Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5345/JKIBC.2014.14.3.195

Improvement Plans on Defect Consulting Report in an Apartment Building through Analyzing on Formal Index and Quantitative Index  

Park, Jun-Mo (Institute of Construction Technology, Chungbuk National University)
Seo, Deok-Seok (School of Architecture, Halla University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction / v.14, no.3, 2014 , pp. 195-206 More about this Journal
Abstract
The main issue of defect dispute is consulting, reviewing, and finally judging as an arbiter. A defect consulting is represented a defect consulting report, but a business custom and a standard of judgment are different each consultants, and have many problems. This study reviews literature studies and institutional researches, set up a research structure. it has 7 indexes that 5 indexes are formal indexes, and the other are qualitative indexed. As a result of case study, formal indexes are respect on the whole. However, each appraiser has different ideas, and, is expected to delay on fixing a construction lawsuit practice. This study suggests to improve a defect consulting report, it is followed. In formal part, suggested to change configuration is adjusted and integrated similar items. In qualitative part, an evaluation system for appraiser and an education program for engineers is suggested.
Keywords
apartment building; defect dispute; consulting report system;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 3  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap12544(2). Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
2 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap43523(2). Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
3 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap22936. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
4 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap12544(1). Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
5 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap4672. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
6 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap2065. Korea, Daegu:Daegu district court in Pohang part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
7 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap770. Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
8 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap1215. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
9 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2009gahap103191. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
10 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2007gahap5406. Korea, Busan:Busan district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
11 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2012gahap2503. Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
12 Lee SC. A Study on Solution for Improvement and Case Analysis of Inspective Business in Defects of Apartment Buildings [dissertation]. Changwon (Korea): Kyungnam University; 2011. 170 p
13 Seo DS, Park JM. Analysis of Consulting Reports on Defect Disputes in Apartment Building. Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction. 2013 Oct;13(5):498-505.   과학기술학회마을   DOI
14 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2012gahap5908. Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
15 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2012gahap255. Korea, Cheongju:Cheongju district court in Youngdong part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
16 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011나22407. Korea, Seoul:Seoul high court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
17 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap43523(1). Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
18 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap135900. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
19 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap18099. Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
20 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap14660. Korea, Suwon:Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
21 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap3663. Korea, Incheon:Incheon district court in Bucheon part; 2008.09.19. Korean.
22 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap121881. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
23 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap94231. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
24 Choi JH, Park JM, Seo DS, Jo JH, Park KW, Kim OK. A study on legal issues about defect repair claim on apartment building. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea (Structure & Construction). 2009 Oct;25(11):147-53.   과학기술학회마을
25 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010gahap64100. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
26 Society for construction lawsuit in seoul central district court. Construction Lawsuit Practice. Seoul(Korea): Society for construction lawsuit in seoul central district court; 2011. 248p. Korean.
27 Pak JM, Kim OK, Kim JL. Revitalization of the Concillation System for Defect Disputes Related to Apartment Buildings. Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction. 2011 Jun;11(3):208-20.   DOI
28 Korean Institute of Construction Engineering and Management. A research for judged standard, investigated method and estimated costing of defect in apartment building. Seoul(Korea): Korean Institute of Construction Engineering and Management; c2012. 460 p. Report No. :KICEM2012-06 .Korean.
29 Seoul south district court. Case-No.2007gahap10079. Korea, Seoul:Seoul south district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
30 Yoo BH. A basic process of construction consulting and consulting case of ice thermal storage system. Korean Journal of Air-Conditioning and Refrigeration Engineering. 2007 Jul;36(11):15-22. Korean.
31 Yoon JY. Improvement for optimizing and specializing on deciding of construction lawsuit. Justice. 2009 Dec;114:6-46. Korean.
32 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011gahap38023. Korea, Seoul:Seoul central district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
33 Kim BS, Park JM, Kim OK, Seo DS. Improvement Plan on Appraisal System of Defect Disputes about Cracks on Apartment Buildings. Proceedings of the Korea Institute of Building Construction; 2011 May 20; Busan, Korea. Busan(Korea): the Korea Institute of Building Construction; 2011. p.185-6
34 Construction consulting report. Case-No.2007gahap14076. Korea, Incheon:Incheon district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.