Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.4275/KSLIS.2017.51.3.265

An Analysis of the Policy Making Process of Contracting-out of Public Library Appeared in Municipal Ordinance on the Establishment and Operation of Cultural Foundation: Based on the Advocacy Coalition Framework  

Hong, Bohyun (연세대학교 대학원 문헌정보학과)
Kim, Giyeong (연세대학교 문헌정보학과)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science / v.51, no.3, 2017 , pp. 265-292 More about this Journal
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to figure out the movements of policy actors in the policy process of the establishment of a local cultural foundation in B-gu(district), A-si (city), then to explore the way to contract out of the management of public libraries to the cultural foundation in the policy process. Data for the study were collected from various sources from newspapers and assembly minutes to blogs and SNS messages of the policy actors, then analysed based on Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF). The results showed that 'agreement of contract-out' coalition only accepted public interest of the public libraries between the public interest and specialty of librarianship which were insisted by 'disagreement of contract-out' coalition's policy beliefs. The comparison between this case and a similar policy case showed that the specialty of librarianship as a core belief is effective in changing the beliefs of other coalition. Eventually, it is required to differentiate and to specialize library services among public services in a local area in order to keep the direct management of public libraries by the local government, and this means that everyday library services influence the decision making of library policies in the local area.
Keywords
Public Library; Contracting-out; Advocacy Coalition Framework; Cultural Foundation; Public Nature; Specialty of Librarianship;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 11  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Weible, C. 2007. "An Advocacy Coalition Framework Approach to Stakeholder Analysis: Understanding the Political Context of California Marine Protected Area Policy." Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory: J-PART, 17(1): 95-117.   DOI
2 Weible, C., Sabatier, P. A. and McQueen, K. 2009. "Themes and Variations: Taking Stock of the Advocacy Coalition Framework." Policy Studies Journal, 37(1): 121-140.   DOI
3 고종협, 권용식. 2009. 제주 해군기지 정책변동과정에 대한 동태적 분석. 한국사회와 행정연구, 20(3): 139-178.(Ko, Jong Hyub and Kwon, Yong Sik. 2009. "Dynamic Analysis of Policy Change of Jeju Naval Post: A Study through the Application of Advocacy Coalition Framework." Korean Society and Public Administration, 20(3): 139-178.)
4 곽동철. 2004. 우리나라 공공도서관 민간위탁의 성과 분석에 관한 연구. 한국문헌정보학회지, 38(1): 51-75.(Kwack, Dong-Chul. 2004. "A Study on the Analysis of Results on 'Contracting Out' of Public Library Services in Korea." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 38(1): 51-75.)   DOI
5 곽동철. 2007. 공공도서관 위탁경영의 현상과 과제에 관한 고찰. 한국도서관.정보학회지, 38(3): 383-404.(Kwack, Dong-Chul. 2007. "A Research on the 'Contracting Out' of Public Library Services in Korea." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 38(3): 383-404.)
6 권나현 외. 2013. 공공도서관 민간위탁 가이드라인의 유용성 평가와 현장 적용성 제고방안. 한국문헌정보학회지, 47(2): 45-73.(Kwon, Nahyun et al. 2013. "Evaluating the Usefulness and Feasibility of Guidelines for Contracting-Out of Public Library Services." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 47(2): 45-73.)   DOI
7 대구 북구, 문화재단 설립 제동.조례 상정 4월로 연기. 2017. 뉴스민. 2월 2일. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 29.] ("Establishment of Cultural Foundation in Buk-gu, Daegu..Ordinance Prescription Postponed to April." 2017. Newsmin. February 2. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 29.] )
8 김태희, 리상용. 2014. 위탁공공도서관 사서의 계속교육 개선방안에 대한 연구. 한국비블리아학회지, 25(1): 363-395.(Kim, Tae-hee and Lee, Sang-yong. 2014. "A Study on Improving a Continuing Education for Public Librarians: Focusing on Privatized Public Libraries." Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science, 25(1): 363-395.)   DOI
9 김해보, 장원호. 2015. 신제도주의 동형화 이론으로 파악하는 지역문화재단의 현재와 미래. 문화 정책논총, 29(2): 26-52.(Kim, Hae-Bo and Jang, Wonho. 2015. "Analysis of Current Situations and Their Future of the Cultural Foundations of Local Governments by Applying the Theory of Neo-institutional Isomorphism." The Journal of Cultural Policy, 29(2): 26-52.)
10 김혁수, 김지원. 2016. 지역문화재단 경영자의 전문성과 효율성 제고를 위한 요인별 특성에 관한 연구. 문화경제연구, 19(2): 121-146.(Kim, Hyucksoo and Kim, Jiwon. 2016. "A Study on the Characteristics by Factors for the Professionalism and Efficiency of Local Cultural Foundation Managers." Review of Culture & Economy, 19(2): 121-146.)
11 "도서관 위탁하면 공공성 훼손" 북구 문화재단 설립 찬반 논쟁. 2016. 매일신문. 9월 27일. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 20.] ("Committing to the Library Damage to the Public, Controversy over the Establishment of the Bukgu Cultural Foundation." 2016. Maeil Shinmun. September 27. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 20.] )
12 김선애. 2012. 공공도서관의 수탁자 평가요소에 관한 연구. 한국도서관.정보학회지, 43(2): 77-98.(Kim, Sun-Ae. 2012. "A Study on Selecting Contractor in Local Government's Contracting out of Public Libraries." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 43(2): 77-98.)
13 김경욱. 2007. 문화재단: 아름다운 문화 거버넌스를 위하여. 서울: 논형.(Kim, Kyeong Wook. 2007. Cultural Foundation: For Beautiful Cultural Governance. Seoul: Nonhyung.)
14 김기영. 2008. 전문직으로서의 사서직 논의를 위한 이론적 접근. 한국문헌정보학회지, 42(1): 313-333.(Kim, Gi-Yeong. 2008. "Discussions on the Theoretical Background for Librarianship as a Profession." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 42(1): 313-333.)   DOI
15 김사랑, 김세준. 2012. 지역문화재단의 조직문화유형이 직무만족과 조직몰입에 미치는 영향. 문화정책논총, 26(2): 213-243.(Kim, Sa Rang and Kim, Sae June. 2012. "The Relationship between Commitment and Satisfaction, and Organizational Culture: Korean Regional Cultural Foundations Study." The Journal of Cultural Policy, 26(2): 213-243.)
16 최봉기. 2008. 정책학개론. 서울: 박영사.(Choi, Bong Ki. 2008. Introduction to Policy Studies. Seoul: Park Young-sa.)
17 이호신. 2016. 공공도서관 관장들의 사서직 인재상에 관한 연구. 한국도서관.정보학회 하계 학술발표회, 2016년 5월 27일, 부산: 부산대학교: 351-375.(Lee, Ho-Shin. 2016. "A Study on the Desired Talents for Librarianship: From the Perspective of Public Library Directors." Summer Conference of Korean Library and Information Science Society, May 27, 2016, Busan: Busan National University: 351-375.)
18 전진석. 2003. 새만금 간척사업의 정치경제와 정책옹호연합모형. 한국사회와 행정연구, 14(2): 207-234.(Chun, Jinsuk. 2003. "Political Economy of Saemangeum Tideland Reclamation Project through Advocacy Coalition Framework." Korean Society and Public Administration, 14(2): 207-234.)
19 전진석. 2014. 정책옹호연합모형을 적용한 논문에 대한 분석. 한국사회와 행정연구, 25(2): 1-28.(Chun, Jinsuk. 2014. "The Analysis on the ACF Articles Published in Domestic Journals." Korean Society and Public Administration, 25(2): 1-28.)
20 최성락, 황혜신, 차성종. 2011. 공공도서관 민간위탁 해외 사례 비교 연구. 한국콘텐츠학회논문지, 11(10): 274-285.(Choi, Seong-Rak, Hwang, Hie-Shin and Cha, Sung-Jong. 2011. "Comparative Research on Outsourcing Public Libraries." Journal of the Korea Contents Association, 11(10): 274-285.)   DOI
21 최윤희, 김기영. 2015. A도서관 직영전환의 정책형성과정 분석. 정보관리학회지, 32(3): 295-316.(Choi, Yoonhee and Kim, Giyeong. 2015. "An Analysis of the Policy Making Process of a Back-In Phenomenon Appeared in Contracting out of Public Library: Based on the Advocacy Coalition Framework." Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, 32(3): 295-316.)   DOI
22 태전동 어린이.주부도서관, 6년 만에 첫 삽. 2016. 경상매일신문. 1월 27일. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 27.] ("Taejeon-dong Children's Library, First Shovel in 6 years." 2016. Gyeongsang Daily Newspaper. January 27. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 27.] )
23 윤정기. 1998. 국내 공공도서관 민간위탁에 관한 고찰. 정보관리학회지, 15(1): 7-17.(Youn, Jeong-Key. 1998. "A Study on Contracting-out of the Public Library in Korea." Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, 15(1): 7-17.)
24 도서관정보정책위원회. 2015. 공공도서관 운영 민간위탁 추진에 대한 반대입장. 서울: 도서관정보정책위원회.(Library Information Policy Committee. 2015. Opposition to Public Consignment Promotion of Public Library Operation. Seoul: Library Information Policy Committee.)
25 류숙원. 2013. 지방자치단체 민간위탁 실태분석. 서울: 감사원 감사연구원.(Ryu, Sukwon. 2013. Analysis of the Actual Situation of the Private Civil Authority in Local Government. Seoul: Board of Audit and Inspection, Audit Researcher.)
26 북구청, 문화재단 설립위한 주민설명회? 토론회?. 2016. 팔공신문. 10월 4일. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 25.] ("Buk-gu Office, Residents' Briefing Session for Establishment of Cultural Foundation? Debating Society?." 2016. Palgong Newspaper. October 4. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 25.] )
27 서혁준, 전영평. 2006. 소수자로서의 비정규직 근로자와 정책변동. 한국행정학보, 40(4): 277-302.(Suh, Hyuk-Jun and Chun, Young-Pyoung. 2006. "Examining the Complex Process of Korean Contingent Worker Employment Policy: Change Through a Social Minority Perspective." Korean Public Administration Review, 40(4): 277-302.)
28 양승일. 2006. 정책변동론. 파주: 양서원.(Yang, Seung-il. 2006. Policy Change Theory. Paju: Yangseowon.)
29 윤희윤. 2008. 공공도서관 위탁경영의 분석과 해법. 한국도서관.정보학회지, 39(3): 3-26.(Yoon, Hee-Yoon. 2008. "Analysis and Solution of Contracting out of Public Libraries in Korea." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 39(3): 3-26.)
30 이만수. 2001. 정보사회에서의 국가 도서관 정책 방향에 관한 연구. 한국도서관.정보학회지, 32(1): 201-221.(Lee, Man-Soo. 2001. "A Study on the Library Policy of National in Information Society." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 32(1): 201-221.)
31 이승모. 2014. 정책옹호연합모형(ACF)의 적용을 통한 정책변동 분석. 한국정책과학학회보, 18(4): 175-201.(Lee, Seung-Mo. 2014. "The Advocacy Coalition Framework and the Policy Change Analysis: The Case of Electricity Transmission Tower Conflicts in Miryang, Korea." Korean Policy Sciences Review, 18(4): 175-201.)
32 배응환. 2010. 지방자치: 정치와 행정 그리고 거버넌스. 한국행정포럼, 132: 26-35.(Bae, Eung Whan. 2010. "Local Government: Politics, Administration and Governance." Korea Administrative Forum, 132: 26-35.)
33 포럼 문화와 도서관. 2011. 공공도서관 민간위탁 가이드라인. [online] [cited 2017. 7. 11.] (Forum Culture and Library. 2011. Guidelines for the Private Sourcing of Public Libraries. [online] [cited 2017. 7. 11.] )
34 김세준. 2013. 문화재단 현황조사 및 특성화 전략방안. 한국문화정책학회 학술대회논문집, 2013년 4월 20일, 서울: 서울대학교: 105-114.(Kim, Se-joon. 2013. "Cultural Foundation Research and Characterization." In Proceedings of the Korea Cultural Policy Association, April 20, 2013, Seoul: Seoul National University: 105-114.)
35 김수진, 김유승. 2012. 운영방식과 고용형태에 따른 공공도서관 사서의 직무만족도에 대한 연구. 한국비블리아학회지, 23(4): 261-282.Kim, Su-Jin and Kim, You-Seung. 2012. "A Study on Public Librarians' Job Satisfaction by Management and Employment Styles: Focused on Public Libraries in Daegu Metropolitan City." Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science, 23(4): 261-282.)   DOI
36 박계옥. 2013. 정책동학의 이해. 서울: 미래의 창.(Park, Gye-ok. 2013. Understanding Policy Dynamics. Seoul: Milaeui chang.)
37 박기혁. 2011. 한미 자유무역협정에 관한 사례 연구: 정책옹호연합모형(ACF)의 적용을 중심으로. 석사학위논문, 한국방송통신대학교 평생대학원 행정학과.(Park, Ki Hyuk. 2011. A case study on the decision making process of FTA between Korea and U.S.A.. M.A. thesis, Department of Public Administration, Graduate school of Korea National Open University, Republic of Korea.)
38 박현경, 이찬구. 2017. 정책옹호연합모형(ACF)를 활용한 임금피크제 정책결정과정 분석. 한국기술혁신학회 학술대회, 2017년 5월 26일, 대전: 충남대학교: 845-872.(Park, Hyun-Kyung and Lee, Chan-Gu. 2017. "Analysis of the policy decision process of the wage peak system using the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF)." Korea Technology Innovation Society Conference, May 26, 2017, Daejeon: Chungnam National University: 845-872.)
39 배순자. 2003. 행정서비스의 민간위탁 사업평가를 통해 본 공공도서관 민간위탁의 함의. 한국도서관.정보학회지, 34(2): 79-94.(Bae, Soon-Ja. 2003. "Implications in Contracting-out of Public Library through the Evaluating Contracting-out of Public Administration Services." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 34(2): 79-94.)
40 백승기. 2010. 옹호연합모형(ACF: Advocacy Coalition Framework)에 의한 의료보험 통합정책에 관한 비교 연구. 한국행정학보, 44(4): 233-259.(Paik, Sung-Ki. 2010. "A Study of the Process of the Integration of Health Insurance Societies in Korea and Taiwan through the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF)." Korean Public Administration Review, 44(4): 233-259.)
41 백옥선. 2017. 지방자치단체와 지역문화재단간 거버넌스 실태분석. 문화정책논총, 31(1): 130-156.(Baik, Ok Sun. 2017. "An Analysis of Governance Status between Local Governments and Regional Culture Foundations." The Journal of Cultural Policy, 31(1): 130-156.)
42 Elliott, C. and Schlaepfer, R. 2001. "The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Application to the Policy Process for the Development of Forest Certification in Sweden." Journal of European Public Policy, 8(4): 642-661.   DOI
43 이은정. 2016. 재벌의 공익법인 악용 현황 및 보완대책. 기업지배구조연구, 52: 166-178.(Lee, Eun Jung. 2016. "Status of Abuse of Conglomerate's Public Interest Corporations and Supplementary Measures." Biannual Journal of Good Corporate Governance, 52: 166-178.)
44 이현식. 2005. 지역문화재단의 역할과 과제. 황해문화, 49: 275-293.(Lee, Hyun-sik. 2005. "The Role and Tasks of the Regional Cultural Foundation." Hwanghae Review, 49: 275-293.)
45 한국사서협회. 2015. 김포시립도서관 문화재단 위탁 문제 해결. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 29.] (Korea Librarian Association. 2015. Solving the Problem of Commissioning the Gimpo Municipal Library Foundation. [online] [cited 2017. 6. 29.] )
46 Brecher, C. et al. 2010. "Understanding the Political Context of "New" Policy Issues: The Use of the Advocacy Coalition Framework in the Case of Expanded After-School Programs." Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory: J-PART, 20(2): 335-355.   DOI
47 Butler, P. 1933. An Introduction to Library Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
48 Ellison, B. 1998. "Intergovernmental Relations and the Advocacy Coalition Framework: The Operation of Federalism in Denver Water Politics." Publius, 28(4): 35-54.   DOI
49 Sabatier, P. A. and Jenkins, H. C. 1994. "Evaluating the Advocacy Coalition Framework." Journal of Public Policy, 14(2): 175-203.   DOI
50 Sabatier, P. A. and Weible, C. M. 2007. "The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Innovations and Clarifications." Theories of the Policy Process: 189-217.