Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2019.47.6.053

Selection and Application of Evaluation Factors for Urban Regeneration Project  

Jang, Cheol-Kyu (Division of Urban Landscape, Daegu University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture / v.47, no.6, 2019 , pp. 53-66 More about this Journal
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to suggest indicator-based selection and improvement plans for evaluating urban regeneration projects. First, we selected the indicators by conducting expert surveys and analysis of the responses received. Additionally, using the selected indicators, we analyzed the residents' opinions in Wongogae Village, where urban regeneration projects were in progress. Based on these, we suggested a plan to improve Wongogae Village. According to the study, we classified the urban regeneration evaluation indicators into 'Physical environment', 'Social environment' and 'Economic environment' according to their characteristics. We selected urban regeneration evaluation factors through the first expert survey and MCB analysis. As a result, we selected six factors for the 'Physical environment' category: 'Traffic and pedestrian environment', 'Residential (housing) environment', 'Safety and security environment', 'Greenspace', 'Landscape improvement' and 'Public space', In the 'Social environment' category, four factors were chosen: 'Resident participation', 'Community activation', 'Role of the local government and support centers' and 'Resident education' while for the 'Economic environment' category three factors were selected: 'Local economic revitalization', 'Creating an economy-based environment', 'Job creation'. Next, we conducted a second expert survey and carried out an AHP analysis using the selected evaluation factors to derive the overall weight for each. Among the evaluation factors for urban regeneration, the 'Residential (housing) environment' has the highest weighted value of 0.108, followed by 'Local economic revitalization' and 'Resident participation'. Lastly, the analysis of the residents' opinions of Wongogae Village using the urban regeneration evaluation factors, Parking environment', 'Maintenance of old houses and living environment', 'Environment for founding town and social enterprises', 'Improve commercial and business environment', 'Maintain and activate existing business' and 'Vitalizing small regional economies such as domestic handicrafts and side-job' had high overall importance, but low satisfaction, which means that it is necessary to improve the focus. Therefore, in order to improve the urban regeneration project in villages, it is necessary to improve the parking environment by expanding public parking lots, eliminate close houses, and idle lands, or open a school playground in the village for the residents. In addition, it is essential to encourage economic activities, such as fostering village enterprises and social enterprises in connection with cooperatives and allow for the selling of the products through resident activities, such as neighboring markets.
Keywords
Residential Area Regeneration; Citizen Participation; MCB Analysis; AHP Analysis; IPA;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Cho, H. J.(2008) Establishment of the Landscape Ecological Planning Model and Applying Standard. MS Dissertation, Kyungpook National University, Korea.
2 Chu, H. S., T. Y. Baek and J. M. Kang(2018) Review of the physical evaluation factors of the campustown project: Focused on Seoul campustown project. Journal of the Korean Society of Civil Engineers 38(1): 149-157.   DOI
3 Choi, G. C.(2008) An Study on the Effects of Pattern Language in a Revitalization of the Old Downtown Area. MS Dissertation, Hanyang University, Korea.
4 Daegu metropolitan city(2016) 2025 Urban Renewal Report.
5 Daegu metropolitan city(2017) Daegu Statistical Annual Report in 2016.
6 Duke, C. R. and M. A. Persia(1996) Consumer-defined dimensions for the escorted tour industry segment: Expectations, satisfactions, and importance. Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing 5(1/2): 77-99.   DOI
7 Ha, C. H., H. J. Kwak and H. S. Kim(2013) A study on utilization and making vegetable garden of vacant land and deserted house in deteriorated low-rise residential area for neighborhood regeneration: Focused on no-song low-rise residence district in Jeonju. Journal of The Urban Design Institute of Korea 14(6): 81-93.
8 Ha, Y. S.(2016) An analytical study on the relationship between urban regeneration evaluation and civic consciousness: With a focus on mediation effect of maul satisfaction. Journal of Public Society 6(4): 121-155.   DOI
9 Hammitt, W. E., M. D. Bixer and P. Francis.(1996) Going beyond important performance analysis to analyze the observance- influence of park impact. Journal of Park and Recreation Administration 14(1): 45-62.
10 Jang, C. K., M. L. Hwang, J. Y. Shin and S. G. Jung(2017) Analysis of satisfaction on Alley Garden’s components by urban regeneration. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 45(6): 137-148.   DOI
11 Jang, K. S.(2016) A study on promotion of urban regeneration program: Focusing on the experiences in the operation of Jeonju testbed project. Public Land Law Review 76: 25-44.
12 Jin, H. S.(2012) The meaning of Maeul mandeulgie and urban regeneration in the view of public. Review of Architecture and Building Science 56(6): 66-70.
13 Jung, S. G., K. J. Moon and K. J. Yoo(2016) A study on related party consciousness for urban regeneration activation: Concentrated on the Sanbok-doro renaissance urban regeneration area in Busan. Journal of The Regional Association of Architectural Institute of Korea 18(1): 131-140.
14 Kang, M. H., H. S. Song and M. H. Lee(2017) A study on the difference of perceptions on major elements of urban regeneration between residents and experts: Focused on urban regeneration areas in Seoul. Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea Urban Design 18(3): 45-59.   DOI
15 Kim, A. L. and J. H. Koo(2014) A study on determinants of elderly residental satisfaction on the planned elements of the participatory residential environment improving projects: Focused on the project of Yonnam-dong. Journal of the Korean Housing Association 25(5): 125- 132.   DOI
16 Kim, K. S.(2014) The effect of urban regeneration on the village satisfaction and community spirit of the citizens of Seoul. Journal of Public Society 4(1): 66-92.
17 Kim. K. Y.(2016) An Analytical Study on the Urban Regeneration in Changwon and Proposals to Improve the Projects. Ph.D. Dissertation. Gyeongsang National University, Korea.
18 Kim, T. D., S. A. Sung and H. Y. Hwang(2014) Comparative resident satisfaction studies between Changwon and Cheongju regeneration projects. Journal of Environmental Policy and Administration 22(2): 153-181.
19 Kim, S. W.(2012) A Study on Urban Regeneration Strategy of Old Downtown in Small-Medium Sized Cities Using the Concept of Compact City: Focus on Gumpo Railway Station Sphere Development District. Ph.D. Dissertation., Hanyang University, Korea.
20 Kuehl, R. O.(2000) Design of Experiments: Statistical Principles of Research Design and Analysis: 2nd Edition. Duxbury Resource Center, CA: Pacific Grove.
21 Lai, I. W. and M. Hitchcock(2015) Importance-performance analysis in tourism: A framework for researchers. Tourism Management 48: 242-267.   DOI
22 Lee, B. D and J. S. Shim(2012) A study on regeneration of derelict urban areas throughout resident's participation: Focusing on the comparison of case studies from Japan, England and the US. Journal of the Korean Cadastre Information Association 14(2): 183-206.
23 Lee, B, D and J. U. Dong(2005) A study on the improvement projects of resident environment in the poor residence for low income families in inner city. Journal of Korea Community Development Society 30(2): 91-103.
24 Lee, H. J., Y. J. Kim and J. G. Kim(2014) Assessment of the urban design elements in urban regeneration space of community business type. Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea Urban Design 15(6): 17-31.
25 Lee, I. H. and J. H. Lee(2011) A study on the urban planning elements for sustainable urban regeneration. Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea Urban Design 12(6): 101-114.
26 Lee, I. S.(1998) Analysis of consistency and accuracy of analytic hierarchy process using various ratio scales and simplified procedure. Journal of Korea Planning Association 33(3): 347-362.
27 Park, D. K., D. W. Jeong and H. S. Kim(2009) Assessment of the downtown regeneration project based on the analysis of planning factors. Journal of the Korean Urban Management Association 22(3): 295-316.
28 Lee, J. K., R. H. Kim, H. J. Kim and S. S. Lee(2016) A study on the order of priority of evaluation․monitoring measures in urban regeneration projects: Focused on 13 priority areas for urban regeneration. Journal of Urban Policies 7(1): 5-22.
29 Martila. J. A. and J. C. James(1977) Importance-performance analysis. Journal of Marketing 41(1): 77-79.   DOI
30 McCarthy, J. and G. Lloyd(2007) Partnership, Collaborative Planning and Urban Regeneration. Urban and Regional Planning and Development Series. Hampshire: Ashgate Pub Ltd.
31 Park, K. O, J. M. An, Y. B. Lee and A. Y. Cha(2016) Sustainable regeneration ways of the deteriorated downtown residential area: Focused on ‘Mural Village’, Suamgol in Cheongju. Journal of Human Ecology 20(2): 91-101.   DOI
32 Sang, N. K.(2010) Toward a Collaborative Implementation Model for Urban Regeneration in Seoul: With special reference to Se-Woon District. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of Seoul, Korea.
33 Saaty, T. L.(1977) A theory of analytical hierarchies applied to political candidacy. Behavioral Science 22(4): 237-246.   DOI
34 Saaty, T. L.(1980) The Analytic Hierarchy Process. McGraw-Hill, New York.
35 Saaty, T. L.(2003) Decision-making with the AHP: Why is the principal eigenvector necessary. European Journal of Operational Research 145(4): 85-91.   DOI
36 Tchah, C. Y. and K. R. Lim(2011) Public Architecture and Public Space Utilization towards Urban Regeneration of Small and Mediumsized cities. Sejong: Architecture & Urban Research Institute.
37 Shin, E. J., C. G. Yoo and S. J. Cho(2015) A study on local residents' evaluation of the planned indicator value for urban regeneration: Targeting local residents in Mokpo. Journal of the Korean Housing Association 26(6): 71-81.   DOI
38 Shin, H. J. and M. G. Kang(2017) Level of community participation in urban regeneration: Focusing on Haebangchon case, Yongsan-gu, Seoul. Journal of The Korean Regional Development Association 29(3): 25-46.
39 Suh, J. H., H. S. Yang(2004) A study on framing techniques of landscape assessment using the analytic hierarchy process: The assessment on the landscape control points. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 32(4): 94-104.
40 Won, J. H. and H. S. Kim(2012) Factors affecting the evaluation of the resident-participatory community design: Focused on the residents’ perception about ‘the pilot project of human town in Seoul’. Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea 13(6): 55-68.
41 www.law.go.kr
42 www.naver.com
43 www.seoguurc.or.kr
44 Bae, W. K. and H. Y. Lee(2014) Effectiveness analysis on the lowrise housing regeneration program(before 'human town') in Seoul, Korea: Focused on the first pilot project area of Yeonnam-dong, Mapo-gu, Seoul, Korea. Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea Urban Design 15(4): 223-238.
45 Ahn, J. G., H. C. Jeong, T. J. Kim and J. H. Lee(2014) A study on the planning factors and residents satisfaction of urban regeneration in large cities. Journal of Korea Planning Association 49(3): 211-226.
46 Ahn, J. S.(2014) Regeneration of Urban Village through Using Shared Space: Focusing on Sansae-Village, Eunpyeong-gu, Seoul. MS Dissertation, Seoul National University, Korea.
47 An, J. S.(2011) Developing Evaluation Criteria for Historic Gardens Preservation Condition by Applying Delphi Technique and Analytic Hierarchy Process. Ph.D. Dissertation. Sungkyunkwan University, Korea.