Browse > Article

A New Approach to the Science Education Assessment Using Partial Credits to Different Science Inquiry Problem Solving Process Types  

Lee, Hang-Ro (Taejon Metropolitan West District Office Of Education)
Lim, Cheong-Hwan (Department of Science Education, Taegu National University of Education)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean earth science society / v.23, no.2, 2002 , pp. 147-153 More about this Journal
Abstract
Reasonable and reliable assessment method is one of the most important issues in science education, Partial credits method is an effective tool for assessing students' science inquiry problem solving. The purposes of this study were to classify the Problem solving types based on the analysis of the thinking Process, and how much the related science concept and the science process skills were used in solving science inquiry problems, and to describe the possibility and rationality of the assessment method that gives partial credit 128 high school seniors were selected and their answers were analyzed to identify science concepts they used to solve each problem, and the result was used as the criterion in the scientific concept test development. Also, to study the science inquiry problem solving type, 152 high school seniors were selected, and protocols were made from audio-taped data of their problem solving process through a think-aloud method and retrospective interviews. In order to get a raw data needed in statistical comparison of reliability, discrimination and the difficulty of the test and the production of the regression equation that determines the ratio of partial credit, 640 students were selected and they were given a science inquiry problem test, a science process skills test, and a scientific concept test. Research result suggested it is more reasonable and reliable to switch to the assessment method that applies partial credit to different problem solving types based on the analysis of the thinking process in problem solving process, instead of the dichotomous credit method.
Keywords
science inquiry problem; science concept; science process skills; thinking process; think-aloud; protocol; partial credit; dichotomous credit method; reliability; discrimination; difficulty;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 An investigation of procedures for computerized adaptive testing using partial credit scoring /
[ Koch, W.R.;Dodd, B.G. ] / Applied Measurement in Education   DOI
2 Development of the perfromance of process skills (POPS) /
[ Matthesis, F.E.;Nakayama, G.;Pottenger, F.M.;Jones, M.L. ] / Test for middle grades students
3 The development of a test to measure performance of elementary education majors on the American Association for the Advancement of Science's integrated process skills of science (Doctoral Dissertation, The University of Connecticut) /
[ Burns, S.F. ] / Dissertation Abstracts International
4 A test of the integrated science process skills for secondary science students /
[ Dillashaw, G.H.;Okey, J.R. ] / Science Education
5 A research methodology for studying how people thinks /
[ Larkin, J.H.;Rainard, B. ] / Journal of Research in Science Teaching   DOI
6 /
[ Ludeman, R.R. ] / Development of the science processes test
7 An alternative of Piagetian psychology for science and mathematics education /
[ Novak, J.D. ] / Science Education   DOI
8 Development of an integrated process skills test /
[ Burns, F.E.;Okey, J.R.;Wise, K.C. ] / Journal of Research in Science Teaching   DOI
9 /
[ Lee, H.R. ] / The Influence of Science Process Skills and Concepts Understanding on the Earth Science Problem Solving in College Scholastic Ability Test
10 /
[ Ausubel, D.P.;Novak, J.D.;Hanesman, H. ] / Educational Psychology: A Cognitive View(2nd ed.)
11 /
[ Hopkin, K.D.;Stanley, J.C.;Hopkins, B.R. ] / Educational and psychological measurement and evaluation(7th ed.)
12 The development of the test of science processes /
[ Tannenbaum, R.S. ] / Journal of Research in Science Teaching   DOI
13 Expert and novice earth and space science teacher's declarative, procedural and structural knowledge /
[ Barba, R.H.;Rubba, P.A. ] / International Journal of Science Education
14 The analysis of partial credit scoring /
[ Master, G.N. ] / Applied Measurement in Education   DOI   ScienceOn
15 The development of a science process assessment for fourth-grade students /
[ Smith, K.A.;Welliver ] / Journal of Research in Science Teaching   DOI
16 The reality of general cognition operation /
[ Lawson, A.E. ] / Science Education   DOI
17 A method for studying differential distractor functioning /
[ Green, B.F.;Crone, C.R.;Folk, V.G. ] / Journal of Educational Measurement   DOI   ScienceOn
18 Extension of the partial credit model /
[ Glass, C.A.;Verhelst, N.D. ] / Psychometrika   DOI
19 Development of a test of science process skills /
[ Moliter, L.L.;George, K.D. ] / Journal of Research in Science Teaching   DOI
20 /
[ Mayer, R.E. ] / Thinking, problem solving, cognition