Browse > Article

Financial Performance Evaluation of Domestic Life Insurers : A Comparison of ELECTREII, SAW and Cluster Analysis  

민재형 (서강대학교 경영학과)
송영민 (서강대학교 경영학연구원 기업성과평가센터)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Operations Research and Management Science Society / v.28, no.4, 2003 , pp. 39-60 More about this Journal
Abstract
In this study, we evaluate financial performance of 21 domestic life insurers using SAW (simple additive weighting), ELECTREII, cluster analysis respectively, and suggest a hybrid approach of combining cluster analysis and ELECTREII to reclassify the life insurers into more meaningful groups according to their respective financial features. We also perform the sensitivity analysis employing ANOVA and Tukey's test to examine the robustness of ELECTREII, which would be influenced by decision maker's subjective preference parameters. Consequently, it is shown that ELECTREII turns out to be a flexible method providing decision makers with useful ranking Information especially under fuzzy decision making situation with incomparable alternatives, and hence it can serve as a complementary method to overcome the weakness of classical cluster analysis.
Keywords
ELECTRE; SAW; Cluster Analysis; Life Insurers; Financial Performance;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 La method ELECTRE II : Une application au media-planning /
[ Roy,B.;P.Bertier;Ross,M.(ed.) ] / Operational Research 1972
2 Multiple Attribute Decision Making /
[ Hwang,C.L.;K.S.Yoon ] / Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems 186
3 MADM(다속성 의사결정 방법)에 의한 신뢰성 평가방법의 선택 /
[ 이명호 ] / 경영학연구
4 Using ELECTRE to Rank Options within an Environmental Appraisal - Two case study /
[ Rogers,M.G.;M.P.Bruen ] / Civil Engineering Systems
5 Ranking of Suburban Line Extension Project on the Paris Metro System by a Multi-criteria Method /
[ Roy,B.;J.Hugonnard ] / Transportation Research Record
6 /
[ 이군희 ] / 사회과학 연구방법론
7 2003년 생명보험 정책과제와 감독방향 /
[ 정채웅 ] / 월간생명보험
8 /
[ Canter,L. ] / Environmental Impack Assessment(2nd ed.)
9 Deciding on How to Decide Best /
[ Cho,K.T.;C.S.Kwon ] / International Journal of Management Science   과학기술학회마을
10 Multi-Attribute Decision Making : A Simulation Comparison of Select Method /
[ Zanakis,S.;A.Solomon;N.Wishart;W.Dublish ] / European Journal of Operational Research   ScienceOn
11 The European School of MCDA : Emergence, Basic Features and Current Works /
[ Roy,B.;D.Vanderpooten ] / Journal of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis
12 Choosing of a Solid Waste Management Systems by Using Multicriteria Decision Analysis /
[ Hokkanen,J.;P,Salminen ] / European Journal of Operational Research   ScienceOn
13 ELECTRE III and IV Decision Aids in an Environmental Problem /
[ Hokkanen,J.;P.Salminen ] / Journal of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis   ScienceOn
14 복합기준 평가방법 ELECTRE의 신뢰도 증진을 위한 방안연구 /
[ 이인성 ] / 한국조경학회지   과학기술학회마을
15 Comparing Multicriteria Methods in Context of Environmental Problems /
[ Salminen,P.;J.Hokkanen;R.Lahdelma ] / European Journal of Operational Research   ScienceOn
16 Multicriteria Analysis of the Impacts of Energy Alternatives : A Survey and a New Approach /
[ Siskos,B.;P.Hubert ] / European Journal of Operational Research   ScienceOn
17 Concordance 분석의 이론과 응용 /
[ 이정전;송명규 ] / 환경논총
18 The Outranking Approach and The Foundation of ELECTRE Methods /
[ Roy,B. ] / Theory and Decision   ScienceOn
19 Classement et Choix en Presence de Points de vue Multiples (La Method ELECTRE) /
[ Roy,B. ] / Revue Informatique et Resherche Operationnelle
20 /
[ Yoon,K.S. ] / Ph.D. Dissertation, Kansas State University
21 A Common Framework for Describing Some Outranking Methods /
[ Pirlot,M. ] / Journal of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis   ScienceOn
22 Decision-aid and Decision-making /
[ Roy,B. ] / European Journal of Operational Research   ScienceOn
23 부정확한 대한평가하에서 모호선호관계를 이용한 다기준 의사결정기법 /
[ 조권익;김성희 ] / 대한산업공학회지
24 Rational System of Preference with one or more Pseudo-criteria /
[ Roy,R.;P.Vincke ] / Management Science   ScienceOn
25 /
[ Vincke,P. ] / Multicriteria Decision-Aid