Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.4332/KJHPA.2007.17.3.106

Ideology and Reality in Health Policy  

Lee, Kyu-Sik (Department of Health Administration, Yonsei University)
Publication Information
Health Policy and Management / v.17, no.3, 2007 , pp. 106-128 More about this Journal
Abstract
The Korean health care system is under great controversy. Over the last 30 years, main goal of health policies was to pursue equal access of health care services. However, another goal of health policies laid on efficiency and Quality of care, it had lower priorities. Superficially, controversy stems from priority setting among goals of health care system, equity, efficiency and quality. At a deeper level, arguments arise from disagreement and confusion about the values of Korean health care system. One of the value spectrums believes that health care is the basic right of human beings, therefore it should be produced and distributed on need approach, and needs are known to be decided by professionals. If we accept need approach, health care is a pubic good. Another value of spectrums considers that health care should be distributed on demand approach. Demand approach means that health care is a consumption good on the positive economics, while normative judgement believes that health care is a public good. In equity aspect, health care is considered as a public good. Over the last several years, some of scholars proposed health care reform based on the principle of competition which is based on demand approach. Others argue that the competition principle based on demand approach is not appropriate for the reform proposal, because health care has to be approached on need base. If we do not make explicit values we should adopt, consensus building for reform is nearly impossible. From this perspective, this article will review an ideology and reality in health policies in Korea.
Keywords
need and demand; value; ideology; normative; health policy;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Samuelson PA. The pure theory of public expenditure. Review of Economics and Statistics. 1954; 36(4): 387-389   DOI   ScienceOn
2 Schlesinger M. On values and democratic policy making: the deceptively fragile consensus around market-oriented medical care. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 2002; 27(6): 679- 699
3 Starr P. The social transformation of American medicine: the rise of sovereign profession and the making of vast industry, New York: Basic Books; 1982
4 Stigler GJ. The theory of economic regulation. Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 1971; 2(1): 3-21   DOI   ScienceOn
5 United Nations. Universal declaration of human rights; 1948
6 Veatch R. Value systems: their roles in shapping policy decisions. In : Bankowsk Z, Bryant JH editors. Health policy, ethics and human values. 1985; Geneva: CIOMS: 84-86
7 Vickers G. The art of judgement, London: Chapman and Hall; 1965
8 Fox DM. Health policies health politics: the British and American experience 1911-1965, Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press; 1986
9 Melhado EM. Economist, public provision, and the market: changing values in policy debate. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 1998; 223(2): 215-263
10 Musgrave RA, Musgrave PB. Public finance in theory and practice, New York: McGraw-Hill; 1976
11 Beveridge WH. Social insurance and allied services. New York Agathon Press; 1942(reprinted in 1969)
12 Fox DM Health policy and the history of welfare states: a reinterpretation. Journal of Policy History 1998; 10(2): 239- 256   DOI
13 Battistella RM. Rationalization of health services: political and social assumption. International Journal of Health Services 1972; 2(3): 331-348   DOI
14 양재모. 사회보장제도 창시에 관한 건의. 보건사회부(미발간); 1961
15 임채원. 신자유주의 국가를 넘어 사회투자국가로. 서울: 한울 아카데미; 2006
16 Alford RR. Health care politics. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press; 1975
17 Arrow KJ. Uncertainty and the welfare economics of medical care, American Economic Review 1963; 53(5): 941- 973
18 Battistella RM. The Political economy of health services: a review and assessment of major ideological influences and the impact of new economic realities. In : Litman TJ, Robins LS, editors. Health Politics and Policy, Albany: Delmar Publisher; 1997; 75-108
19 Blendon RJ, Benson JM, Roches CM, Americans' view of the uninsured: an era for hybrid proposals. Health Affairs Web Exclusive 2003; August 27: 405-414
20 Buchanan JM, The demand and supply of public goods. Chicago: Rand McNally; 1968
21 Busse R, Saltman RB, Dubois HFW. Organization and financing of social health insurance systems: current status and recent policy developments. In : Saltman RB, Busse R, Figueras J, editors. Social Health Insurance Systems in Western Europe. European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies Series, Berkshire: Open University Press; 2004: 33-80
22 Feldstein PJ. Health care economics. 6th ed. Albany, New York Delmar Publishers Inc.: 2005
23 Enthoven AC. Consumer choice health plan: a national health insurance proposal (Memorandum to HEW Secretary Joseph Califano, 22 September 1977), reprinted in Consumer choice health plan: a national health insurance proposal based on regulated competition in the private sector. New England Journal of Medicine 1978; 298(12 and 13): 650-58, 709-20   DOI   ScienceOn
24 Fein R. Medical care needs in the corning decade, Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 1969; 45(3): 255-270
25 Feldstein PJ. Health care economics. 3th ed. Albany, New York: Delmar Publishers Inc.: 2003
26 Flora P. The western european welfare state since World War II: Germany, United Kingdom, Ireland, Italy. Berlin; New York; de Gruyter (European University Institute : Ser. C, Political and Social Sciences); 1986 Fox DM. From reform to relativism: a history of economists and health care. Milbank Memorial Fund Ouarterly/Health and Society 1979; 67(3), 297-336
27 Fox DM. Policy and epidemiology: financing health services for the chronically and disabled, 1930-1990. Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 1989; 67(suppl.2, pt.2): 257-87
28 Fox DM. Health policy and the politics of research in the United States, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 1990; 15(3): 481- 499   DOI
29 Friedman M. Capitalism and freedom. Chicago: Phoenix Books; 1962
30 Fraser D. The evolution of the british welfare state. 2nd ed. London: Macmillan; 1984
31 Fuchs VR. Economics, values, and health care reform. The American Economic Review 1996; 86(1): 1-24
32 Giddens A. Beyond left and right, Cambridge: Polity Press; 1994
33 Giddens A. The third way: the renewal of social democracy, Cambridge: Polity Press; 1998
34 Joseph K. Stranded on the middle ground? reflections on circumstances and policies. London: Centre for Policy Studies; 1976
35 Gre$\beta$ S, Gildmeister S, Wasem J. The social transformation of American medicine: a comparative view from Germany. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 2004; 29(4-5): 679- 699   DOI   ScienceOn
36 Ham C. Management and competition in the NBS, Abingdon, Oxon. Ratcliffe Medical Press; 1997
37 Jeffers JR, Bognanno MF, Bartlett JC, On the demand versus need for medical services and the concept of 'shortage'. American Journal of Public Health 1971; 61(1): 47
38 Klein R. The politics of ideology vs. the reality of politics' the case of Britain's National Health Service in the 1980s. Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly/Health and Society 1984; 65(1): 82-109
39 Klein R. The new politics of the National Health Service. 3rd ed. London: Longman; 1995
40 Lowe R. The welfare state in Britain since 1945. 2nd ed. London: Macmillan Press Ltd; 1999
41 Nozick R. Anarchy, state and utopia, Oxford: Basil Blackwell; 1974
42 Patel K, Rushefsky ME. Health care politics and policy in America, New York: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.; 1995
43 Pauly MV. Medical care at public expense: a study in applied welfare economics, New York: Prager; 1971
44 Priester R. A values framework for health system reform. Health Affairs 1992; 11(1): 84-107
45 Rimlinger GV. Welfare policy and industrialization in Europe America and Russia, New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: 1971
46 Santerre RE, Neun SP. Health economics: theories, insights, and industry studies, Chicago: Irwin; 1996
47 Saltman RB and Dubois HFW. The historical and social base of social health insurance systems. In : Saltman RB, Busse R, Figueras J, editors. Social Health Insurance Systems in Western Europe. European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies Series, Berkshire: Open University Press; 2004: 21-32