Browse > Article

The Assessment of the Landscape Planning Phases by Importance-Performance Analysis - Focused on the Landscape Planning of Development Sites -  

Joo, Shin-Ha (Division of Environment and Life Science, Seoul Women's University)
Baek, Woon-Hae (Korea National Housing Corporation)
Shin, Ji-Hoon (Landscape and Ecological Design Institute, Group HAN Associate)
Mok, Jeong-Hun (Dept. of Architecture, Sejong University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture / v.36, no.4, 2008 , pp. 74-82 More about this Journal
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to reflect on the results of the assessment and analysis of landscape planning projects according to planning phases in a landscape planning system based on landscape law. An assessment of the importance and performance of landscape planning elements by planning phases was studied by statistically descriptive analysis, variation analysis, statistical t-test and importance-performance analysis. As a result of the evaluation, the performance of existing landscape planning projects is 3.813 and the importance of planning elements is 5.648. This means that in spite of the importance of landscape planning elements, the performance of existing landscape planning projects is not sufficient to cover the importance of landscape planning elements. In addition, 'site landscape survey' and 'landscape design guideline' sections are not sufficient when they are compared to 'landscape concept plan' and 'landscape basic plan' to complete the landscape planning projects required by landscape law. It means also that the landscape survey and landscape design guidelines should be complementarily practiced in order to increase the effectiveness of landscape planning projects. As the research is practiced by survey methods on landscape planning projects which are only new development sites, the results cannot represent all types of landscape planning projects. Nevertheless, the results can be applied to new landscape planning at new development sites or old cities to increase effectiveness.
Keywords
Landscape Law; Landscape Planning Process; Importance; New Development Site; Landscape Design Guidelines;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 1  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 건설교통부(2004) 신도시 경관계획기준 마련을 위한 연구
2 국토도시연구원(2006) 생태환경계획 및 경관계획 수립 지표에 관한 연구
3 국토연구원(2003) 도시경관개선을 위한 용도지역별 경관계획 기준 연구
4 건설교통부(2007) 경관계획 수립방향 및 기준마련을 위한 연구
5 Martilla, J. A., and J. C. James(1977) Importance-performance analysis. Journal of Marketing 41(1): 77-79   DOI   ScienceOn
6 Im, Hyun-Jung(2005) Modified importance-performance analysis: An application to festival study. Journal of Tourism and Leisure Research 17(2): 117-136
7 대한주택공사(2006) 경관법 제정을 위한 연구
8 서현철, 송은주, 이상돈(2003) 자연휴양림 이용객들의 이용 후 평가에 관한 연구 -중요도-성취도(IPA) 기법을 중심으로-. 문화관광연구 5(2): 169-188
9 공기열(2006) IPA기법을 이용한 여가활동 평가. 관광연구 20(3): 285- 303
10 임화순, 고계성(2006) 관광목적지 매력속성에 따른 중요도-성취도 연구 -일본 오끼나와 중심으로-. 관광연구 21(1): 177-190
11 이시영, 허준(2004) 도시근린공원의 추구편익에 의한 중요-성취도 분석 -대전광역시 근린공원을 대상으로-. 한국조경학회지 32(3): 114-125