Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.20923/kjas.2022.71.005

Research Trends and Issues of Appraisal of Digital Records : Focused on Datasets and Websites  

Hyun, Moonsoo (부산대학교 사회과학연구원)
Publication Information
The Korean Journal of Archival Studies / v., no.71, 2022 , pp. 5-48 More about this Journal
Abstract
This study explored recent discussions, experiments, and case studies related to the appraisal of digital records, which was focused on datasets and websites. Based on this, it proposed what issues should be addressed for developing appraisal policies. To this end, it categorized appraisal criteria that can be applied to digital records, examined the arguments that in the digital environment total retention is necessary in the era of big data, and that selective retention is still necessary, based on the literature review. Subsequently, after analyzing case studies conducted on datasets and websites, the study dealt with what discussions should be made in terms of targets, tools, objectives of appraisal, and roles/responsibilities which used to develop appraisal policy. This study addressed the following questions to reveal current debates and challenges; First, what appraisal criteria can be applied to digital records in general; second, is the appraisal activities still necessary in the era of digital environment and big data; third, what are the results that case studies produced for the appraisal of digital records; fourth, what changes are expected in the future regarding the appraisal. Based on these questions, it tried to reveal the main issues necessary to develop the appraisal policies that can be applied to various types of digital records created in the public domain.
Keywords
appraisal; selection; appraisal of digital records; appraisal of datasets; appraisal of websites; research trends; issues of discussion;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 9  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 TNA (2014). Operational selection policy OSP27: UK central government web estate. Available: https://cdn.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/information-management/osp27.pdf
2 Information and documentation - Appraisal for managing records. ISO/TR 21946:2018.
3 한국기록학회 (2008). 기록학 용어 사전. 서울: 역사비평사.
4 현문수 (2021). 국가기록평가의 관점에서 본 환경 분야 기록관리기준표 분석. 기록학연구, 67, 139-203.
5 Brown, A. (2006). Archiving website: a practical guide for information management professional. Facet Publishing, 24-41. 재인용: Shenkolewski-Kroll, S. & Tractinsky, A. (2015). EU01-Research on retention and disposition processes in an internet website of the Government of Israel: The Ministry of Foreign Affairs case study. Final paper. (July 7, 2015), 9.
6 Cook, T. (1991). 'Many are called, but few are chosen'? Appraisal guidelines for sampling and selecting case files. Archivaria, 32, 25-50.
7 Cox, R. (2011). Appraisal and the future of archives in the digital era. In Hill, J. ed. The Future of Archives and Recordkeeping. Facet Publishing, 213-237.
8 Cunningham, A. (2008). Digital curation/digital archiving: A view from the National Archives of Australia. American Archivist, 71(2), 530-543.   DOI
9 Cunningham, A. (2016). Describing Archives in Context: Peter J. Scott and the Australian 'Series' System. In Lemieux, V. ed. Building Trust in Information, Springer Proceedings in Business and Economics. Springer International Publishing, 49-57.
10 Dale, K. (2015). RIM's role in harnessing the power of big data. Information Management, 49(4), 29-32.
11 Duranti, L. (2011). Structural and formal analysis: The contribution of diplomatics to archival appraisal in the digital environment. In Hill, J. ed. The Future of Archives Record Keeping. Facet Publishing, 65-88,
12 Duranti, L. (2015). Archival bond. In Duranti, L. and Franks, P.C. eds. Encyclopedia of Archival Science. Rowman & Littlefield.
13 Shenkolewski-Kroll, S. & Tractinsky, A. (2015). EU01-Research on retention and disposition processes in an internet website of the Government of Israel: The Ministry of Foreign Affairs case study. Final paper. (July 7, 2015). Available: https://interparestrust.org/assets/public/dissemination/EU01_20150909_RetentionDispositionProcessesIsraeliForeignAffairs_FinalReport_Final.pdf
14 Tanselle, T. G. (2002). The librarians' double-cross. Raritan; New Brunswick, 21(4), 245-263. Available: https://www.proquest.com/docview/203865559?pq-origsite=gscholar&fromopenview=true
15 TNA (2012). Records collection policy. Available: https://cdn.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/information-management/records-collection-policy.pdf
16 TNA (2021). Using AI for digital records selection in government. Available: https://cdn.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/using-ai-digital-selection-in-government.pdf
17 공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률 시행령. 대통령령 제32223호.
18 Yeo, G. (2012). The conceptual fonds and the physical collection. Archivaria, 73, 43-80.
19 Yeo, G. (2018). Can we keep everything? The future of appraisal in a world of digital profusion. In Brown, C. ed. Archival Future. London: Facet Publishing, 45-63.
20 공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률. 법률 제16661호.
21 문헌정보-기록관리-제1부: 개념과 원칙. KS X ISO 15489-1:2016.
22 McKinsey Global Institute (2016). The age of analytics: Competing in a data-driven world. Available: https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/industries/public%20and%20social%20sector/our%20insights/the%20age%20of%20analytics%20competing%20in%20a%20data%20driven%20world/mgi-the-age-of-analytics-full-report.pdf
23 Eaker, C. (2016). Selection and appraisal of digital research datasets. In Kellam, L. & Thompson, K. eds. Databrarianship: The Academic Data Librarian in Theory and Practice. American Library Association, 245-258. Available: https://trace.tennessee.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.com/&httpsredir=1&article=1018&context=utk_libpub
24 Ham, G. (1993). Selecting and Appraising Archives and Manuscripts. 강경무, 김상민 번역 (2002). 아카이브와 매뉴스크립트의 선별과 평가. 서울: 진리탐구.
25 Harvey, R. (2008). Appraisal and Selection. DCC Briefing Papers: Introduction to Curation. Available: https://www.dcc.ac.uk/guidance/briefing-papers/introduction-curation/appraisal-and-selection
26 Franks, P., Doyle, A., Nobrega, L., Morrison, J. & Wilson, L. (2016). Retention & disposition in a cloud environment. InterPARES Trust final paper. Available: https://interparestrust.org/assets/public/dissemination/NA06_20160902_RetentionDispositionInCloud_FinalReport_Final.pdf
27 Franks, P. (2017). Even in a 'Never delete anything world' compliant information disposition has its place. Information Management Journal, 51(6), 45-46.
28 Franks, P. (2019). Retention and Disposition. In L. Duranti & C. Rogers eds. Trusting Records and Data in the Cloud: The Creation, Management, and Preservation of Trustworthy Digital Content. Facet, 117-134 [e-book].
29 Gilliland, A. (2014). Archival appraisal: Practising on shifting sands. In Brown, C. ed. Archives and Recordkeeping: Theory into Practice. Facet Publishing, 31-61.
30 Jenkinson, H. (1922). A Manual of Archive Administration. 정부기록보존소 번역(2003). 힐러리 젠킨슨의 기록관리편람. 서울: 정부기록보존소.
31 Larson, E. (2020). Big questions: Digital preservation of big data in government. The American Archivist, 83(1), 5-20.   DOI
32 Leahy, E. and Cameron, C. (1965). Modern Records Management. McGraw-Hill, 228. 재인용: Yeo, G. (2018). Can we keep everything? The future of appraisal in a world of digital profusion. In Brown, C. ed. Archival Future (pp. 45-63). London: Facet Publishing, 46.
33 Loukissas, Y. (2017). Taking big data apart: Local readings of composite media collections. Information, Communication & Society, 20(5), 651-664.   DOI
34 McDonald, J. & Leveille, V. (2014). Whither the retention schedule in the era of big data and open data? Records Management Journal, 24(2), 99-121.   DOI
35 Shenkolewski-Kroll, S. & Tractinsky, A. (2017). EU36-Archival Appraisal, Retention Schedules and Metadata in Web Sites - The Case Study of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Israel. Final paper. (November 20, 2017). Available: https://interparestrust.org/assets/public/dissemination/EU036_20171120_AppraisalWebsites_FinalReport.pdf
36 Ministry of Defence (2020). Appraisal report: Ministry of Defence and Armed Forces 1963-2020. Available: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/ministry-of-defence-records-appraisal-report-2020
37 Petrov, C. (2021). 25+ impressive big data statistics for 2021. Available: https://techjury.net/blog/big-data-statistics/
38 SAA [n.d.]. Dictionary of Archives Terminology. Available: https://dictionary.archivists.org/
39 TNA (2013). How to compile an appraisal report: Guidance on completing the Appraisal report template. Available: https://cdn.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/information-management/how-to-compile-an-appraisal-report.pdf
40 설문원, 이승억 (2020). 공공기록 평가제도의 구조와 쟁점. 한국기록관리학회지, 20(1), 47-67.   DOI
41 설문원 (2018). 공공기관의 책임성 강화를 위한 기록평가제도의 재설계. 기록학연구, 55, 5-38.   DOI
42 NAA [n.d.a]. Archiving australian government websites. Available https://www.naa.gov.au/information-management/disposing-information/transferring-information/archiving-australian-government-websites
43 NAA [n.d.b]. Managing social media. Available: https://www.naa.gov.au/information-management/types-information-and-systems/types-information/managing-social-media
44 Rocha, C. L., Claudino, F. C. D., Gonaleves, A., Corbo, D. A. S., Costa, F. M. (2017). LA 01 - Preserving records and managing their lifecycle in a multi-provenance digital government environment - A case study on government electronic system: SIGEPE. InterPARES Trust Project Report. Available: https://interparestrust.org/assets/public/dissemination/IPT_LA01_Report_eng_2017.pdf
45 신동희 (2020). 생산부터 보존까지 기록관리 전반에서 이해하는 기록평가: 미국 뉴욕주기록관의 사례 연구. 한국기록관리학회지, 20(1), 177-199.   DOI
46 왕호성 (2021. 12. 28). 줌(zoom)에서 저자와의 인터뷰 [줌(zoom) 원격 인터뷰].
47 이경래 (2019). 공공기록 평가의 책임과 권한의 분배: '시민참여 평가'를 중심으로. 기록학연구, 60, 49-88.   DOI
48 이경래 (2020). 시민참여형 평가의 실천적 설계를 위한 연구. 한국기록관리학회지, 20(2), 21-40.   DOI
49 이승억, 설문원 (2021). 디지털 정보기술 환경에서 보존기록 평가론의 전환. 기록학연구, 67, 57-97.
50 전보배, 설문원 (2019). 기록 평가에 관한 국제표준의 적용방안 분석: ISO 15489-1과 ISO/TR 21946을 중심으로. 한국기록관리학회지, 19(4), 115-137.   DOI
51 현문수 (2019). 국가기록평가의 권한과 책임 분석: 영국, 미국, 캐나다, 호주 중앙 및 연방정부 기록의 평가를 중심으로. 한국기록관리학회지, 19(4), 175-209.   DOI
52 이경남, 최광훈, 임진희 (2021). 데이터세트 기록관리를 위한 기록관의 역할 연구: KR 사업관리시스템 사례를 중심으로. 정보관리학회지, 36(3), 263-285.
53 김유승 (2019). 디지털 시대의 공공기록평가에 관한 정책적 고찰: 영국 TNA 사례를 중심으로. 기록학연구, 62, 5-39.   DOI
54 Blair, B. (2015). Why we are moving to a world where we will keep everything forever. Available: www.linkedin.com/pulse/why-we-moving-world-where-keep-everything-forever-barclay-t-blair.
55 boyd, D. & Crawford, K. (2012). Critical questions for bit data - Provocations for a cultural, technological, and scholarly phenomenon. Information, Communication and Society, 15(5), 662-679.   DOI
56 Serewicz, L.W. (2010). Do we need bigger buckets or better search engines? The challenges of unlimited storage and semantic web search for records management. Records Management Journal, 20(2), 172-81.   DOI