Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.9708/jksci.2014.19.7.151

A study on the Necessity of the Death Penalty in the Information Society -Focused on the misjudgement cases-  

Lee, Dong-Myung (Dept. of law, Honam University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korea Society of Computer and Information / v.19, no.7, 2014 , pp. 151-159 More about this Journal
Abstract
Sometimes, the misjudgement of imperfect human can not be avoided because capital punishment is decided by a judicial officer, human. Dreiinstanzen system has been adopted to prevent misjudgement. However the possibility of misjudgement can not be entirely excluded in the judgement by a judicial officer as the judgement of a lower court and a higher tribunal depends on the specific criminal cases. And in case of capital punishment executed by misjudgement, it leads to a cruelty result which has not ways to recover the damage. There is an opinion that dangerousness of misjudgement is lacking in persuasiveness because of insufficient demonstration for the abolition of capital punishment. However, also, there is an opinion that the abolition of capital punishment in case of misjudgement is persuasive with reality. In this case, even if other punishments are discussed separately, once capital punishment is executed, it can be irrevocable unjustice because a nation itself commits a crime. According to this, I would like to find out causes of misjudgement in the criminal justice system through the cases of advanced countries, such as United states, Japan, which are rich in studies and case analysis related to misjudgement, and introduce their efforts to prevent misjudgement in this paper.
Keywords
capital punishment; legitimacy; abolition; human rights;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Mae Saka Toshiyuki, "Wrongful Convictions of the Death Penalty", Freedom and Justice, 36(10), p 26-33, 1985
2 Han, iN-Sub, "the problem and improvement scheme of capital punishment". criminal case policy, 5, Korea criminal case policy institute, p. 41, 1990.
3 Oh, Young-kueon, "A historical study on the dispute for maintenance or abolition of capital punishment", International remission committee Korea communication committee, The theory and reality of capital punishment system, Ccachi publisher, pp. 47-49.1989.
4 Llompart Jose, Kanazawa Fumio, Law and Morality : the theory and practice, Tokyo, Seibundoh, p 121, 1973
5 Dongaillbo, p.2, 1985. 12. 20.
6 National human right committee, researching people's consciousness on capital punishment, p. 200, 2003.
7 Bu, Taek Hoon, "A study on the relief of misjudgement and retrial system : focused on the capital punishment case ", doctorate paper, Graduate school DaeJoen University, p. 65, 2001.
8 past affairs arrangement committee for truth and compromise, Total report of truth and compromise committee I, pp. 192-193, 2010.
9 Supreme Court 1982. 9. 14, 82do1479.
10 Seoul Jungang District Court 2012. 10. 22, 2011do14.
11 Supreme Court of Japan 1955. 6. 22. Showa26 1688.
12 Supreme Court 2011. 1. 20, 2008do11.
13 Supreme Court 1975. 4. 8, 74do3233.
14 Sherrer, Hans, Illinois Governor George Ryan Pardoned Four Innocent Men Condemned to Death On January 10, 2003, and the Next Day He Cleared Illinois' Death Row, Justice Denied Magazine January 31, 2003.
15 http://www.innocenceproject.org/Content/David_Vasquez.php.
16 DeClue, G. Psychological consultation in cases involving interrogations and confessions, 33 Journal of Psychiatry & Law, 2005, pp. 313-366.   DOI
17 Supreme Court of Japan 1957. 7. 19. Showa26 1770.
18 Supreme Court of Japan 1968. 10. 25. Showa41 108.
19 High Court in Hiroshima 1972. 12. 14. Showa45 193.
20 Kassin, S. M., Drizin, S. A., Grisso, T., Gudjonsson, G. H., Leo, R. A., & Redlich, A. D. Police-induced confessions: Risk factors and recommendations. Law & Human Behavior. 34(1), pp. 3-38, 2010.   DOI
21 The Secretariat of the National Assembly, The 252th, the assembly records of international legislation judicature committee, issue 1, pp. 14-15, 2005. 02. 18.
22 Wagenarr, van Koppen, & Crombag, 1993(Lee, Kang-Cheon "A study on the Necessity of the Abolition of Capital Punishment and its Alternatives", Department of Law, Graduate School Honam University, 2013).
23 You, Ji Young, "A study on the abolition of capital punishment", doctorate paper, Graduate school Joong Ang University, pp. 137-138, 1995.