Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5394/KINPR.2005.29.3.235

The Legal Study on the Demonstration-on-sea  

Lee Kee-Chun (Maritime Police Science Dept., National Korea Maritime University)
Publication Information
Journal of Navigation and Port Research / v.29, no.3, 2005 , pp. 235-244 More about this Journal
Abstract
A new type qf demonstrations in the temporal and spacial aspects, such as accidental and unprepared demonstration, urgent assembly, demonstration-on-sea, demonstration-on-highway, and etc., which are not intended in the Law of Assembly and Demonstration, are becoming a social problem Especially, the law on demonstration-on-sea needs to be discussed further because it is not clear if the Law of Assembly and Demonstration is applicable here. If so, how can it be explained logically? Or, if not so, which law should be applied to this context? So far, various theories on demonstration-on-sea have been opposed aggressively vs. submissively. However, it should be guaranteed that the demonstration on sea is one of the constitutional rights based on the self-decision right of demonstration's place. Accordingly, these contents have to be interpreted with a concept of demonstration in Demonstration's law in coordination with the Constitution. Therefore, it is not persuasive that Demonstration's law is analogized, or general police law is applied, to such untypical demonstrations. In addition, taking into consideration a demonstrative function for minority under modem situation of demonstration, it is right to apply the Law of Assembly and Demonstration to the demonstration-upon-sea directly.
Keywords
Demonstration upon sea; Legal concept of the demonstration; Selfdecisionsright of demonstrationsplace; Communicational right of constitution; Comprehensive clause;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 이관희(2004), 한국민주헌법론 1, pp. 357
2 이관희/강태수(1995), 우리의 집회시위제도 발전방안모색을 위한 각국의 집회시위제도 비교고찰, 치안연구소보고서 95-12, pp. 10
3 해양경찰청백서(2003), pp. 114
4 Dietel, v. A., Gintzel, K., Kniesel, M.(2000), Demonstrations- und Versammlungsfreiheit (Komm.), 12. Aufl
5 Kniesel, M.(2001), Versammlungswesen, in: Lisken, H., Denninger, E., Handbuch des Polizeirechts (Hrsg.), 3. Aufl, S. 55
6 SpieBhofer, B.(1989), Der Storer im allgemeinen und im Sonderpolizeirecht, S. 240
7 양태규(2001), 집시법상의 문제점 및 그 개선방안에 관한 연구 - 건전 시위문화정착측면을 중심으로, 형사정책연구 제12권 제4호, 통권 제48호, pp. 172
8 해양경찰청연감(1997), pp. 366
9 Miiller, W.(1974), Wirkungsbereich und Schranken der Versammlungsfreiheit, insbesondere im Verhaltnis zur Meinungsfreiheit, S. 104-105
10 해양경찰청연감(1998), pp. 395
11 Bergmann, M.(1996), Die Polizeifestigkeit des Versammlungsgeschehens, S. lf
12 김남진/김연태(2004), 행정법 II, pp. 268
13 장인식(2001), 해상 집회.시위의 합리적 규율을 위한 일고찰, 법학연구(전북대학교법학연구소), 제22집, pp. 279
14 해양경찰청연감(1994), pp. 472
15 김동희 (2004), 행정법 II
16 Ossenbiihl, F.(1971), Spontandemonstration, Der Staat 10, S. 53ff(62)
17 김연태(2004), 행정법사례연습 제2판, pp. 729
18 김승환(2003), 집회시위의 자유에 대한 변형적 규제, 서울대학교 BK21법학연구단 공익인권법센터학술대회
19 Kloepfer, M.(2001), Versammlungsfreiheit, Handbuch des Staatsrechts VI, S. 749
20 홍정선(2004), 행정법원론 하, 박영사
21 박정훈(2001), 사권보호륜 위한 경찰권발동을 위한 연구, 치안연구소보고서 2001-05, pp. 22-31
22 Drews, B., Wacke, G., Vogel, K, Martens, W.(2000), Gefahrenabwehr
23 해양경찰청연감(2001), pp. 437-438
24 Schwerdtfeger, G.(1987), 'Leichtigkeit des Verkehrs' als Grenze der Demonstrationsfreiheit, in: GS fur Martens, S. 456
25 허영(2004), 헌법이론과 헌법, pp. 672-676
26 Pieroth, B., Schlink, B.(1999), Grundrechte, Staatsrecht II, 15. Aufl, S.170