Browse > Article

The Legal Problems and Improvement in the Performance Based Design of Fire-fighting  

Yi, Jong-Yeong (중앙대학교 법학전문대학원)
Baek, Ok-Sun (중앙대학교 대학원 법학과)
Publication Information
Fire Science and Engineering / v.24, no.1, 2010 , pp. 54-63 More about this Journal
Abstract
The buildings relevant to the law should be designed performance-based necessarily according to "Fire-Fighting System Installation Business Act" amended, January 1. 2009. Performance based design means that building design reflects structure, size, purpose, and building capacity to achieve the most effective design of fire-fighting system. Performance based design has meaning to buildings that it is insufficient to control fire-fighting by previous law-oriented design or inappropriate by uniform design, because of buildings becoming bigger and higher. However, it is difficult to implement the system actually, because laws relevant to fire-fighting prescribe only the object and the required qualifications of performance based design, but they don't have rules to enforce performance based design for specific parts. This study suggests improvements for a desirable implementation of performance based design in legal aspects, by analyzing the current legal regulations related to performance based design.
Keywords
Performance based fire-fighting design system (PBD); Fire-Fighting System Installation Business Act; Building Act; The agreement system on the building permission;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 차종호, "성능위주 소방 설계의 국내법규와의 연관성 연구", 시립대학교 도시과학대학원 석사학위논문 (2006.2).
2 Fr. Curtius, "Entwicklungstendenzen im Genehmigungsrecht", S.65 ff.
3 K.-F. Garditz, "Regulierungsermessen und verwaltungsgerichtliche Kontrolle", NVwZ 2009, S.1005 ff.
4 Ph. Kunig, "Das Rechtsstaatsprinzip", S.259 ff.
5 R. Poscher, "Verwaltungsakt und Verwaltungsrecht in der Vollstreckung - Zur Geschichte, Theorie und Dogmatik des Verwaltungsvollstreckungsrechts", VerwArch, Bd.89(1995), S.119 ff.
6 H. Rossen-Stadtfeld, "Die verhandelnde Verwaltung - Bedingungen, Funktionen, Perspektiven", VerwArch. 2006, S.23 ff.
7 J. Saurer, "Die neueren Theorien zur Normkategorie der Verwaltungsvorschriften", VerwArch. 2006, S.249 ff.
8 J. Saurer, "Verwaltungsvorschriften und Gesetzesvorbehalt - Zur Entscheidung des Bundesverwaltungsgerichts vom 17. Juni 2004", DOV 2005, S.587 ff.
9 권순평, "국내 성능위주소방설계(performance based fire protection design, 이하 PBD) 적용 현황과 주요 과제", 소방안전, 한국소방안전협회, 제26권, 제2호 (2006. 여름).
10 김환진 외 4인, "성능위주의 설계를 위한 성능기준에 관한 연구", 한국화재소방학회: 학술대회논문집, 한국 화재소방학회 2004년도 하계학술논문발표회 논문집 (2004).
11 백민호, "초고층 건물의 성능위주 소방 설계방안에 관 한 연구", 한국화재소방학회: 학술대회논문집, 한국화재소방학회 2007년도 춘계학술논문발표회 논문집 (2007).
12 행정안전위원회, "소방시설공사업법 검토보고서" (2005.6).
13 Cl. Franzius, "Funktionen des Verwaltungsrechts im Steuerungsparadigma der neuen Verwaltungsrechtswissenschaft", DV, Bd.39(2006), S.335 ff.
14 국회법제실, "입법이론과 법제실무"(2005).
15 김원국, "성능위주 소방설계의 국내도입에 관한 고찰", 한국화재소방학회: 학술대회논문집, 한국화재소방학회 2002년도 추계학술대회논문집(2002).
16 R. Pitschas, "Neues Verwaltungsrecht im partnerschaftlichen Rechtsstaat?", DOV 2004, S.231 ff.
17 김원국, "성능위주소방설계개념 및 적용 방안", 한국 화재소방학회: 학술대회논문집, 한국화재소방학회 2006년도 하계세미나 발표집(2006.7).
18 H. Hill, "Normsetzung und andere Formen exekutivischer Selbstprogrammierung, in: Hoffmann-Riem/ Schmidt-A$\beta$mann-Vo$\beta$kuhle (Hrsg.), Grundlagen des Verwaltungsrechts", S.959 ff.
19 R. Wahl, "Verwaltungsvorschriften: Die ungesicherte dritte Kategorie des Rechts, in: Festschrift fur 50 Jahre Bundesverwaltungsgericht", 2003, S.571 ff.