Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5392/JKCA.2022.22.08.660

Methodological Quality Evaluation of a Meta-Analysis Study of Rehabilitation Treatment Interventions for Stroke Patients in Korea Applying AMSTAR-2: Focusing on Upper Extremity Function and Recovery of Daily Life  

Hwang, Ho-Sung (건양대학교 일반대학원 작업치료학과)
Ham, Min-Joo (강원대학교 작업치료학과)
Publication Information
The Journal of the Korea Contents Association / v.22, no.8, 2022 , pp. 660-670 More about this Journal
Abstract
This study was analyzed by applying AMSTAR-2, a methodological quality evaluation tool, to evaluate the quality of domestic meta-analysis papers on rehabilitation interventions for stroke patients. The purpose of this study is to provide guidelines for qualitative improvement of evidence-based practice and meta-analysis research by analyzing the qualitative level of the analyzed research. The literature search was conducted using the Research Information Sharing Service, Korean Medical database, and Korean studies Information Service System. Two authors searched, extracted, and reviewed literature using the keywords 'stroke' and 'meta-analysis'. As a result of the AMSTAR-2 quality evaluation of the final 18 studies, 3 studies (16.67%) were 'Moderate', 8 studies (44.44%) were 'Low', and 7 studies (38.89%) were 'Critically Low'. In future research, scientific and objective data selection and extraction process should be performed. It is expected that interest and efforts to improve the quality of meta-analysis research will continue by referring to the contents analyzed in this study as a way to improve the quality of literature.
Keywords
Evidence-Based Practice; Rehabilitation Treatment Intervention; Meta-analysis; Methodological Quality Assessment; Stroke;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 4  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 M. Y. Pang, J. E. Harris, and J. J. Eng, "A community-based upper-extremity group exercise program improves motor function and performance of functional activities in chronic stroke: a randomized controlled trial," Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation, Vol.87, No.1, pp.1-9, 2006.
2 J. Cannell, E. Jovic, A. Rathjen, K. Lane, A. M. Tyson, M. L. Callisaya, and M. L. Bird, "The efficacy of interactive, motion capture-based rehabilitation on functional outcomes in an inpatient stroke population: a randomized controlled trial," Clinical rehabilitation, Vol.32, No.2, pp.191-200, 2018.   DOI
3 B. J. Shea, B. C. Reeves, G. Wells, M. Thuku, C. Hamel, J. Moran, and D. A. Henry, AMSTAR 2: a critical appraisal tool for systematic reviews that include randomised or non-randomised studies of healthcare interventions, or both, bmj, 2017.
4 J. H. Kim and A. K. Kim. "A Quality Assessment of Meta-Analyses of Nursing in South Korea," Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing, Vol.43, No.6, pp.736-745, 2013.   DOI
5 A. C. Lo, P. D. Guarino, L. G. Richards, J. K. Haselkorn, G. F. Wittenberg, D. G. Federman, and P. Peduzzi, "Robot-assisted therapy for long-term upper-limb impairment after stroke," New England Journal of Medicine, Vol.362, No.19, pp.1772-1783, 2010.   DOI
6 김수영, 박지은, 서현주, 서혜선, 손희정, 신채민, 허대석, NECA 체계적 문헌고찰 매뉴얼, NECA 연구방법 시리즈, 2011.
7 S. J. Brown, Evidence-based nursing: The research-practice connection, Jones & Bartlett Publishers, 2014.
8 S. L. MacDonald, S. E. Canfield, S. F. Fesperman, and P. Dahm, "Assessment of the methodological quality of systematic reviews published in the urological literature from 1998 to 2008," The Journal of Urology, Vol.184, No.2, pp.648-653, 2010.   DOI
9 B. J. Shea, J. M. Grimshaw, G. A. Wells, M. Boers, N. Andersson, C. Hamel, and L. M. Bouter, "Development of AMSTAR: a measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews," BMC medical research methodology, Vol.7, No.1, pp.1-7, 2007.   DOI
10 B. J. Shea, C. Hamel, G. A. Wells, L. M. Bouter, E. Kristjansson, J. Grimshaw, and M. Boers, "AMSTAR is a reliable and valid measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews," Journal of clinical epidemiology, Vol.62, No.10, pp.1013-1020, 2009.   DOI
11 I. S. Shin and E. Y. Park, "Review of the meta-analysis research in special education and related field," Korean Journal of Physical, Multiple, & Health Disabilities, Vol54, No.4, pp.157-76, 2011.   DOI
12 V. Sattler, B. Acket, N. Raposo, J. F. Albucher, C. Thalamas, I. Loubinoux, and M. S. Moreau, "Anodal tDCS combined with radial nerve stimulation promotes hand motor recovery in the acute phase after ischemic stroke," Neurorehabilitation and neural repair, Vol.29, No.8, pp.743-754, 2015.   DOI
13 B. Hjorland, "Evidence-based practice: An analysis based on the philosophy of science," Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, Vol.62, No.7, pp.1301-1310, 2011.   DOI
14 M. Yuan, J. Wu, R. E. Austin, F. Lista, and J. Ahmad, Evaluating the Quality of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses About Breast Augmentation Using AMSTAR. In Aesthetic Surgery Journal Open Forum, US: Oxford University Press, 2021.
15 S. Y. Kim, "Methodological Quality Assessment of Meta-Analyses in the Field of Korean Occupational Therapy Using the Korean Journal of Occupational Therapy," Korean Journal of Occupational Therapy, Vol.28, No.3, pp.71-81, 2020.   DOI
16 C. Y. Wu, C. L. Yang, M. D. Chen, K. C. Lin, and L. L. Wu, "Unilateral versus bilateral robot-assisted rehabilitation on arm-trunk control and functions post stroke: a randomized controlled trial," Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation, Vol.10, No.1, pp1-10, 2013.   DOI
17 A. A. Timmermans, R. J. Lemmens, M. Monfrance, R. P. Geers, W. Bakx, R. J. Smeets, and H. A. Seelen, "Effects of task-oriented robot training on arm function, activity, and quality of life in chronic stroke patients: a randomized controlled trial," Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation, Vol.11, No.1, pp1-12, 2014.   DOI
18 H. R. Kim, J. H. Park, C. H. Choi, and E. Jo, "Comparison between AMSTAR and AMSTAR-2, a meta-analysis methodological quality assessment tool: focused on research related to dance therapy," The Korean Journal of Measurement and Evaluation in Physical Education and Sport Science, Vol.23, No.1, pp.21-32, 2021.   DOI
19 L. S. Greenberg and F. L. Newman, "An approach to psychotherapy change process research: Introduction to the special section," Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, Vol.64, No.3, p.435, 1996.   DOI
20 S. H. Park and M. S. Kwak, "Methodological qualitative evaluation of meta-analysis studies in sport management," Korean Journal of Physical Education, Vol.57, No.1, pp.247-258, 2018.
21 조재훈, 메타분석의 이론과 실제, Journal of Rhinology, 2020.
22 M. O. Suh, "The review of meta-analysis and research methodology proposed," Korean Journal of Educational Research, Vol.49 No.2, pp.1-23, 2011.
23 S. H. Cho and K. B. Choi, "The Effect of Virtual Reality Programs on Upper Extremity Function in Stroke Patients: A Meta-Analysis," Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society, Vol.21, No.8, pp.429-439, 2020.   DOI
24 S. B. Shim, J. A. Lee, and H. L. Lee, "Evaluation of the Reporting and Methodological Quality of the Systematic Review from the Journal of Pediatrics of Korean Medicine," The Journal of Pediatrics of Korean Medicine, Vol.34, No.1, pp.26-36, 2020.   DOI
25 M. K. Cho and H. Y. Kim, "A Quality Assessment of Meta-Analyses Research in Social Work," Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society, Vol.17, No.10, pp.158-167, 2016.   DOI
26 S. D. Lee, S. J. Kim, and D. M. Yeum, "Discussion and Proposal for Meta-Analysis Papers of Social Welfare Field," The Journal of the Korea Contents Association, Vol.14, No.1, pp.209-222, 2014.   DOI
27 S. B. Kim and D. H. Kim, "The Effect of Modified Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy(mCIMT) on the Improvement of Upper Motor Function in Adult Stroke Patients Using Meta Analysis," The Journal of Korean Society of Community Based Occupational Therapy, Vol.11, No.2, pp.13-24, 2021.   DOI
28 M. D. McInnes, D. Moher, B. D. Thombs, T. A. McGrath, P. M. Bossuyt, T. Clifford, and B. H. Willis, "Preferred reporting items for a systematic review and meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy studies: the PRISMA-DTA statement," Jama, Vol.319, No.4, pp.388-396, 2018.   DOI
29 J. P. Higgins, J. Thomas, J. Chandler, M. Cumpston, T. Li, M. J. Page, and V. A. Welch, Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions, John Wiley & Sons, 2019.
30 S. H. Park, "Evaluation of methodological quality of meta-analysis studies in early childhood education," Korean Journal of Early Childhood Education, Vol.38, No.5, pp.131-156, 2018.   DOI
31 J. M. Veerbeek, A. C. L. Amersfoort, E. E. Van Wegen, C. G. Meskers, and G. Kwakkel, "Effects of robot-assisted therapy for the upper limb after stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis," Neurorehabilitation and neural repair, Vol.31, No.2, pp.107-121, 2017.   DOI