Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.22246/jikm.2018.39.1.22

The Effect of Cheonmagudeung-eum for Hypertension: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis  

Kang, Ki-wan (Dept. of Internal Medicine, College of Korean Medicine, Woo-Suk University)
Kang, Ja-yeon (Dept. of Internal Medicine, College of Korean Medicine, Woo-Suk University)
Jeong, Min-jeong (Dept. of Pediatrics, College of Korean Medicine, Woo-Suk University)
Kim, Hong-jun (Dept. of Prescription, College of Korean Medicine, Woo-Suk University)
Sun, Seung-ho (Dept. of Internal Medicine, College of Korean Medicine, Sang-Ji University)
Jang, In-soo (Dept. of Internal Medicine, College of Korean Medicine, Woo-Suk University)
Publication Information
The Journal of Internal Korean Medicine / v.39, no.1, 2018 , pp. 22-43 More about this Journal
Abstract
Objective: The purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of Cheonmagudeung-eum (CGE) for essential hypertension by systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods: The period of literature search was until October 30, 2016, and 14 electronic databases were utilized as search engines. The evaluation for the risk of bias (RoB) was conducted by using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool. The meta-analysis was performed by synthesizing outcome data, including total effective rate (TER), systolic blood pressure (SBP), diastolic blood pressure (DBP), and the incidence of adverse events. Result: There were a total of 64 RCTs using CGE on adult essential hypertension. In the RoB evaluation, most of the items were unclear, and the qualities of studies were rated low. The concurrent treatment of CGE and antihypertensive drug (AHD) showed a significant hypotensive effect since the risk ratio (RR) of TER was 1.17 times (95% CI 1.14, 1.20, p<0.01) higher than that of AHD alone. In addition, the mean difference (MD) appeared low as 8.73 mm/Hg in SBP (95% CI -11.36, -6.09, p<0.01) and 5.81 mm/Hg in DBP (95% CI -7.50, -4.12, p<0.01). Conclusion: Through this study, it was identified that the combined treatment of CGE and AHD on hypertension would be more effective than that of AHD treatment alone. However, due to the low quality of the selected original articles, the significance of this conclusion is somewhat limited, and we hope that this would be complemented through more rigorous RCTs in the future.
Keywords
hypertension; antihypertensive drug; Cheonmagudeung-eum; systematic review; meta-analysis;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Lin ZZ, Xing ZH, Liu WP, et al. Effect of Tianmagouteng Decoction on Antioxygen and Carotid Artery Atherosclerosis in Patients with Hypertension. Journal of Hebei North University 2009;26(4):18-20.
2 劉熾彬, 王履京, 任洪波, 蔣希成. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合培哚普利治療高血壓病30例. 中醫藥學報 2009;37(1):55-6.
3 Chen ZJ. The Clinical Observation on High Blood Pressure with Combined Treatment of Traditional Medicine and Western Medicine. Shanxi J of TCM 2008;24(7):27-8.
4 秦風蓮. 天麻鉤藤顆粒與天麻鉤藤湯干預原發性高血壓臨床效果比較. 中醫中藥 2010;17(10):72-3.
5 方顯明, 黎芳, 何勁松, 王强. 天麻鉤藤飮合卡托普利治療高血壓病30例. 陜西中醫 2008;29(3):308-10.
6 Wang HX. Clinical Study of Effect on Essential Hypertension Treated by Tianma Gouteng Yin. Chinese of Traditonal Chinese Medicine 2008;26(2):338-40.
7 Wang Q, Li F, Fang WM. Effect on Tianma Gouteng Decoction and Captopril2 on Blood Pressure and Inflammatory Factor in Patients with Essential Hypertension. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medine 2008;49(1):32-4.
8 Zhang Z, Lin ZZ. Clinical obser vation on the ther apeutic effect of tianma gouteng decoction on the plasma level of malondic aldehyde among patients with hyper tension. China Medical Engineering 2007;15(1):57-9.
9 蔡昌龍, 李明月, 邢之華, 劉衛平, 譚海彦, 張臣. 天麻鉤藤飮對肝陽上亢型高血壓病患者血漿JVN, WN8的影響. 家用醫學雜志 2005;21(3):321-2.
10 Xing ZH, Cai CL, Tan HY, et al. Effect of Tianma Gouteng decoction on the curative efficacy and qulity of life in patients with essetial hypertension. Chinese Journal of Clinical Rehabilitation 2004;8(15):2880-1.
11 Xing ZH, Tan HY, Liu WP, et al. Effect of Tianmagouteng Decoction on Blood Pressure and CAT in Hypertension Patients. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation 2004;19(6):330-1.
12 Liu WP, Cai CL, Li MY, et al. The Effects of Gastrodia and Uncaria Beverage on Blood Pressure and Serum SOD Activity of Patients with Hypertension in the Pattern of Ascendant Liver Yang. Journal of TCM Univ of Hunan 2004;24(6):44-56.
13 Xie MU, Su QY, Wang X. Clinical Study on Effect and Pathogenesis of Tian Ma Gou Teng Yin on Therapy the Hypertensinon. Journal of Heze Medical College 2004;16(4):52-4.
14 Liu WP, Xing ZH, LIN ZZ. Effect of Tianmagouteng Decoction on Plasma Nitric Oxide of the Patients with Essential Hypertension. Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation 2003;18(5):291-2.
15 Gong YP. Study on Effect of Tianma Goutengyin on trentment the Syndrome of exuberance of Liver-yang. Zheiiang college of TCM 2003;27(5):2728.
16 A Report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Clinical Practice Guidelines. 2017 High Blood Pressure Clinical Practice Guideline. 2017, p. 21-2, 71-4.
17 Traditional Medicine Institute. Oriental Medicine Dictionary. Seoul: Seongbosa; 2000, p. 2227.
18 Heran BS, Wong MMY, Heran IK, Wright JM. Blood pressure lowering efficacy of angiotensin receptor blockers for primary hypertension. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2008;4.
19 Zhang MY. Research on curative effects of Tianma Gouteng decoction combined with plendil on hypertension and its mechanism. Medical Journal of National Defending Forces in Southwest China 2016;26(3):249-51.
20 陳培亮. 中西醫結合治療老年高血壓病49例臨床觀察. 湖南中醫雜志 2016;32(2):46-7.
21 陳小飛, 張寶霞, 張寶均. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合硝苯地平控釋片治療肝陽上亢型高血壓病40例的臨床療效觀察. 實用中西醫結合臨床 2016;16(1):16-8.
22 Weng JL, Lin EP. Clinical Study on Tianma Gouteng Decoction in Treatment of Patients With Hypertension and Improving Vascular Compliance and Endothelial Function. China Health Standard Management 2015;6(24):124-5.
23 Sha KC. Observe the Clinical Efficacy of Tianmagouteng Decoction on Treatment of Hyperactivity of Liver Yang Hypertension. Guide of China Medicine 2015;13(20):29-30.
24 Li HF. Thirty-five Cases of Depression Treated with Method of Activating Brain for R esuscitation. Henan Traditional Chinese Medicine 2015;35(10):2524-6.
25 Wang Y, Wu JS, Hu XJ. Curative Observation and Safety Evaluation of Using Varied Tianma Gouteng Decoction Combined with Lisinopril Hydrochlorothiazide Tablets to Treat Hypertension. Journal of Sichuan of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2015;33(5):108-10.
26 Guan W, Ling ZZ. Evaluation of ambulatory blood pressure and Carotid intima-media thickness and left ventricular remodeling of Tianma Gouteng decoction in patients with essential hypertension. Journal of Tianjin University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2015;34(4):215-8.
27 姚永華. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合西藥治療肝陽上亢型高血壓臨床觀察. 新中醫 2015;47(3):25-6.
28 柳叶, 羅冬華, 蔣慧倩. 天麻鉤藤顆粒結合卡托普利治療原發性高血壓63例臨床觀察. 中醫藥導報 2014;20(13):73-5.
29 李鳳云. 觀察中西藥結合治療肝陽上亢型高血壓的 療效. 中西醫結合心血管病雜志 2014;2(16):17-8.
30 劉寒. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合厄貝沙坦治療肝陽上亢型高血壓的療效觀察. 中西醫結合心血管病雜志 2014;2(14):42-3.
31 Jin Y. Efficacy Observation of Enalapril Maleate Tablets and Tianma Gouteng Yin in Treatment of Hypertension of Liver Wind Disturbance Type. World Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine 2014;9(12):1330-2.
32 梁東勇, 林小霞. 天麻鉤藤飮配合西藥治療肝陽上亢型高血壓病療效觀察. 陜西中醫 2014;35(8):978-80.
33 李銳. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合卡托普利治療高血壓44例療效觀察. 實用中西醫結合臨床 2014;14(5):17-8.
34 丁宏, 楊光, 徐丹, 王玉珏. 天麻鉤藤顆粒治療高血壓病30例臨床觀察. 吉林醫學 2014;35(4):785-6.
35 Fang XM, Chen RL, Tang YP, Wang Q, Fang X, Gu GL, et al. Controlled Clinical Research on the Treatment of Hypertension by Tianmagouteng Decoction in Combination with Western Medicine. Journal of Guangxi University of Chinese Medicine 2014;17(4):1-4.
36 Lim KT, Hwang EH, Kim BJ, Park IH, Heo I Chuna Manual Therapy for Essential Hypertension : A Systematic Review. The Journal of Korea CHUNA manual medicine for spine & nerves 2017;12(1):29-42.
37 張寶華. 天麻鉤藤飮治療肝陽上亢型高血壓的療效. 中西醫結合心血管病雜志 2014;2(16):38-9.
38 Cho HJ, Bae DR, Kim HN, Hwang EH. Baduanjin for Hypertension : Systematic Review. The Journal of Korea CHUNA Manual Medicine for Spine & Nerves 2017;12(1):43-56.
39 Han IS, Shin JH, Cho YY, Park HM, Yang CS, Jeong MJ, et al. Qu-Ji-Du-Huang-Wan for Essential Hypertension : Systemic Review and Meta-analysis. Korean Journal of Oriental Physiology & Pathology 2017;31(2):118-25.   DOI
40 Lee HY, Kang KW, Lee E, Lee SH, Han CH, Jang IS. A Systematic Review on Antihypertensive Effects of Oryeong-san. The Journal of Korean Oriental Internal Medicine 2013;34(3):289-97.
41 Song BY. Effect of Kamicheonmagudeungeum on Oxidative Stress and Hypertension. Graduate School of Dongshin University 2007;1-56.
42 項學貴, 丁碧云. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合鈣离子拮抗劑治療高血壓病的有效性及安全性的Meta分析. 中國中醫急症 2015;24(12):2153-6.
43 周倩儀, 馬楷奇, 郭意欣, 戴新芳, 陳新林. 天麻鉤藤飮聯用血管緊張素轉化酶抑制劑治療原發性高血壓的Meta分析. 中國實驗方劑學雜志 2015;21(4):206-12.
44 郭威, 郭煒, 劉穎. 天麻鉤藤飮治療肝陽上亢型原發性高血壓隨机對照試驗的系統評价. 山東中醫雜志 2013;32(11):794-6.
45 周倩儀, 馬楷奇, 郭意欣, 陳潔, 陳新林, 徐謙, 등. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合卡托普利治療原發性高血壓的系統評价和Meta分析. 安徽中醫學院學報 2013;32(4):12-7.
46 董大幸, 姚松林, 余男, 楊波. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合依那普利治療原發性高血壓系統評价和Meta分析. 中國中醫急症 2011;20(5):762-4.
47 Higgins JP, Altman DG, Gotzsche PC, Juni P, Moher D, Oxman AD, et al. The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ 2011;343:d5928.   DOI
48 Yan HH, Wang XL, Sun MG, Wang SJ, Ji H. Clinical effects observation of combined Tianma Gouteng decoction with benazepril hydrochloride on treating liver yang hyperactivity hypertension. Journal of Liaoning University of TCM 2016;18(6):120-2.
49 孫玉章. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合馬來酸依那普利叶酸片治療老年原發性高血壓50例分析. 世界最新醫學信息文摘 2016;16(94):149.
50 Gu H. Mechanism analsys is of Tianma Gouteng decoction treating patients with grade 1 hypertension and improving the clinical symptoms. Chinese Community Doctors 2016;32(14):90-1.
51 李墨. 天麻鉤藤湯治療老年高血壓陰虛陽亢証的療效. 現代養生 2016;6:148.
52 Korean Medical Guideline Information Center. Evidence-based Guideline for Hypertension in Primary Care. 2016, p. 56-60.
53 Bian WS. Impact of Tianmagoutengyin Combined With Levamlodipine Besylate on Blood Pressure, Serum Inflammatory Cytokines Levels and Vascular Endothelial Function of Patients With Essential Hypertension. Practical Journal of Cardiac Cerebral Pneumal and Vascular Disease 2016;24(5):87-9.
54 Ministry of health and Welfare. Korean Centers for Disease control & Prevention. 2015 Health Behavior and Chronic Disease Statistics. Seoul: Ministry of health and Welfare; 2016, p. 50-1.
55 Seoul Asan Hospital internal Medicine. 2016 Recent advances in internal medicine. Seoul: Our medical books; 2016, p. 34.
56 Association of Korean Medicine Professors for Cardiovascular and Neurological Medicine. Cardiovascular and neurological medicine in Korean medicine I. Seoul: Uri medical books; 2016, p. 196-8.
57 Chen CJ. Effect of Tianma Gouteng Decoction on Blood Pressure Variability of Hypertension of Liver-Yang Hyperactivity Type. Journal of New Chinese Medicine 2014;46(3):52-4.
58 Guo CJ. Clinical analysis on the blood pressure of Ganyang Shangkang hypertensive patients by the Tianma Gouteng decoction. Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine 2013;5(16):17-8.
59 Gu HL. Tianma Gouteng Decoction in the Treatment of Primary Hypertension Randomized Parallel Controlled Study. Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Internal Medicine 2013;27(12):10-2.
60 Yang YH. Clinical effect observation on treating 60 cases of hypertension in the integrative medicine. Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine 2013;5(16):77-8.
61 付勇剛. 天麻鉤藤飮治療老年高血壓的療效及對血淸CRPTNF-${\alpha}$和腎功能的影響. 四川中醫 2016;34(5):78-9.
62 王洪興, 韓麗華. 天麻鉤藤飮治療肝陽上亢型高血壓病臨床觀察. 光明中醫 2013;28(11):2298-9.
63 Liu MM, et al. Effect of Tianmagouteng decoction on blood pressure and autioxidant enzyme activities in the hypertensive patients. Journal of Qiqihar University of Medicine 2013;34(8):1117-8.
64 Ye YF, Li SL, Zheng JR, Zhang YM. A Randomized Controlled Study on Tianma Gouteng Decoction in Treating Hypertension of Liver-Yang Hyperactivity Pattern. Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Internal Medicine 2013;27(5):83-4.
65 孔利環. 中西醫結合治療肝陽上亢型高血壓病臨床觀察. 中國社區醫師(醫學專業) 2013;15(10):213.
66 王艷芳, 魯新建. 天麻鉤藤飮聯合西藥治療肝陽上亢型高血壓30例. 陜西中醫 2013;34(9):1136-8.
67 羅琦. 天麻鉤藤飮治療肝陽上亢型高血壓療效觀 察. 中醫藥臨床雜志 2013;25(8):686-7.
68 陳宏斌, 張東. 天麻鉤藤飮治療高血壓病的療效觀察. 中國臨床硏究 2012;25(12):1226-7.
69 Zhou JR. Clinical Observation on Tianma Gouteng Granules Combined with Western Medicine for Treatment of Senile Hypertension. Chinese Journal of Experimental Traditional Medical Formulae 2013;19(7):327-30.
70 樊云. 天麻鉤藤飮与厄貝沙坦-氫氯噻嗪片治療陰虛陽亢型原發性高血壓患者的臨床療效觀察及偶測血壓, 動態血壓對比評价. 成都中醫藥大學碩士學位論文 2013.
71 莫志云, 謝健周, 曾順軍. 天麻鉤藤飮配合長效钙拮抗劑治療高血壓病療效觀察. 求醫問藥 2012;10(10):293-4.
72 程勝軍, 方顯明, 李志英, 阮威君, 羅春蕾, 馮雪霞 등. 精簡天麻鉤藤飮合ACEi類藥對高血壓患者血壓及生存質量的影響. 中西醫結合心胸血管病雜志 2012;19(8):909-10.
73 韋耀力. 天麻鉤藤飮治療高血壓病肝陽上亢型49例療效分析. 深圳中西醫結合雜志 2012;22(5):310-2.
74 尹志鋒. 中西醫結合治療高血壓病50例. 山西中醫 2012;28(4):28-9.
75 尹靖云. 天麻鉤藤飮治療I期, II期高血壓60例. 現代中西醫結合雜志 2012;21(4):407-8.
76 Pu JC. Hyperactivity Hypertension Treated by Decoction of Tianma Gouteng(TGD). Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese 2012;30(1):215-6.
77 于洋, 劉莉, 金娟. 天麻鉤藤飮對肝陽上亢型高血壓病患者SOD及ET的影響. 中醫藥學報 2010;38(2):121-2.
78 林金忠, 劉園園. 天麻鉤藤飮治療中靑年1級高血壓療效觀察. 中西醫結合心胸血管病雜志 2010;8(6):649.
79 朱智德, 李成林, 王慶高. 天麻鉤藤顆粒對高血壓病患者生存質量的影響. 福建中醫藥 2010;41(4):6-7.
80 Dong SY. Clinical Research of Gastrodia Elata Urcaria Enalaprilat in Treating Combined Liver Yang Hyperactivity Pattern Hypertension. China Journal of Chinese Medicine 2010;25(149):709-11.
81 Zhu XQ. Clinical effects on integrative Chinese and Western medicine in treating essential hypertention. Journal of TCM Univ of Human 2009;29(12):67-9.
82 Tan HY, Xing ZH, Chen JB. Clinical Effects of Tianmagouteng Tablets to 30 Patients with Hypertension. Journal of Hebei North University 2009;26(6):24-5.