Browse > Article

Analysis of Middle School Students' Ability in Estimating Order of Magnitude for physical Quantities  

Suh, Jung-Ah (Dongma middle school)
Jo, Kwang-Hee (Seoul National University)
Pak, Sung-Jae (Science Culture Education Research Institute)
Publication Information
Journal of The Korean Association For Science Education / v.23, no.3, 2003 , pp. 229-238 More about this Journal
Abstract
In this study, we investigated middle school student' ability in estimating order of magnitude of physical quantities. Participants were 448 students of seventh grades and ninth graders in Seoul area. A multiple-choice typed questionnaire was designed for estimating five physical quantities such as length, mass, speed, volume, and density. The answers were analyzed through dimension of quantity, size of object, students' grade and their gender. In the results, more than two thirds of all participants chose the right order of magnitude in estimating length, but only around a quarter of them did so in estimating density. They had a tendency to show lower ability when they estimated order of magnitude of more complex dimensioned quantity. Moreover, students' answers had relatively wide distribution in estimating smaller sized objects. Through there was no big difference between seventh graders and ninth graders in estimation, male students where better in estimating base quantities, especially in length. However, more than half of participants did not choose the right order of magnitude in total and it showed their lack of qualitative understanding about these physical quantities and meaningless usage of unit in measuring.
Keywords
estimation; order of magnitude; physical quantity; middle school student;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 우종옥, 이항로, 이경훈(1992). 대학 수학 능력 시험의 자연과학 탐구 능력 평가를 위한 행동 요소의 추출과 평가 목표의 상세화 연구 II. 한국과학교육학회지, 12(2). 81-95
2 Bright, G. W.(1979). Estimating physical measurement. School Science and Mathematics. 79(8), 581-586   DOI
3 Hughes, D. J.(1959). The Neutron story. 김영덕(역). 서울:현대과학신서 27
4 Kunz, K. S.(1971). Visualizing large numbers. American Journal of Physics, Vol. 39, 452
5 Micklo, S.(1999). Estimation: it' s more than a guess (teaching estimation to grade school students). Childhood Education, 64(2), 203-211
6 Physical Science Study Committee(1965). PSSC Physics. PSSC 번역위원회 옮김. 서울:탐구당
7 Kuhn, T. S.(1962). The Structure of scientific revolution. 김명자(역). 서울:동아출판사
8 권재술, 김범기(1994). 초. 중학생들의 과학탐구능력 측정 도구의 개발. 한국과학교육학회지. 14(3), 251-264
9 Klopfer, L. E.(1971). Evaluation of learning in science. In Bloom, Hastings, & Madaus (Eds). Handbook of Formative and Summative Evaluation of Student Learning. New York: McGraw-Hill
10 서정아(2000). 정량적 물리개념에 대한 어림활동과 측정활동이 문제해결과정에 미치는 영향. 서울대학교 박사학위 논문
11 Steen, L. A.(1997). The new literacy. In L. A. Steen (Eds), Why numbers count. Quantitative Literacy for Tomorrow's America. The College Board
12 Thompson, A. G.(1979). Estimating and Approximating. School Science and Mathematics, 79(8), 575-580   DOI
13 Clement, J.(1982). Students' preconceptions in introductory mechanics. American Journal of Physics, Vol. 50, 66-71   DOI
14 Memory, J. D. & Jenkins, A. W.(1977). Estimating orders of magnitude. The Physics Teacher, Vol. 15,43   DOI
15 김미경, 오희균, 박종원(1996). 물리 탐구 실험의 평가를 위한 도구의 개발과 분석. 한국과학교육학회지, 16(1). 51-60
16 American Association for the Advancement of Science(AAAS)(1974). Science-A Process Approach. Washington; AAAS
17 Schofield, B.(1989). Use of apparatus and measuring instruments. Assessment of Performance Unit. Science at Age 13: A Review of APU Survey findings 1980-84. 55-71. London: Her Majesty's Stationary Office.
18 Morrison, P.(1963). Fermi questions. American Journal of Physics, Vol. 31, 626
19 Rogers, E. M.(1960). Physics for the inquiring mind: the methods, nature, and philosophy of physical science. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University press
20 한국표준과학연구원(1998). 측정불확도 표현 지침. 대전: 한국표준과학연구원
21 김인묵, 엄정인, 최준곤(1997). 최신물리학용어사전. 서울:탐구당
22 Crane, H. R.(1969) Problems for introductory physics. The Physics Teacher, Vol. 7(7), 371-378   DOI
23 한국물리학회(1995). 물리학 용어집. 서울: 청문각
24 APU(1989). Science in Schools. Age 15: Report No.1. Center for Studies in Science Education. University of Leeds
25 Fortgang, A.(1995). The triang le of science. Science Teacher, 62(1), 32-36
26 교육부(1994). 편수자료 III- 기초과학. 서울:대한 교과서주식회사
27 송진웅, 김혜선(2001). 기본 물리량 어림의 정확성 및 방법에 대한 탐색. 한국과학교육학회지. 21(1), 76-88