Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.15188/kjopp.2015.06.29.3.246

Review on Reliability and Validity of Questionnaire of Pattern Identification in Traditional Chinese Medicine -Using China National Knowledge Infrastructure-  

Yeo, Min Kyung (Mibyeong Research Center, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine)
Dong, Sang Oak (Department of Data Information Science, Dong-eui University)
Lee, Young Seop (Mibyeong Research Center, Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine)
Jang, Eun Su (Department of Diagnostics, College Korean Medicine, Daejeon University)
Publication Information
Journal of Physiology & Pathology in Korean Medicine / v.29, no.3, 2015 , pp. 246-255 More about this Journal
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to investigate the reliability and validity of the questionnaire of pattern identification (PI) in traditional chinese medicine (TCM), through the systematic review of china national knowledge infrastructure (CNKI) database. We searched the articles related with reliability and validity of the questionnaire of PI and published from January 1994 to December 2013. Seventeen questionnaires were analyzed in this study. The twelve (70.6%) questionnaires were developed on the base of specific disease, and five (29.4%) ones were developed on the base of non-specific disease. Three of PI questionnaires showed low inter-item consistency reliability. Exploratory factor analysis of construct validity, content validity, and criterion validity analysis were commonly used on the assessment of validity, but none of them was analysed at the same study. There was only one questionnaire of the ischemic stroke that examined the sensitivity and specificity of both training and test groups in spite of the absence of a gold standard.
Keywords
Pattern Identification; Questionnaire; Reliability; Validity; Traditional Chinese Medicine;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 4  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Jang, W.W., Jung, K.L., Jan, Y.S., Soo, Y.K., Woo, S.S., Park, H.K. The Development of Korean Health Related Quality of Life Scale(KQUOLS)-Testing Reliability and Validity-. Journal of Korean Academy of Family Medicine. 21(3):382-394, 2000.
2 Hwang, I.H. Research Methods of Questionaries. Journal of Korean Academy of Family Medicine. 15(1):30-35, 1994.
3 Kang, H.C. A Guide on the Use of Factor Analysis in the Assessment of Construct Validity. Korean Society of Nursing Science. 43(5):587-594, 2013.
4 Cha, Y.J., Kim, K. Reliability and Validity of the Korean Version of the Fear of Daily Activities Questionnaire for Patients with Low Back Pain. Journal of the Korea Contents Association. 11(5):224-232, 2011.   DOI   ScienceOn
5 Hair, J.F. Jr., Anderson, R.E., Tatham, R.L. & Black, W.C. Multivariate Data Analysis (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. 1995.
6 Lee, K.H., Shin, S.J. Validity of Instrument Development Research in Korean Nursing Research. Korean Society of Nursing Science. 43(6):697-703, 2013.
7 Lu, M., Wang, M.Q. Analysis on Reliability and Validity of Deficiency-Cold Questionnaire. Journal of Liaoning University of TCM. 11(12):53-55, 2009.
8 Chen, Z.Q., Guo, Q., Liu, X.Z., Fu, Q.Y. Preliminary Development and Evaluation of Scales for the Four Mainly Syndromes in Liver Disease of Traditional Chinese Medicine. China Medical Engineering. 15(8):660-664, 2007.
9 Lu, M., Ding, W.J., Yan, S.L., Wang, M.Q., Chen, W. Reliability and Validity Study on the Scale of Deficiency of Kidney-Yang in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Liaoning Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 33(10):1220-1222, 2006.
10 Wang, J., Yao, K.W., Zhong, J.B., Wu, J.T., Fang, J.Z., Zhu, C.L., Wang, Q.R., Wang, Z.Y. Study of the Scale Based on Clinical Epidemiology for Blood Stasis Pattern. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 49(3):270-272, 2008.
11 Zhang, F.R., Zhao, P. Process in Scale Research of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 23(10):1812-1815, 2005.
12 China Association of Chinese Medicine. Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Internal Diseases in Chinese Medicine Symptoms in Chinese Medicine. Beijing:China Press of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2012.
13 China Association of Chinese Medicine. Guidelines for Diagnosis and Treatment of Common Internal Diseases of Modem Medicine. Beijing:China Press of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2012.
14 Tian F., Xie, Y.M., Yi, D.H., Wu, K., Li, J.P., Cui, Q.R. Reliability and Validity Analysis on Risk Factor and Syndrome Questionnaire of Postmenopausal Osteoporosis in 40~65 Years’ Old Women. Chinese Journal of Basic Medicine in Traditional Chinese Medicine. 18(6):609-611, 2012.
15 Kim, G.G., Kim, J.W., Lee, E.J., Choi, S.M., Cho, M.H., Kim, D.J., Lee, S.Y. Study on the Development of Sasang Constitutional Classification Function using Discriminant Analysis Model, I: Variable Selection in Cronbach Alpha Coefficient. Journal of the Korean Data Analysis Society. 6(2):493-504, 2004.
16 Zhou, J.W., Zhang, F., Li, C.Y., Wang, M. Development and Evaluation of Validity of the Disease and Pattern Combined Scale on Nerve-root Cervical Spondylosis. Sichuan Medical Journal. 27(8):777-779, 2006.
17 Le, M., Huang, X., Gao, Y.Q. Establishment of Measurement Scale for Spleen Deficiency Syndrome in Chronic Hepatitis B. Shanghai Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 42(3):6-9, 2008.
18 Zhou, J.W., Zhang, F., Li, C.Y., Wang, M. Development and Evaluation of Reliability of the Disease and Pattern Combined Scale on Nerve-root Cervical Spondylosis. Journal of Sichuan of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 24(8):31-33, 2006.
19 Wang, Z., Hu, S.Y., Chen, Z.Q., Chen, Z.G. Preliminary Development of the Concision Depression Symptoms Rating Scale of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Chinese Journal of Behavioral Medical Science. 14(10):945-947, 2005.
20 Wang, X.F., Dong, D., Linag, M.X., Zhang, B., Lv, Y.X., Jiang, Z.Y., Cui, Z.Z., Li, Y.N., Liu, X.F., Xu, Y.J., Huang, Y., Zhang, M.W. Reliability and Validity Study on the Scale of Differentiation of Symptoms and Specification of Traditional Chinese Medicine in Children Pneumonia by Data Excavation Technique. Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Pediatrics. 5(1):15-24, 2010.
21 Tang, B.Q., Zhang, T.S., Huang, H.Y., Shi, K.H., Wang, L.X., Yu, X., Fang, H., Wu, Y.G. Establishment of TCM Syndrome Measuring Scale Based on Patient Reported Outcome of Refractory Post-infectious Cough. Shanghai Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 46(4):13-15, 2012.
22 Liu, G.P., Wang, Y.Q., Dong, Y., Zhao, N.Q., Xu, Z.X., Li, F.F., Yan, H.X., Qian, P., Guo, R., Zhang, X.D., Di, D. Development and Evaluation of an Inquiry Scale for Diagnosis of Heart System Syndromes in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine. 7(1):20-24, 2009.   DOI
23 Gao, Y., Ma, B., Liu, Q., Wang, Y.Y. Methodological Study and Establishment of the Diagnostic Scale for TCM Syndromes of Ischemic Stroke. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 52(24):2097-2101, 2011.
24 Zhang, T.S., Tang, B.Q., Zhang, S., LI, X.J., Yang, K.M., Wu, Y.G. Development and Evaluation of TCM Syndrome Measuring Scale Based on Patient Reported Outcome Instrument for Chronic Cough with Unknown Causes. Journal of Liaoning University of TCM. 12(8):113-115, 2010.
25 Tang, B.Q., Zhang, T.S., Huang, H.Y., Shi, K.H., Wang, L.X., Yu, X., Liu, F., Fang, H., Wu, Y.G. Preliminary Construction of TCM Syndrome Measuring Scale Based on Patient Reported Outcome Instrument for Post-infectious Cough. Liaoning Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 40(6):1103-1105, 2013.
26 Gao, Y., Ma, B., Liu, Q., Zhong. H., Huang, Y. Clinical Validation of the Diagnostic Scale for TCM Syndromes of Ischemic Stroke. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 51(1):23-25, 2012.
27 Dai, X., Guo, W. Analysis of Reliability and Validity of Deficiency of Kidney “QI” Identification Scale for Elderly Hypertention. Lishizhen Medicine and Materia Medica Research. 21(9):2324-2326, 2010.
28 Hu, S.Y., Jin, Y.Q. Thinking on the Assessment of Clinical Therapeutic Effectiveness of TCM. Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine. 25(1):72-75, 2005.
29 Guo, Q., Chen, Z.Q., Liu, X.Z., Shen, D.Z. Preliminary Development and Evaluation of the Scale for Primary Hypertension with Excessive Rise of Liver-yang. Chinese Journal of Clinical Rehabilitation. 10(43):20-23, 2006.
30 Guo, Q., Chen, Z.Q., Liu, X.Z., Shen, D.Z. Preliminary Development and Evaluation of Scale for Chronic Hepatitis B with Type of Damp-Heat in Liver and Gallbladder. Chinese Journal of Information on TCM. 14(7):9-12, 2007.
31 Song, N.K., Kim, J.K., Shin, S.H., Kim, Y.H., Hwang, G.D., Ahn, K.S., Choi, S.M. A Study for the Objective Diagnosis by Statistical Analysis to the Bian Zheng Questionnaire. Korean Journal of Oriental Medicine. 11(1):127-138, 2005.
32 Beattie P., Maher C. The Role of Functional Status Questionnaires for Low Back Pain. Aust J Physiother. 43(1):29-38, 1997.   DOI
33 Haywood, K.L. Patient Reported OutcomeⅠ:Measuring What Matters in Musculoskeletal Care. Musculoskeletal Care. 4(4):187-203, 2006.   DOI   ScienceOn
34 Kim, K.K., Seo, B.N., Kang, W.C., Jung, I.C. Guidelines for the Reliability and Validity of the Instrument on Pattern Identifications for Hwa-byung. Journal of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 24(4):331-342, 2013.   DOI   ScienceOn
35 Koo, B.S., Lee, S.J., Han, C.H., Kim, H.J., Park, S.H. The Basic Study for Building the Depression Prescription Guideline of Gamiguibi-Tang -The Evaluation of Reliability and Validity of the Depression Pattern-Identification Questionnaire-. Journal of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 20(4):1-13, 2009.
36 Bae, N.S., Park, Y.J., Oh, H.S., Park, Y.B. Preceding Studies for Questionnaires on Han-Yol Patternization. The Journal of the Korea Institute of Oriental Medical Diagnostics. 9(1):98-111, 2005.
37 Lee, S.J., Park, J.B., Lee, S.S., Kim, K.H. Development of Yin-Deficiency Questionnaire and Examine the Reliability and Validity. Korean Journal of Oriental Physiology & Pathology. 18(2):376-380, 2004.
38 Lee, I.S., Kim, J.W., Chi, G.Y., Lee, Y.T., Kim, K.K. Reliability Study for Upgrade of Diagnosis System of Oriental Medicine DSOM(r) S.1.1. Korean Journal of Oriental Physiology & Pathology. 26(1):88-97, 2012.
39 Huang, C., Song, W.X. Study on Questionnaire and Scale of Pattern Identification in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 29(4):889-891, 2011.
40 Gu, Z.H., Wu, X.F., Wu, Y.L. Review and Outlook on Standardization Study of Pattern in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 48(8):751-754, 2007.
41 Yu, W.Y., Lu, A.P., Han, X.J., Shi, N.N., Wang, L.Y., Wang, Y.P., Wang, Y.Y. Exploration on Syndrome Differentiation Standardization of Chinese Medicine Diagnosis and Treatment Technologies. Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine. 31(10):1419-1421, 2011.
42 Yang, K.S., Choi, S.H., Choi, S.M., Park, K.M., Jeong, W.Y., Ahn, K.S., Eom, H.S., Kim, S.H., Jeon, B.H., Kim, J.B., Kwon, Y.K., Park, J.H., Kim, D.H., Jang, H.O., Kim, S.W., Shin, S.H., Shin, S.W., Ko, H. Standardization and Unification of the Terms and Conditions Used for Diagnosis in Oriental Medicine Ⅱ. Korean Journal of Oriental Medicine. 2(1):381-401, 1996.
43 Park, Y.J., Park, Y.B. A Study on Standardization of Bian Zheng by Some Statistical Methods. The Journal of the Korea Institute of Oriental Medical Diagnostics. 5(2):306-330, 2001.