Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5012/jkcs.2021.65.5.358

Analysis of Textbooks of Chemistry I, II and Survey of Chemistry Education Major Pre-service Teachers' Perception Related to the Electron Transfer Model  

Ryu, Eun-Ju (Department of Chemistry Education, Korea National University of Education)
Jeon, Eun-Sun (Changhyun High School)
Paik, Seoung-Hey (Department of Chemistry Education, Korea National University of Education)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Chemical Society / v.65, no.5, 2021 , pp. 358-369 More about this Journal
Abstract
In this study, the contents of the electron transfer model presented in the 4 chemistry I and the 4 chemistry II textbooks of 2009 revised curriculum and 9 chemistry I textbooks and 6 chemistry II textbooks of 2015 revised curriculum were analyzed in the viewpoint of model's Ignorance. In addition, 3 questions were developed to find out whether 24 pre-service teachers were perceived of the Ignorance of the electron transfer model. As a result, Most textbooks explain the redox reaction of covalent bond substances, which is an inconsistent context of the electron transfer model, with mixing oxidation number change and electron transfer or with electron transfer. In addition, the change to the development and use of the model emphasized in the 2015 revised curriculum was not clearly revealed in the curriculum comparison. Most pre-service teachers incompletely perceived or did not perceive Ignorance of the electron transfer model. Only 1 pre-service teacher perceived Ignorance of the model. In conclusion, the textbook description needs to be improved so that Ignorance of the model is revealed when the textbook describes the inconsistent situation of the electron transfer model. And through the education for pre-service teachers, it is necessary to provide an opportunity for pre-service teachers to perceive Ignorance of the electron transfer model.
Keywords
Ignorance of model; Electron transfer model; 2009 Revised Curriculum; 2015 Revised Curriculum; Chemistry I textbooks; Chemistry II textbooks;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 VanderWerf, C. A.; Davidson, A. W.; Sisler, H. H. Journal of Chemical Education 1945, 22, 450.   DOI
2 Kim, S. K.; Choi, H.; Park, C. Y.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2019, 63, 56.   DOI
3 Schwarz, C. V.; Reiser, B. J.; Davis, E. A.; Kenyon, L.; Acher, A Fortus, D.; Shwartz, Y.; Hug, B.; Krajcik, J. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 2009, 46, 632.   DOI
4 Firestein, S. Ignorance: How It Drives Science; Oxford University Press: USA, 2012.
5 Schwarz, C. V.; White B. Y. Cognition and Instruction 2005, 23, 165.   DOI
6 Cartwright, N. The Dappled World: A Study of the Boundaries of Science: Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 1999.
7 Chang, H. S. Is Water H2O?:Evidence, Realism and Pluralism; Springer Science & Business Media: London, 2012.
8 Firestein, S. Failure:Why Science Is So Successful; Oxford University Press: USA, 2015.
9 Wimsatt, W. C. Re-engineering Philosophy for Limited Beings: Piecewise Approximations to Reality; Harvard University Press: Cambridge, 2007.
10 Thomson, J. J. Philosophical Magazine 1904, 7, 237.   DOI
11 Stieglitz, J. The Elements of Qualitative Chemical Analysis; The Century Company: New York, 1911.
12 Ryu, E. J.; Paik, S. H. Journal of The Korean Society 2021, 65, 37.
13 Kang, N. H. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2017, 37, 143.   DOI
14 Lockwood, K. L. Journal of Chemical Education 1961, 38, 326.   DOI
15 Garnett, P. G.; Garnett, P. J.; Hackling, M. W. Studies in Science Education 1995, 25, 69.   DOI
16 Woolf, A. A. Journal of Chemical Education 1988, 65, 45.   DOI
17 Carr, M. Research in Science Education 1984, 14, 97.   DOI
18 Li, D. S.; Kim, Y. C. The Journal of Educational Research 2014, 12, 159.   DOI
19 Thagard, P. The Cognitive Science of Science: Explanation, Discovery and Conceptual Change; MIT Press: Cambridge, 2012.
20 Brown, M. J. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 2009, 40, 213.   DOI
21 Landa, I.; Westbroek, H.; Janssen, F.; van Muijlwijk, J.; Meeter, M. Science and Education 2020, 29, 1361.   DOI
22 Goodstein, M. P. Journal of Chemical Education 1970, 47, 452.   DOI
23 Sisler, H. H.; VanderWerf, C. A. Journal of Chemical Education 1980, 57, 42.   DOI
24 Lewis, G. N. Journal of the American Chemical Society 1916, 38, 762.   DOI
25 Kauffman, J. M. Journal of Chemical Education 1986, 63, 474.   DOI
26 Anselme, J.-P. Journal of Chemical Education 1997, 74, 69.   DOI
27 De Jong, O.; Acampo, J.; Verdonk, A. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 1995, 32, 1097.   DOI
28 Garnett, P. J.; Treagust, D. F. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 1992, 29, 121.   DOI
29 Gilbert, J. K. International Journal of Science Education 2006, 28, 957.   DOI
30 Osterlund, L. L.; Berg, A.; Ekborg, M. Chemistry Education Research and Practice 2010, 11, 182.   DOI
31 Uhm, J. H.; Kim, H. B. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2020, 40, 543.   DOI
32 Edwards, J. Research in Science Education 1990, 20, 66.   DOI
33 Kim, K. H.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2017, 61, 204.   DOI
34 Schmidt, H. J.; Volke, D. International Journal of Science Education 2003, 25, 1409.   DOI
35 Ryu, E. J.; Paik, S. H. Journal of The Korean Society 2020, 64, 175.
36 Gobert, D.; Palant, A. Journal of Science Education and Technology 2004, 13, 7.   DOI
37 Schmit, A.; Pollard J. WJEC GCSE Chemistry; Hodder Education Group: London, 2016.
38 Chang, H. S.; Duncan, K.; Kim, K. H.; Paik, S. H. Chemistry Education Research and Practice 2020, 21, 806.   DOI
39 Creswell, J. W. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Chosing Among Five Aproaches, 2nd ed.; Hakgisa: Seoul, 2013.
40 Cho, H. S.; Nam, J. H. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2017, 37, 539.   DOI
41 Passmore, C.; Gouvea, J. S.; Giere, R. Philosophy and Science Teaching; Springer: Dordrecht, 2014.
42 Ryu, E. J. The Implications of Perceiving about Ignorance of the Acid-base Models in Science Education. Ph.D. Korea National University of Education, 2021.
43 Silverstein, T. P. Journal of Chemical Education 2011, 88, 279.   DOI
44 Kim, S. K.; Park, C. Y.; Choi, H.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2019, 62, 226.   DOI
45 Paik, S. H.; Kim, S. K.; Kim, K. H. Journal of Chemical Education 2017, 94, 563.   DOI
46 Paik, S. H. Journal of Chemical Education 2015, 92, 1484.   DOI
47 Ryu, E. J.; Paik, S. H. Journal of The Korean Society 2020, 65, 267.
48 Kerwin, A. Knowledge 1993, 15, 166.   DOI
49 Smithson, M. Research Article 1993, 15, 133.
50 Gogolin, S.; Kruger, D. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 2018, 55, 1313.   DOI
51 Giere, R. N. Scientific Perspectivism; University of Chicago Press: Chicago, 2010.