cooled Reactors,' Nucl. Sci. & Engrg., 57, 255-276 (1975)   DOI
13 F.de.Crecy, 'A new Approach to the MDNBR Concept,' Nucl. Engrg. & Des. 149, 243-249 (1994)   DOI   ScienceOn
14 C.R. Lehmann, 'Transient Thermal-Hydraulic Analysis: Impact on Technical Specifications,' 'Combustion Engineering Inc. TIS-6826
15 D.G. Redd and C. F. Fighetti 'Parametric Study Of CHF Correlation for PWR and BWR Fuel Assemblies,' EPRI-NP-2609, (1982)
16 D.G. Reddy and C.F. Fighetti, 'Parametric Study of CHF Data Vol. 3: Critical Heat Flux Data,' EPRI-NP-2609 (1982)
17 R.V. Macbeth, 'Burnout Analysis, Part 4:Application of a Local Condition Hypothesis to World Data for Uniformly Heated Round Tubes and Rectangular Channels' U.K. AEA report, AEEW-R267 (1963)
18 F.D. Lawrence et al., 'Critical Heat Flux in Pwr Fuel Assemblies,' AIChE-ASME Heat Transfer Conf., Salk Lake City, Utah, Aug. 15-17 (1977)
19 SAS User's Guide: Statistics, Version 5 Edition, SAS Institution Inc. (1985)
20 L.C. Edwin et al., 'Statistics Manual, Dover Publications Inc., New York (1956)
21 D.B. Owen, 'Factors for One-SidedTolerance Limits and for Variable Sampling Plans,' SCR-607, March (1963)