Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.15683/kosdi.2018.06.30.203

A Study on the Improvement of Evaluation System of National Infrastructure System using Meta-Evaluation  

Lee, Seong-Yeob (Department of Business Continuity Management System, University of Soongsil)
Lee, Jung-Myoung (Department of Business Continuity Management System, University of Soongsil)
Jung, Yong-Kyun (Department of Business Continuity Management System, University of Soongsil)
Cheung, Chong-Soo (Department of Business Continuity Management System, University of Soongsil)
Publication Information
Journal of the Society of Disaster Information / v.14, no.2, 2018 , pp. 203-210 More about this Journal
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to build a model for the meta - evaluation of the national infrastructure system and to improve the evaluation system of the national infrastructure system using the model. Method: For the study, the disaster-related laws and regulations, the evaluation report of the national infrastructure system published by the government, the guideline for the establishment of the national infrastructure protection plan, the meta-evaluation previous research data, To analyze the actual state of the evaluation. Results: Among the indices of evaluation of the current national infrastructure system, the supplementary requirements were derived from seven indicators such as appropriateness of education and training plan and implementation of disaster response, evaluation and communication with stakeholders, and evaluation committee training time. Conclusion: It is expected that the improvement plan derived from this study can be used to improve the evaluation index of the national infrastructure system.
Keywords
National Infrastructure Protection Plan; Evaluation System; Meta-Evaluation; Functional Continuity; Evaluation Indicator;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Go, G.I. (2017). "A Meta-evaluation Model for Policy Evaluation of Central Administrative Agencies", Pusan University Doctoral Thesis
2 Hwang, M.G.(2008). "Analysis of the efficiency of national R & D project evaluation system using meta-evaluation", Konkuk University Doctoral Thesis
3 "Implementation plan for national disaster management evaluation for 2017"(Disaster Management Office, Ministry of Public Administration and Security)
4 Jung, H.S. (2013). "An Exploratory Study on the Development of Meta-Evaluation Model", Journal of Korean Government 25th 2 :455-478
5 Kim, B.C. (2009). "Meta-valuation", Korean Academic Information.
6 Lee, C.G. (1997). "A Study on Meta - evaluation of R & D Projects", Chungnam National University Graduate School Doctoral Thesis
7 Lipsey, M(2009). "Meta-analysis and the learning curse in evalution practice". Journal of MultiDisciplinary Evalution, 6:32-37
8 "National Infrastructure System Disaster Management Assessment Report in 2017"(The Export-Import Bank of Korea)
9 Orata, Pedro T(1940). E"valuating Evaluation". Journal of Evaluational Research, 33(9): 641-661
10 Disaster and Safety Management Basic Law(14839)
11 Dror, Yehezkel(1971). "ventrus in policy Scriences: Concepts and Application". New York: American Elsevier Publishing Company
12 Scriven, Michael(1969). "An Introduction to Meta-evalution". Education Product Reports, 2(5): 36-38
13 Park T.D.(2013). "A Study on the improvement of the performance evaluation system of the market-based public enterprise from the view point of meta evaluationion". Yeungnam University Graduate School Doctoral Thesis
14 "Development report of national infrastructure protection guideline and evaluation index" (2009, Ministry of Public Administration and Security, National Infrastructure Protection association)
15 "Guidelines for Establishing a National Infrastructure System Protection Plan for 2018"(Disaster Management Office, Ministry of Public Administration and Security)
16 "Guidelines for Establishing a National Infrastructure System Protection Plan for 2017"(Disaster Management Office, Ministry of Public Administration and Security)