Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5303/JKAS.2004.37.1.015

ON THE PHYSICAL BASIS OF THE TULLY-FISHER RELATION  

RHEE MYUNG-HYUN (Yonsei University Observatory, Yonsei University)
Publication Information
Journal of The Korean Astronomical Society / v.37, no.1, 2004 , pp. 15-39 More about this Journal
Abstract
We analyse the results of mass models derived from the HI rotation! curves of spiral galaxies and find that the slope of the luminous mass-circular velocity relation is close to 4. The luminous mass-circular velocity relation with a slope of about 4 can be explained by an anti-correlation between the mass surface density of luminous matter and the mass ratio of the dark and luminous components. We also argue that the conspiracy between luminous and dark matter exists in a local sense (producing a flat or smooth rotation curve) and in a global sense (affecting the mass ratio of the dark and luminous matter), maintaining the luminous mass-circular velocity relation with a slope of about 4. We therefore propose that the physical basis of the Tully-Fisher relation lies in the luminous mass-circular velocity relation. While the slope of the luminous mass-circular velocity relation is fairly well defined regardless of the dark matter contribution, the zero-point of the relation is still to be determined. The determination of the slope of the Tully-Fisher relation needs one more step: the mean trend of the luminosity-luminous mass relation determines the overall shape (slope) of the Tully-Fisher relation. The key parameter needed to determine the zero-point of the luminous mass-circular velocity relation and the slope of the Tully-Fisher relation obviously is the luminous mass-to-light ratio.
Keywords
galaxies: distances and redshift; galaxies: fundamental parameters; galaxies: kinematics and dynamics; galaxies: spiral; distance scale;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Zaritsky, D., 1992, The radial distribution of oxygen in disk galaxies, ApJ, 390, L73   DOI
2 H I and mass distribution in the dwarf 'regular' galaxy UGC 2259 /
[ Carignan,C.;Sancisi,R.;van Albada,T.S. ] / AJ   DOI
3 Optical and H I studies of the gas-rich dwarf irregular galaxy DDO 154 /
[ Carignan,C.;Beaulieu,S. ] / ApJ   DOI
4 /
[ Bottema,R. ] / private communication
5 A technique for determining the extragalactic distance scale /
[ Chiba,M.;Yoshi,Y. ] / ApJ   DOI
6 A modification of the Newtonian dynamics as a possible alternative to the hidden mass hypothesis /
[ Milgrom,M. ] / ApJ   DOI
7 Evidence against Dissipationless Dark Matter from OBservations of Galaxy Haloes /
[ Moore,B. ] / Nature   DOI
8 /
[ Rhee,M.H. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen   DOI
9 The dark matter content of spiral galaxies /
[ Salucci,P.;Ashman,K.M.;Persic,M. ] / ApJ   DOI
10 Mass discrepancies in galaxies - Dark matter and alternatives /
[ Sanders,R.H. ] / A & AR   DOI
11 CO observations of edge-on galaxies. 5. NGC 5907: Central deficiency of gas in an SC galaxymerger in the bulge? /
[ Sofue,Y. ] / PASJ
12 A new method of determining distances ot galaxies /
[ Tully,R.B.;Fisher,J.R. ] / A & A   DOI
13 Distribution of dark matter in the spiral galaxy NGC 3198 /
[ van Albada,T.S.;Bahcall,J.N.;Begeman,K.;Sancisi,R. ] / ApJ   DOI
14 The radial distribution of oxygen in disk galaxies /
[ Zaritsky,D. ] / ApJ   DOI
15 Surface photometry of the sculptor group galaxies- NGC 7793, NGC 247, and NGC 300 /
[ Carignan,C. ] / ApJS   DOI
16 /
[ Freedman,W.L.;Lee,M.C.;Madore,B.F. ] / unpublished   DOI   ScienceOn
17 /
[ Huchtmeier,W.K.;Richter,O.G. ] / A General Catalog of HI Observations of Galaxies   DOI
18 Rotation velocities of 16 SA galaxies and a comparison of Sa, Sb, and SC rotation properties /
[ Rubin,V.C.;Burstein,D.;Ford,W.K.Jr;Thonnard,N. ] / ApJ   DOI
19 Can the Tully-Fisher Relation Be the Result of Initial Conditions? /
[ Eisenstein,D.J.;Loeb,A. ] / ApJ   DOI
20 /
[ Wevers,B.H.M.R. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen   DOI
21 Bias properties of extragalactic distance indicators. 3: Analysis of Tully-Fisher distances for the Mathewson-Ford-Buchhorn sample of 1355 galaxies /
[ Federspiel,M.;Sandage,A.;Tammann,G.A. ] / ApJ   DOI
22 On the Cepheid variables of the nearby irregular galaxy NGC 3109 /
[ Capaccioli,M.;Piotto,G.;Bresolin,F. ] / AJ   DOI
23 Deep CCD photometry of spiral galaxies /
[ Broeils,A.H.;Knapen,J.H. ] / A & AS
24 A Stratified Framework for Scalar- Tensor Theories of Modified Dynamic /
[ Sanders,R.H. ] / ApJ   DOI   ScienceOn
25 /
[ Bottema,R. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen
26 /
[ Lemson,G. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen   DOI
27 The luminosity-velocity diagram- A new distance estimator for spiral galaxies /
[ Madore,B.F.;Wood,D. ] / ApJ   DOI
28 iA catalog of 2810 nearby galaxies-The effect of the Virgocentric flow model on their observed velocities /
[ Kraan Korteweg,R.C. ] / A & AS   DOI
29 /
[ Faber,S.M.;Bruck,H.A.(eds.);Coyne,G.V.(eds.);Longair,M.S.(eds.) ] / Aatronomical Cosmology   DOI
30 H I studies of the Sculptor group galaxies /
[ Carignan,C.;Puche,D. ] / AJ   DOI
31 The density and peculiar velocity fields of nearby galaxies /
[ Strauss,M.A.;Willick,J.A. ] / Physics Reports   DOI
32 Dark halos formed via dissipationless collapse. I - Shapes and alignment of angular momentum /
[ Warren,M.S.;Quinn,P.J.;Salmon,J.K.;Zurek,W.H. ] / ApJ   DOI
33 The mass distribution of the dwarf spiral NGC 1560 /
[ Broeils,A.H. ] / A & A
34 A southern sky survey of the peculiar velocities of 1355 spiral galaxies /
[ Mathewson,D.S;Ford,V.L.;Buchhorn,M. ] / ApJS   DOI
35 The dark side of NGC 3109 /
[ Jobin,M.;Carignan,C. ] / AJ   DOI
36 The distribution of dark matter in the dwarf galaxy DDO 170 /
[ Lake,G.;Schommer,R.A.;Gorkom,J.H. ] / AJ   DOI
37 H I studies of the Sculptor group galaxies /
[ Puche,D.;Carignan,C.;Bosma,A. ] / AJ   DOI
38 An extragalactic data base. Ⅱ- The HI data /
[ Bottinelli,L.;Gouguenheim,L.;Fouque,P.;Paturel,G. ] / A & AS
39 Cold dark matter. 2: Spatial and velocity statistics /
[ Gelb,J.M.;Bertschinger,E. ] / ApJ   DOI
40 Teh Infrared Tully-Fisher Relation in the Ursa Major Cluster /
[ Peletier,R.F.;Willner,S.P. ] / ApJ   DOI   ScienceOn
41 Photometric studies of composite stellar systems. I-CO and JHK observations of E and S0 galaxies /
[ Frogel,J.A.;Persson,S.E.;Mathews,K.;Aaronson,M. ] / ApJ   DOI
42 Measuring the Hubble Constant with the Hubble Space Telescope /
[ Kennicutt,R.C.;Freedman,W.L.;Mould,J.R. ] / AJ   DOI
43 /
[ Freeman,K.C.;Thuan,T.X.(et al.) ] / Physis of Nearby Galaxies: Nature or Nurture? Editions Frontieres
44 The Discovery of Cepheids and a New Distance ot M101 Using the it Hubble Space Telescope /
[ Kelson,D.D.(et al.) ] / BAAS   DOI
45 H I rotation curves of spiral galaxies. I-NGC 3198 /
[ Begeman,K.G. ] / A & A
46 Extended rotation curves of spiral galaxies - Dark haloes and modified dynamics /
[ Begeman,K.G.;Broeils,A.H.;Sanders,R.H. ] / MNRAS   DOI
47 Biased clustering in the cold dark matter cosmogony /
[ Cole,S.;Kaiser,N. ] / MNRAS   DOI
48 Basic parameters of dark halos in late-type spirals /
[ Carignan,C.;Freeman,K.C. ] / ApJ
49 Mass Decomposition of Spiral Galaxies from Disc Kinematics /
[ Persic,M.;Salucci,P. ] / MNRAS   DOI
50 Tests of the Tully-Fisher relation. 1: Scatter in infrared magnitude versus 21 CM width /
[ Bernstein,G.M.;Guhathakurta,P.;Raychaudhury,S.;Giovanelli,R.;Haynes,M.P.;Herter,T.;Vogt,N.P. ] / AJ   DOI
51 An analytical model for spherical galaxies and bulges /
[ Hernquist,L. ] / ApJ   DOI
52 On the local mass to light ratio in galaxies /
[ Petrou,M. ] / MNRAS   DOI
53 /
[ Djorgovski,S. ] / Cosmology and Large-Scale Structure in the Universe   DOI
54 /
[ de Jong,R.S. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen
55 New Cepheid distances to nearby galaxies based on BVRI CCD photometry /
[ Freedman,W.L.;Madore,B.F.;Hawley,S.L.;Horowitz,I.K.;Mould,J.;Navarrete,M.;Sallmen,S. ] / ApJ   DOI
56 The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos /
[ Navarro,J.F.;Frenk,C.X.;White,D.M. ] / ApJ   DOI   ScienceOn
57 Radio observations of H I in UGC 2885 /
[ Roelfsema,P.R.;Allen,R.J. ] / A & A
58 Keck Spectroscopy and Hubble Space Telescope Imaging of Field Galaxies at Moderate Redshifti /
[ Forbes,D.A.;Philips,A.C.;Koo,D.C.;Illingworth,G.D. ] / ApJ   DOI
59 /
[ Broeils,A.H. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen
60 Dark matter in spiral galaxies /
[ van Albada,T.S.;Sancisi,R. ] / Phil.Trans. R. Soc. London Ser. A.   DOI
61 /
[ Allen,C.W. ] / Astrophysical Quantities
62 CCD surface photometry of field galaxies /
[ Kent,S.M. ] / ApJS   DOI
63 The Hubble Space Telescope Extragalactic Distan /
[ Freedman,W.L.(et al.) ] / ApJ   DOI
64 Dark matter in spiral galaxies. I-Galaxies with optical rotation curves /
[ Kent,S.M. ] / AJ   DOI
65 Recalibration of the H_<TEX>$_0.5$</TEX> magnitudes of spiral galaxies /
[ Tormen,G.;Burstein,D. ] / ApJS   DOI   ScienceOn
66 Halo parameters of spiral galaxies /
[ Athanassoula,E.;Bosma,A.;Papaioannou,S. ] / A & A
67 Surface photometry of six local group galaxies /
[ Kent,S.M. ] / AJ   DOI
68 Measuring galaxy distances from optical rotation curves /
[ Schommer,R.A.;Bothun,G.D.;Williams,T.B.;Mould,J.R. ] / AJ   DOI
69 The structure of cold dark matter halos /
[ Dubinski,J.;Carlberg,R.G. ] / ApJ
70 The Cepheid distance scale /
[ Madore,B.F.;Freedman,W.L. ] / PASP   DOI
71 The star formation law in galactic disks /
[ Kennicutt,R.C. ] / ApJ   DOI
72 A Recipe for Galaxy Formatio /
[ Cole,S.;Aragon-Salamanca,A.;Frenk,C.S.;Navarro,J.F.;Zepf,S.E. ] / MNRAS   DOI
73 Star formation rates and abundance gradientis in disk galaxies /
[ Wyse,R.F.G.;Silk,J. ] / ApJ   DOI
74 /
[ Begeman,K.G. ] / Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen
75 A dark-halodominated galaxy- NGC 5585 /
[ Cote,S.;Carignan,C.;Sancisi,R. ] / AJ   DOI
76 Luminosity-line width relations and the extragalactic distance scale /
[ Pierce,M.J.;Tull,R.B. ] / ApJ   DOI
77 The infrared luminosity/H I velocity-width relation and its application to the distance scale /
[ Aaronson,M.;Huchra,J.P.;Mould,J.R. ] / ApJ   DOI
78 Modified Dynamics / MOND / as a Dark Halo /
[ Sanders,R.H.;Begeman,K.G. ] / MNRAS   DOI   ScienceOn
79 H I studies of the Sculptor group galaxies. Ⅲ - NGC 55 /
[ Puche,D.;Carignan,C.;Wainscoat,R.J. ] / AJ   DOI
80 The extragalactic distance scale. I-Corrections to fundamental observables /
[ Tully,R.B.;Fouque,P. ] / ApJS
81 /
[ Djorgovski,S.;de Carvalho,R.;Han,M.S.;van den Bergh S.(eds.);Pritchet,C.J.(eds.) ] / The Extragalactic Distance Scale
82 Dark matter distribution and the HI-H-alpha connection in IC 257 /
[ Martimbeau,N.;Carignan,C. ] / AJ   DOI
83 The pattern speed in the SB0 galaxy NGC 936 /
[ Kent,S.M. ] / AJ   DOI
84 H I studies of the Sculptor group galaxies. IV-NGC 247 /
[ Carignan,C.;Puche,D. ] / AJ   DOI