Browse > Article

Inward Leakage Test for Particulate Filtering Respirators in Korea  

Han Don-Hee (Department of Occupational Health and Safety Engineering, Inje University)
Publication Information
Journal of Environmental Health Sciences / v.30, no.5, 2004 , pp. 432-439 More about this Journal
Abstract
Korean certification regulation for particulate filtering respirators requires inward leakage (IL) test as European Standards (EN) and the standard levels of regulation are the same as those of EN. This study was conducted to evaluate particulate filtering respirators being commercially used in the market by using IL and assess the characteristics of IL. The study began with discussing the concept of IL, comparison of IL with fit test, and IL measurement method. Three brands of half masks and 10 brands of filtering facepieces (two top class, four 1st class and four 2nd class), total 13 brands respirators, and 10 test panels (subjects) who were classified in 9 facial grids in accordance with face length and lip length, were selected for IL test. IL tests were conducted in the laboratory of 3M Innovation Center which was established by EN standard. As expected ILs of half masks were lower than those of filtering facepiece mask. ILs of half masks and some filtering facepieces were significantly different in manufacturers. ILs of 1st class filtering facepieces were found to be much more than those of 2nd class and thus the result would cause wearers to get confused to select a mask. Four of six brands being no compliance with standards were thought that they should be tested again for certification because of a lot of differences from standards. There were no significant differences among ILs of five exercises. In 6 out of 13 brands lognormal distribution of ILs may be a better fit distribution and in 7 brands both lognormal and normal distributions were rejected. The result indicates that geometric mean may be better than arithmetic mean to establish standard.
Keywords
inward leakage test; respirator; test panel; half mask; filtering facepieces;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 한돈희 : 호흡기보호구의 밀착도 검사와 안면규격 Panel 의 개발. 한국산업위생학회, 9(1), 1-13, 1999
2 노동부 : 보호구 성능검정 규정(방진마스트), 고시 제 2003-19호, 2003
3 EN 13274-1:2001: Respiratory protective devices methods of test - Part I: Determination of inward leakage and total inward leakage, British Standard, 2001
4 Han, D.-H. : Fit factor for quarter masks and facial size categories. Ann. Occup. Hyg., 44(3), 227-234, 2000   DOI
5 National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) : Guide to industrial respiratory protection (DHHS/NIOSH Pub. No. 87-116), Washington, D.C., p. 123, 1987
6 Canadian Standards Association. Z94.4-93 : Selection, use, and care of respirators. Rexdale, Ontario, Canada, 1993
7 European Standards. EN 140 Respiratory Protective Devices : Half-masks, quarter-masks; requirements, testing, marking, European Committee for Standardization, 1998
8 한돈희, Willeke K. : 호흡기보호구 착용시 움직임과 매일 착용에 다른 Fit Factors의 변화. 한국산업위생학회지, 6(2), 176-186, 1996
9 OSHA regulation. CFR(Code of Federal Regulations) 'Respiratory Protection' Title 29, Part 1910.134, 2003
10 Standards Australia and Standards New Zealand : AS/NZS 1715, 1716, Respiratory protective devices, selection, use and maintenance of respiratory protective devices. Homebush, NSW 2140 Australia, 1994
11 Oestenstad, R. K. and Zwissler, A. M. : A comparison of fit provided by natural and silicone rubber facepieces of the same brand of half-mask respirator. App. Occup. Env. Hyg., 6(9), 785-789, 1991   DOI
12 Vos, G. A. and Christie, J. D. : LogNorm 2TM Statistics for exposure assessment, InTech Software Corp., Industrial Software Solution, Tulsa, OK 74136, 1997
13 Han, D. H., Willeke, K. and Colton, C. E. : Quantitative fit testing techniques and regulations for tightfitting respirators : Current methods measuring aerosol or air leakage, and new developments. Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J., 58(3), 219-228, 1997   DOI   ScienceOn
14 European Standards : EN.136 Respiratory Protective Devices; Full-face masks: requirements, testing, marking, European Committee for Standardization, 1998.