Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5345/JKIC.2010.10.1.101

A Study on the Interpretation Trend of Current Cases for Warranty in U.S.A  

Cho, Young-Jun (중부대학교 건축공학과)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction / v.10, no.1, 2010 , pp. 101-109 More about this Journal
Abstract
Under the Civil Code and related law in Korea, the liability for defects after delivery belongs to the Contractor. However, various disputes have occurred in relation to the remedy of such defects and the compensation for damages, which are the main liability of a contractor in the event of defects. Despite court decisions regarding defect liability, many problems prevail in the real world. For this reason, this working-level research considers the introduction of a performance warranty contract system. To establish the system successfully, it is necessary to analyze the trend of various warranty cases in the US. Therefore, the warranty system of the US was first examined, and the effect of acceptance, notification and burden of proof, remedies under warranty clauses, and default termination were investigated and analyzed in this study.
Keywords
Defect; Liability; Warranty; Cases;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 3  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 USA Case, H. Bendzulla Contracting, Inc., ASBCA 18588, 74-2 BCA, 10,690
2 USA Case, Harwell Constr. Co., ENGBCA PCC-30, 79-2 BCA, 14,061
3 USA Case, Instruments for Indus., Inc., v. United States, 496 F.2d 1157(2d Cir. 1974)
4 USA Case, Inter-West, Ltd., DOTBCA 2238, 92-3 BCA, 25,073
5 USA Case, Jo-Bar Mfg. Corp., ASBCA 17774, 73-2 BCA, 10,311
6 USA Case, Jo-Bar Mfg. Corp., ASBCA 18292, 73-2 BCA, 10,353, recons. denied, 74-1 BCA 10,392
7 USA Case, Joseph Penner, GSBCA 4647, 80-2 BCA, 14,604
8 USA Case, Joseph Penner, GSBCA 4647, 80-2 BCA, 14,604
9 USA Case, Julian A. McDermott Corp., ASBCA 23435, 80-1, 14,210
10 USA Case, Jung Ah Indus. Co., ASBCA 22632, 79-1 BCA, 13,642, recons denied, 79-2 BCA 13,916
11 USA Case, Keco Indus., Inc., ASBCA 13271, 71-1 BCA, 8727
12 USA Case, Kordick & Son, Inc. v. United States, 12 Cl. Ct. 662 (1987)
13 대법원 1995.10.13. 선고 94다31747,31754(반소) 판결 [약속어음금등,손해배상] [공1995.12.1.(1005),3756]
14 대법원 1996.5.14. 선고 95다24975 판결 [공사대금] [공1996.7.1.(13),1841]
15 대법원 1998.3.13. 선고 95다30345 판결 [공사대금] [공1998.4.15.(56),996]
16 대법원 1999.9.21. 선고 99다19032 판결 [하자보수비] [공1999.11.1.(93),2196]
17 대법원 2000.6.9. 선고 2000다15371 판결 [손해배상(기)] [공2000.8.1.(111),1639]
18 대법원 2004.8.20. 선고 2001다70337 판결 [손해배상(기)] [공2004.10.1.(211),1561]
19 서울고법 1983.2.24. 선고 82나3485 제7민사부판결 : 확정 [손해배상청구사건] [고집1983(민사편),163]
20 윤형인, 조병수, 공동주택 하자보증금 청구소송의 연구, 한국건축시공학회 논문집, 제7권 제2호, 통권24호, 2007.6   과학기술학회마을   DOI
21 Andrew Civitello, Jr., Complete Contracting A-Z Guide to Controlling Projects, McGraw-Hill, 1997
22 Bayraktar M. E., Cui Q.B, Hastab M, Minkarah I, State-of Practice of Warranty Contracting in the United States, Journal of Infrastructure Systems, ASCE, Vol.10, No.2
23 Stokes/Finuf, Construction Law for Owners and Builders, McGraw-Hill., New York, pp.116, 1986
24 USA Case, ABM/Ansley Business Materials, GSBCA 9367, 93-1 BCA, 25,246
25 USA Case, Astubeco, Inc., ASBCA 8727, 1963 BCA, 3941
26 USA Case, Atlantic Hardware & Supply Corp., ASBCA 10450, 66-1 BCA, 5378
27 USA Case, Camrex Reliance Paint Co., GSBCA 6166, 83-1 BCA, 16,485
28 USA Case, Cross Aero Corp., ASBCA 15092, 71-2 BCA, 9076
29 김진호, 건설산업에 있어서 제조물책임법의 시행에 따른 영향과 대응방안 기초연구, 한국건축시공학회 논문집, 제4권 제4호, 통권14호, 2004.12   과학기술학회마을   DOI
30 김대정, 영미법에 있어서의 하자담보책임-대륙법과의 비교법적고찰, 首善論叢第14輯, 성균관대학교, 1990.12
31 김태송, 서용칠, 이상법, 구재동, 도로포장 성능보증(Warranty)계약제도 도입방안에 관한 기초연구, 한국건설관리학회 논문집, 제9권 제4호, 통권44호, 2008.8   과학기술학회마을
32 대법원 1980.11.11. 선고 80다923,924 판결 [손해배상등] [공1981.1.1.(647),13366]
33 대법원 1987.11.10. 선고 87다카876 판결 [공사대금] [공1988.1.1.(815),89]
34 대법원 1990.3.9. 선고 88다카31866 판결 [손해배상(기)] [집38(1)민,121;공1990.5.1.(871),859]
35 USA Case, Oklahoma Aerotronics, Inc., ASBCA 25605, 87-2 BCA, 19,917
36 USA Case, Luster-On prods., Inc., ASBCA 23367, 80-2 BCA, 4,777
37 USA Case, Massman Constr. Co., ENGBCA 3443, 81-2 BCA, 15,212
38 USA Case, Mercury Chemical Co., ASBCA 12882, 69-1 BCA, 7769
39 USA Case, Philadelphia Biologics Center, ASBCA 32567, 88-3 BCA, 21,147
40 USA Case, Southwest Welding & Mfg. Co. v. United States, 188 Ct. Cl. 925. 413 F.2d 1167, 1969
41 USA Case, Triple "A" Machine Shop, Inc., ASBCA 16844, 73-1 BCA, 9826
42 USA Case, United Tech. V. United States, 27 Fed. Cl. 393 (1992) recons. denied, 31 Fed. Cl. 698, 1994
43 USA Case, Utley-James, Inc., GSBCA 6831, 88-1 BCA, 20518
44 USA Case, Wickham Contracting Co., ASBCA 32392, 88-2 BCA, 20,559
45 USA Case, Davis v. Hedges(1871), L.R, 6QB. 687 : Stokes/Finuf, Construction Law for Owners and Builders, McGraw-Hill., New York, p.116, 1986
46 USA Case, Ed Dickson Contracting Co., ASBCA 27205, 84-1 BCA, 16,950
47 USA Case, Elliot Consol School Dist. v. Busbroom(1964), 227 F. Supp. 858, S.D. Iowa.
48 USA Case, Ganary Bros., ASBCA 7779, 1963 BCA 3721