Browse > Article

A Study on Landscape Architecture Planning and Design as Communicative Action  

김연금 (서울시립대학교 대학원 조경학과)
이규목 (서울시립대학교 도시과학대 건축도시조경학부)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture / v.31, no.5, 2003 , pp. 73-85 More about this Journal
Abstract
With more and more people paying attention to substantial democracy, participatory democracy is presented as a practical strategy and an index of Korean democracy. In this social and political atmosphere, participation in environmental planning and design is essential. Nonetheless, the true meaning of “participation” is not used properly because many people do not understand it correctly, The concept of social and political participation is “the action or attempt of ordinary members of society for affecting on the result of decision making.” Based on this concept, participation is accomplished through conventional means and as a form of mobilization in environmental planning and desist Most of the theories on public participation in landscape architecture are technical theories. Therefore, this paper proposes that planning and design of landscape architecture be understood as a communicative action that aims to enable stakeholders to reach a consensus through communication. This study offers the framework of theory to understand and practice planning and design of landscape architecture as a communicative action, after reviewing communicative action theory and communicative planning theory. Results suggest that communicative action theory should be accepted in landscape architecture to overcome the shortcomings of instrumental rationality -- the same way planning theory accepted this theory --and to join the culture of experts focusing on the artistic truth and the culture of life of the world. In addition, accepting communicative action theory enables the acquisition of the instrumental effect and social learning effect and the making of social capital. This study also suggested prerequisite for using the method. There should be change in the social institution and in individual action. In addition the method is composed of three steps: creating the atmosphere for communication; communicating, and; reaching a consensus among stakeholders. Finally, raising the possibility of applying the theory presented in this study requires the accumulation of know-how through trial and error.
Keywords
Participatory Design; Communicative Action; Communicative Planning Theory; Landscape Architecture;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 /
[ 문화연대 ] / 문화도시 서울 어떻게 만들 것인가
2 /
[ Agris,C.;D.Schon ] / Theory in Practice
3 우리시대의 설계언어: 프랑스(15) - 피에르 도나디유. 경관의 창조적인 보전을 위하여 /
[ 박정욱 ] / 환경과 조경
4 Modern and Postmodern Architecture /
[ Harbermas.J. ] / In the svddeutdche Seitung of 5-6 December
5 /
[] / Reconstructing the Environment Reconnecting People, Rebuilding Families
6 /
[ Forester;John ] / The Deliberative Practitioner
7 /
[ Tumer;Jonathan,H.;정태환 (외 역) ] / The Structure of Sociological Theory;현대 사회학 이론
8 /
[ Fischer ] / Citizens, Experts, and the Environment
9 하버마스의 토의적 민주주의 이론 연구: 민주주의에 대한 규범적이고 사회학적인 연구 /
[ 강병호 ] / 서울대학교 철학과 석사학위 논문
10 /
[ 김찬호 ] / 도시는 미디어
11 /
[ Harbermas,J. ] / Die Neue Unvbersichtlichkeit
12 Communicative Planning theory /
[ Sager;Tore ] / Brook-field USA:Avebury
13 Architecture and Societal Values: Evidence from the Literature /
[ Kapper;Chenoweth ] / Landscape journal   DOI
14 프레데릭 로 옴스테드의 도시공원관에 대한 재해석 /
[ 조경진 ] / 한국조경학회지   과학기술학회마을
15 Participation and community at the landscape scale /
[ Jones,Stanton ] / Landscape Journal   DOI
16 /
[ 한국일보 ] /
17 The Humane City /
[ Short;JohnR. ] / 인간의 도시
18 Consensus Building and Complex Adaptive Systmes /
[ Innes;Judith;David E.Booher ] / Journal of American Planning Association   DOI   ScienceOn
19 /
[ 김만흠 ] / 지방자치와 참여민주주의 (참여사회연구소 편, "참여와 한국 사회")
20 /
[ Hester,R.T ] / Juror Comment: What Makes Participation Exemplary?, in places
21 Ecology, community and delight sources of values in landscape architecture /
[ Thompson;Ian,H. ] / London: E & FN Spon
22 주민 참여를 통한 도시 소공원 설계 및 조성 /
[ 김영모 ] / 한국조경학회지   과학기술학회마을
23 /
[ Harbermas,J.;서규환 (외 역) ] / Theorie des Kommunikativen Handelns;소통행위 이론
24 /
[ 이규목 ] / 한국의 도시 경관
25 Communicating Landscape Architecture /
[ Sommerville;Shiona,L. ] / A thesis presented to the faculty of Graduate studies of The University of Guelph
26 지방자치와 지역발전의 연계 /
[ 소지광 ] / 서울대학교 환경대학원 2002년 21세기 국가발전과 국토 환경에 대한 세미나 자료집
27 The geography of planning practice /
[ Forester;John ] / Environment and Planning D: Society and Space   DOI
28 Groundwork at 21 /
[ Duxbury ] / Landscape Desing
29 계획이론에 있어 새로운 패러다임의 모색 /
[ 이수장 ] / 지방행정연구
30 Wessen Landscahft planen wir? /
[ Luz,F.;U.Weiland ] / in Naturschutz und landschaftsplanung
31 /
[ Jory,J. ] / Modern Landscape Architecture: Redefining the Garden
32 일본의 주민참가와 마치즈쿠리 /
[ 최선주 ] / 시민교통 창간 준비
33 /
[ 김대환 ] / 참여의 철학과 참여민주주의 (참여사회연구소편 "참여와 한국 사회")
34 The Prosperous Community /
[ Putnam;Robert ] / The American Prospect
35 /
[ Sanoff;Henry ] / Community participation methods in design and planning
36 /
[ Schon,D. ] / The Reflective Practitioner
37 점증적 계획이론의 과제 /
[ 김영모 ] / 대한부동산학회
38 Using visualization techniques for enhancing public participation in planning and design: process, implementation, and evaluation /
[ Al-Kodmany ] / Landscape & Planning   DOI   ScienceOn
39 /
[ 미후네야스미치;도시및마을만들기연구체 ] / 커뮤니티를 위한 도시계획 및 설계
40 Co-op Consolidation /
[ Wates,N. ] / The Architectural Review
41 Knowledge and Public Policy /
[ Innes;Judith ] / journal of the American Planning Association   DOI   ScienceOn
42 /
[ 김재현 ] / 하버마스 사상의 형성과 발전 (김재현 등, "하버마스의 사상")