Browse > Article

A Study on the Validity of Refuting Literature about the Bonghan theory  

Lee, Sang-Hun (Division of Standard Research Acupuncture, Moxibustion & Meridian Research Center, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine)
Zhang, Wenji (Division of Standard Research Acupuncture, Moxibustion & Meridian Research Center, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine)
Soh, Kwang-Sup (Biomedical Physics Laboratory, Department of Physics & Astronomy, Seoul National University)
Lee, Byung-Chun (Biomedical Physics Laboratory, Department of Physics & Astronomy, Seoul National University)
Sung, Baek-Kyung (Biomedical Physics Laboratory, Department of Physics & Astronomy, Seoul National University)
Ryu, Yeon-Hee (Division of Standard Research Acupuncture, Moxibustion & Meridian Research Center, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine)
Publication Information
Korean Journal of Acupuncture / v.27, no.3, 2010 , pp. 129-142 More about this Journal
Abstract
Background : The Bonghan theory is a hypothesis on the anatomical structure of the acupuncture point and meridian system. It has been regarded as a misunderstanding of the lymphatic system, or as a made-up story, for the past 40 years. Since 2002, Many studies have been published either to support the theory or to refute the old viewpoint. Objective : The purpose of this study was to find out the validity of the refutation by reviewing the publications. Methods : Searches were made from online databases (Riss4u.net, Google.com, Sciencedirect.com, Pubmed.com, baidu.com, and ci.nii.ac.jp) from 1960 to 2009. The search terms that were used were "Bonghan," "Bong han," "봉한," "thread-like structure," "KИM БOH XaHOM", "CИCTEMA KEHPAK," "鳳漢," "鳳漢管," and "鳳漢学說." References from the searched publications were also used. Results : Since the 1960s, 107 publications were identified as related works, but only 11 publications sought to refute the Bonghan theory. Two publications were researches, and nine were reviews. In the analysis of the correlation of the arguments with the publication contents, it was found that the research of G. Kellner reviewed the Bonghan system properly but that V. V. Kosmatov did not classify the ear-reflex zone as a traditional acupuncture point. For the review publications, only two reviews contained proper arguments, but seven publications were identified as broad interpretations, wrong translations, etc. Moreover, the two proper reviews were grounded on the research of G. Kellner. Conclusions : We found that the scientific origin of the refutation of the Bonghan theory is only one research by G. Kellner. This result suggest that Bonghan theory was not discussed enough to determine the invention.
Keywords
Bonghan; Bong han; G. Kellner; acupuncture points;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 S. W. Wong. Acupuncture and Psychiatry The Hong Kong Practitioner. 1980 : Dec: 381-91.
2 Shin HS, Johng HM, Lee BC, Cho SI. Soh KS. Baik KY. et al. Feulgen Reaction Study of Novel Thread-like Structures (Bonghan ducts) on the Surfaces of Mammalian Organs. Anat Rec. 2005 : 284B : 35-40.   DOI   ScienceOn
3 Chan SH. What is being stimulated in acupuncture : evaluation of the existence of a specific substrate. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 1984 Spring ; 8(1) : 25-33.   DOI   ScienceOn
4 Felix Mann. SCIENTIFIC ASPECTS OF ACUPUNCTURE 2nd edition Butterworth- Heinemann Ltd. 1983 : 1.
5 Vyacheslav Ogay, KH Bae, KW Kim, KS Soh, Comparison of the Characteristic Features of Bonghan Ducts. Blood and Lymphatic Capillaries. JAMS. 2009 : 2(2) : 107-17.
6 Fujiwara S, Yu SB, Bonghan Theory : morphological studies. Igakuro Ayumi. 1967 : 60 : 567-77.
7 Tiberiu R, Gheorghe G, Popescu I. Do meridians of acupuncture exit?: A radio-active tracer study of the baldder meridian. American Journal of acupuncture. 1981 ; 9(3) 251-6.
8 張永賢 經脈醫學-21世紀的生命科學.中國醫樂大學曁附設醫院: 中華針灸醫學會雜誌.2003 : 1-4.
9 Bensoussan. Alan. The Vital Meridian : A Modern Exploration of Acupunclure Melbourne Melbourne : New York : Churchill Livingstone. 1990 : 53.
10 D. Sergeyev. Publications Evolution of morphological substrate of biologically active points and energy meridians in the system of Chinese classical Chern-tsu therapy [in Russian]. Journal of Mathematical Morphology. 2009 ; 3 : 166-79.
11 Kim. BH. Kyungrak System. J Acad Med Sci DPR Korea. 1961 : 1-38.
12 W. S. Kroger. Acupunctural Analgesia Am. J. Psychiatry. 1973 : 130 : 8.
13 VV Kosmatov. OA Sergeev. AS Ledovskoy. Publications Search BONHANOVYH cells and tubules in the human ear lobe [in Russian]. Journal of Mathematical Morphology. 2009 : 1 : 180-4. in Russian.
14 Felix Mann. The Ancient Chinese Art of Healing. Reprinted New York Random House : 5.
15 Kellner G. Bau und Funktion der Haut. Deutche Zeitschrift fur Akupunktur 1966 ; 15 : 1-31.
16 Soh KS. Choi SM. Reviews on recent Korean work on Bonghan systems. J. lntl. Soc. Life lnfo. Sci. 2005 ; 23(1) ; 280-5.
17 김근배. 과학과 이데올로기의 사이에서 : 북한 '봉한학설'의 부침 한국과학사학회지 1999 : 21(2) : 194-220.
18 Kim. BH. Sanal Theory. J Acad Med Sci DPR Korea. 1965 : 168 : 5-38.
19 Kim. BH. Sanal-Cell cycle of blood cells. J Acad Med Sci DPR Korea. 1965 ; 114 : 1-6.
20 WS. Kroger. Acupuncture Analgesia. Am. J. Psychiatry. 1973 August ; 130: 8
21 Hu XL, et al. Modern scientific research in acupuncture channels and collaterals in traditional Chinese medicine [in Chinese]. People's Hygiene Publishing House, Beijing. 1990 : 21.
22 Sung BK, Kim MS, Lee BC, Yoo JS, Lee SH, Kim YJ. et al. Measurement of flow speed in the channels of novel thread-like structures on the surfaces of mammalian organs. Naturwissenschaften. 2008 : 95(2) : 117-24.   DOI   ScienceOn
23 Lee BC. Seol SK. Lee BC. Hong YK. Je JH. Soh KS. Alcian Blue staining method to visualize Bonghan threads inside large caliber Iymphatic vessels and X-ray microtomography to reveal their microchannels. Lymph Res Biol. 2006 ; 4(4) : 181-90.   DOI   ScienceOn
24 Lee BC, Yoo JS, Baik KY, Kim KW, Soh KS, Novel thread-like structures (Bonghan ducts) inside lymphatic vessels of rabbits visualized with a Janus Green B staining method. Anat Rec. 2005 ; 268B : 1-7.
25 박미용. 봉한학설의 전개 과정과 북한의 정치.사회.과학적 상황. 서울대학교 대학원 석사학위 논문. 2006.
26 Lee JS. Bonghan system and Hypothesis on Oncogenesis. J. ISLIS Japan. 2004 : 22 : 606-8.
27 Simon K, Guiraud G, Esquerre J P, Lazorthes Y, Guiraud R. Acupuncture meridians demystified Contirbution of radiotracer methodology. Press Medicale. 1988 : 17(26) : 1341-4.
28 Bossy J Morphological data concerning the acupuncture points and channel network. Acupuncture& Electrotherapeutics Research 1984 ; 9 : 79-106.
29 吳淸忠, 人體使用手册: 達觀出版事業有限公司. 台北(三版). 2007 : 21.
30 Gong Q H, Xiang Y M. Cao J R, Wang W J, Wei H X Studies on the relationship between the channels and the lymphatic system. TCM Digest. 1985 ; 1(2).
31 SAMUEL H. H. CHAN. What ls Being Stimulated in Acupunclure: Ewaluation of the Existence of a Specific Substrate. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews. 1984 : 8 : 25-33.   DOI   ScienceOn
32 Kim. BH. On the Kyungrak System. J Acad Med Sci DPR Korea. 1963 : 1-35
33 Francisco Antonio de Oliveira. Evidencias cientificas da acao da Acupuntura. PERSPECTIVAS, Campos dos Goytacazes. 2005 : 4(7): 88-105.
34 張揚. 話說 " 김봉한 사건" 今晚報 2009. 8. 21(21版).
35 Zhang CL. Dissipative Structure of Electromagnetic Field in Living System. HBI Deutschland. 2003 : 12 : 1-7.
36 북한연구소. 북한총람. 19 : 북한연구소. 1983 : 1022.
37 Kim. BH. Research about the realities of kyungrak. J Acad Med Sci DPR Korea 1961 : 9 : 5-13.