Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2019.47.6.045

Comparison of The Importance of Evaluation Items for Landscape Performance and Sustainability Using Analytic Network Process (ANP)  

Ryu, Myeung-Ji (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, Graduate School, Kyungpook National University)
Lee, Hyung-Sook (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, Kyungpook National University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture / v.47, no.6, 2019 , pp. 45-52 More about this Journal
Abstract
As international criteria and standards are required in the fields of design and construction, landscape performance must also be considered not only for the value of the landscape but also for providing quality assurance and sustainability. Given the lack of research on landscape performance, the present research was purposed to analyze the importance of potential assessment categories and items using an analytical network process. A list of assessment items, which is composed of 20 items and 6 categories, was derived through a literature review and a preliminary survey of 11 landscape professionals. An ANP model was established and a survey was conducted among 30 landscape practitioners to determine the weight of priorities considering the criteria. The results of ANP showed that the categories of site selection, preservation and health, and convenience had high priorities while materials had the lowest importance score. For the assessment items, a monitoring plan was the highest importance, followed by cultural/ historic preservation, management cost reduction, and natural ground areas. Despite the difficulties in quantifying landscape achievements, most respondents agreed that there needs to be an evaluation system for landscape performance in order to assure the quality and sustainability of landscape development. More research and discussion are needed to develop an assessment system for landscape performance that is applicable to Korean context.
Keywords
Performance-Based Design Method; International Standardization; Sustainable Sites Initiative; Multi-Criteria Decision Making;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Choi, Y. (2013) Analyzing weights of certification assessment criteria on the g-seed system using the ahp method -Focused on certification standards for apartment buildings. KIEAE Journal 13(6): 113-120.   DOI
2 Choi, Y., B. H. Song and B. Y. Yang(2007) A study on the improvement and application of environmentally-friendly factors at outdoor spaces in apartment complexes. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 35(3): 37-49.
3 Global Procurement Assistance(2016) Protocol Amending the Agreement on Government Procurement.
4 Han, C. K.(2018) Needs for performance centered quality standard. Construction Economy News.
5 Hirst, J.(2008) Functional Landscapes:Assessing Elements of Seattle Green Factor. The Berger Partnership.
6 Kim, J. H. and S. H. Kim(2017) Evaluation scheme for ecomobility policy based on multi-criteria decision making. AHP and ANP, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation 35(3): 183-196.
7 Jang, D. H., H. S. Kim and T. H. Kim(2012) A study on the supplementation of the biotop area ratio by case study of outdoor environmental planning indicators. Journal of the KIEAE 12(1): 3-10.
8 Jung, Y. J. and K. H. Lee(2017) A development of evaluation criteria for selection of revitalization areas for urban regeneration through ANP. Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial Cooperation Society, 18(1): 115-123.   DOI
9 Kim, H. Y.(2015) A Study on Development Evaluation Model of Outdoor Space for Remodeling Apartment, Master Thesis of University of Seoul.
10 Kim, M. S.(2007) Preparatory applications for performance-based regulatory system in Japanese landscape architecture related field, Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 35(5): 37-45.
11 Kim, T. H., T. H. Kim, K. S. Jung, J. H. Ku and J. M. Won(2009) A development and application of evaluation criteria for pedestrian quality of service using analytic network process. Korea Planning Association 44(1): 211-222.
12 Kim, Y. J., S. J. Hong and K. H. Ahn(2011) A study on the revitalization of old city centers of small and medium sized cities through analytic network process. Journal of the Korean Urban Management Association 24(3): 89-108.
13 Kwon, S. A.(2012) Standardization of construction specifications and design criteria based on performance. Korea Institute of Construction Technology.
14 Ministry of Foreign Affairs(2001) Agreement on technical barriers to trade. http://www.mofa.go.kr/www/brd/m_3893/
15 LaClergue, D.(2013) Seattle Green Factor: Improving livability and ecological function through landscaping standards.
16 Landscape Architecture Foundation(2018) Evaluating Landscape Performance: A Guidebook for Metrics and Methods Selection.
17 Lee, H. S.(2014) Assessment items of outdoor environment through analysis of SITES-Focused on the comparison with G-SEED and LEED. KIEAE Journal 14(4): 11-18.   DOI
18 Lee, H. S.(2016) A study on sustainable outdoor design strategies and assessment system through analysis of SITES certified projects. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 44(3): 56-64.   DOI
19 Lim, S. N. and J. H. Lee(2006) A study on development of the friendly environment valuation indicator for the exterior space of complex. Housing Studies Review 14(2): 195-220.
20 Na, C. H.(2012) Needs of Performance Standards in Landscape Architecture. Lafent.
21 Nam, H. R. and B. Y. Lee(2016). Research on the well-being-centric green building certification. KIEAE Journal 16(6): 29-38.   DOI
22 Roh, T. I., S. H. Kim, S. W. Ji, S. K. Chio and C. H. Seo(2009) A fundamental study on the standardization of performance-based building codes focused building materials. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea 25(3): 77-84.
23 Saaty, T. L.(2008) Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process. International Journal of Services Sciences 1(1): 83-98.   DOI
24 Seong, S. T., S. Yu and S. Yang(2012) Open space design for certificated green apartment housing. Urban Design 13(3): 83-92.
25 City of Helsinki Environment Centre. www.integratedstormwater.eu
26 Sun, T. K.(2019) In needs of an integrated system for landscape management and performance standardization. Korean Construction News. 2019. 07. 29.
27 Yoon, S. M., T. I. Roh, S. H. Kim, S. W. Ji, S. K. Choi and C. H. Seo(2009) A fundamental study for the establishment of performance based systematic method for selecting building materials. Conference Proceeding of the Architectural Institute of Korea 28(1): 487-490.
28 Yu, C. K., K. Byun and S. Cho(2014) Defining a village-focused green index and evaluating value structures using AHP. Journal of the Regional Association of Architectural Institute 16(1): 41-48.
29 Landscape Architecture Foundation. www.landscapeperformance.org
30 Sustainable Sites Initiative. www.sustainablesites.org