Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.13088/jiis.2015.21.2.19

Membership Fluidity and Knowledge Collaboration in Virtual Communities: A Multilateral Approach to Membership Fluidity  

Park, Hyun-jung (Management Research Center, Ewha Womans University)
Shin, Kyung-shik (School of Business, Ewha Womans University)
Publication Information
Journal of Intelligence and Information Systems / v.21, no.2, 2015 , pp. 19-47 More about this Journal
Abstract
In this era of knowledge economy, a variety of virtual communities are proliferating for the purpose of knowledge creation and utilization. Since the voluntary contributions of members are the essential source of knowledge, member turnover can have significant implications on the survival and success of virtual communities. However, there is a dearth of research on the effect of membership turnover and even the method of measurement for membership turnover is left unclear in virtual communities. In a traditional context, membership turnover is calculated as the ratio of the number of departing members to the average number of members for a given time period. In virtual communities, while the influx of newcomers can be clearly measured, the magnitude of departure is elusive since explicit withdrawals are seldom executed. In addition, there doesn't exist a common way to determine the average number of community members who return and contribute intermittently at will. This study initially examines the limitations in applying the concept of traditional turnover to virtual communities, and proposes five membership fluidity measures based on a preliminary analysis of editing behaviors of 2,978 featured articles in English Wikipedia. Subsequently, this work investigates the relationships between three selected membership fluidity measures and group collaboration performance, reflecting a moderating effect dependent on work characteristic. We obtained the following results: First, membership turnover relates to collaboration efficiency in a right-shortened U-shaped manner, with a moderating effect from work characteristic; given the same turnover rate, the promotion likelihood for a more professional task is lower than that for a less professional task, and the likelihood difference diminishes as the turnover rate increases. Second, contribution period relates to collaboration efficiency in a left-shortened U-shaped manner, with a moderating effect from work characteristic; the marginal performance change per unit change of contribution period is greater for a less professional task. Third, the number of new participants per month relates to collaboration efficiency in a left-shortened reversed U-shaped manner, for which the moderating effect from work characteristic appears to be insignificant.
Keywords
Virtual community; fluidity; turnover; member retention; knowledge collaboration;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Burt, R. S., Structural Holes, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1992.
2 Butler, B. S., "Membership Size, Communication Activity, and Sustainability: A Resource-Based Model of Online Social Structures," Information Systems Research, Vol.12, No.4 (2001), 346-362.   DOI
3 Butler, B., L. Sproull, S. Kiesler, and R. Kraut, Community Effort in Online Groups: Who Does the Work and Why?, In Leadership at a Distance: Research in technologically supported work, S. Weisband and L. Atwater (Eds.), 2007, 171-194.
4 C arley, K ., "Organizational Learning and Personnel Turnover," Organization Science, Vol.3, No.1(1992), 20-46.   DOI
5 Carr, N. G., "The Ignorance of Crowds," strategy+business, Vol.47(2007), 1-5.
6 Coleman, J. S., "Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital," American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 94(1988), s95-s120.   DOI
7 Constant, D., L. Sproull, S. Kiesler, "The Kindness of Strangers: The Usefulness of Electronic Weak Ties for Technical Advice," Organization Science, Vol.7, No.2(1996), 119-135.   DOI
8 Crowston, K., K. Wei, Q. Li, and J. Howison, Core and Periphery in Free/Libre and Open Source Software Team Communications, Proceedings of the 39th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Vol.6(2006).
9 Csikszentmihalyi, M., S. Abuhamdeh, and J. Nakamura, Flow, in Elliot, A. J. and C. S. Dweck, Handbook of Competence and Motivation, New York: The Guilford Press, 2005, 598-698.
10 Darmon, R. Y., "Identifying Sources of Turnover Costs-A Segmental Approach," Journal of Marketing, Vol.54, No.2(1990), 46-56.
11 Dess, G. G. and J. D. Shaw, "Voluntary Turnover, Social Capital, and Organizational Performance," Academy of Management Review, Vol.26, No.3(2001), 446-456.   DOI
12 Ducheneaut, N., "Socialization in an Open Source Software Community: A Socio-Technical Analysis," Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW), Vol.14, No.4(2005), 323-368.   DOI
13 Faraj, S., S. L. Jarvenpaa, and A. Majchrzak, "Knowledge Collaboration in Online Communities," Organization Science, Vol.22, No.5(2011), 1224-1239.   DOI   ScienceOn
14 Farzan, R., L. Dabbish, and T. Postmes, "Increasing Commitment to Online Communities by Designing for Social Presence," CSCW '11: Proceedings of the ACM 2011 Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work, (2011), 321-330.
15 Garcia, R., R. Calantone, and R. Levine, "The Role of Knowledge in Resource Allocation to Exploration Versus Exploitation in Technologically Oriented Organizations," Decision Sciences, Vol.34, No.2(2003), 323-349.   DOI
16 Geister, S., U. Konradt, and G. Hertel, "Effects of Process Feedback on Motivation, Satisfaction, and Performance in Virtual Teams," Small Group Research, Vol.37, No.5(2006), 459-489.   DOI
17 Glebbeek, A. C. and E. H. Bax, "Is High Employee Turnover Really Harmful? An Empirical Test Using Company Records," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.47, No.2(2004), 277-286.   DOI   ScienceOn
18 Goldhammer, F., J. Naumann, A. Stelter, K. Tóth, H. Rolke, E. Klieme, "The Time on Task Effect in Reading and Problem Solving is Moderated by Task Difficulty and Skill: Insights from a Computer-based Large-scale Assessment," Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol.106, No.3(2014), 608-626.   DOI
19 Griffith, T. L., J. E. Sawyer, and M. A. Neale, "Virtualness and Knowledge in Teams: Managing the Love Triangle of Organizations, Individuals, and Information Technology," MIS Quarterly, Vol. 27, No.2(2003), 265-287.   DOI
20 Hackman, J. R. and G. R. Oldham, "Motivation through the Design of Work: Test of a Theory," Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, Vol.16(1976), 250-279.   DOI
21 Hoffman, L. and N. Maier, "Quality and Acceptance of Problem Solutions by Members of Homogeneous and Heterogeneous Groups," Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, Vol.62(1961), 401-407.   DOI
22 Hom, P. and R. Griffeth, Employee Turnover, Cincinnati, OH: South-Western Publishing, 1995.
23 Humphrey S. E., J. D. Nahrgang, and F. P. Morgeson, "Integrating Motivational, Social, and Contextual Work Design Features: A Meta-analytic Summary and Theoretical Extension of the Work Design Literature," Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol.92, No.5(2007), 1332-1356.   DOI   ScienceOn
24 Huselid, M. A., "The Impact of Human Resource Management Practices on Turnover, Productivity, and Corporate Financial Performance," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.38, No.3(1995), 635-672.   DOI
25 Jackson, S. E., A. Joshi, and N. L. Erhardt, "Recent Research on Team and Organizational Diversity: SWOT Analysis and Implications," Journal of Management, Vol.29, No.6(2003), 801-803.   DOI
26 Jehn, K. A., G. B. Northcraft, and M. A. Neale, "Why Differences Make a Difference: A Field Study of Diversity, Conflict, and Performance in Workgroups," Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol.44, No.4(1999), 741-763.   DOI   ScienceOn
27 Johnson, S., "Should I Stay or Should I Go? Continued Participation Intentions in Online Communities," Proceedings of Academy of Management Annual Conference, Leslie A. Toombs (ed.), 2010.
28 Kane, G. C. and M. Alavi, "Casting the Net: A Multimodal Network Perspective on User- System Interactions," Information Systems Research, Vol.19, No.3(2008), 253-272.   DOI
29 Joyce, E. and R. E. Kraut, "Predicting Continued Participation in Newsgroups," Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, Vol.11, No.3(2006), 723-747.   DOI
30 Kacmar, K. M., M. C. Andrews, D. L. van Rooy, R. C. Steilberg, and S. Cerrone, "Sure Everyone can be Replaced . . . but at What Cost? Turnover as a Predictor of Unit-level Performance," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.39(2006), 133-144.
31 Kane, G. C. and M. Alavi, "Information Technology and Organizational Learning: An Investigation of Exploration and Exploitation Processes," Organization Science, Vol.18, No.5(2007), 796-812.   DOI
32 Kane, G. C. and R. G. Fichman, "The Shoemakers Children: Using Wikis for IS Research, Teaching, and Publication," MIS Quarterly, Vol.33, No.1(2009), 1-22.   DOI
33 Krackhardt, D. and L. W. Porter, "When Friends Leave: A Structural Analysis of the Relationship Between Turnover and Stayers' Attitudes," Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol.30(1985), 242-261.   DOI
34 Kraut, R., M. Burke, and J. Riedl, Dealing with Newcomers, In Evidence-based Social Design: Mining the Social Sciences to Build Online Communities, R. E. Kraut and P. Resnick (eds.), Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2010, 1-43.
35 Kuk, G., "Strategic Interaction and Knowledge Sharing in the KDE Developer Mailing List," Management Science, Vol.52, No.7 (2006), 1031-1042.   DOI
36 Lakhani, K. and R. Wolf, "Why Hackers Do What They Do: Understanding Motivation and Effort in Free/Open Source Software Projects," J. Feller, B. Fitzgerald, S. Hissam, and K. Lakhani (eds.), Perspectives in Free and Open Source Software MIT, Cambridge, 2005.
37 Madsen, T. L., E. Mosakowski, and S. Zaheer, "Knowledge Retention and Personnel Mobility: The Nondisruptive Effects of Inflows of Experience," Organization Science, Vol.14, No.2(2003), 173-191.   DOI
38 Lazar, J. and J. Preece, Online Communities: Usability, Sociability and Users' Requirements, In Cognition in the Digital World, H. van Oostendorp (ed.), Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc., 2002, 127-151.
39 Leana, C. R. and H. J. Van Buren, "Organizational Social Capital and Employment Practices," Academy of Management Review, Vol.24, No.3(1999), 538-555.   DOI
40 Li, F., Y. Li, and E. Wang, "Task Characteristics and Team Performance: The Mediating Effect of Team Member Satisfaction," Social Behavior and Personality, Vol.37, No.10 (2009), 1373-1382.   DOI   ScienceOn
41 March, J. G., "Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning," Organization Science, Vol.2, No.1(1991), 71-87.   DOI
42 Morgeson, F. P. and S. E. Humphrey, Job and Team Design: Toward a More Integrative Conceptualization of Work Design, In Research in Personnel and Human Resource Management, J. Martocchio (ed.), Emerald Group Publishing Limited, London, 2008, 39-92.
43 Nahapiet, J. and S. Ghoshal, "Social Capital, Intellectual Capital and the Organizational Advantage," Academy of Management Review, Vol.23, No.2(1998), 242-266.   DOI
44 Nemoto, K., P. A. Gloor, and R. Laubacher, "Social Capital Increases Efficiency of Collaboration among Wikipedia Editors," Proceedings of the 22nd ACM Conference on Hypertext and Hypermedia, (2011).
45 Nonaka, I. "A Dynamic Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation," Organization Science, Vol.5, No.1(1994), 14-37.   DOI
46 Park, J. B., Theory and Practice of Survival Analysis, Shinkwang Publishing Company, 2007.
47 Nonaka, I. and R. Toyama, "The Theory of the Knowledge-creating Firm: Subjectivity, Objectivity and Synthesis," Industrial and Corporate Change, Vol.14, No.3(2005), 419-436.   DOI
48 Oldham, G. R. and J. R. Hackman, (2010) "Not What It Was and Not What It Will Be: The Future of Job Design Research," Journal of Organizational Behavior, Vol.31, No.2-3(2010), 463-479.   DOI   ScienceOn
49 O'Reilly, C., "Corporations, Culture, and Commitment: Motivation and Social Control in Organizations," California Management Review, Vol.31, No.4(1989), 9-25.
50 Pelled, L. H., K. M. Eisenhardt, and K. R. Xin, "Exploring the Black Box: An Analysis of Work Group Diversity, Conflict, and Performance," Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol.44, No.1(1999), 1-28.   DOI
51 Putnam, R., "Tuning in, Tuning out: The Strange Disappearance of Social Capital in America," Political Science and Politics, Vol.28, No.4(1995), 1-20.
52 Qin, X., M. Salter-Townshend, and P. Cunningham, "Exploring the Relationship between Membership Turnover and Productivity in Online Communities," Proceedings of the Eighth International AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media, (2014), 406-415.
53 Ransbotham, S. and G. Kane, "Membership Turnover and Collaboration Success in Online Communities: Explaining Rises and Falls from Grace in Wikipedia," MIS Quarterly, Vol.35, No.3(2011), 613-627.   DOI
54 Ren, Y., R. Kraut, and S. Kiesler, "Applying Common Identity and Bond Theory to Design of Online Communities," Organization Studies, Vol.28, No.3(2007), 377-408.   DOI
55 Shaw, J. D., M. K. Duffy, J. L. Johnson, and D. E. Lockhart, "Turnover, Social Capital Losses, and Performance," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.48, No.4(2005), 594-606.   DOI
56 Robert, L. P., A. R. Dennis, M. K. Ahuja, "Social Capital and Knowledge Integration in Digitally Enabled Teams," Information Systems Research, Vol.19, No.3(2008), 314-334.   DOI
57 Schultze, U. and D. E. Leidner, "Studying Knowledge Management in Information Systems Research: Discourses and Theoretical Assumptions," MIS Quarterly, Vol.26, No.3(2002), 213-242.   DOI   ScienceOn
58 Seibert, S. E., M. L. Kraimer, and R. C. Liden, "A Social Capital Theory of Career Success," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.44, No.2(2001), 219-237.   DOI
59 Shaw, J. D., N. Gupta, and J. E. Delery, "Alternative Conceptualizations of the Relationship between Voluntary Turnover and Organizational Performance," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.48, No.1(2005), 50-68.   DOI
60 Siebert, W. S. and N. Zubanov, "Searching for the Optimal Level of Employee Turnover: A Study of a Large UK Retail Organization," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.52, No.2(2009), 294-313.   DOI
61 Silva, L., L. Goel, and E. Mousavidin, "Exploring the Dynamics of Blog Communities: The Case of Metafilter," Information Systems Journal, Vol.19, No.1(2008), 55-81.   DOI
62 Spreitzer, G. M., S. G. Cohen, and J. G. Ledford, "Developing Effective Self-managing Work Teams in Service Organizations," Group and Organization Management, Vol.24, No.3(1999), 340-366.   DOI
63 Stewart, G. L., "A Meta-analytic Review of Relationships Between Team Design Features and Team Performance," Journal of Management, Vol.32, No.1(2006), 29-55.   DOI
64 van der Vegt, G. S., S. Bunderson, and B. Kuipers, "Why Turnover Matters in Self-Managing Work Teams: Learning, Social Integration, and Task Flexibility," Journal of Management, Vol.36, No.5(2009), 1168-1191.   DOI
65 Szulanski, G., "The Process of Knowledge Transfer: A Diachronic Analysis of Stickiness," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, Vol.82, No.1(2000), 9-27.   DOI
66 Tett, R. P. and P. Meyer John, "Job Satisfaction, Organizational Commitment, Turnover Intention, and Turnover: Path Analyses Based on Meta-Analytic Findings," Personnel Psychology, Vol. 46, No. 2(1993), 259-293.   DOI
67 Ton, Z. and R. S. Huckman, "Managing the Impact of Employee Turnover on Performance: The Role of Process Conformance," Organization Science, Vol.19, No.1(2008), 56-68.   DOI
68 Wagner, C. and A. Majchrzak, "Enabling Customer - Centricity Using Wikis and the Wiki Way," Journal of Management Information Systems, Vol.23, No.3(2006), 17-43.   DOI
69 Wang, X. and S. Lantzy, "A Systematic Examination of Member Turnover and Online Community Health," Proceedings of ICIS, (2011), 25:1-25:10.
70 Warkentin, M. E., L. Sayeed, and R. Hightower, "Virtual Teams Versus Face-to-Face Teams: An Exploratory Study of a Web-based Conference System," Decision Sciences, Vol.28, No.4(1997), 975-996.   DOI
71 Wasko, M. and S. Faraj, "Why should I share? Examining Social Capital and Knowledge Contribution in Electronic Networks of Practice," MIS Quarterly, Vol.29, No.1 (2005), 35-57.   DOI
72 Wegner, D. M., "Transactive Memory: A Contemporary Analysis of the Group Mind," In Theories of Group Behavior, B. Mullen and G. R. Goethals (eds.), New York: Springer-Verlag, 1987, 185-208.
73 Arguello, J., B. Butler, E. Joyce, R. Kraut, K. S. Ling, C. Rose, and X. Wang, "Talk to Me : Foundations for Successful Individual-Group Interactions in Online Communities," CHI '06 Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, (2006), 959-968.
74 Williams, K. Y. and C. A. O'Reilly, Demography and Diversity in Organizations, In Research in Organizational Behavior, B. M. Staw and R. M. Sutton (eds.), JAI Press, 1998, 77-140.
75 Abelson, M. A. and B. D. Baysinger, "Optimal and Dysfunctional Turnover: Toward an Organizational Level Model," Academy of Management Review, Vol.9, No.2(1984), 331-341.   DOI
76 Ackerman, M. and L. Palen, "The Zephyr Help Instance: Promoting Ongoing Activity in a CSCW System," ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, (1996), 268-275.
77 Alexander, J. A., J. R. Bloom, and B. A. Nuchols, "Nursing Turnover and Hospital Efficiency: An Qrganizational-level Analysis," Industrial Relations, Vol.33(1994), 505-520.
78 Ancona, D. and D. Caldwell, "Demography and Design: Predictors of New Product Team Performance," Organization Science, Vol.3, No.3(1992), 321-341.   DOI
79 Anthony, D., S. W. Smith, and T. Williamson, "Reputation and Reliability in Collective Goods: The Case of the Online Encyclopedia Wikipedia," Rationality and Society, Vol.21, No.3(2009), 283-306.   DOI   ScienceOn
80 Argote, L. and D. Epple, "Learning Curves in Manufacturing," Science, Vol.247(1990), 920-924.   DOI
81 Bateman, P. J., P. H. Gray, and B. Butler, "Research Note--The Impact of Community Commitment on Participation in Online Communities," Information Systems Research, Vol.22, No.4(2011), 841-854.   DOI
82 Batt, R., "Managing Customer Service: Human Resource Practices, Quit Rates, and Sales Growth," Academy of Management Journal, Vol.45(2002), 587-597.   DOI
83 Bantel, K. A. and S. E. Jackson, "Top Management and Innovations in Banking: Does the Composition of the Top Team Make a Difference?," Strategic Management Journal, Vol.10(1989), 107-124.   DOI   ScienceOn
84 Becker, G. S., "Investment in Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis," The Journal of Political Economy, Vol.70, No.5(1962), 9-49.   DOI
85 Brown, C. and J. Medoff, "Trade Unions in the Production Process," Journal of Political Economy, Vol.86(1978), 355-378.   DOI