Browse > Article

A Critical Examination of Public Sphere Communication in the Decision-making Process in Relation to Seoul City Hall Plaza  

Kim Yun-Geum (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, Graduate School, The University of Seoul)
Lee Kyu-Mok (School of Architecture, Urban Planning, and Landscape Architecture, The University of Seoul)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture / v.32, no.5, 2004 , pp. 11-22 More about this Journal
Abstract
A few years ago, many people proposed that a plaza be added to Seoul City Hall. The proposal, however, did not materialize because of traffic confusion. The June 2002 World Cup cheering in front of Seoul City Hall has prodded the public to reconsider the plaza. Even though the exercise failed to gain support, many democratic procedures, opening a Web page and design competitions, and so on were attempted while the design and management of Seoul City Hall Plaza was being deliberated. In the future, the need for proper communication and democratic procedures in the process of making decisions regarding public spaces is expected to increase because of the strengthening of the requirement of participatory and deliberative democracy. An examination of the nature and extent of the communication that has been carried out in relation to the plan to add a plaza to Seoul City Hall will be very helpful in gathering feedback to guide decision-making in regards to the use of other public spaces. Thus, this study has a three-fold purpose. : (1) to examine the theories that may justify the need for public input in relation to decisions made regarding the use of public spaces, and to propose the criteria to be used for the methods of communication (2) to examine the contents and conflicts of communication in relation to the decision made regarding the design and management of Seoul City Hall Plaza and (3) to examine the potential distortion of that communication by analyzing the communication according to the criteria previously proposed. The study method that is used herein is the analysis of articles about the subject matter, which have been posted on the Seoul City Hall Plaza Website and which have been published in newspapers such as the Chosun ilbo, Donga ilbo, the Jungang ilbo, and the Hankyoreh. Diverse article contents are also discussed. As result, there are many differences in the contents and viewpoints of the newspapers that are included in this study. In addition, the related Internet bulletin board has not been used actively, but has contributed to forming public opinion on this issue. Finally, the public demanded to be given acceptable reasons for the results of the design competition, and for the decision to make the grass plaza, which ignores the chosen design in the newspapers or on the Web page. However, their demand was rejected. The communication therefore became distorted and consequently did not become successful in bringing about its intended result.
Keywords
Seoul City Hall Plaza; Public Sphere; Public Space; Communication;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 이상헌(2004) 도시 공공공간으로서의 광장. 환경과 조경 7월호:140-143   PUBMED
2 Habermas, J.(1981a) Modernity Versus Postmodernity, NewGerman Critique 22, Winter: 3-14
3 Habermas, J.(1981b) Kleine politische Schriften(1-4). Suhrkamp Verlag
4 Mitchael, D., and R. V. Deusen(2001) Downsview Park:Open Space of Public Space?, in Downsview Park Toronto,ed. Julia Czeniak. New York: PRESTEL, pp.102-115
5 최갑수(2001) 서양에서 공공성과 공공영역. 제 44회 전국역사학대회 발표요지, pp.17-37
6 Austin, J.(1965) How to Do Things With Words, NewYork: Oxford University Press
7 http://www.seoul.go.kr
8 김연금(2004) 소통적 조경계최 및 설계에 관한 연구, 서울시립대학교 조경학과 박사학위논문
9 Habermas, J.(1962) Struckturwandel der $\ddot{o}$ffentlichkeit : Untersuchungen zu einer Kategorie der B$\ddot{u}rgerlichen Gesellschaft, 한승완(역), 공론장의 구조변동, 서울: 나남출판, 1990
10 Foucault, M.(1983) The Subject and Power, in H. Dreyfusand P. Rabinow. eds., Michel Foucault: Beyond Struc-turalism and Hermeneutics. Second Edition. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press
11 배정한(1998) 조경이론으로서의 환경미학. 한국조경학회지25(4): 89-106   과학기술학회마을
12 Forester, J.(1988) Critical Theory and Planning Practice, in John Forester. ed., Chtical Theory and Public Life. Massachusetts: The MIT Press, PP.202-230
13 황기원(2004) 좋은 시작. 거친 과정. 나쁜 결과, 도시연대기관지 걷고싶은 도시 5 . 6월호: 10-13
14 김재현(2000) 하버마스의 사상의 혈성과 발전(장춘익 외. '하버마스의 사상'). 서울: 나남출판, pp. 1-33
15 http://www.dosi.or.kr
16 Forester, J.(2001) The Deliberative Practitioner, Massa-chusetts: The MIT Press
17 시사저널(2003) 언론/밤엔 KBS. 낮엔 조선일보 731: 55-56