Browse > Article

The Effect of Alliance Activity on Patent Litigation : In the Case of Printed Electronics  

Kang, Minjeong (한국과학기술원(KAIST) 기술경영학부)
Yoo, Jaewon (한국과학기술원(KAIST) 기술경영학부)
Kim, Wonjoon (한국과학기술원(KAIST) 기술경영학부)
Kim, Namil (한국과학기술원(KAIST) 기술경영학부)
Publication Information
Journal of Korea Technology Innovation Society / v.21, no.1, 2018 , pp. 265-299 More about this Journal
Abstract
Patent litigation has been considered as a tool to protect and facilitate innovation. Ironically, yet, the misguided uses of patent litigation as a strategic tool for vigilance against competitors are acting as a hindrance for innovation. Previous studies show that the better the quality of a patent, the higher the chance of the patent being litigated. Therefore, it is particularly important for the innovating firms to take strategic precautions to minimize the risk of patent litigation. This study investigates the moderating role of firms' past alliance experiences on the relationship between patent quality and patent litigation from the perspective of a defendant. A unique dataset on patents, infringement lawsuits, and firm performances in the printed electronics industry confirms that firms' previous alliance experiences mitigate the impact of patent quality on infringement litigation. For instance, the results confirm that the presence of past alliance experience reduces the litigation rate by 33% for firms with median-quality patents. This paper makes two major contributions. First, it contributes to the literature on alliance experience by confirming its role as a reputation in mitigating future litigations. Second, this paper contributes to the literature on patent litigation by identifying a unique moderator, i.e., alliance experience, on the linkage between patent quality and litigation. An innovating firm is likely to become an alleged infringer under a false accusation. Therefore, this paper focuses on firms that partake in infringement lawsuits unwillingly. Despite the importance, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to investigate patent litigations from the perspective of defendants.
Keywords
Patent litigation; Alliance experience; Printed electronics;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Denton, F. R. and Heald, P. J. (2002), "Random Walks, Non-Cooperative Games, and the Complex Mathematics of Patent Pricing", Rutgers Law Review, 55: 1175.
2 Dollinger, M. J., Golden, P. A. and Saxton, T. (1997), "The Effect of Reputation on the Decision to Joint Venture", Strategic Management Journal, 18(2): 127-140.   DOI
3 Doz, Y. L. and Prahalad, C. K. (1991), "Managing DMNCs: A Search for a New Paradigm", Strategic Management Journal, 12(S1): 145-164.   DOI
4 Dreyfuss, R. C. (1989), "Federal Circuit: A Case Study in Specialized Courts", NYU Law Review, 64: 1.
5 Dyer, J. H. and Singh, H. (1998), "The Relational View: Cooperative Strategy and Sources of Interorganizational Competitive Advantage", Academy of Management Review, 23(4): 660-679.   DOI
6 Gardner, W., Mulvey, E. P. and Shaw, E. C. (1995), "Regression Analyses of Counts and Rates: Poisson, Overdispersed Poisson, and Negative Binomial Models", Psychological Bulletin, 118(3): 392.   DOI
7 Granovetter, M. (1985), "Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness", American Journal of Sociology, 91(3): 481-510.   DOI
8 Greenhalgh, C. and Rogers, M. (2007), "The Value of Intellectual Property Rights to Firms and Society", Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 23(4): 541-567.   DOI
9 Greenhalgh, C., Phillips, J., Pitkethly, R. H., Rogers, M. and Tomalin, J. (2010), "Intellectual Property Enforcement in Smaller UK Firms", SSRN Working Paper.
10 Griliches, Z. (1984), R&D, Patents, and Productivity, University of Chicago Press, 1-20.
11 Lanjouw, J. O. and Schankerman, M. (1999), "The Quality of Ideas: Measuring Innovation with Multiple Indicators", National Bureau of Economic Research.
12 Lanjouw, J. O. and Lerner, J. (2001), "Tilting the Table? The Use of Preliminary Injunctions", Journal of Law and Economics, 44(2): 573-603.   DOI
13 Lanjouw, J. O. and Schankerman, M. (2001), "Characteristics of Patent Litigation: A Window on Competition", The RAND Journal of Economics, 32(1): 129-151.   DOI
14 Lanjouw, J. O. and Schankerman, M. (2004), "Patent Quality and Research Productivity: Measuring Innovation with Multiple Indicators", The Economic Journal, 114(495): 441-465.   DOI
15 Lavie, D. (2007), "Alliance Portfolios and Firm Performance: A Study of Value Creation and Appropriation in the US Software Industry", Strategic Management Journal, 28(12): 1187-1212.   DOI
16 Lee, Y. G., Lee, J. D., Song, Y. I. and Lee, S. J. (2007), "An In-Depth Empirical Analysis of Patent Citation Counts Using Zero-Inflated Count Data Model: The Case of KIST", Scientometrics, 70(1): 27-39.   DOI
17 Lemley, M. A. (2000), "Reconceiving Patents in the Age of Venture Capital", Journal of Small and Emerging Business Law, 4: 137.
18 Lemley, M. A. (2001), "Rational Ignorance at the Patent Office", Northwestern University Law Review, 95(4): 1495-1532.
19 Gulati, R. (1995), "Social Structure and Alliance Formation Patterns: A Longitudinal Analysis", Administrative Science Quarterly, 40(4): 619-652.   DOI
20 Lemley, M. A. and Allison, J. (2004), "Valuable Patents", The Georgetown Law Journal, 92: 435.
21 Lemley, M. A. and Shapiro, C. (2005), "Probabilistic Patents", The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19(2): 75-98.   DOI
22 Lerner, J. (1995), "Patenting in the Shadow of Competitors", Journal of Law and Economics, 38(2): 463-495.   DOI
23 Gulati, R. (2007), Managing Network Resources: Alliances, Affiliations, and Other Relational Assets, Oxford University Press on Demand.
24 AIPLA (2011), 2011 Report of the Economic Survey, https://www.aipla.org/learningcenter/library/books/econsurvey/2011/Pages/default.aspx (2018.03.01.).
25 Aistrup, B. (2009), Linking into the Value Chain for the Printed Electronics Industry, http://www.aistrupconsulting.com/Resources/LinkingIntoTheValueChain_PrintedElectronics.pdf (2018.03.01.).
26 Al-Khalifa, A. K. and Eggert Peterson, S. (1999), "The Partner Selection Process in International Joint Ventures", European Journal of Marketing, 33(11/12): 1064-1081.   DOI
27 Gulati, R. (1998), "Alliances and Networks", Strategic Management Journal, 19(4): 293-317.   DOI
28 Gulati, R. (1999), "Network Location and Learning: The Influence of Network Resources and Firm Capabilities on Alliance Formation", Strategic Management Journal, 20(5): 397-420.   DOI
29 Hall, B. H. (1999), Innovation and Market Value, National Bureau of Economic Research.
30 Hall, B. H. and Ziedonis, R. H. (2001), "The Patent Paradox Revisited: An Empirical Study of Patenting in the US Semiconductor Industry, 1979-1995", The RAND Journal of Economics, 32(1): 101-128.   DOI
31 Hall, B. H., Jaffe, A. and Trajtenberg, M. (2005), "Market Value and Patent Citations", The RAND Journal of Economics, 36(1): 16-38.
32 Meurer, M. J. and Bessen, J. E. (2005), "Lessons for Patent Policy from Empirical Research on Patent Litigation", Lewis & Clark Law Review, 9(1): 1-27.
33 Levinthal, D. (2000), Organizational Capabilities in Complex Worlds, The Nature and Dynamics of Organizational Capabilities, 363-379.
34 Long, C. (2002), "Patent Signals", The University of Chicago Law Review, 69(2): 625-679.   DOI
35 Lorenzoni, G. and Lipparini, A. (1999), "The Leveraging of Interfirm Relationships as a Distinctive Organizational Capability: A Longitudinal Study", Strategic Management Journal, 20(4): 317-338.   DOI
36 Moore, K. A. (2005), "Worthless Patents", Berkeley Technology Law Journal, 20: 1521.
37 Narin, F., Noma, E. and Perry, R. (1987), "Patents as Indicators of Corporate Technological Strength", Research Policy, 16(2-4): 143-155.   DOI
38 Nordhaus, W. D. (1969), Invention, Growth and Welfare: A Theoretical Treatment of Technological Change, No. HD45 N65. 1969.
39 Oliver, C. (1997), "Sustainable Competitive Advantage: Combining Institutional and Resource-Based Views", Strategic Management Journal, 18(9): 697-713.   DOI
40 Allison, J. R., Lemley, M. A., Moore, K. A. and Trunkey, R. D. (2003), "Valuable Patents", The Georgetown Law Journal, 92: 435.
41 Anand, B. N. and Khanna, T. (2000), "Do Firms Learn to Create Value? The Case of Alliances", Strategic Management Journal, 21(3): 295-315.   DOI
42 Bessen, J. E. and Meurer, M. J. (2005), "The Patent Litigation Explosion", Boston University School of Law Working Paper, (05-18).
43 Bessen, J. E. and Meurer, M. J. (2008), Patent Failure: How Judges, Bureaucrats, and Lawyers Put Innovators at Risk, Princeton University Press.
44 Harhoff, D., Scherer, F. M. and Vopel, K. (2003), "Citations, Family Size, Opposition and the Value of Patent Rights", Research Policy, 32(8): 1343-1363.   DOI
45 Hall, B. H. and Ziedonis, R. H. (2007), "An Empirical Analysis of Patent Litigation in the Semiconductor Industry", University of California at Berkeley Working Paper, 217-242.
46 Hansen, H. C. (2013), Intellectual Property Law and Policy, Bloomsbury Publishing.
47 Harhoff, D., Narin, F., Scherer, F. M. and Vopel, K. (1999), "Citation Frequency and the Value of Patented Inventions", Review of Economics and Statistics, 81(3): 511-515.   DOI
48 Hilbe, J. M. (2011), Negative Binomial Regression, Cambridge University Press.
49 Hill, C. W. (1990), "Cooperation, Opportunism, and the Invisible Hand: Implications for Transaction Cost Theory", Academy of Management Review, 15(3): 500-513.   DOI
50 Pakes, A. (1984), "Patents as Options: Some Estimates of the Value of Holding European Patent Stocks", National Bureau of Economic Research.
51 Park, G. and Park, Y. (2006), "On the Measurement of Patent Stock as Knowledge Indicators", Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 73(7): 793-812.   DOI
52 Patil, B. B., Mishra, S. S. and Mohapatra, Y. N. (2016), "Patent Trends in Printed Electronics and Printed Tags", International Journal of Computer Science and Electronics Engineering, 4(1): 21-24.
53 Bhagat, S., Bizjak, J. and Coles, J. L. (1998), "The Shareholder Wealth Implications of Corporate Lawsuits", Financial Management, 27(4): 5-27.   DOI
54 Powell, W. W., Koput, K. W. and Smith-Doerr, L. (1996), "Interorganizational Collaboration and the Locus of Innovation: Networks of Learning in Biotechnology", Administrative Science Quarterly, 41(1): 116-145.   DOI
55 Reinganum, J. F. (1989), The Timing of Innovation: Research, Development, and Diffusion, Handbook of Industrial Organization, 1: 849-908.
56 Rothaermel, F. T. (2001), "Incumbent's Advantage Through Exploiting Complementary Assets via Interfirm Cooperation", Strategic Management Journal, 22(6-7): 687-699.   DOI
57 Bessen, J. E., Neuhaeusler, P., Turner, J. L. and Williams, J. W. (2015), "Trends in Private Patent Costs and Rents for Publicly-Traded United States Firms", SSRN Working Paper.
58 Bhagat, S., Brickley, J. A. and Coles, J. L. (1994), "The Costs of Inefficient Bargaining and Financial Distress: Evidence From Corporate Lawsuits", Journal of Financial Economics, 35(2): 221-247.   DOI
59 Hu, M. C. (2008), "Knowledge Flows and Innovation Capability: The Patenting Trajectory of Taiwan's Thin Film Transistor-Liquid Crystal Display Industry", Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 75(9): 1423-1438.   DOI
60 Hoang, H. and Rothaermel, F. T. (2005), "The Effect of General and Partner-Specific Alliance Experience on Joint R&D Project Performance", Academy of Management Journal, 48(2): 332-345.   DOI
61 Scherer, F. M. (1965), "Firm Size, Market Structure, Opportunity, and the Output of Patented Inventions", The American Economic Review, 55(5): 1097-1125.
62 Rothaermel, F. T. and Deeds, D. L. (2006), "Alliance Type, Alliance Experience and Alliance Management Capability in High-Technology Ventures", Journal of Business Venturing, 21(4): 429-460.   DOI
63 Saxton, T. (1997), "The Effects of Partner and Relationship Characteristics on Alliance Outcomes", Academy of Management Journal, 40(2): 443-461.   DOI
64 Schankerman, M. and Pakes, A. (1986), "Estimates of the Value of Patent Rights in European Countries During the Post-1950 Period", The Economic Journal, 96(384): 1052-1076.   DOI
65 Scherer, F. M. (2001), The Innovation Lottery, Expanding the Boundaries of Intellectual Property: Innovation Policy for the Knowledge Society, 3(3).
66 Scotchmer, S. (2004), Innovation and Incentives, MIT press.
67 Scott Long, J. (1997), Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent Variables, Advanced Quantitative Techniques in the Social Sciences 7.
68 Simonin, B. L. (1997), "The Importance of Collaborative Know-How: An Empirical Test of the Learning Organization", Academy of Management Journal, 40(5): 1150-1174.   DOI
69 Chien, C. V. (2011), "Predicting Patent Litigation", Texas Law Review, 90: 283.
70 Chen, Y. S. and Chang, K. C. (2010), "The Relationship Between a Firm's Patent Quality and Its Market Value-The Case of US Pharmaceutical Industry", Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 77(1): 20-33.   DOI
71 Chien, C. V. (2012), "Reforming Software Patents", Houston Law Review, 50: 325.
72 Cho, Y., Kim, E. and Kim, W. (2015), "Strategy Transformation Under Technological Convergence: Evidence from the Printed Electronics Industry", International Journal of Technology Management, 67(2-4), 106-131.   DOI
73 Cooter, R. D. and Rubinfeld, D. L. (1989), "Economic Analysis of Legal Disputes and Their Resolution", Journal of Economic Literature, 27(3): 1067-1097.
74 Cremers, K. (2004), "Determinants of Patent Litigation in Germany", ZEW-Centre for European Economic Research Discussion Paper, 4-72.
75 Cyert, R. M. and March, J. G. (1963), A Behavioral Theory of the Firm, Englewood Cliffs NJ 2.
76 Czarnitzki, D. and Kraft, K. (2004), "Innovation Indicators and Corporate Credit Ratings: Evidence from German Firms", Economics Letters, 82(3): 377-384.   DOI
77 Kale, P., Dyer, J. H. and Singh, H. (2002), "Alliance Capability, Stock Market Response, and Long-Term Alliance Success: the Role of the Alliance Function", Strategic Management Journal, 23(8): 747-767.   DOI
78 Ireland, R. D., Hitt, M. A. and Vaidyanath, D. (2002), "Alliance Management as a Source of Competitive Advantage", Journal of Management, 28(3): 413-446.   DOI
79 Jaffe, A. B. (2000), "The US Patent System in Transition: Policy Innovation and the Innovation Process", Research Policy, 29(4): 531-557.   DOI
80 Jaffe, A. B. and Trajtenberg, M. (2002), Patents, Citations, and Innovations: A Window on the Knowledge Economy, MIT Press.
81 Kim, E., Cho, Y. and Kim, W. (2014), "Dynamic Patterns of Technological Convergence in Printed Electronics Technologies: Patent Citation Network", Scientometrics, 98(2): 975-998.   DOI
82 Kingston, W. (2010), Beyond Intellectual Property, Books.
83 Kline, D. (2000), Rembrandts in the Attic: Unlocking the Hidden Value of Patents, Harvard Business Press.
84 Kortum, S. and Lerner, J. (1998), "Stronger Protection or Technological Revolution: What is Behind the Recent Surge in Patenting?", Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 48: 247-304.   DOI
85 Lanjouw, J. O. (1994), "Economic Consequences of a Changing Litigation Environment: The Case of Patents", National Bureau of Economic Research.
86 Stefanadis, C. (1997), "Downstream Vertical Foreclosure and Upstream Innovation", The Journal of Industrial Economics, 45(4): 445-456.   DOI
87 Simonin, B. L. (2000), "Collaborative Know-How and Collaborative Advantage", Global Focus, 12(4): 19-34.
88 Somaya, D. (2003), "Strategic Determinants of Decisions Not to Settle Patent Litigation", Strategic Management Journal, 24(1): 17-38.   DOI
89 Stearns, L. B. and Mizruchi, M. S. (1986), "Broken-Tie Reconstitution and the Functions of Interorganizational Interlocks: A Reexamination", Administrative Science Quarterly, 31(4): 522-538.   DOI
90 Teece, D. J., Pisano, G. and Shuen, A. (1997), "Dynamic Capabilities and Strategic Management", Strategic Management Journal, 18(7): 509-533.   DOI
91 Trajtenberg, M. (1990), "A Penny for Your Quotes: Patent Citations and the Value of Innovations", The RAND Journal of Economics, 21(1): 172-187.   DOI
92 Wassmer, U. and Dussauge, P. (2012), "Network Resource Stocks and Flows: How Do Alliance Portfolios Affect the Value of New Alliance Formations?", Strategic Management Journal, 33(7): 871-883.   DOI
93 Weatherall, K. G. and Webster, E. (2010), "Patent Infringement in Australia: Results from a Survey", Federal Law Review, 38(1): 21-70.   DOI
94 Weatherall, K. G. and Webster, E. (2014), "Patent Enforcement: A Review of The Literature", Journal of Economic Surveys, 28(2): 312-343.   DOI
95 WIPO (2016), "World Intellectual Property Indicators - 2016", http://www.wipo.int/publications/en/series/index.jsp?id=37 (2018.03.21.).
96 Wu, M. F., Chang, K. W., Zhou, W., Hao, J., Yuan, C. C. and Chang, K. C. (2015), "Patent Deployment Strategies and Patent Value in LED Industry", PloS One 10(6): e0129911.   DOI