Browse > Article

A Study on Developing the Performance Audit Methodology for Performance Evaluation of Transportation Planning Process  

Lee, Yong-Taek (감사원)
O, Chang-Seok (감사원 감사연구원)
Publication Information
Journal of Korean Society of Transportation / v.29, no.2, 2011 , pp. 47-58 More about this Journal
Abstract
Nowaday OECD countries actively introduce the performance audit to evaluate the performance of public policies. Motivated by the current trend in practice, this paper presents performance audit indices and methodology developed for evaluating the transportation investment projects and policies. The main contribution of this study would be twofold:1) key performance indices, 5Es + 4Cs rule, and methodology of performance audit are derived from foreign (GAO, NAO) and domestic (BAI) audit reports; 2) checklists (key issues and focuses) of performance audit are suggested as ranks. It is also suggested that further studies are needed to maintain the indices and the methodology to achieve sustainable performance of transportation projects and policies.
Keywords
Transportation Audit; Performance Evaluation; Performance Audit; Importance Performance Analysis; 5E(Efficiency, Economy, Effectiveness, Equity, Environmental Sustainability)-4C(Causality, Continuing, Cooperative, Comprehensive) rules;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 NAO(2009b), The Department for Transport : The failure of Metronet
2 OECD(2002), OECD Guidelines towardsEnvironmentally Sustainable Transport
3 NAO(2009a), Reviews of Value for Money savings reported by the Department for Transport and the Home Office
4 NAO(2008), Transport and Environment : Options for Scrutiny
5 GAO(2007), Intermodal Transportation: DOT Could Take Further Actions to Address Intermodal Barriers, GAO-07-718
6 NAO(2005a), Maintaining and improving Britain's railway stations
7 NAO(2008a), The Department for Transport - Letting Rail Franchises 2005-2007
8 NAO(2009), Improving road safety for pedestrians and cyclists in Great Britain
9 GAO(2009d), Recovery Act: States' Use of Highway Infrastructure Funds and Compliance with the Act's Requirements, GAO-09-926T
10 NAO(2005), Delivery Chain Analysis for Bus Services in England
11 GAO(2008), Physical Infrastructure: Challenges and Investment Options for the Nation's Infrastructure, GAO-08-763T
12 이용택, 오창석(2010), "교통시설 투자개선을 위한 선진 교통감사기법 및 사례연구", 감사연구원.
13 감사원(2006), "물류거점 항만운영 및 확충실태" 최종보고서.
14 감사원(2007), "항공안전 관리실태" 최종보고서.
15 고승영․오동규(2010), "국내․외 교통정책 동향 및 감사 시사점", 감사연구원 자문용역 보고서, pp. 21-33, 43-48
16 도철웅(1998), "교통공학원론(하)", 청문각.
17 문태식(2006), "성과평가의 이론과 실제-지방정부 업무를 중심으로", 미국U.C.Berkekey 동아시아 연구소 연수보고서
18 DFT(2006), The Eddington Transport Study.
19 감사원(2008), "대형 항만건설사업 추진실태" 최종보고서.
20 감사원(2007a), "국가기간도로망구축 및 운영실태 감사" 최종보고서.
21 GAO(2009b), Federal Energy and Fleet Management: Plug-in Vehicles Offer Potential Benefits, but High Costs and Limited Information Could Hinder Integration into the Federal Fleet, GAO-09-493
22 GAO(2005), Highway And Transit Investments: Options for Improving Information on Projects' Benefits and Costs and Increasing Accountability for Results, GAO-05-172
23 GAO(2009a), Transportation Programs: Challenges Facing the Department of Transportation and Congress and Operations, GAO-09-435T
24 감사원(2009), "민간투자사업 추진실태" 최종보고서.
25 감사원(2009a), "국가기간철도망 구축 및 운영실태" 최종보고서.
26 감사원(2009b), "국도건설사업 추진실태" 최종보고서.
27 GAO(2009), National Airspace System: FAA Reauthorization Issues are Critical to System Transformation and Operations, GAO-09-377T
28 감사연구원(2010), "국내외 교통정책 동향 및 감사시사점", 감사연구원 자문용역보고서.
29 GAO(2008a), Surface Transportation: Principles Can Guide Efforts to Restructure and Fund Federal Programs, GAO-08-744T
30 GAO(2008b), Traffic Safety Programs: Progress, States' Challenges, and Issues for Reauthorization, GAO-08-990T
31 GAO(2009c), Transportation Security: Key Actions Have Been Taken to Enhance Mass Transit and Passenger Rail Security, but Opportunities Exist to Strengthen Federal Strategy and Programs, GAO-09-678