Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5012/jkcs.2020.64.3.175

Analysis of 'Ignorance' in Acid-base Models Contents of Chemistry I and Chemistry II Textbooks & Teacher's Guides in 2009 & 2015 Revised Curriculum  

Lyu, Eun-Ju (Shintanjin High School)
Paik, Seoung-Hey (Department of Chemistry Education, Korea National University of Education)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Chemical Society / v.64, no.3, 2020 , pp. 175-188 More about this Journal
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to analyze chemistry textbooks and teachers' guidebooks from the perspective of 'Ignorance', one of the important features of model. This is because the emphasis is on developing modeling capabilities for students in the 2015 Revised Curriculum. For this, Arrhenius model and Brønsted-Lowry model were selected as acid and base models in neutralization reaction which are important contents in chemistry curriculum. The analysis criteria of this study were extracted by analyzing previous studies and four general chemistry textbooks dealing with 'Ignorance' related to acid and base neutralization reaction. Based on the analysis criteria, we analyzed nine chemistry I textbooks and teacher's guides and six chemistry II textbooks and teacher's guides of the 2015 revised curriculum. In addition, we analyzed contents of four chemistry I textbooks and teacher's guides and three chemistry II textbooks and teacher's guides in the 2009 revised curriculum for comparison according to revised curriculums. We analyzed the contents related to the concept of 'neutralization reaction', 'neutrality', 'quantitative relation of neutralization reaction', 'degree of ionization', and 'ionization constant'. Based on the results of this study, we proposed a way to present 'Ignorance' of the models in teachers' guidebooks that chemistry teachers can understand 'Ignorance' of model and teach modeling capabilities for students.
Keywords
Ignorance; Arrhenius model; Bronsted-Lowry model; 2009 Revised Curriculum; 2015 Revised Curriculum; Chemistry I textbook; Chemistry II textbook; teacher's guide; modeling capability;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 15  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 NGSS Lead States. Next Generation Science Standards: For States, By States; The National Academies Press: Washington, DC, 2013; Available at http://www.nextgenscience.org/.
2 Gilbert, J.; Justi, R. Modeling-based Teaching in Science Education; Springer: Switzerland, 2016.
3 Kim, S. K.; Park, C. Y.; Choi, H.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2018, 62, 226.   DOI
4 Oh, P. S.; Oh, S. J. International Journal of Science Education 2011, 3, 109.
5 Cho, H. S.; Nam, J. H. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2017, 37, 539.   DOI
6 Kang, N. H. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2017, 37, 143.   DOI
7 Clement, J. J. International Journal of Science Education 2000, 22, 1041.   DOI
8 Clement, J. J.; Rea-Ramirez, M. A.; Mimez-Oviedo, M. C. An instructional model derived from model construction and criticism theory. In J. J. Clement, M. A.; Rea-Ramirez; Mary, A., Eds., Kluwer Academic: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008, 23.
9 Gobert, J. D.; O'Dwyer, L.; Horwitz, P.; Buckley, B.; Levy, S.; Wilensky, U. International Journal of Science Education 2011, 33, 653.   DOI
10 Justi, R.; Gilbert, J. K. International Journal of Science Education 2011, 25, 1369.   DOI
11 Kim, S. K.; Kim. J. E.; Park, S. H.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Association for Research in Science Education 2019, 39, 457.
12 Buckley, B. C.; Boulter C. J. Investigating the role of representations and expressed models in building mental models. In Developing models in science education, J. K. Gilbert; C. J. Boulter Eds.; Kluwer Academic: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2000, 119.
13 Redish, E. F. American Journal of Physics 1994, 62, 792.   DOI
14 Cho, E. J.; Kim C. J.; Choe, S. U. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2017, 37, 859.   DOI
15 Schwarz, C. V.; Gwekwerere, Y. N. Science Education 2007, 91, 158.   DOI
16 Snow, R. E. International Journal of Educational Research 1990, 14, 455.
17 Gilbert, J. K.; Boulter, C. J.; Rutherford, M. International Journal of Science Education 1998, 20, 83.   DOI
18 Jonassen, D.; Strobel, J.; Gottdenker, J. Interactive Learning Environments 2005, 13, 15.   DOI
19 Schecker, H. P. Physics Education 1993, 28, 102.   DOI
20 Windschitl, M.; Thompson, J.; Braaten, M. Science Education 2008, 92, 941.   DOI
21 Gobert, J. D.; O'Dwyer, L., Horwitz, P.; Buckley, B.; Levy, S.; Wilensky, U. International Journal of Science Education 2011, 33, 653.   DOI
22 Chang, H. S. Is Water H2O?:Evidence, Realism and Pluralism; Springer Science & Business Media: London, 2012.
23 Stuart F. Ignorance: How It Drives Science; Oxford University Press: USA, 2012.
24 Asnat R. Z.; Sharona T. L. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 2019, 56, 881.   DOI
25 Paik, S. H.; Choi, J. I.; Park, E. J. Journal of the Korean Association for Research in Science Education 2013, 33, 1273.   DOI
26 Kim, S. K.; Choi, H,; Park, C. Y.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2019, 63, 56.   DOI
27 Paik, S. H. Journal of chemical education 2015, 92, 1484.   DOI
28 Rea-Ramirez, M. A.; Clement, J.; Nunez-Oviedo, M. C. Model Based Learning and Instruction in Science; Springer: Netherlands, 2008.
29 Park, J. S.; Youn, Y.; Jung, J. O.; Cho, E. M.; Ryu, S. K. Chemistry I; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2011.
30 Ryu, H. I.; Kim, C. S.; Lee, G. P.; Lee, J. B.; Bak, S. B.; Kang, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, H. G. Chemistry I; Visang Press: Seoul, 2011.
31 Noh, T. H.; Choi, S. S.; Kang, S. J.; Lee, S. Y.; Bae, B. I.; Go, S. Y.; Ju, Y.; Choi, S. Y. Chemistry I; Chunjae Press: Seoul, 2011.
32 Kim, H. J.; Kim, H. S.; Lee, B. K.; Lee, S. M.; Lee, Y. S.; Lee, J. H.; Lee, J. S.; Lee, H. N.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry I; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2011.
33 Ryu, H. I.; Kim, C. S.; Lee, G. P.; Lee, J. B.; Bak, S. B.; Kang, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, H. G. Chemistry II; Visang Press: Seoul, 2012.
34 Noh, T. H.; Choi, S. S.; Kang, S. J.; Lee, S. Y.; Bae, B. I.; Go, S. Y.; Ju, Y.; Choi, S. Y. Chemistry II; Chunjae Press: Seoul, 2012.
35 Hong, H. K.; Jeon, H. G.; Lee, B. K.; Kim, M. S.; Seok, D. J.; Sin, I. J.; Kim, H. S. Chemistry I; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2018.
36 Park, J. S.; Youn, Y.; Jung, J. O.; Cho, E. M.; Ryu, S. K. Chemistry II; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2012.
37 Park, J. S.; Park, J. H.; Kang, S. H.; Ryu, S. K.; Sin, D. H.; Lee, S. Y.; Cho, S. Y.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry I; Visang Press: Seoul, 2018.
38 Noh, T. H.; Kang, S. J.; Ju, Y.; Go, S. Y.; Kim, Y. H.; Choi, S. Y.; Yang, C. H. Chemistry I; Seoul: Chunjea: Seoul, 2018.
39 Jang, N. H.; Kang, S. J.; Park, J. B.; Lee, H. I.; Kim, H. C.; Bae, S. W.; Oh, C. J.; Og, J. S.; Lee, J. M.; Lee, H. N. Chemistry I; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2018.
40 Choi, M. H.; Seo, I. H.; Han, M. J.; Jeong, D. Y.; Kim, H. K.; Choi, G. S. Chemistry I; Mirea-n: Seoul, 2018.
41 Lee, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, J. B.; Kim, H. J.; Kang, S. G.; Park, B. K.; Kim, S. H.; Park, H. J. Chemistry I; Jihaksa: Seoul, 2018.
42 Kang, D. H.; Lee, S. M.; Park, G. S.; Choi, J. M. Chemistry I; YBM: Seoul, 2018.
43 Hwang, S. Y.; Jeon, H. Y.; Lee, S. H.; Noh, D. G. Chemistry I; Donga Publisher: Seoul, 2018.
44 Ha, Y. K.; Jeon, S. C.; Bae, B. I.; Noh, K. J.; Kang, S. H.; Kim, J. O. Chemistry I; Kumsung Publisher: Seoul, 2018.
45 Hong, H. K.; Jeon, H. G.; Lee, B. K.; Kim, M. S.; Seok, D. J. Sin, I. J.; Kim, H. S. Chemistry II; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2019.
46 Park, J. S.; Park, J. H.; Kang, S. H.; Ryu, S. K.; Sin, D. H.; Lee, S. Y.; Cho, S. Y.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry II; Visang Press: Seoul, 2019.
47 Roh, T. H.; Kang, S. J.; Ju, Y.; Go, S. Y.; Kim, Y. H.; Choi, S. Y.; Yang, C. H. Chemistry II; Chunjea: Seoul, 2019.
48 Lee, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, J. B.; Kim, H. J.; Kang, S. G.; Park, B. K.; Kim, S. H.; Park, H. J. Chemistry II; Jihaksa: Seoul, 2019.
49 Jang, N. H.; Kang, S. J.; Park, J. B.; Lee, H. I.; Kim, H. C.; Bae, S. W.; Oh, C. J.; Og, J. S.; Lee, J. M.; Lee, H. N. Chemistry II; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2019.
50 Choi, M. H.; Seo, I. H.; Han, M. J.; Jeong, D. Y.; Kim, H. K.; Choi, G. S. Chemistry II; Mirea-n: Seoul, 2019.
51 Hong, H. K.; Jeon, H. G.; Lee, B. K.; Kim, M. S.; Seok, D. J.; Sin, I. J.; Kim, H. S. Chemistry I Teacher's Guide; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2018.
52 Choi, M. H.; Seo, I. H.; Han, M. J.; Jeong, D. Y.; Kim, H. K.; Choi, G. S. Chemistry I Teacher's Guide; Mirea-n: Seoul, 2018.
53 Park, J. S.; Youn, Y.; Jung, J. O.; Cho, E. M.; Ryu, S. K. Chemistry II Teacher's Guide; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2012.
54 Roh, T. H.; Kang, S. J.; Ju, Y.; Go, S. Y.; Kim, Y. H.; Choi, S. Y.; Yang, C. H. Chemistry II Teacher's Guide; Chunjea: Seoul, 2019.
55 Brown, T. L.; LEMay, H. E. Jr.; Bursten, B. E.; Murphy, C. J.; Woodward, P. M. Chemistry: The Central Science 2th ed.; Prentice Hall: USA, 2012.
56 Zumdahl, S. S.; Zumdahl, S. A. Chemistry 8th ed.; Cengage Learning: Singapore, 2010.
57 Mcmurry, J. E. Chemistry 10th ed.; McGraw-Hill: NY, 2010.
58 Oxtoby, D.; Gillis, H. P.; Campion, A. Principles of Modern Chemistry, 7th ed.; Cengage Learning: NY, 2012.
59 Schmidt, H.-J. International Journal of Science Education 1991, 13, 459.   DOI
60 Wobbe, D. V.; Albert, P. Journal of Chemistry Education 2001, 78, 494.   DOI
61 Paik, S. H. The History of Chemistry: imotionmedia: Seoul, 2018.
62 Brubaker Jr. C. Journal of Chemical Education 1957, 34, 325.   DOI
63 Go, H. S.; Kim, K. E.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2012, 56, 628.   DOI
64 Paik, S. H.; Go, H. S.; Jeon, M. C. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2013, 57, 279.   DOI
65 John, H.; Go, M. J. The History of Chemistry; Book's hill: Seoul, 2005.