Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2013.41.6.062

An Importance Analysis on the Problem of Design Competition of Landscape Architecture  

Lee, Joo-Hee (Dept. of Urban Design and Landscape Architecture, Graduate School of Urban Studies, Hanyang University)
Cho, Se-Hwan (Dept. of Urban Design and Landscape Architecture, Graduate School of Urban Studies, Hanyang University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture / v.41, no.6, 2013 , pp. 62-71 More about this Journal
Abstract
This study is conducted for the purpose of analyzing and contemplating the problems with the competition in current landscape design, with the goal of improving the landscape design competition system by using the AHP technique. The result of this study, first describe the Landscape design competition system that formed the problems and show the most important problem followed by other problems shown in order of importance, which are 'design changes after winning', 'Guidelines for design competition' and 'Landscape design competition manner'. Secondly, in the low rank article make up the level one -From a total 12 elements from the low rank article corresponding in 'process of winner selection' the 'Unprofessional landscape participate the screening' collected comments for the biggest problem, 'lack of expertise in judgement', 'problems with the examination scoring system' and other articles, the corresponding in 'process of winner selection' appears at the highest ranks. It also happens that after making the choice in the landscape design competition, the importance of 'client's design change symptoms' appears high. As a result the overlooked details of the landscape design competition's problems were analyzed. This study has prioritized the problems by problems which landscape design competition institutions most frequently have. Based on this ranking, there is significance purpose to create proactive system improvements in the future. By analyzing these problems, we will be better able to develop improvements to the future system.
Keywords
Process of Winner Selection; Guidelines of Competition; Professionalism of the Judges; Screening Method; Design Changes Randomly; AHP Method;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Environment & Landscape Architecture(2013) Expert Forum: Strategies for the Growth and Development of Landscape Design Competition. Paju: Environment & Landscape Architecture No.307: 100-109.
2 Hong, Y. S.(2011) A comparative study of landscape design competitions's guidelines and entry plans. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 39(2): 18-28.
3 Jeong, Y. J.(2010) A Study on the Improvement of Landscape Design Competition of New Town. Master's thesis of Seoul National University, Seoul.
4 Kim, A. Y., M. J. Koh and H. S. Oh(2006) Re-reading Chuncheon G5 international design competition from a viewpoint of landscape urbanism. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 43(3): 120-138.
5 Kim, K. S. and S. W. Kang(2008) An analysis on the factor for the economic cooperation in the yellow-sea region using AHP. Journal of Korea Distribution Management 11(4): 133-149.
6 Lee, J. H. and S. H. Cho(2013) An analysis on the problems of design competition process of landscape architecture by the Delphi analysis method. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 41(3): 83-93.
7 Lim, E. S.(2006) Determining the situation of selecting a reasonably. Planning and Policy 294: 128-135.
8 Pae, J. H.(2002) Downsview park international design competition and its implications = New strategies for contemporary landscape design. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 29(6): 62-71.
9 Saaty, T. L.(1977) A scaling method for priorities in hierarchial structures. Journal of Mathematical Psychology 15(1): 234-281.   DOI
10 Suh, J. H. and H. S. Yang(2004) A study on framing techniques of landscape assessment using the analytic hierarchy process. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 32(4): 94-104.